It's alright. Let the disrespect continue. All that matters is Purdy and the Niners keep winning, and hopefully, the Super Bowl.

It’s insane!

I agree. Tua should be a top 10 QB. Apparently you need a rocket arm to be decent on this list. Burrow and Tua have comparable arm strength and while I would still have Burrow higher up to this point in their career it's not like this huge gap. It's mostly a media driven narrative with Tua. Watch him lead the league in yards again next year.

@@andrewwilliam4741 at this point I’m convinced he could actually be #1 in every statistical category and it’s gonna be used against him somehow. He led the #1 offense in the NFL in terms of passing yards and I think total yards as well, from week 1 on. The only point in the season anyone had more passing yards was during Miamis Bye week.

Also behind Rodgers who I would bet money will be retired before the end of the 3 year window. I think he likely retires after this year, during which he'll playing at 40 coming off an Achilles injury.

@@stolve8847 even if he isn’t retired, the last time anyone saw Rodger’s pass for more than 300 yards in a game was early in the 2021 season. His last season in Green Bay he was objectively worse than any year of his career since his first season as the starter and worse than Jordan Love was last season, in his first year starting, with the exact same supporting cast. Even if he is still playing, I doubt it’s just going to suddenly turn around and start looking like Aaron of 5+ years ago. And I don’t even want to hear about his MVP seasons. One of them was given to him when it should’ve went to Brady, and the other could’ve went to any of a handful of guys that were just as deserving, if not more so.

Bahahaha I love how delusional u Fins fans are. Do u not watch him play? He is accurate and does nothing else at an elite level. His WRs, his play caller and running game are all elite. Any QB in that system and team would flourish Tua isn't a talented QB and that's why 90% of experts don't have him top 10. Use your damn eyes and watch game film he isn't special really in any way. Sorry to be so harsh but it's just facts.

As opposed to off the field play?

Herbert is better if we are being honest.

@@user-wn2uj7oe9ithat’s delusion, not honesty. Dude puts up empty stats and that’s it😂

Lamar has had more draft capital spent on wrs in the first 2 rounds than any other qb since 2018. Maybe it's the qb..

@@crustybs46Lamar’s best receiver was 32 year Odell with 2 torn acls and a broke ankle lol. The last 2 receivers they drafted were 5’9 160 lbs come on bro

@@lornegreen6755 3 1st round wide recievers in his time as a raven come on is right

@@crustybs46 Hollywood brown, zay flowers and whose the 3rd guy some guy they drafted in the 4th rd? Hollywood is on his 3rd team, zay showed potential and again we drafted a 4th rd guy lol. You tried so I respect it.

@lornegreen6755 @lornegreen6755 Bateman brown and jones. 7 wide recievers in the first 4 rounds of the draft. And multiple high-end tight end draft picks including mark Andrew's lol

And Goff. Two Super Bowl qbs.

Ya Geno over Goff is crazy. Like Purdy over Geno but not sure how anyone objectively takes Geno over Goff

Brock Purdy has never lost to Geno Smith, including the playoffs

It is odd. Herbert is a good QB, but he's been given quite a bit. No, he didn't have a great Game managing HC, but Herbert does seem to get the benefit of the doubt a LOT.

@@segagenesis7708 Alwyas gets excuses

@@OldAfrobeatsHerbert hasn’t done anything in this league. Overrated and no one wants to talk about it

@@segagenesis7708dude he had Shane Steichen as OC his rookie year who has shown to be an *Elite* HC, he’s Phillip Rivers 2.0 atp

I really think it’s because a certain segment of the American population can’t get the idea that a QB is supposed to be a big strong good looking white guy out of their heads. Same thing with Trevor.

same way Burrow is only #6..... they made their lists while drunk. Only explanation.

Because its not a power ranking its a draft so they partially projecting. Trevor is younger and arguably in a worse circumstance while burrow has major injury concerns. Not saying i agree just giving the reasoning

Partially projecting? He has been in the league for 3 years, we have actual evidence of his play. At this point projecting him that high is just the stubborness of someone desperately holding on to who he was in college

@richardgiles5608 hes only 22. Luka is 25 playing in his first ever finals. Jordan at 22 had no finals appearances or MVPs. Lebron made it to the finals at 22 and didnt go back until he was 27. Ant definitely has time to improve

Trevor Lawrence holds the ball and fumbles WAY too much to be top anything

Playoffs

I think this year is going to add more clarity to QB rankings more than any other year in history. The credit Burrow gets for that Super Bowl berth a few years ago is starting to wear off and Josh Allen is going to have to get it done full time without Diggs. And Lamar is now in his 2nd year in a real passing scheme plus has the addition of Derrick Henry the most decorated skill player he’s ever had as a teammate offensively. This could be the year Lamar not only definitively shows he’s a top 2 QB but makes it historically embarrassing that they ever ranked ppl like Herbert ahead of him

@@HockeyDudeJames2 If that were remotely the case, what could possibly be justification for Herbert over Lamar? He literally has 0 playoff wins in his career and only 1 playoff appearance in his career

@@truthbearer7891 Lamar is 3 but let's not act like out of all the top QBs Herbert has been in the worst situation. Chargers are a Bottom five defence. Individually he has been nice.

Couldn’t agree more with you. The Lamar disrespect is sickening at this point. He gets dropped for lack of playoff success but Allen and Hurbert don’t?? However he is the only 2x MVP not named Mahomes.

He is a far better passer than Lamar, and given their ages I doubt Lamar is gonna be the run threat he used to be... not to mention neither of them have won shit so that's pretty even. Especially when you consider Lamar is playing for a top 5 nfl program known for elite defense, and a top 5 nfl coach.... something Herbert never had.

@@Noahvon503 to say neither of them ever won shit is wild. Lamar is a 2x MVP of the league, 2 playoff wins to Herbert’s 0, 3 division titles to Herbert’s 0 and wins 72% of his games. Also in this video they both went on about how Lamar is developing as a passer, assuming that continues and he’s not immobile I think it’s a big jump to take Herbert over him.

@@Noahvon503hmmm one guy blew a 21 pt lead in the playoffs and the other one didn’t. One guy has 2 playoff wins and the other doesn’t. One guy has 2x MVPs and the other doesn’t. Which one you taking?

@lornegreen6755 the guy that actually can stay healthy and has the better coach.

@@Noahvon503 I don’t wanna hear that lol. Justin Herbert always gets the benefit of the doubt . He blew a 21 pt lead in the playoffs and everybody acts like that didn’t happen, yet yall keep pushing this narrative that he better than Lamar bc he has pretty passing yards but Lamar gets the same amnt of yards. And he’s never had the offense help Herbert has had. Lamar’s best receiver was a 32 year old obj with 2 torn acls and a broke ankle

Biased and defensive fans are so funny. God forbid they critique your ‘pretty good but flawed’ QB.

@@dillonmurphy2394 How is he flawed? How is he worse than two rookies and Trevor Lawrence?

@@sprcrzy110 physically pretty limited in terms of arm and size, shows up when forced to throw from crowded pockets and becomes erratic/chaotic far too often (much better than he was in college though). Overall a nice player and a good story but the Shanahan offense, specifically with that roster, makes his life 100x easier and anyone without bias can see that. Put Lawrence or whoever you have a gripe with in SF’s offense and it’s likely better. Offensive context and watching tape is paramount when looking at QBs and their production, not just looking at box scores.

@@dillonmurphy2394 Then why did he have a top 5 qbr when pressured?

@@sprcrzy110 in large part due to the offense he plays in. Overall think he’s good at scrambling and creating plays under pressure, but he has clear limitations that are insulated by the offense he plays in. Good player! not elite, and that’s fine.

Burrow is the most overrated qb in the league.

@@crustybs46 I’d say Herbert is. Burrow can deal. Seen him in person every time they come to Baltimore. He has had crazy good weapons since his first full season (2nd year). However his Oline has been one of the worst year in and year out. I dont think he’s the 2nd best QB in the league, that would be overrated in my eyes, but like I said he’s somewhere in the top 5, when healthy. When you look at burrow, Lamar and Allen their notable achievements are… Burrow - got to the SB, winning record against Mahommes Lamar - 2 time MVP, 2 #1 seeds Allen - can beat everyone except Mahommes when it matters, although it’s been close af. I think Allen and Lamar are clear 2-3 (doesn’t matter which number it’s so close) in the league and burrow is 4.

Truth. These three are the clear best after Mahomes and any team would be happy to get one of them over the other 28 starting QBs.

im a pack fan and joe burrow is my favorite qb, but id go Stroud. younger, big, no injury history. he had a marino rookie season. after mahomes and allen, he is the next guy for me.

dude... nobody respects lamar except for "tv personalities" and ravens fans. the guy cant win a game in the playoffs and nobody fears him from the pocket

List me at saying Josh Allen is more explosive than the dude they wanted to play WR out of college.

Please, Trevor Lawrence is the most overrated player right now. He needs 5+ seconds to look down field and his 60 turnovers in 3 years are inexcusable. His hair is lovely, so I’ll grant you that.

Judging a guy off one game is idiotic. Go watch that Raiders game with his multiple 4th and long conversions with the season on the line in 2021 and talk about him “not carrying” their team. Love Joe but peoples opinion of Burrow is inflated due to the Super Bowl run, which was as much in part due to their defense than anything.

@@dillonmurphy2394 notice how your argument dates back to 2021. Hasn’t done anything since his rookie year.

@@shaqquackk his rookie year was 2020. Was elite in 2020 and 2021, very good in 2022 despite broken ribs and was hurt most of last year. Stupid take.

@@dillonmurphy2394 very good right, playoff wins? Yea that’s what I thought. Good in the regular season. Absolute sh*t when it matters

​people still trying to argue QB wins can be easily and safely ignored.

Proves what lmfao. He had the best rookie season ever by a QB and then had 40 TDs and 5000 yards in his 2nd season while being hurt the last two while still performing well. Top 3 arm in the league, elite pocket presence and processing with good accuracy and decision making. Easy top 5 guy to anyone who watches QBs on a remotely regular basis.

@@dillonmurphy2394 top 5? Can I have whatever you’re smoking? Hasn’t done anything since his rookie year. He’s top 15. At best

Proves he can win meaningful games . This isn’t fantasy football

@@matteagan1288 that’s a very dumb way of looking at it, IMO. “Meaningful” games doesn’t mean anything substantive and it’s only what YOU decide is meaningful (aka the single playoff game we’ve seen him in), so it’s always going to line up with your belief. Watch 10 minutes of Herbert tape and maybe you’ll get it!

@@shaqquackk did you miss the part of my comment where the very next year he threw for 5000 yards and 40 TDs? And has largely been good the last two years but dealt with like 3 different injuries, including playing through broken ribs for 80% of 2022.

Mina praises the Rams and Niners to no end to overcompensate for her fandom.

nate is not a seattle fan

@@reubenclay4379 What team does he root for?

@@sprcrzy110 none. He was a Vikings fan as a child, but after the way they fired his dad, he just became a good football fan. He is a Timberwolves and Mariners fan though.

@@reubenclay4379 I didn't know that. I assumed he was a Seahawks fan because he's wearing a Seattle sweatshirt.

Lamar has never been better. What does he do better outside running 😂😂

Lamar has been in a way better situation

he plays for the Bears is why

He knows more ball than both of us put together but his take here is questionable

I think she's 🔥

His weapons were never healthy and had arguably the worst HC in the league for years.

It's Herbert All day if you're drafting every other than rushing there's nothing physically Herbert can't do better than Lamar nd even he isn't a statue he's got some wheels on him too

And I get the apprehension but having him below Levis/Fields/Baker is funny to me because in three years I don’t think those guys will even be starting QBs. And in 3 years he’ll be younger than all of those guys are right now. In 3 years I’d be willing to bet most people will have McCarthy in their preseason on top 8-12 range. But for now I suppose I’ll be the only one bullish on the kid.

He will be better than the most efficient qb in football in his first year? I don't think so.

Lot of flaws

Because of his defense. His playoff stats are kinda mid

You do realize that teams beat other teams right? Burrows run to the Super Bowl was mostly because of clutch defensive play

Jeff fisher and Joe burrow get so much credit for going to the Super Bowl and LOSING…..I wonder why

If that's the criteria, Goff should be number 2.

Love beat the Chiefs.

Ya crazy

his injury record is his biggest concern, and its a significant one. Hes missed so much time

Jordan love has some insane tape, it’s fine to say you disagree with him, but saying he doesn’t know his stuff is disrespectful. Just because you don’t share his opinions doesn’t mean you should just discredit him.

Allen’s defense gives up 32 points per game in the playoffs. He’s statistically the best QB in the post season the last 4 years besides Mahomes. His WR1 hasn’t had 100 yards in a post season game since 2020. And QB’s don’t face QB’s guy they face defenses which he’s obliterated outside of the Bengals which also Mahomes struggles against

@@jasoneng3161 I like Love. He was good in '23. But it's way too early to rank him that high.

@@zacharyking6596 Allen's still played very well regardless of who the QB is, but when it comes to winning a playoff game your opponent matters a lot. You win games by outscoring the other team, playing backup QBs is undeniably a massive advantage in playoffs wins. Agreed the Bills defense has sucked in playoffs vs KC, but he's still had great defenses for a while to get to playoffs. Bills didn't coast to playoffs from the defense, Allen's a huge reason they win, but it did help. Allen's defense also allows 24.8ppg in playoffs, not 32. 25 isn't even that bad, esp vs playoff teams, esp considering they played Mahomes 3 times. Bills defense wasn't even bad in a lot of their playoff games- 3/10 they held to under 20. 7/10 they held under 30. Only reason Allen's defense allows 24.8ppg in playoffs is cuz they played KC 3 times, factor them out & Allen's defense has allowed only 20.1ppg in playoffs. That's not bad at all, it's actually pretty good. --2019 Bills D shut the Texans out an entire half while the Bills offense only scored 6 (from 2 FGs) the whole 2nd half and only had 1 TD the whole game. That L is on the offense, 13 of their 19 points came from the kicker. --2020 the Bills held the Colts to 10 points in 3 Qs combined. Bills win. --2021 the Bills held the Patriots to 17. Bills win. --2022 Allen was great vs Miami. --2022 loss to Cinci was on the offense for only scoring 10 points. Bills moved the ball but couldn't score. They had 3 points the whole 2nd half. Bills defense didn't lose them this game, the offense just sucked. --2023 Bills held the Steelers to 17. Bills win. Bills lost '21 cuz they got screwed by the coin toss. Defense sucked vs the Chiefs, but that's only 3/10 games & it's still hard to blame them for losing to Mahomes cuz everyone does. I hated seeing them lose to KC in '21, Allen was incredible and was keeping up with Mahomes in 1 of the best games I've ever seen. NFL changed the OT rules cuz they knew the coin toss fucked the Bills unfairly. Allen should be ranked really high, he's phenomenal. Esp in playoffs.

@@anthonysclafani3963 I thank you for being logical. I’ll say you’re not adding context 2019 we all know Allen wasn’t good in that game, but the Bills offense tied that game up late and the defense gave up a game winning FG drive in OT 2020, the Colts in the 4th quarter were on fire and almost came back and won that game because the defense let them back in and because Rivers didn’t have the arm strength it didn’t get there on the Hail Mary. The defense won them the Ravens game with a pick six. The Bills whole team got outclassed and outcoached by the Chiefs in that AFC title game 2021, the Bills and Allen had the only perfect offensive game in NFL post season history against the number 2 defense that year against the Pats. Then the amazing stride for stride game with Mahomes that ended cause Allen didn’t get the ball in OT 2022, Allen was amazing against the Dolphins a team he historically is great against. The whole team was bad against the Bengals but to only blame the offense is half the story, the Bengals oline had backups and the Bills starters couldn’t sniff Burrow who get sacked A LOT. 2023, Allen was great against the Steelers and yes so was the defense against an offense that really only ran the ball so they were limited but the offense beat up on that good defense. And he was once again great against the Chiefs who were the number 1 defense that year but his defense couldn’t stop a napkin in the breeze that game and so they lost by 3 which the offense is the only reason that game was close and 1 defensive play where Hardman fumbled

49er fan here, not angry, just perplexed at Drake May, Herbert, those dudes being so high. Less about the purdy stuff, I'm used to it by now lol. But the rest of this list, idk.

He will be properly rated after MVP #3 and Ring #1

Minus the great and the hope.

cant really be the great white hope when the majority of quarterbacks are white

By that logic Goff is better than Herbert Lamar Allen & Love since he made a super bowl…. Lamar also has 2 MVP’s (one being unanimous) Burrow has 0 sooo

Lol he got to a super bowl 3 years ago and lost...

Joe burrow is the only person besides Jeff fisher who gets more credit for going to the SB and LOSING lol. Playoff records mean NOTHING if you don’t have a ring.

We’ve also never seen Burrow without some form of Chase and/or Higgins.

Love and Stroud had almost identical playoff runs. Thought Stroud was more consistent but Love's highs were on a different level.