So they are actually playing by their own rules. Never actually thought they would cheat but coming back to a trick judged wrongly is actually really noble.

This so clearly displays how fair minded these guys are (and their honest intent of helping countless magicians via this show!!) 2 wonderful magicians, 2 wonderful brains, 2 wonderful human beings ☺️

Love that they have the humility to realize their mistake, and go out of their way to correct it

Really love it. I love the concept that they were able to retroactively give the man a trophy. One of the previous commenters pointed out something I didn't notice, which is that it was always the red chip.

One thing I noticed on this trick originally and just noticed again is that it's always the red chip that moved

2:06 that “oh!” Has me crying

Penn and teller pretend that they hate getting fooled. But after watching the show for a long time I’ve concluded that they actually enjoy getting fooled and enjoy giving up the trophy. They’re actually rooting for the magicians

It's astounding they fell for such a simple trick, but it's so well executed

I saw that he always switched back to the red chip. makes me think he had 4 chips - 2 red

Nice one chap, good work.

Amazing trick. Wish I had those sleight of hand skills. Congrats.

Real class act, these two. Much respect.

It takes a man to admit when he is wrong and only to ask for forgiveness in return… cheers

this was weird, i thought tricks like this are usually done with sleight of hand, not gimmicks

Awe he actually fooled them. With the beginning it seemed more like it was obvious that the red chip somehow became the green chip and that he did a good job at hiding the chips in his hands. Great sleight of hand. 🖐🤚

The 4th chip of one particular color..good 👍

Yeah, their guess was wrong but I am not going to act smarter since they were not able to pause like I did. They could only rewatch after the fact, so its very cool that they called him back. I am sure they know how he did it, the likely method I thought of and believe to be visible in the tape is mentioned in the comments here, so if we know they do. It's jsut their guess was wrong at the show so they have to honor that, well they don't have to but thats what makes it cool that they did play by their own rules.

I thought he had three chips in each hand. He just hid one and revealed the other at the same time, simultaneous slight of hand

I'm actually surprised they were fooled by this. I guess the short amount of time they had to figure it out and them thinking you were doing something you weren't is why. I suspect after watching it again they realized what you did.

This felt like they were gonna punk him again as they say its on April 1st.. I thought it was gonna be a trophy saying F*** U or something and tell him of course he didnt fool us!

so much more respect

Now I wanna see them take some trophies back LOL

I wouldn't have thought the chips were gimmicked. Just that he was holding the chips he needed in the receiving hand, and was ditching the ones he didn't need anymore into his sleeve or something.

There's 4 chips. He's hiding a chip in his "empty" hand.

when he swaps his hands over for the last chip if you slow it down you can see where it hits inside his sleeve

simple sleight of hand........ but.....................done so dog dam well even at .25 speed you can barely see it unless you know what to look for. like so smooth you need frame by frame. even .25 speed took 10 times rewatching. dude im so amazed. i was so impressed and entertained watching 1st time. i hit rewind like 50 times. you fooled me and my slo-mo replay even. dam you good!

Love it.

4 chips, 2 red ones. As for the last move, the only thing that is possible, in my mind, is that when he moved his hand to his armpit, he delivered the red chip in a pocket, and then it was just theatrics until the end when he just do his normal trick of making the other red chip rolls behind the others in his left hand. Now, what I think he tried to do was to make 2 fake movements to lead them astray. First he suggests he could be pressing the chip in his armpit, but he reveals it cannot be it when he releases it. In addition, he makes some hand movements that could suggest he hid the chip in the middle of the index and middle fingers. Then he showed the palm, and he moved it again to the palm and showed the back of the hand, and then moved the chip inside his suit. Now, I'm betting on a pocket because the hiding behind fingers stuff seems ridiculously hard for me (a layman). And I could not grasp how could he transfer from the back of the hands to the palm again even at 0.25 speed. If that's how he did it, wow. Amazing hands.

This is an amazing performance. Yes, I know how it's done (let's just say there are not 3 chips), but his skill is amazing. Also he bluffs how he does it so elegantly, I'm blown away.

Trick is simple, but the timing and speed is very high skill.

Thought it was pretty obvious there were 4 chips from the first watch. You can see him palming it in his left hand constantly

replay it you can see he was pinching the chips... he acted like he stuck the last chip in his armpit then showed he didnt cause it didnt fall.. there is a pocket in his suit jacket hidden so it would not fall

Also means the backstage judges got it wrong. Which is weird, because they know how the trick is done. I'm genuinely confused how this slipped through.

Got to love obnoxiously loud intros followed by a quieter video.

How did they NOT see the extra chip palmed in his left hand!?

1:58 the second red chip is clearly visible between his index and middle fingers of his left hand when he crosses his arms

When they come back from the break they are taking their trophy back from Jibrizzy

Shuffling . Not 6 chips ?lol

All I have to say is there is a veerrry good reason the only color chip he sends across is the red one.

Okay so I hit the back button a few times. I think that you just moved very very fast. Faster than the eyes can focus. Or you defined gravity.😂

Lol this is the only trick I managed to solve my own. Like 1:04 he just shoved the red chip under the green and blue one in his right hand and the second red chip he took from the palm of his hand. This trick is pure slight of hand

lol. cool. 😎

There is two red chips. He hides one at a time

good guys

they did the right thing!!!! Good on them to give him a trophy APril fools , u didnt fool us , give us a that trophy back luls or he walks behim stage and it disapears , and has a letter in the place of it saying , "happy April fools day "

class acts.

his trick is actually stupid simple thats why he thought he didnt fool them

I think the guy had 2 red chips one in each hand and he showed one while hiding the other, then he hid the red chip again when he "changed" it for the green chip and showed the other one, still having a red chip in each hand, otherwise, why would he change the chips?

So was it they simply guessed wrong in code talk, but we're close enough that Simon thought they had right? Then later, how did they understand they were wrong? Was it him talking on KZfaq, or did someone point it out later? It's cool they openly stated they were wrong, just wondering what transpired to bring it all up.

Interesting that this foold Penn and Teller. This is literally the oldes trick in the book. I just know a few coin tricks and I'm not even a magician but it is the most common coin trick. You can also "see it" in a couple of moves. Still he has awesome skills.

At 1:04 he sends over the red chip. Then suddenly it’s a green chip. Then at like 1:30 he sends over the red chip. Then it’s purple

that intro kill anyone else's ears? I think they're bleeding

1:04 / 1:05 you can see the chip in both hands at the same time :)

Zooty zoot zoot!

So he didn't use a gimmick coins and is truly just great at slight of hand? Ahh don't watch where the coin is just ignore everything ,but the hand the "appear" in. Interesting change of finger placement during the switch and am I crazy or at about 1:28 the hand he raises looks white between his fingers before the reveal. I assume it's the light reflecting and he really has 4 coins.

So what mistake was made? They would have said in code how he did it and he happily and willing accepted they had figured it out. Did they say it was coins and it turns out it wasn’t? Have to respect Penn and Teller to admit they were fooled and ensure he got his trophy.

He had other coins palmed the entire time...Just watch one hand or even at the very beginning. His fingers are open for a few frames and you can see the extra coins. So although this is "noble" I'm pretty sure there was more to it lol there is no way they were actually fooled. They've been in the game a very long time to fall for this.

Let's act surprised even though we were brought onto the show and wired up for audio with lapel mic! Totally unexpected!

Wow! I have no idea how he does that.

Did he give them 4 chips to inspect?

ok... actually he didn't fool me... always the same red poker chip and the same routine :D

the earrape at start...why???

There is one thing I can't seem to figure out... Who was the surprise guest?

Shouldn't he get two trophies? One for fooling them with the trick and one for fooling them that he didn't fool them!

I'm not going to pretend I know how everything was done but (spoiler alert) if you slow the video down for the first chip, you can actually see the 4th chip in his left hand before the chip completely disappears from his right!

Freeze at 1:10. Tell me I'm seeing things.

Pause at :51 ... Two red chips. One hidden the other shown.

This is one of the easiest tricks I haver seen. lol

GREAT showman, but such a simple sleight; I think Penn n Teller phoned it in, like when kids are on; They weren't fooled. If you watch this full-screen, and in KZfaq change the * cog Settings >> Playback speed to -> 0.25, you can easily see what he's doing at least with the first two coins. Yes. Count em up and you seem to go ahem, past 3 coins total. A coin held sideways is not a coin at all. When the coin leaves one side, the magician doesn't rotate the remaining poker chips to show them from their sides. Hmm. Why is that? ;)

nope

love yourself

Watch video at .25 speed

into way too loud

Watch on slow motion. U can see it. Follow the red coin. Kinda dumb actually.

oh wow, that intro is soooooooooo loud.

huh? Why are the vids clipped.. not even expanation on why they were fooled.

Maybe I’ve watched too many of these but it was super obvious to me how this was done. Surprised it fooled Penn & Teller 🤔

Now a days, that would never happen, admitting that you were wrong. It takes character and honesty to do that and Penn & Teller just proved themselves to be of high character and honesty, unless they are performing magic themselves. Great job Gentleman.

Now they need to give Jay Sankey a trophy too! He fooled them and humbly left the stage with Penn and Teller thinking they hadn't been.

Unnecessarily loud intro music is unnecessarily loud.

intro is slightly too loud not hating just saying

Oh come on even I figured out how he did it, he had extra chips in his palms, especially at the first move you see him hiding red one behind other two and bringing same ones that he kept behind fingers, sleigh of hand mastery definitely, but a fooler, not..

This isn't your video. Let the original magicians upload their own stuff.

Your intro is horribly loud.

intro so loud. didn't watch.

I hate these annoying useless sound intros...

Come on... actually you can see very clear where he switched to his other hand and hiding the chips, can't understand this judge now, when someone has a phenomenal routine then they didn't get fooled bc a big magician does it once in another show, but this b-day trick fool them, feel sorry for those who does deserved it more than this lame act, even he feels so surprised about it so dunno pfff..