Surah Yunus, verse 89.....as far as I understand, and Allah knows best

​@@tahsinahmed-og3vk 'Ikrimah said this in the explanation of the ayah

No that's not wrong, dua after prayer in congregation is wrong

وعليكم السلام ، ورحمة الله وبركاته , saying "ameen"

@@one_dawah could you explain what the Shaykh means at 1:53 ? Is it when the Imam says Ameen and everyone else says it after?

@@aliyanib dua in congregation after salah is not permissible, rather making dua not too loud nor too quiet and each time saying aameen with it,. You can make dua and say aameen yourself, thats what it ment

@@believer8263 بارك الله فيك

@@one_dawahso he said it’s permissible if the imam does the dua and the people just say ameen only?

When the imam says the dua and everyone says ameen

When the imam says the dua and everyone says ameen

He remembers abdul haq hashimi and those who refuted the practice but doesn't remember the thousands of scholars who have allowed it (with conditions).

@@J-u-n-d can you provide a link for evidence for allowing personal dua after prayer?

Brother Aslamualaikum He is not Scholar of desires brother. What's described in generations of Salaf, he is just saying that and warning us to stay from every bidat. U can listen to other Sheikh Like Sheikh uthaymeen, Sheikh baz regarding this. This congregational dua is done in subcontinent also and prominent scholars also prohibit the same May ALLAH guide us

Bro..don't be first in judging scholars. Do u know him. First LISTEN and get more knowledge before you sting any scholar

Make dua between adhaan to Iqamaah, while it's raining, during the last third of night, in sunnah and nafl prayers while you are in Sujood and in tashhud, after sunnah and nafl prayers by raising hands, in fard prayers while you are in Sujood and tashhud, at times of calamity, when you are oppressed, when confronting enemies,… You have the best times to get dua answered, and you want to make dua right after fard prayers that is not legislated. If making dua immediately after fard prayers is legislated, it would have been done by the messenger of Allah ﷺ and the best of generations, but none of them did it. We follow them. We need scholars to understand the Deen; Honour the scholars. Abdus Salam ash Shuwayir (May Allah preserve him) is a real scholar who has good manners. Some of the fake scholars that people elevate them to the level of scholars • Muhammad Ismail Menk • Hamza Yusuf •Nouman Ali Khan • Yasir Qadhi • Omar Suleiman By getting a degree, we become only a student of knowledge. Becoming a scholar is not so easy.

A similar statement that dua immediately after fard prayers is not legislated by Shaykh Salih ibn al-Uthaymeen رحمه الله An-Nisa' 4:103 When you have finished As-Salât (the congregational prayer), remember Allâh standing, sitting down, and (lying down) on your sides, but when you are free from danger, perform As-Salât (Iqamat-as-Salât). Verily, As-Salât (the prayer) is enjoined on the believers at fixed hours. He said remember Allah; not supplicate kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f7h6lbiKl6qqdJs.html

How quickly you make accusations against scholars though your so ignorant Understand the sheikh never said making dua is a bidah rather he said making dua after every salah specifically is a bidah as the prophet ﷺ never did that Anything which the prophet ﷺ didnt do as worship is then a bidah Make Allah Protect us From Ignorant People