How has the world forgotten about pure talent like this

I mean TALENT! No wonder why she has 19 #1 hits and 18 of them were written by her.

Holy crap she's undoubtedly a musical GENIUS. No one in the industry could freestyle like that.

Her sense of melody is just a+mazing!

This is the reason why Mariah is different from other legend. The woman is insanely talented, and dare i say, I think she is a bit underrated!

OK BUT SHE SLAYED MY WHOLE LIFE

I always listen this every year since it release 🤣🤣

She shrugs afterwards like she didn’t just end a few careers with this impromptu song.

I love how her band is equally as talented and slowly starts incorporating a beat to her freestyle and ends up with a nice orchestra lol

I am not a Christmas song fan, honestly. But why can't THESE Mariah moments go viral?! Indisputably live, indisputably talented, indisputably beautiful. +mariahcarey

And they said she is done with singing and being Mariah Carey, bullshit she is still beautiful and going with her voice.

Her mind is so brilliant!

I really like the beat and the melody. She should make a song out from it.. But her skill is really dope. You'd really know that shes a great writer. I dont hink other artist are able to freestyles nowadays

found this in youtube trending.. her voice is still beautiful :)

Shame on her for being so talented. I love it. Someone rush Mariah to a studio in Aspen & get this song fully written, recorded, mastered, pressed, & available for download by Christmas.

Mariah is so great at freestyling... now let's see her do some freestyle rap!

her spontaneous songwriting skill is uncanny and singing it at the same time as she makes up the song as she sings along speaks volume of her talent.

This video single handedly proves how she's always been capable of writing massive hits in a matter of minutes.

Damn she's beautiful!

Someone PLEASE tell Mariah that she needs to make a full single track of this for next year!

this woman is unbeliavable talanted

MC cant help it -- when it comes to finding a melody, & using the right tone with her still-amazing voice, she's just a natural with a special gift for the melancholy. ALL HAIL LEGENDARY MARIAH CAREY !!!!

Her musicality is second to none people! Looking and sounding absolutely gorgeous

I NEED THE STUDIO VERSION. CDQ.. THIS IS HER NEXT #1.

at the beginning of this video, the way she talks sounded exactly like her 90's speaking voice!!!

I feel like this could be a massive hit! A real R&B #1 smash!

The undisputable Queen of Christmas!

: we're all still here three years later, right? : ]

the most intelligent and talented artist ever!

I don't think any other r&b/pop singer has a sense of melody and songwriting like Mariah does. She is beyond talented! People need to see these moments of hers and appreciate them. What she did most artists wouldn't be able to do on the spot or at all for that matter. Her musicality has always been supreme.

This is the proof that she really wrote most of her songs 😍😍😍😍 #proudLambhere #confidentlybeautiful

Now we need a new album to break all Adele's records!

her whisper voice is so beautiful!

it's officially Christmas... MC did that :)

That legendary shrug of "I just slayed your lives" at 2:19 :D

True songwriting. Improvising on the spot. Your faves could NEVER

No one is at your level Mariah when it comes to adlib, impromptu and wit. It makes me smile listening to this, every year.

she's TOO GOOD

I wonder what kind of IQ she have.. she's so damn genius.. ugh.. 😕

The best vocalist, songwriter to ever do it. 👑👑👑

The last time she did something similar to this was on one of her concerts in Australia back in 2013. She really feels comfortable and confident on stage rather than on live tv. So good to see her performing and looking like this! Lambily 4 life!

2:16 that "new York" was so soothing !

@1:17 yas bitch. Yas. You better sang. And she looks absolutely beautiful.

She does it on the spot while it takes me a year to even write my first line.

I wish she actually make a song out of this...the melody is so right and puts you in that romantic Christmas feeling. Leave it to Mariah to find a melody and perfect it. Beautiful....

This should be a single!

#MARIAHHHHHHHUUUGHGHGHGGHGHGH UGHGHGGHGH WHEN YOU DO THESE THINGS!!!!!!!!

It's why the legends call her the Songbird Supreme. Fitting!

And the band also is sooo amazing. They quickly blend to Mariah's creativity. The next thing you hear, all instruments are playing.

let's make this viral. let's go lambs!

Can this go viral lol. She's so perfect

: MERRY CHRISTMAS, LAMBS! : ]

Wow! That talent emanating from her. To be in her presence is an honor. These people are so lucky and blessed!

This Woman is EVERYTHING! I cry everytime she sings literally just cry. No other artist will ever come close to Miss Mariah Carey

Wow this is actually a pretty great melody and not bad lyrics for improvising!

CHRISTMAS IN NEW YORK LYRICS (Impromptu) by Mariah Carey Happy-jolly and its merry Christmas in New York What you feel like doing today? Is it snow? Will it snow? Will it keep on raining snow? We gon' shopping We're not stopping Ain't no stopping Cuz' its Christmas in New York, New York We gon' be singing and shouting, pressing Its amazing Christmas in New York I'm free-styling, its not my best But we'll be still there, still there Its Christmas in New York (I feel like a dog???) cuz' I don't know much to say about it But the package is everywhere, City streets, bright lights and people I love you so, come you know to my Beacon show, oh oh oh oh We gon' make it snow, we gon' make it snow On the stage later on I hope we going to make it snow Let it snow, let it snow Christmas song makes me feel so good Especially when its Christmas in New York. Is this correct? Someone tell me if there are errors. I'm not quite sure about I hear "I feel like a dog" LOL! But I replayed it hundred times already. I will appreciate if you do. Thanks!

Freestyle rap only requires rhyming, freestyle singing like MC requires melody and rhyme...MC is geniussss

Yes Mariah !

She looks damn good! She sounds good too!😁

this is one of her best looks I've ever seen , she's just iconic

Happy, jolly and it's merry.. Christmas in new york. What a hook!

You won't be surprised if she said she can write a song in a min coz come on, she's the QUEEN!!!!!

46 HATERS

:( I wish Mariah could still sing like this, OH WAIT!

im really amazed on how she sounded today... but what impressed me more is that freestyle, she did an impromptu performance and make a song......

She needs to make this a song for real.

wow really awsome!!! New single CHRISTMAS IN NEW YORK come on ya we could make this happened!!

Wow your amazing MC let it snow

One reason why I'm a lamb ! Love this, make it go viral y'all !

U can see in here the personal who wrote 17 Number ones which is actually greatest than to have, 18 th N. ones , no other solo artist have but 17 wrote by himself i dont thing never again will be other , plas her 5,2 vocal Rangel the whistle register she use to , vocal técnic on the 90 th 00 th 10 th , and how she cope with her vocal issue For keep being one of the best vocalist through the rían .

: this is #1 with a bullet on my holiday chart!! : ]

Not only is she a helluva singer but this takes musicianship also. Go Mariah!

She looks beautiful!!!!!

it's not even Christmas but because of her I feel so 🎄❄

OMG????!that voice though.,,,❤️

That DIVA SHRUG is EVERYTHING!!! @2.21... Luv MC!!! >3

She looks and sounds AH-MAZING!!!

When Mariah doing improvisation still slay all those singers doing a proper song.

Come on !!!! Where are all the lip sync comments ? Where is Wendy Williams ..... they love to kick our girl ... come on .... where are you now ? Oh i forgot ....Mariah bought you all chairs for Christmas to have a seat !!!!!!

I love it when does things like this!!!! I saw her in Vegas and she was EXCEPTIONAL!! Going to see her in Dec.!!!!!!

She needs to finish this song and release it.

this is the incredible Mariah Carey she is an amazing song writter and her voice is unbelievable

Let it snow, let it snow, christmas time makes me feel so good especially when it christmas in new york!!!! love it...

Only the queen could pull this off lol

i was there that day

she looks and sounds amazing shes definitely in a new space

MARIAHHHHH!! She needs to make this song asap this Christmas! ☺️😍

nobody can touch the 90's mariah still doing her thing!!!

UNDENIABLE TALENT! She's got it to give awayyy!

she is LITERALLY God. #YaaasssssssQueen

Okay, but why do I know the lyrics to this impromptu moment like it’s a legit song? I have it committed to memory lol

On the spot baby :) #freestyling

I want this to be a real song ASAP.

I am in looooove

No one else like her!! Mariah is the all time best!!! This is proof SHE STILL GOT IT.

Yas, Festive Queen!

Oh myyyy I can't get enough. This woman's talent is just beyond words to be described. Truly sent from up above.

Her and her band’s musicality is AMAZING!

One word to describe "legendary"

She needs to make a new album right now with that beautiful ass voice sounding like an angel. She so talented i "can't even know what to say"! Not only her voice but her lyrics and melodies are amazing idk how she does it!