0:40 FATHER REFERENCE

I love how it doesn't focus on the victim but more on mario's deteriorating mental state and the victim is that little scare at the end.

The idea of being thrown into a world where everyone despises you and everyone close to you without explanation has abandoned you is genuinely an existentially terrifying thought.

This is such a fresh take on MARIO. I like how instead of Mario being evil and spooky, he's just confused about everything that's going on. He really acts as a Player stand-in. It's honestly a tad bit funny. The last part with the actually scary stuff is also phenomenal, nice way to tie in VICTIM 1, without them being the focus.

This is scarily accurate to how KZfaq and Newgrounds brainwashed an entire generation into thinking Mario was evil.

The sight and noises from whom I'm assuming is Mario dead inside a pipe, is very unsettling. This is great work man, love your horror

The fact that this is fully made in 3d is amazing.

The concept of Mario slowly going insane is fantastically on display here. I love this so much!

Alternative title: Mario explaining Yoshi his villain arc from 2014 to 2017

Yoshi giving Mario a dead pan stare is both funny and terrifying at the same time

The idea of everyone leaving you and blaming you for a perceived fault, people you once knew and trusted highly, is an extremely effective idea imo. It's a very unique form of loneliness and mental torture.

MARIO was probably one of the many creepypasta’s I saw as a child that managed to stick with me. As someone that grew up with Nintendo and especially Mario games, it’s terrifying to play a otherwise extremely normal game that has such a dark secret. Even scarier is the idea that MARIO is a ROM, leaving you to wonder who could’ve possibly made this. The victim? Or the offender? …. … .. . Don’t you think you’ve caused enough trouble?

Dammit, MatPat. You made Mario go insane.

Mario telling His problems* Yoshi: adios

Dude, I remember when this game first came out, and being so terrified when I saw the image file. Seeing this brings such a smile to my face. I’m so hyped for this. Edit: Wow, for being so short it’s really unsettling, and depressing, the way you make the body contort and move in such an extreme and unusual fashion really makes it unsettling, like a buildup to a jump scare, and when it displays a modified version of the original image at the last frame, it really spooked me, max respect for not using an audio stinger.

I LOVE how you actually cared about the messages in the original game unlike anyone else who made their own interpretations of this creepypasta! The whole idea of everyone blaming Mario for everything bad happening is realistic, perhaps he messed up once and everyone have highlighted that mistake instead of remembering the times when he did something right and blamed him for other things that he didn't do? *Wait that's literally Twitter*

I just love the voice choice for mario where it sounds a bit more like how he sounded like before Charles with a tiny bit of Charles’ voice.

I think this is now my most favorite vibing leaf video. Not only is it a video related to my favorite gaming creepypasta, but it's also well written and still creepy despite it being one minute long. You can feel how heart broken and desperate Mario is, how he tries to think of a reason why everyone is gone and why no one is around. You start to feel bad for the guy, but at the same time, you feel like something isn't quite right. And the fact that Yoshi is just listening and glaring at Mario like he is judging him, just makes me feel uneasy.

My guess is that Mario is a representation of a real man, and "yoshi" is one of his friends. there's some imposter mario that's making him look evil, akin to shadow mario in sunshine. When Yoshi disappeared, it was this "shadow mario" person who took him and put his corpse in the sewer.

Tbh this creepypasta is one of the best ive ever seen, no cliches and its just ends so abruptly it leaves you with thoughts like "What was the intention behind this ROM being made? Was it for somebody?"

Yoshi really went "That's cool and all but I gotta go pick up some milk brb"

I need to say, that was creative as hell, also, “corpse stuck in sewer pipes” is actually more creative than “body found on carpet”, especially for Mario creepypasta, W

Here's my take. After countless years of saving the day, Mario grew tired of it all. Perhaps he snapped at Peach. Told her she's useless for always getting kidnapped. Or maybe Mario really didn't do anything, and everyone turned on him for no reason. Whatever happened, it took a toll on Mario. Alone with his thoughts, he entered into a green pipe. But he never emerged from the other side. He got stuck down there. He'd scream and yell for help, but no one could hear him. For weeks he starved. Until eventually, he died. Three months later, he was found dead. His eyeballs had rotted out of the sockets. Now, Mario's soul is stuck in purgatory. He vents his frustrations to his former friends that were never there to begin with. For eternity he'll ponder about the pipe below him. If he chooses to look down, all he will see is his own rotten body.

Mario really let himself go since he got diagnosed with Terminal 7.

This was made in 3D? Even 1:08!?! God this is terrifying. I love the effect of the video it reminds me of the old school consoles, and the models are so cool! Look like the old 3D cover art. Honestly this was creepy as hell. Dude your vids keep getting better and better🔥

i love this take on the Mario's voice, sounds so different but at same time close to the og, like if Mario was actually saying something serious. smth i don't like at all is the new victim#1 text, it could be interpretated as something from the game like if mario did or as something outside the game, here is just in the mario universe. and also, the original line can be interpretated as a crime victim, here can even be mario himself stuck, (wich i honestly don't think since the face isn't similar in any way) don't get me wrong, i still love this and it's a nice interpretation, it's just that in my opinion the original line and history of the game can be interpretated in more of one way

0:40 Every dream Stan’s father be like

The MARIO hack is one of the only creepypastas from back in the day that were actually kinda spooky. I guess the fact nothing violent or super insane happens, which makes the story more grounded in reality. and while the rom-hack itself is pretty darn simple and just ends on a black screen, it leaves a whole lot of room for interpretation.

Ah, yes. The one creepypasta that scared me as a kid. It wasn't the story, just the image of the victim... I am so happy to see it be reimagined on this channel! Edit: Finished the video. I LOVE IT! Mario sounds so confused and desperate. The main thing I want to figure out is whether or not Mario actually committed the crime or not, assuming everyone hates him because they believe he did it. We can see his mental health deteriorating, but was it before or after the crimes? If it was before, I think an interesting take is him committing the murders, believing he was doing good, possibly from paranoia or some other belief which would justify him wondering why people hate him. He could've been confused by what was in the pipes because it was victim one. We don't know the exact time between each murder, so it could've been so long he forgot. If he didn't commit the crimes, people might just be blaming him because of a preconceived belief that, due to him not being mentally well at the time of the crimes, he must have been the one behind them. Especially if it was a very sudden change from his normal demeanor. If it was after the crimes, his mental state could be deteriorating due to both the blame and, if he did kill them, the guilt. He could be trying to deny that he did it both to convince others he didn't do it and himself that he didn't. So, his wondering of what is in the pipes could be from him pretending not to know. Nobody else is there, but pretending could be a coping mechanism and a way to convince himself he didn't commit the crimes. If he didn't do it, then the mental health deterioration is most likely due to the shunning and blame he is receiving for something he didn't do. Sorry for the long post I just love speculating on things. It is so fun to me.

Yeah, man, one of my favorite pastas! This is..actually kinda lorebuilding for the story, isn't it? At least a little.

This is exactly how I imagined this pastas mario to act. He doesn't understand what the hell is going on and why everyone hates him

There are content creators who have fun. And then there’s VibingLeaf. You are amazing man, turning one of favorite creepypastas into your own. Keep up the good work man

Actually disturbing for a 3d reimagining of the MARIO creepypasta's ending. Good job.

That is shockingly well animated, was not expecting that at all. Keep up the great work!

I absolutely love this retake! I think it's interesting and sad how since in the story Mario is in purgatory, and in this video he has a hallucination that yoshi is there with him, but he's really just talking to no one, and Victim#1 is keeping him in an endless cycle.

I feel like Mario is either suffering from Amesia or Dementia. Dude really can't recall if he murders or have become bad or not.

0:40 *Yoshi has left the server*

I adore the detail that focuses on the detail of Mario's mental state and the emotional charge that he is now "the bad guy", then the victim, in detail

The fact that the victim's eyeballs were unable to be found suggests that there may have been some kind of trauma or injury to the victim's head. However, without more information, it's impossible to determine the cause of death. The fact that the victim was found stuck inside sewer pipes raises questions about how they ended up there. It's possible that they were forced into the pipes or accidentally fell in, but again, without more information, it's difficult to say for certain. The fact that the corpse stayed in the sewer pipes for 3 months suggests that the victim may have been deceased for a significant amount of time before they were discovered. This could complicate any attempts to determine the cause of death, as the body may have undergone significant decomposition. Overall, this is a tragic and disturbing situation, and I hope that investigators are able to uncover more information about what happened to the victim.

oh my god thank you so much vibingleaf for this this was one of my most favorite creepypastas ever and im so thankful you decided to cover it!

As someone who is a fan of the original MARIO creepypasta, I love this so much.

God damn VibingLeaf, you never fail to make great and impressive content ❤

Bro this is amazing. I wouldn’t mind seeing it turned into a analog horror series showing off Mario’s decline into insanity.

I like the concept of Mario going insane from hoot knowing why people all of a sudden hate him.

The ambiance gives off the feeling of loneliness, desolate, and hopelessness...

mario after the hole internet still calling him sociopath

I love the angle on this, both literally and metaphorically. It plays on the romhack itself being so...inexplicable due to how and why it was made; As a joke that still genuinely freaked people out, and just happened to use Super Mario World as a vessel. As a result, even Mario doesn't actually know what the hell is going on or why he's been put through this. He's just another person trying to solve the mystery. A mystery that unfortunately, has no end-point by design.

damn its been many years since this really good creepypasta has gotten any acknowledgement, great video

vibingleaf, you have to be one of my new favorite youtubers. the work you do for these videos and reviving creepypasta really makes me happy. i cant wait to see your fnaf game. i already know its gonna be awesome

Short, innovative, and most importantly, EFFECTIVE. Jesus, the goosebumps I got from the ending scene are going to be unmatched for a really looooooooong time.

As he stared down into the abyss, He saw a figure, Staring back at him through the dark, And it was then that he realized why all this went down, Why everyone suddenly hated him, Why all that he was left with was the letters that showed him exactly what they really felt, He wasn't Mario, He just impersonated him in an attempt to keep the truth out of his own head, And now, He was alone, Left with nothing except a dead corpse, A reminder of why he's here, A reminder...of what he's done.

its interesting how Mario himself doesnt know whats going on

man, it's so awesome to think that these days you can just create amazing content like this by yourself with a computer and for free. It's so cool to be able to create stories in a little world made by yourself. Keep it up man!

SO excited that you got around to this one. I used to be obsessed with that Mario picture when I was younger. Absolutely awesome video

This is the type of video that you don't think much of in the morning but you hide under your blankets at nights because of it

The fact this is based on a true story on the creepypasta is crazy

god the victim looks horrifying I've been loving these shorter "Re-Takes" you have been doing

Funnily enough, this is completely in Charles' vocal range.

Wow, the highly anticipated and long awaited “Mario steals your liver reimagined” is finally out!

Me trying to impress this girl by telling things about me The girl: 0:40

Damn this looks amazing! The description says that several victims were found, and we only saw the 1st one, who are the other victims? I like how Yoshi doesn't seem to be real since in the og rom hack, he was just there without a purpose. Also why was the victim now found inside sewer pipes instead of lying on her carpet?

This recreation you made of the imfanous creepypasta mario is epic leaf 👍 Also i feel like victim 1 is actually Princess peach, because at the beginning of the mario rom hack it explains how mario is at it again instead of bowser which could possibly mean mario saved peach from bowser so many times he decided to just kill her so that he wouldn't have to go through the same cycle of saving her again, which caused everyone to hate him which explains all the hateful messages within the game like "dont you think youve caused enough trouble" and how at the end mario is filled with so much guilt he decides to kill himself by jumping down a pipe that leads to nothing, and he imagines doing it with yoshi even though in reality he is not there and mario is just hallucinating it

this is my favorite creepypasta. felt real, i remember not being able to sleep thinking her body was on my floor.

Fun Fact: The sentence for Yoshi would make sense if you play as Luigi. His model is different from Mario's its basically almost fully black but his eyes and gloves are visible.

Man this creepypasta has always been my favorite because of how real the myth really is with the actual game containing the image. This interpretation reminds me of the original red mist creepypasta with the victim report

I just found out what this is based off of and honestly you did an amazing job at making this creepier than what its based off of

that was so awesome i hope if you do another one (since the description says several victims were found) you reference the canon victim 2 and 3 descriptions

As a Sonic the Hedgehog fan, you really got me sympathizing with Mario, the poor guy is just confused about why everyone is against him, to the point he’s just going insane and hallucinating, imagining Yoshi was there, and then for the few seconds left, it shows the corpse Mario *SUPPOSEDLY* killed… “Victim #1” “Eyeballs were unable” “to be found.” “The victim was found stuck” “inside sewer pipes.” “Cause of death unknown.” “It was found that the corpse stayed 3 months in there” … *Jesus Christ!*

This has to be the best creepypasta channel ive seen so far

This is a Very well made reimagined version of that creepypasta

Props to whoever voiced mario, amazing content all around!

This will be Mario creepy pasta in 2015

Always wanted a video like this with MARIO and I got to say I definitely pretty glad also btw very unique take just having most it about Mario losing his sanity seeing things that aren't there.

This is short. but creepy and mysterious just like the creepypasta. good job

Oh god, where do I start? I remember the MARIO CreepyPasta when it was originally published, and with the image of Victim #1 does scarred so many people, even with the message of Victim #1 itself. With the retake/remake itself of the MARIO CreepyPasta is pretty much surreal to me. Especially with the fact that how Mario was out of character when he says the fact that everyone was against him. And the buildup for an unexpected scene have gave me the unnerving vibes there, and even the visuals itself is also fantastic. Anyways, hope you are having a wonderful day, and I definitely can't wait to see what other projects/retakes that you'll do next

the victim had 17 years according to the autopsy the mother of the corpse revealed that she was called *_C A R M E N W I N S T E -_*

Good job once again my friend! Creepy as always! (Please don't stop unless you want to)

Maybe none of this is in a Mario game, but Mario (the murderer) thinks he is in one, and doesn't remember the murder

you made a creepypasta that traumatized me feel actually human

Didn't think the image could be made worse, but apparently it can.

This is honestly so amazing. VibingLeaf does it again folks! :D

Wow that really makes creppypastas better cuz they come to life in ur vids great MARIO ROM reamake i hope for victim 2

I like that mario conserves his personality

Thanks for the video, it’s a great birthday present for me since I love analog horror (it’s my bday)

Did you use a Text to Speech program for Mario’s Voice? If so than you picked a great one for this

When you don’t do the Mario:

Omg I loved how u also included the police report thing (also I AM SUPER EARLY THIS VIDEO ONLY HAS 600 VIEWS WHAT)

A hood classic made into a masterpiece

Man, I remember listening to a reading of this back when I was a preteen. I could hardly stand to listen to it, I had to take a break every few seconds. Last week I turned 20, and some things never change!

Victim 1#. Eyeballs were unable to be found. The victim was found stuck inside sewer pipes. Causes of death unknown. It was found out that the corpse stayed 3 months in there.

This is both really good and unnerving!

Very well done as always!

poor mario, he's going insane because of the 2012 parodies of mario

Fun fact: that scary face is actually a girl doing a cosplay from a guy called "Kyo". This guy is a vocalist group from a Japanese band called "Dir En Grey" a band that was famous back 1990s. Many believed that was a photoshopped mango. The unedited image was discovered on september of 2023.

0:29 the look I give to the kid who tells the teacher about the homework they forgot about

Wow, this is amazing. Vibing leaf I’m very curious of. What is your plan for dead Bart retake

That was spooky. Great job!

The ending with the twitching dude is unsettling

This is terrifying and amazing!

my last comment was wrong so i will just fix some things this video is really great for having on how the character that you grew loving as a child being treated as the bad guy because of the large ammount of creppypastas