Perfectly told Talinh, perfectly told.

I read this in their voices

Oh yeah? How am I awful?

It makes sense though. Absolutely spot on, but this, in a way is exactly how they intend to be. Graham, represents the shoulder that you can cry on. He provides constructive criticism without destroying your soul. Gordon is a perfectionist who is completely insulted by dishes that taste bad, and look bad. Gordon takes it easy on people who check at least one of those boxes. If your plate looks like shit, but it taste good, he will find you useful, and vise versa. Joe, represents the Restaurant manager. He’s the guy who will attack your character on top of your cooking techniques because he’s the one who is going to tell you whether you can run a business or not. Its not about what or how you cook, it’s also who you are as a person. If you’re weak, if you’re an asshole, or if you take things too personally, you won’t make it. You will crumble. Joe is the drill sergeant of MasterChef.

@@nsalerno91 well said, dude

He's an asshole

@@ethenswords2134 Gordons passionate about food and cooking,Joe's just spiteful

Ben101 Joes much more serious than Gordan, both are cool dudes if you do the dish through their expectations.

Yeah...uh...you're right. Cant redeem Joe on this one. He's just a dick...BUT...i find his douchiness hilarious

Oh No how dare he be serious about his job

Nah he's just an ass

@@jacurururur8848 And a perv. He will be the next to join Mario Batali in the sex scandal.

At least he's not in full denial🤷🏻‍♂️

What did he do? What happened?

well said

That was during an interview after the event

Joe didn't taste his food and insulted him

@@thanos6635 but he was just saying what he thought in the interview after he finished making the dish.

Human Effigy I know! Joe was such a jerk...

human effigy ohhh the nostalgia :(

seems to me that all the judges felt bad for the guy, Joe was so unnecessary

I think Joe was absolutely right...I would have told the guy the same thing. Absolute waste of time

Human Effigy m

sej1895 THE WHOLE PLATE

I like douchbag 😂

Joe actually changes a lot in the later seasons, way nicer, still a bit harsh, but much better.

Food isn’t supposed to be wasted, chefs who waste food shouldn’t be called chefs

You forgot the "Thank you for nothing".

You should watch the whole episode

How tf are people defending Howard

@@leeeverett8497 its not even about him. Joe is just a dick in general

@@leeeverett8497 He isnt even critiquing it, He is just an asshole

@@doctorbrydin7294 joe's kinda right here tho. The guy asked why would he want to taste the same dish as others (it's not what he said but similar interpretation) when it's a replication challenge, but yeah he's really just an asshole too. Gordon often argue with him bcoz even tho the dish is good, joe still hate it 🤣

They wanna be like gordon..THE BOSS xD

Lol Joe is the one who wants to be Gordon xD The other chef is usually pretty sensible.

Lol I noticed that too, laaame. I think Joe doesn’t it all the time too lol

Agreed.

*Master

In my opinion, he demoralizes no one. He's just an arrogant prick. He doesn't taste the plates and he acts like he does it with his mind, he doesn't let the judges taste the plates because he has thrown so many dishes that Masterchef is now under dept (could be), he insults you - *and not only your food* - like he's your enemy ... I mean hey man, you're not that badass. Calm the fuck down arrogant bitch. He thinks that he just came out of a fucking Netflix series. He's ridiculous and predictable.

madmaxgaming Walker no he’s not Italian, even we Italians can’t stand that arrogant dick

@@Malaachi31 he is though lmao

@@Madmaxgaming130 no he's not. And you can argue the family is not Italian to begin with.

apostolis anastasiou yeah but you are only justifying the contestant, because Joe might be rude but he certainly knows better about cooking. And if we keep justifying contestants’ mistakes they’ll never learn. And also, I’m Italian and if you want to watch some MasterChef Italy videos you gon see that the level is totally different, and since in Italy food and cooks are a lil bit better, now back in America Joe certainly isn’t satisfied

😂

There's no honour amongst thieves

But he already obtain his narcissist while the other guy... pray for his soul.

Howard is not a narcissist. If he was he wouldn't admit that he is not "confident in his dish". He also agreed with the older lady... If he was a narcissist his dish would have been perfect and the judges would be stupid idiots. On the other hand Joe showed many signs of narcissism. He thought only his opinion matters and devaluated the people who might like Howard's cooking by calling them "6 people at a dinner party" he also had comments about the elderly judge and said she was just being nice which is also a form of devaluation and giving more importance to HIS honest opinion. Also the word spin at the end and the fact he threw the dish away before the other judges had a chance to taste shows he is looking for attention not only amongst the contestants but the other judges as well...

Maybe he's speaking as an expert on the subject of being a narcissist 😂😂😂

@@hshshshshshshs8831 WRONG. Joe is SPOT ON. Howard was completely narcissistic. Of course they expect one of the same from each. This is to show you have mastered the art and basics of cooking.

This is how you know that he is a protective and nice person. He even insults the food to hide the reality behind his actions. It's like flushing drugs down the toilet infront of a junkie.

The fat guy loses weight because of Joe.

That fat guy isn't fat anymore nowadays lol. Maybe thanks to Joe.

elchucofried There is legend that each time Graham tries to eat somewhere Joe just magically appears and throws his food into the nearest bin

elchucofried There is legend that each time Graham tries to eat somewhere Joe just magically appears and throws his food into the nearest bin

it is if you can cook.

That's what I was thinking...

im not sure but i think bc the mom talked about classics they were supposed to make a more rustic dish, not a high experiment

no, it was a challenge to replicate a dish, so making your own adjustments was not part of the challenge

😂

@@thenameless2016 joe isn’t self made so no good

@@thenameless2016 Marco Pierre white is my favorite chef of all time no one will ever be better he’s self made and came from nothing I heard his childhood story...

@@thenameless2016 😂joe mama diary of of a wimpy kids

@@thenameless2016 yeah joe can’t even compare with Marco or Gordon lol they are miles ahead of him

Webbs Kruiser he said don't be in denial of it, maybe he's accepting of his own narcissism. I mean this is a too 1%-er who isn't exactly known foe his philanthropy telling a rookie chef that HE'S a narcissist.

Yes but Joe is Actually good at what he does

Joe sits in his throne on master chef, enough said

@@callumwebb4927 yeah, he's good at being a narcissist

@@autismisuncontrollable4925 He seems everything but narcissistic to me. He's a very empathic person actually.

I think he was quite speechless that Joe did it in style too haha

+Choco Later in style? that gay bald is pure shit

+Miko Okay. To be fair, Howard was being incredibly arrogant throughout the competition and he even went as far as to do the exact opposite of what they had instructed him to do, missing the point of the challenge. Furthermore, Joe went on record saying that stuffed pasta is something that is very dear to him on a personal record before the challenge started. So it also really offended him personally. Trust me when I say that he can back up anything he says or critiques. He knows his stuff.

+Jacob Voronkov whatever man but... what I mean on my hating on him is. He wants to be like Gordon Ramsay. I know that guy for some months watching some of his whatever videos n stuff. Little by little together with gordon ramsay. Now his rudeness and ridiculous looking face is getting higher.

JOE IS A COCKY ARROGANT PERSON--HE'S DONE THE SAME TO HIS MOTHER

Bcs someone is gonna die

Idk TV be like that

@@retardbuster1498 😆 lol

Yea why is a good question because joe is not a boss. He's not even a chef

He is not in denial about it 😆

I mean, I guess it takes one to know one. Like, the guy looked into the face of narcissism and realized it looked exactly like him. Bald, albeit more explosive.

Damn right girl. Only a real man has the balls to go bald. And we know it. We get more pussy then other men because we are masculine. Girls won't leave me because they need that sense of protection and not some pretty boy. I call the shots because I am a man. I won't have it any other way.

You are no doubt a fat, 20+ yr old male virgin living in mommy and daddies basement - fuck off!

sure you are, sure..

Homestuck Kawaii the only difference is that one is successful af while the other failed to boil pasta and use the correct ingredients

Now that you say it. I wish he did the Amy's Baking Company episode instead of Ramsay.

Enigminator oh man, I would watch that, definitely

Enigminator I would love to see that. It would be music to my ears. They could have them come onto the Masterchef show.

omg........Amy and Sammy would literally kill him XDXDXDXD

To be honest I would say to him "With the second part you mean yourself? As even Ramsay Gordon isnt as much of an ass as you are and hes certainly much better cook. Im done. Good bye." and I would leave the show instantly. That Joe thinks too highly of himself and the "Narcissist in full denial (of his own cooking level)" fits him so good that he basically described himself.

@Chloe Welsh ...ok? no one really asked...?

Chloe Welsh troll

Yes but he knows what good food tastes like, so when it isn’t good, obviously his point is valid, no?

@@user-ni7ui1nk8p I mean not necessarily I’m pretty sure regular people like us know when food is bad he not even a chef so he basically like the rest of us food tasting wise

@@yadig1423 but he owns a restaurant so obviously his standards will be high.

Say it right, Joe is a twat who shouldn’t even be a judge, anyone with either common sense or the ability to do a google search should know that

twat

are you 9?

Twat

Who the fuck censors twat

He's not wrong on that one!

Did anyone else hear morgan freeman say this

Actually yes. You WANT 15 of the same dishes. That is consistency. You make GOOD food CONSISTENTLY, you are a great chef.

Uhhhh yeah? That's why is funny :D

+christopher morrone The moment you know you're fucked: even Gordon flinches at your comment to Joe

Xd

Hes not wrong lol

@@sheshiechan F U C K

@@happylittlematty 😨😆

He is italian and they cooked pasta sooooo

@@moonknight5743 one of the dumbest things I've read in awhile.

@@Vendrix86 the guy he judged here cooked pasta and so what????

@@moonknight5743 you implied that he's italian and he cooks pasta...as if that in itself makes him qualified. The point that the OP is making is that this guy isn't a cook, he's a businessman. You don't seem to comprehend that for some reason.

Rocelyn S Wait what?

but it was RAAAAAWWWr!!

That attitude is raw, and frozen, and doesn’t even lamb sauce

He was licking his lips

Ramsay be like. "I wanted to say that!"

+LeafBucket He fucking destroyed that guy lol

When he insults someone, he makes sure it sticks

I don't think it is. In my opinion, he basically described himself. The guy just made a question, and Joe insulted him like that guy just bunged Joe's mother.

@apostolis Howard didn't asked a simple question, he was trying to be a smartass with his question and he got served.

DarkPiggy Howard only asked that because Joe was like "you would duplicate the dish"; he just took it a bit too far

Gordon Ramsay: Intelligent criticism that melts you down and pressures you into becoming a diamond. Joe Bastianich: Personal insults that crush you, demoralize you, and implode you into becoming dust.

But at least Joe is a good chef

@@qqq386 Joe a good chef? Joe is not a chef Lewis, the guy owns a few restaurants and winery's but that's about it. Joe was never a professional chef.

@@devineleven1818 r/wooosh

@@TrashSniper what was the joke?

If you saw this season, you can see that Joe had his back and was trying to help him. This is how the contestant paid him.

xmonks 😂😂😂

If you'd seen the whole season, you would know why Joe is so pissed at him before tasting the food.

It's about his behaviour not the food

Howard just argued cooking with Joe's mother one of the more famous Italian chefs. Of course he'd be upset. I think he was DQ'd for presenting something he didn't cook.

Exactly, joe there to taste their food and help to them get better at cooking, not insult them like some high school bully.

Me: is you fucking blind? 1:40

Nah if u see Christina next few seasons, y'll want joe back so badly

I really missed Joe; Christina is unbearable.

In NYC, I knew a manager that worked at one of Joe’s restaurants, the guy is a complete clown along with everyone that works for Joe and Joe himself is “cheap trash trendy liberals”.

Joe nuts

*Joe is so bad that he’s ironically entertaining to make fun at*

Who Joe?

Nice catch 🤣

@@robertisham5279 Who else?

@@robertisham5279 Joe.... MAMA

Chef Ramsay wouldn't toss your food unless it really was trash.

@@MrOarson yea

I would've asked the bald guy "and you are?" His reaction 1:14.

Another thing that some people have seem to forgotten These are amateur cooks that are trying to achieve a title that would have taken them years to get in months Joe is being harsh because people like the contestant there think he's the big shot and deliver half assed dish Joe has every right to be pissed

It's a replication test for God's sake. Not a creativity test

@@abhishekagarwal3852 that as well and seeing how he botched the dish it's a wonder why people are calling him a jerk

Who puts jalapeños in an *Italian* dish? Keyword:Italian

@@spazerabanekozeroshki Really? I see joe being an asshole literally to every participant, and him being a fucking hypocrite is the biggest irony of them all. He is known as a chef because of his parents, not as if he is thriving. And should I mention the fact that he critiques the personality not the fucking food, literally each one of your arguments fail. Gordon ramsay has been impressed by a chef who is really cocky but makes some good food. Does he complain about it? No.

ZAIN AKBAR trust me he can. “I can *cook* Joe...” The most cold and brutal thing you’ll ever hear him say honestly

@@madison1858 😆

Ramsay is way more terrifying in Hell's Kitchen because in Masterchef, at least there's a lot of people who can cook while in Hell's Kitchen, there's a lot of idiot who likes to ruin food and focus on drama. In Masterchef, the dramas happen in the house or after the challeng while in HK, the dramas always happen in kitchen especially on service. Also, Ramsay is way softer in Masterchef.

Idk what you're talking about. Joe's insults lose all their impact when Joe is the one saying them.

His entire childhood has been “joe mama” jokes. Now he is a hardened, cold man incapable of giving helpful criticism, living in fear of his past.

@@thenameless2016 Okay, there’s a fine line between giving helpful criticism for people to improve and being a toxic pessimist to berate others, which you seem to be the latter. Joe is rude, at least in this clip, and does not tell the contestant how to improve his dish. If you cannot teach without humiliating people for their mistakes, you should not be in any service industry. At least Gordon knows when to be compassionate, and when to speak his mind.

@@thenameless2016 shut the fuck up, and take a joke

@@thenameless2016 “You toxic rat” says the one that cant take a dumb joke and is being toxic to everyone in this comment. B r u h

Poor bastard already deleted his comments in shame

Ask him to come out for a chat after the show and he hides behind his bitch of a mother. Worthless family of narcissistic pieces of shit

Exactly. He has always been a terrible judge. Ugh can't stand him

@@brayallen7290 ?????????????????????????? He is a good judge lol

😂😂😂 you made my day

Giano182 i waould watch if i understand the language

Giano182 😡

DooDee0608 There’s something named SUBTITLES.

Paul not every video have subtitle in it ?

LINK!!!!

...he fucked up

...he had his foot out the door and his one-way ticket home.

He was right though like come on you really want 10 of the same dishes!!!!

@@glitteringdusk9651 Well, it was a replication task. You can tweak it. BUT little by little. Replicate the dish before you elevate it.

15**

Why was I laughing so hard at this.. xdddd

lolthat comment made my day, thx...

i died at this xD

and then Bear Grylls eats his own shit

HA

Ridley I just realized that this whole show is scripted....

@@abolisher it’s not scripted , it’s a real competition show

You missed the part where he said that he did this multiple times and every time he shows up with puppy teary eyes.

oh fuck yeaaah

TheBlack yeti lmao the fight of a lifetime

Ohh yeah that would be a awesome fight good idea

Haha yeah!

I'd actually root for amy and the husband😂😂😂

"fuck me, I mean, I should have used those insults"

Yeah... He was probably taking notes lol

_"fuck my arse"_ no, that's too gay for him to say

I always like to think he's thinking, "I never even get to try the food because this asshole throws it out EVERY TIME!"

+Amaethon fuck you

I know. Comparing Gordon Ramsay to Joe Bastianich is like comparing a bee to a wasp. Gordon represents the bee, who only gets pissed when attacked or insulted. Joe's the bastard wasp, who waits for a target and suddenly attacks him/her.

0mgiPiex everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

His mom is the chef he is a rich prick that thinks he knows everything

So true, this guy sees Ramsay yell and people and thinks it's totally ok for him to do it too, but really it isn't because he's just a dick when he does it

I was watching a compilation the other day, and I realized that Chef Ramsay will taste something, say whatever he honestly thinks about it, then Joe will taste it, say exactly what Ramsay said, and then throw it out. At least have some respect for the kitchen staff. Graham always goes hungry, but that's beside the point. The point is Joe knows only a little about cooking, and kind of bullshits his way through everything else, like same thing in this video she tastes the dish, and then he comes up, and just says that it's worse.

Random Guy Seems like it.

Marco Pierre White?

@@robertisham5279 yes

Marco is the GOAT

I believe my skin is too thick for him.

+Scott Velez You talk tough but I don't think anyone's skin is too thick for him

Oscar Hayden (Perdition Bound) Well, I'm not saying I'm tough... But I don't even shed a tear at funerals

+Scott Velez Fair enough. But a stare from Joe makes funerals look like a ten minute wank

I wonder what Marco Pierre White would think of Joe Bastianich.

+David Dimalanta yeah lol! that was delivered well. howard serves joe a plate of shit to taste. in return, joe serves howard his ass on a plate! haha!

EtherealAesthetic LOL! I bet Howard enjoyed his meal after he shut the fucked up by Joe.

+David Dimalanta yea at the end gordan ramsay was like oh damn gotta learn from that

Itachi | tf LOL! And, he'll gonna Ramsay'd for it later on using his new arsenal he learned.

He's not the shit, he's plain shit.

When did he talk back?

You can see Joe's brain go into fight or flight mode right when that music starts too. Makes it even funnier.

@@crystalwater505 right????🤣

It's MASTERchef. It's about some of the most talented people in the country, and at a bare minimum you should have a basic idea of how to cook food properly, and how to harmoniously mix flavors.

with the difference that in this case they asked them to REPLICATE a dish, not create something of their own. and he did not replicate it, purposely

He decided he doesn't like the bloke after he spent a chunk of the season getting all weepy that his dish sucked. That kind of person pretending to be talented and pretending to be a chef has no place in a serious competition.

majesty327 That's fair enough but it's still a cooking competition regardless and I just happen to think it's very unprofessional to reveal your obvious dislike of anyone when judging.

LilyK. Oh fair enough, I'm in the UK and have not watched this as a whole, so maybe my comment only applies generally and not specifically to this scenario.

lee frazile ikr he's like "fuck me that's my job"

Nah Howard was at the bottom consistantly and wasnt listening and grasping everyone's adivice

@@veenakrishnan823 Howard was bad, but that attitude sealed his fate.

@@danbradley9754 yeah and joe was pissed bcause, he went out and said that Howard had potential in front of everyone

Twitch Chronicle lol you’re good

I wanna see him smash several plates over their faces.

korruption maybe Robert Irvine

korruption*nods head several times*

BEST COMMMMMEEENTTTT EVER

Though nothing anyone says to that crazy woman will make her change for shit....

Thank you! Someone with a brain 👊

That or “You know what else you can sample? My dick”

I mean it was a duplication test and the guy decided he wasn't going to follow contest rules. That screams narcissist with no respect for the people he's feeding. By all means Joe had the right to be pissed.

It makes sense if you know the original dish so well that you can make it with your eyes closed. But if you're a pretty weak participant (and Howard was regularly among the worst before that) then maybe it would be more logical to make exactly the original dish, whose recipe was shown to you? 15 equally good restaurant-quality dishes it may not have been so interesting from the point of view of producers who want to see trash on the plate of evil judges spat out food and Joe throwing portions into the trash. But from the point of view of the judges as people giving advice and acting as some kind of mentors to these homecook chefs - it would be nice. That everyone performed equally well and everyone listens to the advice they are given.

This was a recreation challenge and also you could maybe make a small little tweak if you want but what Howard did was way too much

yeah there’s a difference between being a harsh critic and just being rude-

He is talking to a mirror

Zé Silveira It's a shame that he won't be on the show for season 6, he really does make the show more intense.

Zé Silveira yeah hes the simon cowell of masterchef. now joe is replaced with some dumb broad

neonballroom93 MasterChef isn't MasterChef without Joe, but Christina Tosi...is both a qualified...and rather attractive...addition to the current season. I LIKE HER.

Damian Blue don't call her a dumb broad just cause hes not a big jackass like joe

Sagittaire Christina surprised me. I expected her to be the typical "nice" judge like so many other reality shows do. But damn, when she gets pissy, look out.

Chef Scott might be a wannabe Gordon Ramsay in HK, but even he can be taken more seriously and is more respectable than Joe.

Or Marco Pierre White