Andy’s panicked ASL at 1:31 gives me life

the panic in andy's eyes before each song is such a mood

andy's confusion before bursting into song is the funniest thing

Andy, getting into it: Who made me so sad... Andy: *gets cut off and looks offended* Matt, extremely scared and confused: *mAMA*

andy looks so offended when his light turns off

When Andy starts signing when it’s Hanschen’s solo in My Junk 😍

I love how Andy didn't even think about the signing he just started doing it

I love when Andy starts signing

andys excited shouting of 'fUCKED' is so funny

my wig has left the building

I love that andy is doing his sign language at his solo in my junk xD. It seems like he just *has* to do that when he is singing the part xD

the slow shift of facial expressions in the dark I know well from "HA we figured out what song it was" to "wait... this song... sad..."

darned impressive to sing mid-cue with song switch-ups... for songs they didn't sing no less!

I love how Andy started signing. That's so adorable and shows he remembers it and is important to him.

Love it when Andy starts signing along while singing

I love how andy started signing during my junk!

Hi, again Playbill. It's been 4 weeks since I first commented and I'm still here waiting for someone to respond. Since November 11th, I've repeatedly asked you on all forms of social media (commented on here, messaged on KZfaq, Tweeted, tagged on Tumblr, messaged on Tumblr, & emailed) and still no one has responded to my easy request of turning on Community Captions. Auto captions are NEVER a reasonable substitute for FULL captions. By not doing captions yourself (or not turning on Community Captions) and just allowing KZfaq to auto caption the video you are leaving out an extensive community who would enjoy the video too. I won't leave it alone, until there are captions on this video.

andy deserves the world

The Hanschens! I love them so much ♡

Man, Matt Doyle is so talented ;_; I especially enjoy how he sings his part of 'And Then There Were None' 2:20

Someone should do a special vid with Andy & all the Ernsts he's ever performed with like Joshua Castille, Ben Moss, & Ben Fankhauser (& more? Lol hard to keep track)

2:43 just so soft when Andy's singing.

Almost two years later and I'm still coming back to watch this video. So precious!

WoW, why I am only finding this video now ? Absolutely brilliant.

This is one of the BEST videos to ever exist & it leaves me wanting more!!

Omg Matt Doyle had a glo up

Oh my god, I miss Spring Awakening so much. It was the first show I ever saw and Christy Altomare was Wendla.

Andy's signing when he gets to sing a Hanschen line. :) So funny. Although he was probably barely aware he was doing it. A total muscle memory.

THEYRE BOTH SO ADORABLE

i was smiling the whole time

It was so cute when he started signing!

The one dislike is Herr Sonnenstich

i am so blown away by how quickly andy can get into key halfway through songs he didnt even sing, what an absolute icon especially from mama to bitch?? amazing

Hey wait that was the best thing I’ve ever seen?

THIS VIDEO IS WHY I LIVE AND BREATHE

The panic when the music changes is amazing

Ooooh, Andy is wonderful. Very very wonderful.

When Andy started signing his part in my junk omg a babe

I love Matt jumping to reach the high note 😂

My favorite part is Andy panicking and then yelling “YEAH YOU’RE FUCKED ALL RIGHT”

im crying i miss spring awakening sm :(

i love the fact that andy signed his part of my junk 💕💕

This is my new favourite video on the internet

Are you going to caption this video? If you aren't, can you turn on Community Captions, and I will.

I love how Andy starts signing in my junk😍

awesome andy go baby !!!

Clearly the harmony at the end proves there should have been more in this video.

1:32 why is that signing so gorgeous Probably cause it's coming from a gorgeous man And ASL in general is a sort of art I only noticed that on like my dozenth watch Also smthn about it is subconscious and instinctual Anyway *Beautiful*

I NEED A COVER OF ANDY MIENTUS SINGING THE DARK I KNOW WELL ASAP

Damn Andy me ent us

I love Andy doing ASL to remember the words xD

I love this! Can't stop watching this vid! Well done Matty & Andy, good job xo 😉

I swear they changed the song every time when it was Andy's part just to fuck with his (already) panicked mind.

andy impresses me SO MUCH in this video!!!! he seriously knows his SA songs😂

wow so good at catching them

Andy's so cute

Oh man, this was amazing. Loved it.

I love this so much

love love love it

me when i play spring awakening on shuffle

This was beautiful!

Everything I did not know I needed

why can't I like this more than once

this is precious

I LOVE THIS WOW YAS

I have been Baptised from this video

i love.

YES

why did i JUST notice andy going “woooork” after totally fucked im literally dead

Interesting that they made Andy the only one that had to figure out the songs from the music cues. Much tougher position than Matt's.

😍😍

#blessed

Well heck.

god is real and exists as this video

The quiet "oh god"

🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

Andy looks sooo different

More

andy meringue is such a quuerio

Playbill, please make a video with these two together bi-yearly at least. Thank you.

OMG!! they look like twins.

Anyone almost burst out laughing when Andy started signing his lines for My Junk?

I might motherfuckin cry

hahahahhaha this needs to be done with every musical

This is the funniest thing ever

andy: *panic* YEAH YOURE FUCKED ALRITE

2:14 2:27

My only context and knowledge for Matt Doyle is from mbmbam

Is that Matt Doyle??

They didn’t make them do word of your body reprise

Captions? Please?

is that matt doyle?

is that matt doyle

ALBUM PETER AND THE HUSBAND OF OFFBROADWAY PETER SINGING TOGETHER I D I E

is that Matt doyle?

Do you think.... maybe.... is that Matt Doyle...?

HIS GAY LAUGH AT 1:16 OML

I swear Andy like baaaas at 2:41

MATT DOYLE????? MATT DOUyLE

I've watched this video far too many times