آزاد نے پاکستان کے بارے میں جو بھی کہا اوہ سب سچ ثابت ہوا

No matter even if he was a muslim intellectual, we Indians will forever be thankful to such a visionary education minister like him who gave us IITs, IIMs & AIMS that too in Such a challenging time but he never compromised with the importance of STEM for India's education. If India's education ministers of later times were even a inch visionary like him, our education system could have competed with the education system like china

Jinnah has British mindset but Azad indian mindset Humanity concepts

Maulana Qalam Sahab was great representative of humanity. We have great respect for him

Difference between muslim nationalist and nationalist muslim

Jisey ALLAH chahey usey kaun mitaey. PAKISTAN ZINDAHBAD.

برصغیر کے نامور شخصیات میں شمار ہوتا تھا اللہ تعالیٰ انکی درجات بلند فرمائے

Mulana Abdul Kalam Azad ne jo baat ki wo sache sabit hoi hum logo qomiyat ma batay howy hain

Proud as a Pakistani (my grand father from UP India) And lots of thanks for Jinnah Sahab after Allah pak for MY LOVELY MY FAITH PAKISTAN ❤️❤️❤️💐💐💐🌺

Defining "Nation" and "Nationalism" is probably one of the hardest topics to discuss. We as Muslims have been quite unclear about drawing a clear line between where it starts, and where it ends. The crux of the matter is how you define "nation" and "nationalism". I myself personally, advocate for "Islamic Nationalism" rather than Regional Nationalism. Regions and boundaries have been, and will always be subject to changes. No country/empire is permanent.

Molana Kalam was the real leader of the subcontinent.

India wins freedoms the last 30 pages of Azad are best pages I have ever learned 😊😊😊

آپ سے نام بولنے میں بار بار بھول ہوئی ہے۔ ان کا نام عبدالکلام نہیں بلکہ ابوالکلام تھا۔

ابوالکلام آزاد کتنا سچا آدمی تھا یار، کیا دور اندیش ولی تھا۔۔۔۔

His name is ABUL Kalam , not ABDUL Kalam. Voice over person didn't read it well and no one even noticed ?

Allah darjat buland farma de ...Aamen a great sincere leader of subconenent ....will be live in our hearts and minds forever😍😍❤

عبدالکلام نہیں ابو الکلام

Molana Abul kalam Azad ny jo kuch kaha ...wo bad main bilkul sach sabit huwa

We indian proud of maulana,azad, jinnah is not a Muslim wo khanjeer ka meet khata tha sharab peeta tha usne kabhi namaz nahi padi aur uska Mazar bana diya

دن کو عشائیہ نہیں ظہرانہ ہوتا ہے

Molana *Abdul kalam* × Molana abul kalam √

Molana Azad was a miraculous human being among devils and stupids. India was lucky to respect him and gave him due respect.

Thanks nice information of Abdul Kalam

Allah Jannat Naseeb Kara Ameen Ameen Ameen

برصغیر کی تقسیم اصل میں مسلمانوں کو تقسیم کرناتھا تاکہ برطانیہ اپنا اثرورسوخ قائم رکھ سکے. دوسرا جو شراب اور ش

His only mistake was not to resign from congress when it decided to accept partition of India. Azad should have continued to struggle to stop partition from independent platform with like minded peoples

Abul kalam azad was a great person I wish we could have remain united

Excellent

Azad was not a leader of Muslim people. He was a congress activist who pushed congress policy faithfully. After partition, since no Muslim was left on leadership platform, he assumed the role of Muslim leader, albeit still a congress man. As for his policy of united subcontinent, Hindutva ascendency, has proven him wrong. He stood as a genocide against Muslims happened in Hyderabad Deccan. I would rate him a great failure as far as Muslims are concerned. They made him remove Urdu. He was a Urdu scholar.

Maulana azad preficted the same for india as happening and this is the real reason of his anti Pakistan ideology he said in his interview that many muslims will go to Pakistan but those who cannot travel to Pakistan will be in great problem as hindus and Sikhs won't give them their rights but if there is a large quantity of Muslims then the quantity is enough to get their rights

A worrier

Time proved abul kalam was a visionary man😢

Maulana azad Pride of india❤❤❤

Good❤️🤲

Zabardast

The speaker is saying abdul kalam and not abu al kalam... please rectify your mistake.

مولانا ابو الکلام آزاد۔ بلکل سئی درست تہیں

Abul Kalam Azad was not a representative or leader of muslim people. He was a congress political activist and followed the directives of Congress high command. First speech he gave to muslims was after independence. There were many different leaders and parties, with different views and aspirations who wanted to lead muslims. The most popular muslim party was Muslim League; Iqbal and Jinnah belonged to this party. In provincial election of 1946, ML’s manifesto was based on separate nation of Pakistan, a clear majority of muslims (69%) voted for Muslim League and Pakistan. If Azad was a true democrat he should have accepted this mandate gracefully. However, neither Azad nor Congress nor India accepted this democratic will of muslim people to this date. These are the facts.

VERY INFORMATIVE AND NICELY PRESENTED ❤THANKS

Great man✨♥️

Why she is calling him Maulana Abdul Kalam? He is Maulana Abul Kalam

Mohammad Ali Jinnah is in the British mind set. Maulana Azad is in the humanity mindset. He is a dynamic and intense indigenous leader.

❤❤❤❤❤

❤❤❤

Quaid e Azam vision prevailed in all times. Even more now as a bright sun. Molana Azad aaj hota tu jotian ghata........

Thank you Quaid e Azam

❤

شُکریہ!

Allah-Hu-Akbar !!! Astaghfirullah !! Guilty conscience !!

کاش کے آزاد بھی زندہ ہوتے اور کا ان کا نظریہ بھی زندہ ہوتا 😢

Wonderful information

Great man ❤

کہتےھے لڑوں نھیں لڑاؤ 😢😢 ھمارے ساتھ وہی ھوا جس کا ڈر تھا تحریک آزادی کے جانبازوں کی راہ میں روکاوٹ 😢😢😢 مجھے یقین ھے ابوالکلام آزاد کی سوچ فکر تحریک نظریہ بےکارنھیں تھا بلکہ امتیاز تھا وہ الگ بات ھے ھماری ٹکراؤ چھوٹی کی فرنگیوں سے تھی تحریک آزادی کے جانبازوں کو سلام پیش کرتےھے

This video opened with the narrator reading the name wrong made it completely meaningless. It's not Abdul Kalam it's abulkalam. Bbc is losing it fast now.

Allah Magfirat farmaye

REQUEST TO BBC, URDU. KINDLY DO NOT DELETE MY COMMENTS/ OBSERVATIONS, Again: 1. The above broadcast is the exact urdu translation of a previous broadcast made by Rehan Fazal (ریحان فضل) through his famous fortnightly programme named "VIVECHNA" ( विवेचना) aired by BBC, Hindi Service about 3- 4 months back. Rehan Fazal is a marvelous story teller, researcher & narrator. He is very popular among the BBC, Hindi audience. His research, on a topic that he chooses to present, is generally reliable & authentic. 2. The above programme on Maulana Azad is indeed very informative , except about his "Character Assasination" done deliberately or inadvertently( God knows better) painting Azad as a great islamic scholar, who subsequently became a "drunked" at the fag end of his life, (when he became the Education Minister). Especially , when Maulana Azad is not alive to defend himself against this allegation. 3. Rehan Fazal , his motives unclear, has relied upon a book by Mr. M.O. Mathai(1909- 1981). Mathai was a personal secretary from 1946 to 1959 of India's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. Mathai was removed/ dismissed from his post in 1959 on the ground of corruption. 4. Mathai in his two infamous books( authored by him) , namely " Reminiscences of the Nehru Age (1978)" and My Days With Nehru(1979) have seriously criticised Nehru, Mrs. Gandhi and others including Maulana Azad ( of him turning into a cherisher of champagne & whisky). Absolutely nonsense. 5. Even supposedly , it is correct, would Rehan Fazal dare to speak or narrate such" nonsenses" in his programme "VIVECHNA" about those Indian eaders against whom Mathai have indulged in Character Assasination, in his books mentioned above giving references or quoting from those books. He will certainly not. Late Khushwant Singh (خشونت سنگھ) have called Mathai a Namakharam about his dirty comments against Jawaharlal Nehru. My this post is at variance with my original post made about three hours back.

Kash aisa hota Lekun jo khuda ko manzoor tha...

He was a great visionary

Please name any female voiceover urdu channels on youtube

Sir, both Mr Jinnah and Mr Abul Kalam Azad were very complex personalities . Both loved wine and smoking and yet represented Indian Muslims standing on either side of 2 nation theory. It shows the variation and diversity of Islamic ummah !

Azad's biography "India Wins Freedom" clearly indicates that real power was in the hands of Hindu leadership comprising Mohan Das Gandhi and Jawahar Lal Nehru, Azad could not do what he wanted to do like making government in UP. Azad did just clerical work for the Congress party. It is a fact, if you do careful study of his book referred above.

پہلے جملے میں آپ نے کہا عبدالکلام انکا نام ابو الکلام آزادھے۔

How many Muslim Ministers in Modi Government. How many Muslim CM in India ? How many Muslim Army ,Air ,Naval Chiefs?

Jinnah ghalat nahiin tha. . Aur azaad Sahib theek kehty hain . Prediction was the great 👍🏻 by azad

مولانا آزاد ❤

Qauid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah Rehmat Ullah Alliah Zinda Abad

His actual name was Abul Kalam Not Abdul Kalam. Azad was absolutely right in his vision.

Poor VO. The lady continuously kept saying the name wrong..... Its ABUL not ABDUL..... A VO artist should know the difference.

What a Great Leader Muhammad Ali Jinnah RA. ❤❤❤

نارسائی کے احساس سے ضبط کے حوصلے غم کے سیلاب میں بہہ گئے ، آنکھیں پتھرا گئیں پاؤں شل ہو گئے جاگتے جاگتے جسم و جاں سو گئے

😊🎉🎉

شراب سے متعلق کسی ایک شخص کی لکھی روایت کو شامل کرنا علمی اصول کے خلاف ہے، کسی بھی روایت میں وٹنس ہونا ضروری ہے۔ کوئی اور دو تین لوگوں کی اس سے متعلق آرا ہوتیں تو ہی درست تھا یہ روایت شامل کرنا،اتنے بڑے ادارے کو غیر ذمہ دارانہ امر سے اجتناب کرنا چاہیے۔

Why Gandhi and nehru didn’t support maulana Azaad

He was president of national conference, he sacrificed his position for the shake of freedom of India. Nehru was indirectly responsible for it,(even in the English movie Gandhi this topic was enlightened, no one apposed it). Else Azad as president of NC had chance of becoming first pm.

تقسیم تو مسلمانوں کی ہوئی ہے جن کو تین حصوں میں تقسیم کر دیا گیا آزاد تو ہندو ہوئے ہیں جن کی تقسیم نہیں ہوئی

نام عبدالکلام نہیں ابو الکلام ہے

aaj hi school me is bande ke bare me phar ke aya aur youtube ne ye video recomend kar de aesa sirf mere sath hota ha ya app ke sath kabhi hua

تمام کمنٹس پڑھنے کے بعد حتمی فیصلہ: 😂 1۔ قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح جو پاکستان بنانا چاہتے تھے وہ ایک نظریاتی اور اسلامی فلاحی ریاست تھا جس نے پورے امت مسلمہ کو مضبوط بنانا تھا۔ لیکن ان کے بعد پاکستان پر نااہلوں کا قبضہ ہوا اور سب کچھ ختم۔ 2۔ مولانا آزاد مسلمانوں کو اکٹھے رکھ کر ایک بھاری قوت بنانا چاہتے تھے۔ ان کا خیال تھا کہ مسلمان ہی انگریزوں کے بعد ہندوستان میں حکومت کرسکیں گے کیونکہ ہندوں میں لیڈرشپ کی کوالٹی نہیں۔ اور یہ بات درست بھی تھا کیونکہ اگر مسلمان اکٹھے ہو تے تو وہ آج اقلیت نہیں بلکہ اکثریت کے قریب ہوتے کیونکہ اسلام ہندوستان میں کافی تیزی سے پھیل رہا تھا کیونکہ آزادی مذہبی تقسیم ہوئی اور ہندوں نے اپنے مذہب کو ڈیفنڈ کرنا شروع کیا اور اسلام کو ہندو مخالف مذہب قرار دیا۔ اس طرح آزادی سے مولانا آزاد کا نظریہ ختم۔ 🙏 نوٹ: دونوں اپنے لحظ سے بلکل صحیح تھے 💯 اور گریٹ لیڈر تھے لیکن اگر اس وقت کے لحاظ سے دیکھیں تو مولانا آزاد کا نظریہ تو ممکن نہیں ہے لیکن قائد اعظم کے نظریات کو ہم قائم کر سکتے ہیں۔ ❤❤❤

اے قائد اعظم تیرا احسان ہے احسان ❤

Good person Abdul kalam azad

جو پپیش گوئکی تھی پاکستان کے بارے میں بلکل سچ نکلی۔

He was visionary.

Jinnah to me was neither Muslim or even Indian

Azad made the biggest mistake of life by not threatening or actually resigning from congress on Partition issue. He should have resigned and could have started a movement with all like minded persons to stop partition and May be he could have prevented it. In any case he was the greatest political leader Hindu or Muslim

Molana Azad was right about the muslims migrating to Pakistan that one day their value will be of an uninvited guest. Still the urdu speaking population of Pakistan whose ancestors came from India are discriminated.

مولانا آزاد کو کانگریسی کے بارے میں خوش فہمی تھی وہ برہمن کی چالوں سے واقف نہیں تھے شاید۔

نیچے اردو میں لکھا ہوا ہے Jinnah was alcoholic and fornicator(father of many illegal childrens), he had no knowledge of Islam not even basic knowledge(like namaz, roza), (Jinnah is father of Nusli wadia). An alcoholic and fornicator can't create a nation he was tool, what ever is taught in Pakistan about him are lies created by his sister(she had eye on his property, when Jinnah joined politics from nowhere she started leaving with him). She glorified a scoundrel jinnah by creating dummy stories. He barrowed the concept of two nation theory from his guru savarkar(self declared veer, he use to get pension from British as gift) He was used by Nehru, pant, RSS and Nehru's illegal sasural(British). Jinnah was doubtful person, he saved sardar Patel when they were allegations of mismanagement of lakhs of money ofAhmedabad corporation Gujarat. He sacrificed everything to save his best friend sardar Patel, Pakistan was created by jagirdar muslims (not common muslims) they were not even 1% of total muslim population, Common muslim had no right to vote. Jinnah use to drink pig soup. Pakistan was planned by British,jinnah agent of rss,Patel and Nehru. On 14 aug 1947 When lakhs of hindus,muslims and Sikhs were massacared he was enjoying party with Britishers surely alcohol and women's were on menu.(I have invitation card if you want to see give your email, Facebook, Twitter account I will post). Allama Iqbal and other leaders wanted proportionate partition/United India with reservation for muslim in parliament, what jinnah got is tip from Nehru and Patel, Pakistan and Bangladesh is like toilet and bathroom of big Mansion(India). After partion and lot of bloodshed when he was counting his dates he accepted his mistake before Liaquat Ali and was feeling guilty. L.K. Advani (rss,enemy of true faith)visited the grave of jinnah to thank jinnah(slave of ill minded Hindus) Jaswant Singh (rss) wrote a book praising jinnah. In recent gathering(2022, April) in Gujarat rss praised jinnah as great leader. 70% who died in freedom struggle to free subcontinent were Muslims. what jinnah achieved beggar's tip. sir syed ahmed and sir iqbal spoke about partion as option, thier demand was reservation for Muslims in parliament or reasonable partition (not a beggar 's tip which jinnah accepted) جناح شرابی اور زانی تھا (بہت سے غیر قانونی بچوں کا باپ)، اسے اسلام کا کوئی علم نہیں تھا نہ کہ بنیادی علم (جیسے نماز، روزہ)، (جناح نصلی واڈیا کے والد ہیں)۔ ایک شرابی اور زانی ایک قوم نہیں بنا سکتا جس کا وہ آلہ کار تھا، پاکستان میں اس کے بارے میں جو کچھ بھی سکھایا جاتا ہے وہ اس کی بہن کا بنایا ہوا جھوٹ ہے (ان کی جائیداد پر اس کی نظر تھی، جب جناح نے سیاست میں شمولیت اختیار کی تو وہ اس کا ساتھ چھوڑنے لگے)۔ اس نے ڈمی کہانیاں بنا کر ایک بدمعاش جناح کی تعریف کی۔ اس نے دو قومی نظریہ کا تصور اپنے گرو ساورکر سے لیا تھا (خود کو ویر قرار دیا تھا، وہ بطور تحفہ انگریزوں سے پنشن حاصل کرتا تھا) اسے نہرو، پنت، آر ایس ایس اور نہرو کے غیر قانونی سسرال (برطانوی) نے استعمال کیا۔ جناح مشکوک شخص تھے، انہوں نے سردار پٹیل کو بچایا جب ان پر احمد آباد کارپوریشن گجرات کے لاکھوں روپے کی بدانتظامی کے الزامات تھے۔ اس نے اپنے بہترین دوست سردار پٹیل کو بچانے کے لیے سب کچھ قربان کر دیا، پاکستان جاگیردار مسلمانوں نے بنایا تھا (عام مسلمان نہیں) وہ کل مسلم آبادی کا 1 فیصد بھی نہیں تھے، عام مسلمان کو ووٹ کا حق نہیں تھا۔ جناح سور کا سوپ پیا کرتے تھے۔ پاکستان کا منصوبہ انگریزوں، RSS کے جناح ایجنٹ، پٹیل اور نہرو نے بنایا تھا۔ 14 اگست 1947 کو جب لاکھوں ہندوؤں، مسلمانوں اور سکھوں کا قتل عام کیا گیا تو وہ انگریزوں کے ساتھ پارٹی سے لطف اندوز ہو رہا تھا یقیناً شراب اور خواتین کے مینو میں شامل تھے۔ علامہ اقبال اور دیگر رہنما متناسب تقسیم/ متحدہ ہندوستان چاہتے تھے جس میں پارلیمنٹ میں مسلمانوں کے لیے ریزرویشن ہو، جناح کو جو کچھ ملا وہ نہرو اور پٹیل سے ٹپ ہے، پاکستان اور بنگلہ دیش بڑی حویلی (بھارت) کے بیت الخلا اور باتھ روم کی طرح ہیں۔ تقسیم اور بہت خونریزی کے بعد جب وہ اپنی تاریخیں گن رہا تھا تو اس نے لیاقت علی کے سامنے اپنی غلطی مان لی اور خود کو مجرم محسوس کر رہا تھا۔ ایل کے اڈوانی (آر ایس ایس، سچے عقیدے کے دشمن) نے جناح کا شکریہ ادا کرنے کے لیے جناح کی قبر کا دورہ کیا (بیمار ذہن ہندوؤں کا غلام) جسونت سنگھ (آر ایس ایس) نے جناح کی تعریف کرتے ہوئے ایک کتاب لکھی۔ گجرات میں حالیہ اجتماع (2022، اپریل) میں آر ایس ایس نے جناح کو عظیم رہنما کے طور پر سراہا تھا۔ آزاد برصغیر کی جدوجہد آزادی میں مرنے والوں میں 70 فیصد مسلمان تھے۔ جناح نے بھکاری کی ٹپ کیا حاصل کی؟ سر سید احمد اور سر اقبال نے ایک آپشن کے طور پر تقسیم کے بارے میں بات کی، ان کا مطالبہ پارلیمنٹ میں مسلمانوں کے لیے ریزرویشن تھا یا معقول تقسیم (کسی بھکاری کی نوک نہیں جسے جناح نے قبول کیا)

حالات اور وقت نے ثابت کیا کہ مولانا ابوالکلام آزاد کا موقف سو فیصد درست تھا۔ دو قومی نظریہ تقسیم ملک نہیں بلکہ تقسیم مسلم کا نظریہ تھا۔

Great man great khan Imran Khan Imran Khan.

Maulana Azad waqaye azad thay... Hum azad ho kar bhi Ghulam hai... Aor Ghulami mai na kaam aaty hai tadbeerain na shamsheeray...

You have done programs on many Pakistani and Indian leaders. Why haven't you done any documentary on Allama Mashriqi?

Never heard he drank until now although to me it was his personal issue

What a great visionary Quaid Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah (RA) was. If somehow he carved more geographical land to accommodate all Muslim population in one place. His vision has been proven 100% valid in the light of recent developments in India.

As far Azad character is concerned he made efforts for Congress govt in Punjab where Muslim League was morally required to do so . On this Azad decision Nehru was not happy and he directed Azad for his immoral decision . As such later on Muslim League performed the Punjab govt .

Molana Abul klam Azad was right and time has proved it I can proudly said it from Pakistan that M Ali Jinnah Two nation theory is proved Wrong

A visionary leader

Mostly fake especially about wine usage spam misleading I was not expecting this type of nonsense from BBC Urdu plz remove this.

پاکستان زندہ باد ❤❤❤❤❤

The narrator is again and again saying ABDUL whereas its ABUL

The commentator should know that he was Abul Kalam ( not Abdul)