- More Dr. Ataie talks: mcceastbay.org/ataie

One of the most brilliant presentation, but sadly it’s too short. We need a 6hrs lecture please.

I love Dr Ataie, may Allah bless him and his family and spread his knowledge all over the world. May Allah always keep him funny, it's so refreshing. It adds lightness to a heavy topic.

🤯 Fantastic speech, I'm "not religious" but thoroughly believe history and the Abrahamic Traditions and shared global stories as several continents can't be wrong! This has fascinated me - especially how you make the languages and meanings in different interpretations just flow off your tongue!

I learned so much as always from your lectures Doctor...Jazak Allah khair

Thank you for sharing. This kind of teaching really benefits my spiritual journey.

Alhamdulillah Better audio, from this gem of knowledge

thank you Dr Ali ... for sharing your knowledge ... alhamdulillah ... from Malaysia

Takbeer!!

Very interesting, fascinating lecture. I chuckled many times.

Dear Dr. Ataie, you are great, you are wonderful and so knowledgeable. Wev I earn a lit from you. We are proud of you! Thank you! Thank you! Thank you indeed! We are proud of you being an Iranian who teaches us about Islam! We are proud of you, as an Iranian scholar. Thank you so so much!

Allahumma barik

A delight to listen to.

Ali atai is my superman

I love these interfaith events, and Ataie is perfect for it. Abdal Hakim Murad and Hamza Yusuf also being there would be absolutely delicious and the literal internet would break.

He must be a fan of Ahmad Deedat

👍

35mins in , Injeel is an Arabicized Greek word? I thought the Greeks got it from Aramaic 'Awon-Galee-Yoon' anybody know?

Ma wadda aka Rabb buka wama qala? Right? Not qaha?

18:36

1- No Muslim is extremist…. We are the (And thus we have made you a just community that you will be witnesses over the people and the Messenger will be a witness over you) Yet extremism is a none Muslim term where it never existed throughout the Islamic history in the way that the west try’s to label Muslims at all. The more Muslims are committed to their religion the farther they are from any form of extremism. That being said: Islam doesn’t believe in political parties and militates and groups. Literally peace to humanity. I wonder who would like to label it and paint it with other than it’s pure lights, brightness, and transparency!!! Allah had warn us from evil and its traits, and never to follow its foot steps. 2- Muslims are just even to their enemies. 3- Muslims are like a palm tree… ignorant people, and media throws stones at that palm tree 🌴 and the tree returns it’s fruit to them. 4- would humans go wrong and out of patience being hit with stones all the time? 5- of course Dr. Ali did answer all questions he was asked just like he always have been a wonderful model to those that seek knowledge in the areas of his expertise, but sometimes the ignorance of those that see themselves as the greatest and most educated nation that has the biggest universities on earth happens to be the most ignorant illiterate of all, and once they find out about Islam: nothing keeps them from embracing it when they are true to themselves.

Female prophets? Please enlighten me.

This "trasmissional knowledge" that you are referring to is hardly a way to preserve the knowledge of God's teachings. In fact, this type of traditional teaching is the primary way that the teachings of men corrupt religion! Jesus himself denounced the Pharisees for adding to oral law such that they contradicted the written law, what you refer to is absolutely no different. If one wanted truth they would prefer the man who has studdied scripture without the hindrance of the traditions of men.