I feel like for the first theory c!Karl from the future is more logical term, cause like they said; c!Karl may or may not be bringing different versions of c!Karl from different timeline.. to try and right the wrong. But what *is* he afraid of..? Is the future that bad that he tries to change it..? I also have a mini theory- *includes spoilers from big q stream* Yk how c!Karl and c!Quackity got into a fight because he “apparently” murdered him- (even tho it was a team plan) . Imagine; if that wasn’t the c!Karl version that we know. What if it was one of those versions that we see in the inbetween. But the question is. Why is he blaming c!Quackity for murdering him?... do they ended up hating each other in the future? Or did c!Quackity(from their timeline) did murder him... because it doesn’t make sense. If c!Karl did lost his memory, why is it only Quackity? And why does he only remember the bad stuff? Because as far as i know. George and Sapnap was there. They all planned it together.. c!Karl himself also agreed on that plan... (also somebody said that c!Sapnap was the one who suggested it, but im not that sure)

Oh Karl, guess the creator likes exposing some secrets rip Karl's secret

LMAOO THE PERSON WHO SAID "how was skeppy riding you" LMFAOO

"Vurb: How was skeppy riding you?" Me: 🤚🏽💀

1:35 That part actually might make sense, at first Wilbur couldn't find the button, then Karl probably saw something worse than L'manberg getting blown up, only to put the button back.

I LOVE DSMP THEORIES

Everyone: :0 karl tried to save le' manburg? Me: Verbs comment at the bottom of the tweet i cant 🤣🤣🤣🤣

they should react to georges theorys his lore is sooo underrated

The first on goes well with my au because he owns the in-between but he doesnt know so for punishment of not knowing he looses his memory everytime but when he realizes he owns the in-between he will get his memorys back

definitely needs more of these :D also idea: maybe make them react to the Icarus video?

This is a really cool idea, good job

Bro I'm getting chills, this girl is genius

"how was skeppy riding you"

Plus when Wilber was talking to Phil about to blow up the button he said he was going to come their earlier but it wasn’t working

WAIT BEFORE YOU READ THIS COMMENT TW: IT CONTAINS SPOILERS! The first video at the end said “something bad is gonna happen and he can’t stop it.” What if that “something bad” was about how Tommy asked Tubbo to nuke the prison but Jack messes it up and the whole server blows up? What if Karl in trying to stop all of these events in the past so that everyone won’t die?

You should make them react to where Karl had been time traveling and some more theories

Nice theories, but Vurb's tweet killed me dnkslss

1:38, and then theirs Vurb. "How was skeppy riding u"

Love this to much as a fellow theorizer

"hiw was skeepy rideing you" LMAO

Oh my God it makes to much sense- I'm speechless-

What if this is why there are so many arcs and aus?If Karl has different versions of him then they have to be from different storylines of the smp. so all the versions of him have a different storyline than the original Karl and original smp.....Like maybe one of the storylines from another Karl was lmanburg/manburg never blew up or dream didn't go to prison.....or maybe quackity did kill that Karl and the one that came back didn't know he came to the original smp and so the original Karl was stuck in the inbeetween and is now controlling it and having the "quackity killed Karl" version of him in the original smp making that Karl not aware of what happened in the original smp so maybe that Karl that was sent into the original smp didn't lose his memory he just......... didn't know what happened in the original smp....and this drama because of the original smp and original Karl......(And of course this is just a theory that I have came up with but who knows it might be true😅)

Can you make a dsmp reat to Karl Minecraft but everything is OP Please

Hello I am new subscriber I really love your channel ❤️ and can you please do more I really like your videos ❤️? Like mini theory’s

Is no one noticing the end where verb said is skeppy done riding you o-0

Its pretty sad I now I now it is only a game But it is still sad 😔

i love theorys

Wait Spoilers of new stream.(Tommy’s final What if they big thing he was trying to prevent was tubbo and Timmy using the nuke taking the whole server with it.

noooooooo verb did not look under bbh's tweet XD

New subscriber and are you gonna make more reactions like this? No pressure just asking ❤️✨

MORE!

Luved it

i have a hc that has to do with karl kinda so you know the enderwalk arg one of the thing we solve is a code that looks like karls swirls and ranboo also forgets alot so i think hes a time travler edit:this is my moms acount but im to lazy to retype

Wait- Karl forgot Quackity...that led to something bad (the engagement)...THIS PERSON IS SMARTT❤

Considering the newest tales of the smp the first theory of Karl controlling the in between is proven false :,) Love the new episode tho y’all should watch it if you haven’t

So now the girli(in the TikTok) IS the Female MatPat? xD it would be hilarious tho.

omg he broke a button moms gonna be so mad i better start recording

Since Karl saw many versions of himself was he in a black hole, because in a black hole time slows down and by the second years are going by in real time and also that makes karl a time travler, because her can go to that black hole all the time so he can time travel anywho thats a different story though. But in a black hole you see many versions of yourself so I know im not trippen though.

I'm convinced she can tell the future I feel like these are true but what's gonna happen in the future...?

are we gonna ignore the comment under bads comment on karls tweet

can you do the one with George is the one will help dream escape

Karl why did u break the button thruogh my birthday

Wait has anyone ever ask what time does Carl come from because if he constantly time travels then where is he really from

Yeah all the dsmp died look like someone prediction

These theories was so wrong I can't stop laughing !

part 2???

I have a theory Karl was afraid of the dsmp finale. Tommy and Tubbo made a plan to nuke Dream and Punz, but they would need one of them to go in and get them to stay. Now, we already know Karl knows having Tommy alive is the best outcome, but Tommy would die in each one. Karl couldn't time travel in time to stop this, and everyone died, except for Wilbur and somebody else. **Tommy died.** We both know discduo is NOT functional, so history would just repeat but in a different way. I'm thinking, Tommy would replace George, meeting DreamXD. Tubbo would replace Quackity. Quackity would be the president of l'manburg, exiling George. and Schlatt, wouldn't even be there. Wilbur would be manipulating George, and Dream would also be manipulating George. But then, after a while, Dream might remember everything, so he helps George and then manipulates Tommy again.

T-the thing is I k-know this was 3 months ago but I think t-the big thing will h-happen soon a-and I-it’s probably t-tommy g-going I-insane I m-mean it’s p-pretty o-obvious

At the end of the video* she antgoing talk about the comments 🫣

Is it just me that I cannot find the username anymore?