Your videos make me so happy! There are so many elements from the children and your recipes, but the best part is your smiling face that is such a reflection of God's love. Thank you!

Kendrick has stolen my heart. My grandson is 34 and reminds me of him exactly as I’ve watched him grow up. This has been a real treat for me, since he is my only grandson. I now have 2 great grandson but neither one is this much like him. Kendrick warms my heart.

My fav thing about this channel is it’s not about your fancy kitchen. Or bragging about all you make. You just knock out volumes of food with a smile. 🎉

I love how you use everything, no waste….like letting the boys clean the bowls and beaters (no waste there by the way they clean it up BEFORE they wash them) and also how the boys help do their part in speeding up the wrapping, by eating as many as they can before they are wrapped, that way less to wrap!

I’m a Pa Dutch girl who grew up near Lancaster and we ate Whoopie Pies like there was no tomorrow. This brought back such great memories. I truly love the Zimmerman family SO much….❤️🙏🏼🤗

My husband just ordered me a Bosch mixer with extra attachments. I am so excited!

I was born and raised Mennonite in kalona Iowa area . My Mennonite grandmother in Michigan made Whoopie pies every Christmas. They were the best! Now i live in Oklahoma about 1 and a half hours away from an Amish bakery that makes them! 😊

I just love watching Harrison’s face light up when you are cooking. So cute.

I'm so glad I found your channel. Your videos remind me so much of my childhood. I hated every minute of gardening/farm life. Now as an adult and grandmother, those were my best memories and I wish I could now give that to my grandchildren. FYI, my grandmother made whoopie pies all the time and she would change the flavor.

Making afterschool snacks is the best mom job ever!

You have no idea the joy that your videos being me! I love to see Harrison, who seems to be in the kitchen with you pretty often. He sure seems to like his food. I think he may grow up to be the cook in his family, lol.😂😂

I grew up in South western PA. Your lifestyle reminds me of the way we were raised. We milked 52 Holstein cows. We started milking at 4:30 every morning and 5 in the evening. My mom made everything from scratch. I cherished all the skills she taught me. I have taught my childern the skills I learned. I love watching your channel. I reminisce on years past. Thank you. God Bless you and your family.

The smiles on the kids faces said it all, their whoopie cakes were delightful. 🙏🏻

The "twins" are so helpful and sweet . I call them twins because they are always together and really love each other. Love your channel !

All your hard work has paid off. You have a beautiful wonderful family. There is so much honesty in love in your eyes. I feel blessed that your channel came on my stream. I am currently obsessed with Amish Canning practices and use all the recipes that you've put on the channel. You are living my dream and i hope to get there one day and have my own little corner of land for my family!!😊 thank you

What a beautiful family vlog done by the family on Good Friday making whoopi pies, they looked delicious & I have never ever tried a whoopi pie because I’m in Scotland and we don’t have them here. I’m beginning to think that this granny could be making a “single” batch of them one day. I love the relationship between Harrison & Kendrick true brothers at heart, the joy of Harrison seeing the waffle whoopi pies and immediately shouting on Kendrick to come because he would be so happy to see what was there. I love Harrison’s gentle loving tough to his mama but also to his big sister Stacie arms open wide for a giant hug and the love is given back in spades. It is a joy to watch your beautiful family , thank you for opening your door to us 🩷🌸

Thank you so much for the recipes! My mother made these when I was a little girl and I loved them! Actually, I began to bake when I was about 9 and this recipe was the first thing that I made! Instead of tablespoons of cocoa, I used teaspoons! As you can imagine, they were very light in color, but other than that, they came out pretty good! We had the no powdered sugar frosting for them. I’m so happy to have this recipe! Brings back sweet memories!! Hubs is a truck driver and these would be perfect for him as he’s driving down the road!❤️❤️❤️

Happiness is cooking with the sound of laughing children in the background.

God bless you ,Ruth My husband loves whoppi pies , What a wonder story , I appreciate all your beautiful stories they help me daily , We lost our youngest child and only daughter at age 19 5 months after graduating high school here in Montgomery County, Texas 🙏 Your calming voice helps me , Ive followed you since you started , I just found an amish store right by us and I love shopping there . Thank you Mrs josette Montgomery County, Texas 🙏

Oh my goodness, I was taught how to make Whoopi Pies when I was very young. Gramma used Lard too 😉💗💗💗💗 I also make a carrot 🥕 cake ones too. Yummy!!!

I make whoopie pies every Christmas. This is a tradition I carry forward from my maternal grandmother whom I miss terribly even after many many hears. My kids and grandkids look forward to them every year.

Thank you for saying out loud what I say or think about not wanting to take out the mixer due to not having enough kitchen counter space and also for me with the chore of making cookies…

"Flour" frosting is our family's favorite with Chocolate cake. Whoopi pies will be a great addition to our next family gathering. Love watching the boys help in the kitchen💕💖

The excitement from your children is so awesome! I love it. ❤

I remember the Whoopie Pie assembly line!! Those were always favorites for school fundraisers. I can remember being so tired of fiddling with them but determined to make our sales goals. Great memories! The waffle ones look fantastic as well. Will definitely be trying those.

I made these yesterday ( a single batch). They are a huge hit. Thank you, Ruthann. And my grand babies thank you too ❤😊

I chuckle when I watch you cooking with your kids around and around. We did everything by scratch, eve tamales, . I remember nursing a baby and stiring the spagetti sauce. Had to stop some of that when they were teens and I went to work outside the home.

You"re such a good cook and make everything look so easy.

You are such a joy to watch! Your interactions with your children are so genuine, and the skills that you are sharing are wonderful! Thank you!

Whoopie pies are addicting! I'm blessed to live in a part of Central Pennsylvania where there's so many great bakers. The local general store makes Coffee ones.

Your children must have the best sense of accomplishment. They seem to enjoy whatever they are doing. ❤

Good Morning we love whoopie pies. My grandma used to cook 11:13 Pennsylvania Dutch meals. She was born just outside of Lancaster, PA.

I love hearing your wind chimes..... They always make me happy hearing them when the wind blows. I have several sets. I've always thought I'd like to try that style mixer so I'm glad to see yours in action! ❤

Love your channel!! A mom always has to tell the babies to wash your hands with soap and water in every household .. All around the world, I'm sure .lol..

My grandchildren will love this!!

We love whoopee pies. My Mom makes oatmeal, chocolate, pumpkin, and red velvet pies. We like them frozen as well. We are Mennonite in SE Louisiana. We are not conservative or old order.

Thank you SO MUCH for confirming that woopie pies and Gobs are the same thing!!! We are from PA originally and so a lot of our family favorites are PA Dutch. My grandmother made Gobs for every important family function. My brother loves them. I so want to make him some!!! God bless you!

Harrison made good on the Whoopie Pie legend! He came in and let out a masterful whoop! lol

I have always thought that whoopie pies were a Maine creation, Funny I just told my husband this afternoon that I planned to make a double batch for a family gathering this summer, I said he was going to have to help me because it's a pretty big project. I enjoyed seeing your little grandson. I have 3 little grand babies now. They are such a blessing!!

I love watching you and your family. So good to see their are still families who are being taught to okd ways which consists of respect , hard work, discipline and trust.

My grandmother used to make these in the Appalachian mountains so it isn't just a PA Dutch baked goods. She also did this same thing with many other "flavors" soooo good! I have to try to make some.

Grew up making and eating whoopie pies. My grandmother would always have a ton of them for us. My favorite way to eat them is from the freezer. Kind of like an ice cream sandwich. Shortening is more traditional. Yum. The cooked frosting is our family's favorite

Whoopie Pies!!! My daughter called them "woofie pies" when she was little, and they were a favourite from the little Mennonite store near us then. Will have to try making these for her!

.....more than the food...love those kids enjoying life..what beautiful memories they are collecting..they are truly blessed

What a few variations of such a delightful treat. Thank you for all you do. Also thank you for such a wonderful opportunity to be able to win and have our very own Bausch mixer and dehydrator. I've always wanted a mixer as this one. Love to you all.

I'm glad you and Michelle our collaborating. I subscribed to her channels as well. My heritage is Pennsylvania Dutch. Although, my father married a "southern" and our tradition's changed quite a bit. Some of my fondest early childhood memories are of my Gran and Granaw (Great grandmother and grandmother) cooking things like scrapple and pigs feet jelly... I could go on and on but those two start the list. Thanks for introducing me to Michelle.

OH MY GOODNESS!!! ❤ I made these yesterday with the original filling. I was sure glad I didn't double the recipe enjoyed their fill I was wished I was wishing I had a doubled it. Lol they enjoyed them so much. They raved and raved about how good they were. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe and helping me to make my family happy.

We certainly didn’t need these in our house, but that didn’t stop me from making them today 😂 They were a hit! Thank you 😊

Thanks for the recipe. Our grandsons graduation party guests loved the pies. I couldn’t find grandma’s recipe! I did tweak your a bit. If you cream butter & sugar forever like I do and then use King Arthur flour the batter is stiffer, but still baked up great! Thank God. My granddaughter Noella worked all day & I could not have done it alone! She loved seeing your kids do what she loves. God bless you all ❤

Whoopie pies are great! I especially love to watch your helpers and how they enjoy themselves in work and play (and dessert)😊

Hi RuthAnn and sweet family! Whoopie pies looked so delicious and the children were so happy when they saw the whoopie pies. I hope everyone is doing great and the beautiful grandbaby is getting some grandma and grandpa time in. I hope everyone has a blessed day!

I love whoopie pies. I actually worked on a recipe till I got one right. I'm a cake decorator so I had a lot of frosting left over and what I did was take my buttercream and add some marshmellow cream in the mix till I got the consistency I wanted, and it worked great. Love your channel, I saw the whoopie pies and said, yep I'm watching this!

I’ll have Whoopie pies! I grew up in Lancaster alongside Amish and Mennonite families and we always got all kinds of Whoopie pies!!

Your kids are just so polite…i love watching them choose which woopie is best to eat!!! And…I am watching this at 10 pm..guess who has a craving for woo pie pies!!!! No fair! I hope I wake up and the craving is gone lol. Pigs are my favourite farm animal..thank you for filming them having a ‘whale’ of a time in their wallow. Happy pigs! Makes my heart sing! X

Your Whoopie Pies look so Delicious! I haven't made them in years! I need to make some! Yum Yum! I really enjoyed watching all the Children helping .......and the little boys licking the Bowl! Brought back great memories for me.

I can sit and watch your videos for hours. People don't realize what a wonderful life you have. And I realized that rather you work on a farm are factory work is always hard. My grandmother grandpop was a poor share cropper at the end of the harvest the owner them a big ham and a case of Orange crush soda. Once a year . My stepdad hitchhiked from North Carolina to Baltimore MD the big miserable city met my mom and worked a hot factory spray painting n got lung disease. Anyway we all need to appreciate what we have. And when I see RUTHANN working I know it's hard but she's a good wife n momma and that is priceless. Women work a job and pay a sitter what do they have left. Work at home moms that's the best you could ever give them

Those kids smile in they faces when they saw the pies were priceless 😅 Happy babies , happy mama's. God bless 😁

I have wanted this mixer for so long. Keeping my fingers crossed. My grand children love whoopee pies.

I'm from NJ and spent a lot of time in Lancaster because my dad partially grew up there. Now I live in CA and you can't get a good whoopee pie anywhere; thanks for the recipe!! 💕

Love watching you and your children working together! Such a delicious treat!! YUM!!😋

I’ve always heard of woopie pies but never had one and didn’t know the history, what fun. Thank you!

I love watching your KZfaq channel. Love your recipes, lifestyle and your beautiful family. I’ve always loved to bake cook and can. I only found KZfaq a couple years ago when my husband passed away from cancer and I was looking for a more reasonable cable network and found the Roku channel and KZfaq. It has been a Godsend. Thank you for your wonderful videos ❤

Before my children grew up I would also wrap Whoopie pies individually and freeze them. We also loved them frozen. I’ll have to make some for a family gathering. My favorite filling was made by cooking a paste of milk and flour then whipping in granulated sugar, shortening (or butter), and vanilla. Now that I’m further into this video I see that the frosting in your waffle pies is almost exactly my favorite.

I love Whoopie Pies so much. This is the first Saturday of the month, so I will be going to our Mennonite store close to us because it is Donut Day! (first Saturday of the month) I also always pick up a Whoopie Pie, so it is double treats. Thanks so much for the video showing the whole process making it possible for me to make my own. Loved watching the kids snatch up the tasty treats, and they were so helpful! Have a great week!

RuthAnn, TY, for ALL of Amazing videos! WHOOOPIII, Whoopi Pies!! Blessings to you and your family! 🙏🏼❤🫂

My husband and I are catching up and love watching your videos. we have a garden, I love to cook simply good for us and love learning your wonderful secrets of both!! We wish your family all Gods blessings as God is good all the time🙏😍💗

Thank you so much for all your recipes and teaching. I can't wait toake these whoopie loss.

I don't think my grandmother ever weighed anything for her baking and yet everything was so good.She did everything by eye and feel. She was also the one who taught me to cook. From 4 years old I was in the kitchen with her. 😊

Love your vlog. The younger generation needs to learn these valuable lessons.

I don't know what makes me happiest!? Learning a new recipe or watching your delightful children (including your grown daughters) dance and sing your praises for preparing such a wonderful treat. Thank you

Absolutely loved the storytelling behind Whoopie Pies and seeing them come to life in your kitchen! 😍 Your dedication to preserving and sharing these traditions is truly inspiring. 🎉

I had the oatmeal whoopie pies in Durango Mexico from the Mennonite community. I still cherish that memory and crave that treat! This was over 20 years ago!

I got to try whoopie pies and shoo fly pie when we got to visit PA. We use the “cookies” for making ice cream sandwiches in the summer with our homemade ice cream from cows milk. My husband loves the oatmeal ones because he says they remind him of little Debbie oatmeal sandwiches.

Omgosh, whoppie pies remind me of my great grandmother. I've never made them but you made them look easy.

I so enjoyed these two recipes and the fillings but especially the smiles of your wonderful family. Thank you for all you do and share a little slice of wonderful! God Bless you and your family.

That’s a lot of Whoopie pies! I’m going to make some this weekend using your recipe. My mouth was watering watching this video.

Thank you for sharing this recipe! I have been looking for something special to make for "Husband Appreciation Day"! Watching this video brought back many happy conversations and memory sharing surrounding "growing up". My husband grew up in PA and enjoys Gobs; however, I have never had or made Gobs! I am so happy for the inspiration you have given me! As always, I appreciate you and your family! Wishing you, your family, and fellow KZfaq subscribers a beautiful day!

Ruth-Ann, I am glad I found your channel. I have canned potatoes for the first time in 72 years and I have tried many other of your recipes. My Grandma was Pennsylvania-Dutch, and she and Grandpa Berglund, Swedish, lived in Shawnee, Kansas.

Your whoopie pies look sooooo much better than the commercial madd ones that i never found a liking for. I look forward to your video every week. You are a super star and your children are precious! Many Blessings from Deborah in West Virginia!

I grew up in SW Pennsylvania with lots of PA Dutch recipes. We called these cookies gobs. Fond memories of my Mom and Grandma making lots of them!

Thank you from my husband,lol, one of his favorite treats! Since moving south, we miss the Amish at our local farmers market. Now I can make these for him, and hear him say, “Whoopie!”. Also, I have never made frosting with flour, I am very curious, and I can’t wait to try making it!❤️

Thank you so much for the historical background on the Whoopie pie, I absolutely enjoy abd love every bit of your childhood memories you allow us to know and it is the same for all the stories that have come down generation to generation. I have learned so much from your channel because if yout feed to your family I know that yout are giving your best recipe's and suggestions on ingredients and all the great tips and tricks. The fact that you do not try and hide anything from accidentally making gardening mistakes, farming animals mistakes, what happened when gates are left open and how tirelessly you work at providing aid, ALL while educating the children of how mistakes happen the consequences and the hard work in trying to rectify the situation. You have the patients of a saint when the kids are helping in the kitchen and I always laugh when the kids think they are getting away with something when you are not looking because I know you will see it when editing your videos, it is hilarious and i would love to be a fly on the wall when you see those on your edits. Thak you for being you, being strong , consistent in your beliefs and the confidence toy have when discussing what negative comments that may have been left, you do it with such grace. I pray Bosch sends you a dehydrator because if anyone deserves one, you absolutely do. Bless you and your family, enjoy the grandson time, they grow up so fast and of course I cannot leave out the furbabies, dogs and cats and of course your farm animals. Unfortunately although I think I have a instragram acct? I do not know how to use it, but I will have my daughter try and help me just to try and see if I win something I have been drooling over for awhile.

Your comment to your son made me giggle, i think all moms everywhere must ask the hand washing question in two parts. "Have you washed your hands?" Yes."With soap?!" Thanks for another yummy recipe.

Wow, whoopie pies! I havent made or eaten one in probably 40 years! Made whoopie pies (chocolate) as a kid growing up. Have not had waffle, pumpkin or carrot cake whoopie pies, but they sound and liok delicious too! 😊

I should not have watched this fantastic video with my grandchildren, now they are begging me to make some of your delicious looking Whoopie Pies. Have a blessed day.

Eastern PA here: we can buy chocolate with white filling, chocolate with peanut butter filling, and red velvet cake with cream cheese filling. The ones we can buy are always very dry. These look great!

WHOOPIE!! I make pumpkin whoopies, but I am going to love your recipes. Thank you again. Love your channel!!!

I just made these. Oh my goodness! They are SO delicious. Also the recipe proportions were right on the money. There was an exact amount of filling for the cakes made. The only thing I wished was that you had said about how long to cook the cakes. I wasn’t sure if it was 5 minutes, 10 minutes or some other time. For my oven it was right around 10 minutes. Thank you! What a fun recipe and I can easily understand why you have “do not double!” on your card. At some points there’s a lot going on and with little ones under foot it could get hairy

I love your sweet personality and down to earth teaching with all the tips and secrets in all that you do!! Please don't change. God bless❤

Looks like the laundry was taking a beating. That is a mighty amount of cakes. Wow.

I have always loved whoopie pies and I'm so glad I have the recipe.

You make my day. The way you’re raising your kids, the always smiling face, the good home healthy, sensible cooking. It all unites to make a good, happy, pleasant family. You’re the tops.

My husband is from Pennsylvania, lived among the Amish. He likes Whoopie pies! Every time we go to visit family back east. We buy Whoopie pie …yum in the tum! Thanks, Ruthann. Enjoyed your commentary & video! Keep well & stay vigilant!☺️🙏🏻👍🏻

My German descent great grandmother (born 1890) gave our family this same Cooked Flour/Milk icing recipe many years ago. My cousin shared it with a famous New York Pastry Chef and he knew the heritage instantly. It’s still a favorite and often requested birthday cake treat. Love your channel and family. ❤

I watch to the end every video because in my mind, that’s the win! I love he idea of replacing store bought with home made! Can’t wait for this series. I will checkout your friends channel. If it’s anything like yours, I am in!😊

God bless. I love learning new things from you. Your peaceful spirit is a reflection of God’s love!

Whoopie pies are a Maine thing also. Had not heard the lunch story. Just wicked good! The Bosch appliances are very generous!

Happy Saturday Zimmerman family!! Another great video!

I love watching your videos. Thanks for sharing the whoopie pie recipes.

Hi, I started making these years ago and they are our favourites, but the waffle pies are so neat, I gotta try them. I know what I will be doing later today, thanks so much. Love your channel 🇨🇦🌷