Origins will always be my favorite. The location & story was incredible. Bayek is easily one of the most fascinating assassins. Especially since Bayek & Aya basically founded the entire thing. Loved every second of the hundred plus hours I played!

I must say ac odyssey is easily the hardest game in the trilogy because the Npcs are aggressive towards u. This makes it significantly harder because if ur fighting spartan/Athenian soldiers on the streets sometimes the npcs help the soldiers and while the npcs are pretty weak, killing them raises ur bounty and puts mercenaries on u. They are the biggest annoyance when I played on nightmare.

The reason I loved all 3 of these games is because they take us into so many eras of time that you would never see in a traditional Assassin's Creed game. It's incredible being a Medjay in Egypt, a Misthios in Ancient Greece, and being a Viking.

I feel like, Bayek had much greater character aspect in story, overall story was good, every villian had a backstory and after assassination scenes were great that made assassinations look justified. Egypt as well as afterlife maps were great. For me every question mark on map was like a piece of candy. AC odyssey lacked in something in story and characters. Alexios/K were more of killing machine. also at this stage those question marks on map were more of a chore to be done. DLC maps were great though AC Valhalla itself seemed like a chore after 2 hours of gameplay, story felt too bland so I procrastinate on playing it

Played these 3 games, stopped Valhalla at 80+ hours, still playing Odyssey at 200+ hours, playing Origins inconsistently because of Odyssey.

"NPCs in Odyssey can't swim" *literally almost beat him to death*

People hate odyssey, but I never played it as an ac game, I love Greek history so odyssey is an 10/10 from me. Water physics, Barbaras, kassie, soundtrack, locations. Are just beautiful heart ♥️

My favorite is Origins. - First, the game has a story line associated with previous games. The construction in the context before the assassin guild was born, making its gameplay reasonable and not pushed too far. - Second, the game was built in Egypt, the mysterious civilization, the game has a moderate length, the task is reasonable, this is also the factor that makes me appreciate the game. - Odyssey and Valhalla are built with too many mythological elements, especially Odyssey, which makes the game deviate from the rails, even the plot is very disjointed and unconnected. The gameplay is not much improved, the map is large, there are a lot of side quests but the repetition takes place continuously. That suddenly becomes the burden of the player. If you have played through Origins, believe me, you will feel very bored when playing the other 2 games.

Odyssey was INCREDIBLE. I know a lot of people said it’s bloated but I loved how there was so much to do. The dlc was the cherry on the cake. Incredible game, incredible story. Origins was great too but odyssey took it for me

For me, the one with the most enjoyable story is Origins, but Odyssey's decision making changes the story and that makes the player to be involved in the character's development, which is more interesting; on the other hand, Valhalla's combat system (with the stamina and stuff) makes the game harder because you have to be aware of your movements and the stamina you spend while dodging and attacking

Origin the best imo....we see where the cutting of ring finger originated and the story is very rich...I especially learned a lot about Pharaoh's era because of this

I've played Odyssey and Valhalla twice each (as all 4 characters) but am giving Origins a go for the first time. I prefer Odyssey so far simply because of the ancient Greek setting, which interests me. I love AC in general because of the fact you can climb literally anything. I'm currently playing Watchdogs: Legion and the fact that you can't even climb over a 10ft fence/wall is frustrating.

Origins has awesome cloth physics

Hands down Origins. If you’ve been a fan from the beginning than you can see how origins was a HUGE breath of fresh air. Just finished the story line and still see myself getting back on to complete more quests. Absolute S TIER

Im a sucker for adventures and stories that have a LOT going on. Good or not..Odyssey kept me invested for more than 400 hours now. Its the most fun and complex game, considering all the stats, builds, RP-G and play styles,. World is absolutely gorgeous. Odyssey is more challenging that other games (except Unity..I can't master that game at all HAHA). Odyssey is the world I'd lose myself in every time..Sure it has flaws but then again, every game does. Plus..I love the amount of content im the game

Odyssey is my favourit basically because of the general setting. I love ancient Greece and i think they did a pretty good job in creating the open world of Odyssey. I also liked Valhalla, because im from Norway and the general culture and setting in the game is very accurate, and it all feels very familiar. The Wrath of the Druids dlc was also very good.

For me personally it was Odyssey. The setting, family moments/ death of a certain someone, cult and Atlantis ending was a great payoff and I just enjoyed the speed of the gameplay is all...(most of my gear was assassination focused with combat on the side)

I would say Origins is best overall. Especially Bayek character agenda was very personal and actor bring the best performance.... Odyssey although i love Kassandra VA performance but she is lacking the emotion like Bayek has, probably if they r focusing her as a solo character the outcome would be better. Valhalla. Yeah thats my gripe on these 3 titles...

For me, Number one is Origins. I was always interested in and loved the time-period of Ancient Egypt, even though the one in Origins is already late, late Egyptian-period, more like the "downfall" of Ancient Egypt (keep in mind the Egyptian-period lasted for over 2500 years; Cleopatra is actually closer to our time than she is to the construction of the Pyramids, let that sink in). You know when you sometimes sit there and just think "Man, I wish I could go back in time and just see how everything looked back in the day. Alexandria, the Pyramids, the villages. The vibrant colors and the Nile River" and I think Ubisoft does a great job in giving us the actual opportunity being able to interactively visit those places. And now we are about to even see Bagdad and later feudal Japan!!! How cool is that? Imagine living in the 1800s and the only thing you ever heard about Egypt, Greece or Feudal Japan was some words from a book or word of mouth... we actually get to go there without huge efforts on our part. Even though not everything is exactly how it was back then, obviously, but you get a glimpse of what it could've been and you can even interact with it. Rather than watching a short Documentary or something for an hour. You can explore, you can climb, you can experience all of it, in it's glory. For a moment you can forget that you are living in 2020/22 and teleport back to 44 -49 BC (or 431-422 BC). Same goes for AC: Odyssey - Ancient Greece comes right after Egypt for me, therefore it was really nice to experience that too. Meeting Sokrates, Perikles, Pythagoras, seeing Athens... - wow. Ubisoft could even completely go a separate way of AC and just make games that go back in time and do a random story they want - I would buy most of the games, just to experience the time periods. They already went that kind of way with the 'Discovery Tours' for Origins and Odyssey which are, from a learning perspective, really really cool! Imagine just being able to actually interactively visit the a city in Ancient Egypt instead of some boring drawn picture or old video or something. Story/Fun wise though Origins was way better, it had more of a red string you could follow, and an actual story behind the character that was interesting and gripping. I'm kinda sad though that the DLCs for Origins were rather disappointing tbh compared to all the DLCs Odyssey got. Origins will always have a special place in my heart though. Same goes for the very first ACs I have never given Valhalla a real chance as of yet (maybe later this year) - but I was actually looking forward to the game; Vikings, England etc. and all the features. But once I heard how the game is stretched out so extremely hard that it feels like a huge chore I just lost interest right quick.

playing Odyssey has completely spoiled me in terms of mobility and freedom of movement Like, you can climb over everything and get anywhere no problem. Games with limited mobility and those that only let you climb where they want you to climb (like Tomb Raider reboot games for example) felt suffocating and frustrating in comparison

Odyssey was the one for me, it just included everything other ac games had. Except the on field synchronization where you'd be able to see through walls but that would be OP. Although origins fluidity and flawlessness of the engine with barely any glitches or lag was an amazing feeling to have in game. ac 2, black flag, untiy, origins, odyssey, and valhalla were all huge successors of one another in my opinion.

I have only played Origins so far since my laptop can't handle Odyssey up to Valhalla. But I like Origins so far. Bayek's journey for revenge is good and having him talk with his enemies and finding out their purpose and reason is really enjoyable for me. But I can't compare it to the other two since I haven't played them.

"Ac odyssey has most realistic NPCs"....Meanwhile the NPC sees Kassandra maul 15 elite soilders to death using A sword and Bow that has fire abilities...*Proceeds to fight Kassandra with a broom.

Valhalla Great gameplay, Odyssey Great World, Origins Great Story.. Each are unique and beautiful. 10/10 for Odyssey, I love the architecture. Both AC Origins and AC Valhalla 9/10..

Origins without a doubt. Ubisoft did an amazing job with Egypt, atmosphere is spot on, its so immersive especially maxed out settings on PC.

I love all of them! Every of them is unique in their own way. I love ancient Egypt. I love ancient Greece and of course Vikings. but Odyssey is my favorite because the map is so large. Love it!

Odyssey was clearly my favorite. The story was amazing and the game play fit really well.

I’ve played through all of these games but for me playing odyssey as Alexios was so elite

Crazy to see all the different feedback. My favorite was definitely Odyssey. The best part of it were the solid amount of plot twists. There didnt seem to be much surprise in other games. Origins was alright, but i didnt enjoy the gameplay much. Valhalla seems great so far. I love the story and how it all ties together. The only thing that its missing is a solid amount of intrigue.

Not sure about Origins and Valhalla, but in Odyssey, if you synchronize in buildings, you can hold C + Shift and they will do a vertical flip in leap of faith.

I love this details comparison. Thank you for the effort.

Origins is honestly the only game that justifies its existence among these games. Parkour is rudimentary because it wasn't developed, assassinations were basic because there weren't any techniques centred around it. Story was brilliant, the voice acting was excellent. So many brilliantly written quests. My favourite part is egypt though. They did such a great job with the desert (hallucinations) and explorable locations that I actually wanted to explore it. Perhaps the only cool thing the other games did was how they showed the birth of templars in valhalla and gave us Basim. Odyssey is pretty much irrelevant to me as an ac game.

The three are good games with flaws like the increased amount of time with the next entries, so there was a point that I wanted to progress in another assassin's creed to have everything at 100%. But even if they became too long, the plots are very entertaining that can hook anyone.

I enjoyed Odyssey the most. The setting was beautiful compared to the rather dull one of Valhalla. The DLCs were also incredible and the whole fighting system was really cool. I learned to not force an Assassin theme when playing these games, so with Odyssey I could just enjoy a cool Greek mythology game. I played Origins after Odyssey so I only just then realized that it build the groundwork in terms of UI and fighting style and it was also a great game. Looking forward to Mirage because not only does it seem to bring back the Assassins theme but the setting also looks promising. I just hope they make it as vibrant looking as Origins/Odyssey because Valhalla looks a bit washed out for me

Odyssey is my favorite due to the gameplay and world. AC Black Flag was my favorite of the older games, so I thoroughly enjoy sailing and exploring. Origins, I love the setting. I always liked desert areas in most games. Valhalla is good and the combat is pretty fun. I'm glad they added other things to do like fishing.

Thanks for your 2 videos. I just started playing the game after many years of knowing it, and I am amazed. The comparison was helpful. But what about the fight comparison? Did I miss this part?

I actually appreciate this. I'm just playing Valhalla and want to expand into the AC world but don't want to feel like I'm stepping backwards in terms of graphics quality. Thanks!

Gonna be valhalla for me, im a huge viking culture buff having roots from danish and celtic pagans, it just hits a very special place in my heart

Odyssey is the on for me out of these three. Origins combat felt stiff and a little underworked, but Odyssey felt like it polished the combat and expanded on it. Of course I prefer the original combat system of assassins creed over this new combat system, im playing an assassins creed game, I don’t want to be brawling in the street like some gladiator.

i think these 3 are the best "games" in the whole series but as everyone knows the assassins aspect is next to none

I like Odyssey the most of the three but all 3 games have game play functions that I liked. Odyssey wins it because it had a bit of everything in it from past games like ship battles etc.

Ive played a bit of Origins but recently I started Odessey and I am hooked! All I can think about is hopping in and discovering more of the beautiful world. Origins was chill and I might go back but not till I play a lot more Odessey lol

Sorry if this is a silly question, but where did you get the white and black horse in Valhalla at the 8:04 mark?

These new mythology AC games actually I really like

Origins was my favorite of the 3 but I’m pumped about mirage because I want to actually play as an assassin again

I love anything Viking related. Sadly, it is not my first place option. In my opinion it’s a great Viking game, but not a great AC game. I play assassins creed for the story more than anything. So I have to say Origins is the best of the three. The ship battles in Odyssey was ultimately what brought me the most joy, and the fact that you’re like Leonidas’s grandchild.

I have just finished Odissey yesterday and that was the last AC game I hadn't finished yet. Been playing all of them since 2014 I guess, having played all until AC Black Flag twice. Being a hardcore fan, I really really love each of the games and their uniqueness when compared to each other, and the same goes for these 3. I really love them all, love the Origins story and Bayek's journey, with that breathtaking and very entertaining world, also love the evolution of Eivor and the combat system, love exploring England and all, but for me by far Odissey is the favorite. I just love how many activities there are in that game, the endless experiences and impact you can cause with some pretty well crafted storylines, even in places you'd never ever go near just by playing the main story. It's so so colorful and fun, while serious and full os emotion, the combat and enemies are very enjoyable, ship battles, mercenary system, cult, greek stories and legends, the war, the arena. And finally, the chance to relive it all with the opposite gender/choices and have a completely different experience. It's a 10/10 for me.

Great video to everyone who put time into it. I thought it was hilarious when you beat the hell out of the npc in Odyssey and then ‘nope, he can’t swim’ 😂

Odyssey for me.. Beautiful field 🥰

2:00 wtf 99 level civilians 😅

Great comparison, thanks!

I was today years old when I found out that corner swings even existed in Origins! I never had to use it to free run and never even knew those pulleys were there in the first place. One of my favorite things to do is aim a hunting bow at the head of a target that is too far away for a direct hit. Then slowly raising the cross hair higher and higher above their head until their health bar popped up and then release and let the arrow do this insane arc as it hit them (raise a little higher and you can nail them in the head every time). Even more impressive to hit a moving target this way. I would decimate an entire fort from one location using my hunting bow instead of a predator bow. It reminded me of a Skyrim mod where you can tag an npc, then fire a ton of arrows into the air, a mountain's distance away and then all the arrows would find their target. 😂

10:07 demigod spotted🤣🤣🤣

I played Valhalla on release didn’t like it,started again last night and it looks totally different and I think they changed the skill tree I’m actually enjoying it a lot more ,I prefer the old creed games more tho

15:24 0 snow interaction! U don’t leave a trail unless ur on the ground, the snow won’t fall of when u walk on buildings or grab onto them, and if it’s snowing outside, the snow will not build on your clothes! 2020 game 💀

bro can u do this with combat and abilities between the three games that would be fantastic like only from the last 3 games combat n abilities tho so it could be in depth

Story - Origin, Fun, Exploring beautiful scenery - Odyssey, Rich history and gameplay - Valhalla

Odyssey is my fav because of the map and side objectives

Assassin's creed 2 and Brotherhood are the best but if you choose from these three, then Valhalla is undeniable better

Origins has the complete package of all the assassin's creed, it was open world RPG but it still had assassin's creed roots and I love the story. Odyssey had little assassin's creed elements and it look like a completely new game. Mostly open world RPG and it could have been another game. Valhalla is all over the place the only assassin's creed elements are the order of the ancients and synchronization. The story feels out of place and I feel like his assassination have no purpose like you are killing people just for your clan.

Origins is the best. The setting of ancient Egypt is unbeatable. Also, Bayek has the most tragic and engaging story. I love Bayek's character so much that I even place him above Ezio

Odyssey is the best AC ever. It has unique combat system. The game doesnt threaten you with desync. when a civilian is killed unlike others. Either they gather and defend themselves or bounty hunters try to kill you. That s great . Nightmare mode makes it even better. Also, with fascinating views, statues and the sea, the world itself is one of a kind. Love it.

7:38: Idk why, but that dude's death yell made me laugh.

Origin way above. Egypt is incredible, Bayek is deep and touching, as Aya is, really in love with this game

I am Egyptian, so yeah, AC Origins for me is the best last canonical AC in terms of everything hands down.

Origins is not a game bro, it’s a masterpiece! 🐫

I can't compare them, as I have only played Origins, but I have to say. I am 26 years old and I played Origins for the first time last year; The last time I felt that immersed in a game was when I was a teenager. Bayek is an incredible protagonist, very human, very flawed, with a purpose for everything he's doing. The ending was bittersweet and believable, and I keep coming back to this game again and again. Not to mention the setting in Egypt evokes this sense of mysticism that just pulls you in as you go along.

3:24 not the vogue dip while on fire🤣

I genuinely liked Valhalla but there was so much more to do in the other games and the quality was not as good. Out of the 3 odyssey was definitely my favorite. I loved watching the enemies burn, it was so satisfying every time

I love all these games. But for me it’s Origins that takes the top spot out of the trilogy for me. Valhalla is okay and Odyssey was fun. But I see myself coming back to Origins when I want to replay any of these.

Gotta say, AC Odyssey actually gave me the feeling of “damn, the enemy defeated me” when I’m very close to finishing them off but one stupid charge attack enemy use and killed me. Without end game stats, some enemies are kind of hard to deal with. Bandits AC Odyssey are also nightmare. The poison that the dagger inflicts so fast I can even parry it. The spin kick combo when enemies are glowing is also annoying, they do a lot of damage. One more thing, the daughter of Artemis are burning me alive. All of them aim at the same time, I have to keep on rolling.

For me if you could put into one game. Egypt setting from origins. Storyline from odyssey and graphics/details from valhalla. Combat from the originals series. Old school white assassin cloak and blade. Perfect

I like odyssey best by far because u can slaughter civilians and even get rewarded by it with generating bounty. Which I think adds something very big to the whole experience. Amazing still.

Bro we know everyone will be like "new game bad old game good"

Very cool video, good job!!! 😃😃😃👍🏼🤜🏼🤛🏼

I don't recognize the point you jumped from in oddessy? Is there a different map?

Odyssey is the best game, Origins is the best assassins creed, Valhalla is…. Well at least Norway is quite cool

as egyptian i will always choose origins but in general syndicate is my all time favourite

All were beautiful awesome games I hope we get more of this type as well as og assassin's creed, personally I love the og style. I can say the pitcher style ac were so good in it's own way we need both.

11:19 It does spread if the material is dry, like a dead bush, or a dry hay built structure

Origins. Bayek is fully human. (No demigods. No Allfather). Just human. A father and husband avenging the death of his child. He is the most grounded character with a believable story about the beginnings of the Assassins. Loses his marriage but helps start a movement. A lot of Bayek's identity and emotional trauma are very relatable to the player.

None lol, I don't really like the supernatural effect of the new games but if I had to choose, it would be origins. I prefer AC unity- my favourite game of the franchise. I think the newer games have repetitive combat and trash climbing. No hate though you have a great channel keep up the good work.

Alexios beating npc to death. Body falls into water. "nah he can't swim"

Just started Odyssey a few days ago and so far it‘s my fave AC. Have not played Valhalla yet.

In the next game if they have a story like Origins, a decision making like Odyssey and a combat system like Valhalla, it will be perfect.

I like Assassins Creed Valhalla MOST because I am a Viking Fan!

Slaughtering NPCs in ac odyssey definitely the best thing that ever happened

i played and love both origin and odyssey. only problem is that they require a bit grind of level before doing progressing each story line quest. Will try Valaalla too soon

In terms of graphics and physics, the three are very similar and have their strengths and weaknesses. I think you should pick based on which culture you prefer. Personally, I prefer the Greeks :)

They are all very nice games!

Origins is good but i really couldn't get into Valhalla. But odyssey is on another level fell in love with it from the beginning.

I liked origins the most. Some of the check marks and tasks in valhalla just seemed annoying or tedious. I got every thing on the map on origins and dlc in around 60 hours. Oddsey I remember beating but can't remember much about it. It was the first of the 3 I beat. All of them are cool. But as far as completionist I'd sat origins but I liked all 3.

Origins for the world environments, Odyssey for combat and Valhalla for story. Ultimate Favourite: Valhalla 🔥

I believe Origins to be a masterpiece and the following two games to be major mistakes in design and more importantly, narrative. Sacrificing the Assassin vs Templar story and ridding the series of the debate between chaotic freedom and controlled safety only hindered the series. Especially when all we got in exchange was a grindy mess where you're more of a superhero than an assassin in a series called ASSASSIN'S CREED! Where I no longer care about the main character and actively in some cases root against them! My major pet peeve with Vallhalla in particular is the narrative. Specifically, who we play as and what we're doing. In this game, I'm expected to raid towns, burn villages, and conquer and enslave the people. As the supposed Assassin sympathizer, shouldn't the MC be focusing more on things like freedom and staying your blade from the flesh of an innocent? Alfred should be the good guy. Taking back his lands from the savages who invaded it. I don't feel like a hero while playing this game. I feel like a monster who raids monasteries and burns down the homes of poor peasents.

It is 2023 and Odyssey is still not properly optimized,. But i am still enjoying the game very much. def my top 3 AC game i ever played.

Origins and odyssey are my favorites of the rpg trilogy, although origins does win over odyssey by a bit.

All the trilogy mechanics were made with ancient egypt setting in mind, and so, Origins feels the right game for all the gameplay features. For example, having the ability to use a torch is near useless in Valhalla, but in Origins it is vital for tomb explorations.

I like all the Assassins Creed games.....I accept change and I'm glad Ubisoft didn't keep it the same from the beginning

My favorite has gotta be origins. The setting is awesome bayek is a great protagonist with a lot of heart and also seeing the birth of the brotherhood is so cool

Odyssey is top tier even now,5 yrs after