me too.i can’t believe she did it.

I went to her Girlie Show in NYC back in '93 (it's actually 30 years ago to the day tomorrow 10/17/93---my God can't believe it's been 30 years lol) but anyway I can't remember if she sang Bad Girl during that concert. I do remember she sang the unreleased track "In This Life" from her Erotica album and all the hits from it, but I just can't remember Bad Girl being performed, so this must be the first time she's done it live. Sorry for the rant, but your comment made me think of The Girlie Show.

❤️‍🔥

@@Christopher070 Thank you for your comment. She didn't perform Bad Girl during The Girlie Show. Same with This Used to Be My Playground. She ignored her beautiful ballads so many times. I'm glad she performes it now

She waited until her own girl grows up and play the piano for her.

I agree and yes it is

she aint playing it ... ^^

yes she is a pianist@@fynnbergstein

its not live. its prerecorded. cmon. she doesnt even have a band with her on this tour. ^^@@MCobos

@@fynnbergsteinthe band is behind the screens, like the previous tour, and There are tons of videos or mercy playing piano.

no there is no live band ^^ she aint playing live. sorry bro. proof it. cause ive seen it. she aint playing. @@MCobos

Was it crowded?

it was sold out @@coolfinetime

@@fynnbergstein i wish i was there

It was sold out @@coolfinetime

È unica, ammirevole grintosa. Vera leggenda.

Some songs half live...most of the songs playback as usual Madonna...I admire her but she was never a great singer...just surrounded by the right people...

@@davidgahan-ks5jhyep, she’s a hardworker, businesswoman, family-woman, still around and has this recent tour😉👍🏾 while most of her fellow musicians are gone.

I wouldnt if i were there, but im thankful for those who did😅

social media/ smartphones are the new mass cancer.

I would like hire someone to phone the show, and I just enjoy it😊.

I do agree, it must be a backup singer

Madonna is wearing wigs on the Celebration Tour…

what makes you say that? is it because the song was part of her SEX/Erotica era?

She doesnt like Words, then. 😂😂😂 one of the best of the album, and she never sang

She’s said this was one of her favorite albums

Thats why she put this on the setlist? She said she likes it alot in an Insta video.

Madonna is mostly known for dance songs - so any ballad of hers really gets the short stick in terms of concerts . She will perform Them, but not 3 million times like “like a prayer” or “holiday” or “music”… in a way makes them far more special. Also Bad Girl has very personal lyrics, it’s a dark pop song: perhaps she thinks it’s not great for a concert full of pop fans

your nuts it sounds great there’s no other track playing.

I agree, I noticed it too and now I can't unhear it 😢

The original song is playing with her 1992 vocals and she is singing over it. It’s distracting as you can hear 2 voices, her current one is deeper

Why do you think she’s not truly singing? Because we were all conditioned to think of her as a non-singer. I bet you would not think that of Joni Mitchell, Diana Ross or Barbra Streisand who are much older if you heard them sing well in 2023. Madonna’s had much vocal practice and training throughout her career, starting as far back as 1979. There were no Auto-Tune, Waves Tune and Melodyne when she recorded all those 80s and most of those 90s albums. She would *never* have had a record deal and a career if she was a non-singer. This performance is sung live! There is a low volume backing track playing in the background, but the live vocals are loud and clear.

@@RockVeteran that's answered my thoughts, backing track which is of her singing when she was much younger, thank you 😊

Agree totally, it's distracting.

It's her.voice and no playback,.she's always sung this song live. Some people should clear their ears and souls......

@@DeuDeoEgo really open your ears lol i mean she has never been able to sing live this is true but come on just lip synch 100% to the record. it would sound better.

@@blahblog4322 you seem to be full of hatred, do you have any room for some reason!? NO! You don't 👍🤗 tell me you are over 50 without telling me you are over 50 😂😘😘😂😂