its amazing and shock, i need some time to analyse, what was thinking after watching the movie, william kindnapped henry son and made him afton,the wife of henry did marry william but divorce of him and married henry but what you said, william see himself as the crying child, make a lot of sense because somehow therapy cd and ggy of tales of pizzaplex Gregory(a kid that look like crying child) is the mastermind behind everything, the one pulling all the strings most important, the house from fnaf 4 minigame being the house in the hills, i don't sure yet but henry being afton brother, make a lot of sense there a lot of reason, when henry loses his daughter in trilogy, he made charliebot that fall in hand of jane but is never explained how william did get them (there a lot confusion about remnant, but to explain simple way, remnant is actually a memory that repeated a memoryin a loop, that generates manys types of emotions, the strongest one is agony, any person soul is made of two types of remnants contain their existance, Light remnant"happy memories", Dark Remnant"Tragedy memories", remnant can haunt a place or objected, if remnant was fused with any intelligence will give sentience, it can split more and more, but the consequence, they started believing they are character they are haunting) i am been thinking about one single, 4th Charliebot wasn't lying in the trilogy when she said, she was the charlie john meet when they are kids Elizabeth is a charliebot that gained sentience after being fused with remnant, she is 2th charliebot, the one was created by loss, like henry missed charlie love, she missed his the 1th charliebot was the ella doll using a ilusion disk, 2th charliebot is never show it somehow who the remnant elizabeth have “It feels like home...”/Charlie said the same way in trilogy, that herself think that place as her home “It feels like, my birthday. Did you have a gift for me?”/Circus Baby is remembering her Birthday Party in fnaf 6, party recreated by henry in the same location of charlie birthday party where she died yup, its charlie remnant, the final dialogue of fnaf 6, wasn't about Circus Baby and Henry (the reason we don't listen puppet talking to henry in fnaf 6 ) but is about the final dialogue Charlie and Henry after decades (its the same as story susie come homes, but for charlie there is two,the puppet and Circus Baby) the one circus baby reffers as "us" in her dialogue, The puppet and Herself Circus Baby never once metioned killing kids, she metioned she was unable to fulfil her purpose before, because the pieces are scarttered everywhere, but henry and mike collected them all in one place, now she can finally do what they created for like she said, fnaf 6 was gift for her and the puppet The name of program in the puppet and charliebot, is called Baby william afton steal baby and creates his own version of it, Circus Baby that why is so confusion to undertand what she saying, she isn't a villain? she is more like a twisted charlie, or evil charlie so why she did that with mike in fnaf sister location (just one reason, mike deserves that, he caused the bite 1983) one thing the one being talking in nightmarionne and lefty in ultimate custom night, its was elizabeth, both has the same way talking Circus Baby AR-"I am so glad that I found you...let me find room for you...inside..." Lefty UCN-"Shhhh...I'm so glad that I found you, let me make room for you."

While I initially like the brother idea, there's some pretty glaring holes. The main one being William and Henry's accents. If the two grew up together, and Henry is, as you suggest, the older brother, there's no reason Henry wouldn't share William's heavy English accent. All of William's children have the same accent, so it's hard even to argue that it might have been something to do with growing up in different places, as all of William's children are presumably born and raised in the US. Secondly, Henry's relation to William could not have been the retcon you mentioned, as Scott confirmed that was from one of the original 5 games. Pizza Sim hadn't come out yet, Henry wasn't a games character, thus no changes to his relationship to William (even in Scott's head canon) would have counted as a retcon.

YES! Someone else who believes the Brother theory

Cool video! but that car alarm scared the shit outta me

Based

Though I personally disagree, this is a unique theory. I actually quite like it! The only thing I feel like I need to mention is that it seems impossible to obtain remnant from a person that was already dead for some time. Remnant is basically either body + emotion + nearby object (preferably a metal object) or just a flying emotion/memory like in FNaF AR (remnant can also be in liquid form, but it isn't important for now). So you either need a completely alive person or you need a person to die near some object. Under your take, William wouldn't be able to obtain remnant from the person who that grave belongs to, because they've been dead for some time already. Other than that, this video is pretty cool. It's refreshing to see something like this. Keep it up! Want to hear more of your unique takes, even if I'll disagree.