Exactly. Cricketkit is BLUE-GRAY like STORMTAIL. It makes no sense for them to be Runningwind’s kits when Dappletail and Stormtail were clearly a thing. I call bull every time and say those are Bluestar’s little siblings.

YEAH. A blue-gray kit and a white kit? Just like Stormtail’s DAUGHTERS?? Kinda sus.

I remember reading in Bluestar's Prophecy that Stormtail ended up taking Dappletail as a mate after Moonflower died, and the idea of her kits being Runningwind's juat took me for such a loop! Like huh? What happened to Stormtail?? 😂

wasn't stormtail dead by that time tho?

@@renbarber6908 he probably would have been an old cat, although I doubt he would have been an elder, even at the age of one

Same!!

I kinda felt like that but antfur just felt wrong, then I realized I was thinking about antpelt lol

In the seventh arc, they talked about Antfur at some point, and I was confused because it didn't fit what I remembered. I later learned that Antpelt is someone else.

I was like, who’s Antfur? I remember Antpelt. And then Moonkitti made the comparison ten seconds later

I honestly forgot who Antfur (?) is. Unfortunately for you background characters I don't have a good memory.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY BY THE WAY!!!

Yea

We would inrerrogate them for many other things, they're too much mistakes we need to have a clear explanation

Yeah

Same

Spiteful trying to prove someone's semi negative accessment of my abilities is the exact kind of thing young me would've done

wait moonkitti has a birthday

Yeah that’s what I thought as well. I figured since she mentored him she would know how he would be as a mentor but the thought of him catching wind of her thoughts of him mentoring and him being helpful with apprentices out of spite makes me laugh.

Looked at Secrets of the Clans! "Bluestar Blue-gray she-cat with piercing blue eyes and silver hairs tipping muzzle and tail. Wise, kind, beloved, and strong. Brought a kittypet named Rusty to join ThunderClan. Rusty (renamed Firepaw, and later Fireheart) grew to become one of the most essential, valued, and respected cats in all the forest. Deputies: Redtail, Lionheart, Tigerclaw, Fireheart (later Firestar) Apprentices: Frostpaw (Frostfur), Runningpaw (Runningwind), Firepaw (Fireheart)"

cool seeing you here!!! i didnt know this information 👀

I love how I’m Fire and Ice Bluestar says “no, Runningwind does not have the patience for mentoring” (I don’t know if the words are exact) and then I just say “WELL OF COURSE RUNNINGWIND WAS YOUR APPENTICE!!!”

@@theoneandonlyspider ur english is pretty good!!

Yes please! :D

I agree! TallStar is so cool! I love TallStar’s Revenge, along with YellowFang’s super edition is my favorite book

I agree but she did say not to put suggestions on this video lol

Sorry y’all but the only outright gay characters were Ravenpaw and Barley because they were considered mates. It was only ever heavily hinted that Tall was gay(though, like, REALLY heavily hinted).

@songbird 64 true doh I member Ravenpaws farewell it was heavily hinted at

Ow, why does this hurt my heart

@@gremlininblue2601it hurt mine too, they were so happy to see eachother

O shit, I made my suggestion before she said that.

nahh currently hes nomorerunnigwind😍

She's not taking suggestions on this video

I like them aswell

I love Foxleap my favorite OotS tom

ive been asking for this every video!!

I love Foxleap!!

Well they must have been, Runningwind hang out quite a lot with Fireheart, Graystripe and Sandstorm throughout Fire and Ice, Forest of Secrets, and Rising Storm

Tallstar still top favorite character despite almost being dethroned by Gray Wing

@@Amanecer458 Yesss

It would also be cool to see her talk about Sorrel,Tail because she already talked about her daughter Poppy,Frost

yessss I love sorreltail so much lol xx

Sorreltail is cute, but I wish she was still friends with Leafpool.... Their friendship was cute and it should have been more relevant.

YESSS PLS.!!!

“DONT PUT SUGGESTIONS ON THIS VIDEO THIS VIDEO IS JUST A BONUS”

Yeah in the preview for ASC flamepaw talks about how distant she is and it’s INTERESTING

@@quietsong2583 oh, oops

RUNNINGWIND'S TIME TRAVEL

I mean, his character development is off the charts! He's an incredibly important warrior who deserves more attention.

I doubt it, I don't think Erins would want to bother explaining why there were only 6 cats born/survived to apprenticeship (Darkstripe, Longtail, Dustpaw, Ravenpaw, Sandpaw, Graypaw) between Bluestar becoming deputy and Into the Wild (which would be about 3 years, and they would kinda need to cover that happening offscreen... plus they would also need to reveal who was Graypaw's father and who were the parents of Sandstorm (no, it wasn't Redtail and Brindleface, that was "decanonized" sometime ago apparently)

Irk! She started out as a kitty pet like firestar and she is raggedstars half sister and seems to have a close partnership with Blackstar and would have made a stern but reasonable leader similar to black star. Not super aggressive and whiney but they also stand their ground.

@@Spectorwing I know, shes such a cool character with a non generic background+ she was literally killed by a protagonist and I feel like she definitley deserves a talk, if I can't get her a talks here after trying for a handful of videos I may try the patreon. I love listening to these videos as background audio and I want to hear about Russet so bad.

I LOVE RUSSETFUR I have an AU where she became leader

I'm hoping Mousewhisker will get a mate in the next arc; actually with the whole thing about the warrior code changing, I remembered that in The Sight he had a crush on Minnowtail (then apprentice like him) from RiverClan, I would LOVE if that came back^^ Also Molewhisker and Cherryfall, too, at least one of them should have kits with somebody. Wasn't there something hinted between Cherryfall and Stormcloud once?

jakeclan

@@catxborsuq1 Knowing the Erins, they probably managed to forget about that crush he literally betrayed the whole Clan for.

@@catxborsuq1 Yes they did mention Storm X Cherry once in Bramblestar’s storm. And apparently it’s stated by the website that Mousewhisker is the father of Sorrelstripe’s kits.

@@valeqium Ah shoot! Sorry I thought they said Mousewhisker, thanks for clarifying.

Honestly I love this idea

Mhm! We also need more maps w her!

I never really cared for her (she just came across as generically nice) until I read her manga recently, it made me really understand why she took to Crowpaw even with his prickly personality. Plus I personally read it as PTSD representation. People focus so much on her death when I feel like she's so much more than that.

I... actually understand! She *is* more than her death and how she sacrificed herself. @@kuehnerthanyou3409

Idek what my opinion is anymore, i’m agreeing w everything 💀

Tbh I personally was never that interested in her idk she seems a bit too generic and too plain to really be that interesting but that's just my opinion and she can be quite interesting sometimes. And any love I had for her cooled when in the last book of TBC she was shown to be crueller and less forgiving as well as being jealous of Crowfeather spending time with Leafpool when she encouraged Leafpool to get with Crowfeather. Anyone else think that all the Starclan cats are more annoying, cruel and less forgiving when they die???

Yeah, Runningwind has a lot of lost potential. I wish he had stayed alive! I always liked him, and I think they could have further fleshed him out into a good character. He could have matured as he got older, or been a respected senior warrior.

@@fireworksforme2 If they replaced Runningwind with Mousefur, I would've been fine with that. Mousefur didn't have much coming for her. (I love her a lot as a character, but Runningwind had a lot more potential than she did!) If it weren't for Runningwind, Firestar would probably be a much softer cat, as he didn't have many older cats to actually look up to that were stern but not evil, besides Longtail and Bluestar. (Which both had their own flaws.) Runningwind was much more simply a code-follower extremely loyal to his Clan. I think seeing ThunderClan evolve with him around rather than Mousefur, or, Hell, even making him leader. would be extremely fun to see. I just hope he gets a spotlight in the future: if it weren't for Runningwind, ThunderClan would've been so much different. After all, Runningwind was also Bluestar's apprentice. She has only mentored a few cats, so being the apprentice of a leader is very special: many background characters who were apprentices to leaders got some sort of special spotlight at some point. (ex. Whiteclaw, Gorsepaw, Sleekwhisker, Lionheart, etc.) Runningwind deserves that spotlight, too! And, sure, Whiteclaw, Gorsepaw, and Lionheart were all killed, and Sleekwhisker ran away and became evil. But Runningwind should have gotten more plot. That's all I'm asking for from the Erins. More plot for him. Or perhaps from Whitestorm or Brackenfur, too, that'd be nice! Basically, anyone from Arc 1 should get more relevance besides 'I'm a spooky dead ghost, I haunt peoples dreams' of which only turn out to be Bluestar, Lionheart, Spottedleaf, and Yellowfang.

Exactly, same bruv :)

Yes, please!

@@flowerpoots According to the article`s title: "Introducing the official Warrior Cats game on Roblox". It`s also been confirmed by the game`s developers, etc. WCUE doesn`t limit what you can roleplay as. When people do refuse to do their duties, a Clan roleplay can die out, yeah. But, there are people who DO do Warrior duties! I`ve noticed that Queens go to the Medicine Den, practically every server now. A Clan can be organized, even with non-cats in it. I`ve met a variety of non-cat players(and am one myself), most of their OCs do Warrior duties and have interesting backstories. Voiding is always an option if you don`t want to roleplay with them(Don`t harass, that can get you reported to a game moderator). Even if that species doesn`t speak cat in the canon, it can in game. (WC:UE isn`t the books!) For example, Midnight spoke cat, Millie spoke dog, and some dogs spoke cat!

@@flowerpoots Ah! I suggest joining the WC:UE discord if you`re over 13, they have rp events there that act as more organized than an unplotted public server. The events always have interesting plots and the admins who host them are really nice.

@@flowerpoots ^^;

It’s honestly kinda hard to support them rn, and damn does the community (especially the discord server) makes me want to never touch the game again. Horrible shit goes down all the time.

@@bashfulwolfo6499 Yes, the game has had its drama, but a decent amount of the community really isnt that bad

I liked him too! And then rereading it I realized how very little he actually did and I wonder why I was so sad at his death.

@@CatoftheStorm this exactly! I have a feeling I just liked his name

She’s my comfort character as well!

i always hated him when i was 12 idk why i barely remember his charakter🤷‍♀️

To be fair, we got only about one scene of him and Tawnypelt before they became mates (which, really, I hope there will be a Special Edition about ShadowClan settling beside the lake and it would cover how they became mates because of how quick he was in that scene to accuse her of being a traitor, and then about 8 moons later they have kits together xD I mean, I can buy it, but I would love to see this love story), and since then they seemed to have good chemistry. He supported her decision to go to the Tribe, she stood by him when the Clan turned on him, and his spirit comforted her in her novella.

Well, Leopardfoot mated with Pinestar and Leopardfoot was a appreciate with Bluestar... So extreme age differences are common in warriors

Oh I think she already did a whitestorm one 👍

@@melodymelgoza Ah, no, that was about him supposedly being the father of Ashfur and Ferncloud according to the website, not about Whitestorm in general

Yes star flower vid pls

imagine being in love with a girl but she dumps you and hooks up with your dad lol