One with the size of 2006 model with the building techniques of the 2024 model would be peak

I think the new one looks the best Team 2024 👇

2006 size and 2024 structure would be great

I was never interested in these until the 2024 one. They never really looked too good IMO. This new, however, has a good balance of accuracy and play features that appeals to kids and adults and that really does it for me. I think the smaller size works in its favor, it makes it look more proportional which I greatly favor over size.

The 2006 is a personal favorite of mine. Its old blockiness just screams LEGO Star Wars the most to me. Look wise, the 2024 one is probably the cleanest looking one by far. Also thanks for putting it alongside the others. It actually doesn't seem that much smaller than the 2014 version by comparison, surprisingly.

For the 2024 interior I agree the bridge is smaller than is desirable and the 2014 is better there. For the rear internal section even though it is smaller I think the aesthetics and the details in the 2024 version are nicer that the other two. I think the 2024 has the best exterior look too. The upper bridge on the 2006 is a really nice play feature even if it does not look as good externally.

The new one is 160 not 170 it is by far the best value and as a moc builder it actually looks good

Personally I just like the one from 2024

2024 has the most playability. Also the point of a comparison video is to tell people with one is the best quality 13:45.

I'm surprised how much i prefer the 2024 version despite it being the smallest

2006 will always be GOATED imo

2006 was the best in terms of playability but my god did it fall apart easy lol. Really want to incorporate the bridge and hologram features into my 2024 one when I get it

People seem enamored with the 2024 and its only real advantage is better greebling, handle incorporation and better engine placement over the 2014 model. Otherwise it’s just outright disproportional to the source more than it should while being smaller to boot. In particular the main body is far too small to the bridge tower which is huge. This set feels more like a Rebels design where all the ships are oddly warped in their proportions. I’d get one, download instructions for 2014 version and get the extra parts and build that.

2014 one to is the best, it's a good size, easy pop up handle, slightly larger area to work and has the same exact features as the '24 model.

I plan to mod the new one into a Victory-class so it looks closer to scale with my 2014 one on display. I just can't get behind the 2006 one. The white & bright neon break up the design too much, and that Technic brick under the bridge needs to be covered up. It just feels incomplete.

The Lightcruiser actually came before the Star Destroyer. They were used during the Clone Wars.

12:58 It got hit by a laser canon that's why those things are there.

Oh my gosh again the light cruiser was a ship developed in the republic it is not a new variant of the Star destroyer watch the ahsoka temple bombing episode and you will see what I mean

The 2006 version is one of the first LEGO Star Wars sets I owned, and my first one to exceed 1,000 pieces and come with more than one instruction manual! I remember the first time I finished building it, I flew it around my house, humming the notes that played in the opening scene of A New Hope when the Star Destroyer flies overhead! BTW, the turntable in front of the Palpatine hologram is for the Darth Vader minifigure to kneel on while speaking to his master (and yes, it's missing a clear 1x1 plate for one of Vader's legs to attach to). And the sliding panels at the rear are supposed to reveal blasters attached to clips. And the black cheese slopes on either side of the superstructure are meant to hold green lightsaber blades that can be fired by flicking the gray Technic axles (Lego's first attempt at flick-fire missiles, although they were hard to fire consistently).

Can you post photos showing the size differences between these three? I have 2 from 06 and am concerned about the size of the new one.

2006 size, 2014 interior and 2024 exterior and build structure would honestly be perfect

I think you just saved this set for me 🙏 Great comparison

2006 is actually the perfect base if you want to mod it. It has so much potential for more details.

and also the venator class republic attack cruiser from 2009 don't forget that too

7:37 The engines on the other 2 ISD's spin as well. Pretty weird detail to mention instead of the fact that the 2024 model's engines don't stick out of the ship, which is movie accurate. 7:49 The 2014 model didn't have any functionality on the bridge either. It was only the 2006 model. Pretty weird thing to say again. 8:43 The 2006 model didn't have a lift arm. The 2014 model barely even attempted to hide it's lift arm, which is more cumbersome to use and leaves a gap in the front. It's only the 2024 model that seamlessly integrates the lift arm without affecting the design. Again, pretty weird thing to say. 9:55 There's only one officer minifig in this set. So why didn't you sit him on the other side to be in front of a computer? 10:15 Moff Gideon's cruiser has a wildly different shape than the ISD which just allows for more space. What a weird comparison. Like apples to oranges. 10:31 "The same ship"? You sure about that? 12:13 You spent almost twice as much time on the 2024 model as the other 2 models, so how is it possible that you say "that's all there is to say about it"? 13:37 It seems like "the nostalgia" points are leading the majority of reviewers to biased conclusions against the 2024 model. Despite it being better in almost every way there is, everyone will trash it in plain sight because it doesn't fill their eyes as much as the old models did. And that's pretty sad.

2024 looks the best from the outside but the 2006 one is just so nostalgic and will always be one of the BEST $100 sets of all time

The short size really ruins it the 2024 one for me. The proportions seem very off, it would need to be a few cm longer and wider for the bridge to not look out of place. That would also greatly help with interior size.

i still have my lego star destroyer set back from 2014, its also in great condition.

I dont think bro likes the new one

The new one definitely looks the best and better but I wish it was a bit bigger

I was critical of the new one but it does look good and not so much downsized comparred to the 2014 one

2024 Interior and exterior + 2014 size 💪🏻

I personally like the 2014 one because its the only star destroyer i got and i got it for only $180 on ebay

You're wrong about the price on the 2024 one, its $159.99, not $169.99.

2024 looks awesome

I've got the 2014 one I followed the instructions n mine has a gap between the panels

2014 is the best one, i actually own it but its in pieces😅 I could actually build it again🙂

You're 75055 is missing pieces at the front.

I have the 2014 version and I've pre ordered the 2024 version 10yr difference 💀

Great video 🎉 I see things I like more and less with each of them, too.

100 dollars is so insanely well priced

That inside for the 2024 is not the best as far and space and interior details go

I have never liked Venator or star destroyer sets because they’ll always be super downscaled

W

i think everyone here is like 14, so they dont know how lego was back in the day, personaly i think the 2014 version is the best

2006 is better for play 2024 is great for display and I think 2014 is the best of both worlds

the original is quite ungly, big, but too gappy

The 2006 version is the best in my opinion

I prefer 2014 version

noice

2024 best

2006 is the best

The proportions of the new one are so movie accurate!!!

Moths cruiser isn't even a cruiser it's a Corvette witch is pretty funny this thing is the size of a of the ship the rebels use in a new hope

Yeh 2024 looks good but its so much smaller for what you pay for. I hate these sets getting smaller especially for the price its ridiculous. I wanna pay for a expensive price for a 2006 size and not for a small set. I care about size more than "techniques" I rather want a set worth it than it being as big as a 75$ ship set or something.

2024 doesn’t look much better than 2014, but much smaller.

I don’t like 2014 at all