COME ON JJ!!!!!!

@@Cristiano_km shut up

not really mate

@@Cristiano_km nah

What video is that in again?

that one was easiest for me. i dont know man, my life and people close to me matter more than 5 strangers.

@@nukrisamyurashvili1630 facts

@@nukrisamyurashvili1630I would intervene and make sure the trolley kills anyone trying to save them selves.

Nobody of reasonable intelligence would sacrifice themselves for 5 people in that scenario. Human nature prioritises self preservation. If someone puts a gun to your head: you would do exactly what that person says, unless they're telling you to kill somebody much closer to you (family, child, close friend) in which case you may doubt it. There's no reason for you to act so selflessly, the average human fears death to a certain extent, even if they don't actively contemplate it.

@@commander1suv492 💯

Why would anyone sacrifice themselves for random strangers lol

@@maazali1595 your personal belief system? overall and mathematically pragmatic good? Like I get not wanting to but you cant say "why would anyone want to" as both are completely morally just and have their arguments, you cant lok at this like only your perspective is right. Peoplw in wars sacrifice themselves for complete strangers, are you saying they are fools for trying to save and protect them?

@@nbassasin8092 its not personal belief system tho. Its people in all their comforts wanting to be the hero without actively contemplating the repercussions. Simon for example is saying he would sacrifice, but really? That is nonsense. Would he really give up every little thing hes done in his life for 5 random people? Im a million percent sure he wouldnt even do it for 5 of his friends, and that is completely normal. There are certain things such as love, attraction, self preservation that have been present in humans since the dawn of time. Those wont change just because you want it to.

Look at it this way, nearly anyone could die today and save 5 people... Just by being a organ donor... I don't see people doing that? Heck I'm not even seeing alot of people giving up their spare kidney's to save a strangers life. So anyone saying they would sacrifice themselves, I think is just BS everyone would save themselves.

I would, but not only to save 5 randoms as you said, but also because I would not be able to live with myself knowing that I could have saved 5 people but chose my own ass instead

also, this is only half of the pharsing of the problem. lets say a train is coming and you need to choose to either jump in front of it or push 5 people, and you have to chose one. what do you chose now?

@@Orphen_ bro just said ‘spare’ kidney

@@nbassasin8092 if no one knew i pushed those people, i would defo pick that option without thinking

you are wrong he makes it look easy but he puts so much effort but he's white so he can get views easily, if he was black he would not be as big. BLM.

Yes You Are

Yes You Are

Man didnt hold back

Yea you are

nah fam

U wouldnt pull the lever at all, even if its the mona lisa. Im not killing anyone, i didn't kill anyone, im just witness

@@Jeevzsk thats what i am saying. if i pull the lever that means my action is killing someone and that will haunt me. its just unlucky that those people got in that situation.

@@nukrisamyurashvili1630 yh but knowing you let 4 more people die is way worse

Not concerning at all. It's the natural law of self-preservation. People would probably like to think they're selfless when asked in surveys, but in reality I'm betting 90%+ of people wouldn't give up their life savings or their lives to save 5 random people.

@@s94628 you didn't let 4 people die, you observed 4 people die. Switching the trolley could even lead to complications futher down the track you didnt know about. On the end, by not switching you also didn't save the one person, you let the train do its natural course Also switching could mean that you get charged for murder, accessory for murder or at best man slaughter

I'd save the clones, 5 of me would rule this world!!!

@@dailyelevation2813but then you would be dead?

​@@dailyelevation2813you are not gonna respawn as your clone buddy

Being a wtiness and doing nothing still means you will be held accountable by yourself. You'd see yourself as a murderer and you would technically be one.

@@zabcdzabcdzabcdzabcd5302 No you wouldn't. Having no direct impact on the events that occurred means that you're only classified as being a witness. Whether or not you see yourself as a murderer is entirely up to you but you wouldn't be legally marked as one as you had no input in what was happening

@@aabidhjaufer7225 How could this fly in court? If you had a situation where you clearly figure out that you can derail a trolley to NOT kill 5 people, surely the law can make you accountable for the deaths of those 5 even if they're on the preset path of the trolley. You not making a choice IS a choice in itself.

@@Karppaguy Choosing to derail the trolley would mean that you're deliberately killing that one person who would've otherwise been completely safe had you not done anything about it. You're literally participating in an action that involves putting someone's life in servere danger whereas choosing to remain as a bystander would mean that you aren't responsible for anything that occurred.

@@aabidhjaufer7225 That's just an idealistic way to think of the situation. In real life, when you know you have the ability to save those 5 people and kill the 1 person for it, you kill the one person. Otherwise, you KNOW you "observed" 5 dying despite having the ability and complete control over the situation. There is no competition. I'd be glad to be ostracized as a murderer in that point (although I wouldn't be). The problem didn't occur because of me, I made the best case scenario CHOICE in the scenario I came up upon, in which I had all the info needed to save the most amount of people. Nevertheless, my original comment had NO ONE dying if you pull the lever. You'd still be "observing" 5 people dying if you did nothing. But the whole point is that you know that you have the choice to alter the situation. Hence you pull the lever.

And it ain’t great honestly.

yaa she didn't need it

She has surgery all over,dk how simon is ok with it

@@niranjanrajesh1058 I mean it is her choice, not his.

Yeah i was wondering why everyone wasnt talking about it

Cheers jeff

Thats really sad your life depends on these two🥱 Get up and do something

@@Ltforlife22 let him enjoy whatever he wants lmao ur the actual sad one for being that much bothered over something so little 😪

I don't understand y'all...why do you wanna sacrifice yourself for literal random strangers

@@maazali1595 Because, why should 5 people lose their lives for the sake of one? It's called not been a selfish arse

@@darrenhatfield4578 for the sake of one? Bro that's not some random.. that's literally you lol

@@darrenhatfield4578 don't try to act like some hero...if that situation actually happens even you know you won't sacrifice yourself lmao

@@darrenhatfield4578 sou you say you would also sacrifice your own parents for 5 random strangers?

You didn't kill them The person who tied you up and kidnapped you killed them

That wasn't your fault tho

Nah

It won't...go and try it out lmao

True

But what if it's ur family 😱

@@oliverp8555 that's a different debate...but if those are random ass people...then idgaf about them

@@oliverp8555 then I’m killing myself

@@maazali1595 exactly

I was trying to find this comment to see I wasn’t the only one.

Thts what i thought I was like simon looks a bit different

Very true

They were tied down to the track, forcefully against their will I'm assuming. None of them intended to die. Your take makes no sense.

U can still prevent 5 deaths Everyone is going to die one day but we would still save people

Well yes, but by making the active choice of not saving them, you are killing the 5 people exactly as you would be killing the 1. Concept of choice and consequence.

@@madting2984 no you are not killing 5 people. i did not tie those people down and i am not driving trolley, i am just a witness to what is going on. but if i pull the lever that means my action killed someone and that will haunt me.

@@nukrisamyurashvili1630 but you will be haunted regardless by the thought that you could have saved 5 people and that your inaction led to their deaths....so no matter what happens the psychological damage will always be there so u may as well make the logical choice and pull the lever if guilt and fear is your issue here

Alot of charities are a scam

damn, no likes?

dang youtube fell off lmao

What the fuck is youtube doing here??😂😂

I think everyone would pull the lever

If there are no law related consequences to my action...then I would pull yeah

What is there were 20 people on the other track and they were all really close family like parents and stuff and then really close friends aswell

@@Bernieboii36 sorry but id still save myself, its not great but if im being completely honest then yeah

what if you had to push 5 or jump yourself? does that change your answer

Like you don't really know how dying feels like 🤷