Wow. The lightness and the flow of their movements. The song. The voice. What a powerful performance.

This performance is splendid. It feels like his dancers are impersonating Jinki’s thoughts and that his words resound through their movements… This is stunning. I absolutely love it. And of course, no words can describe Jinki’s voice and the way it calms you heart. Thank you so much for this performance! 💙

Most unique MCD stage ever!!! Healing & killing just as MCD admin tweeted with his outstanding vocals, visuals and this amazing song. Album of the year.

I love Onew's overwhelming voice and the dignity with which he can express his magnificent world. I love his warm singing style in the early days of SHINee, and also love deep, cool, yet beautiful voice like the ocean when he and Jonghyun were pulling back a bit to support the other members. I have always been impressed by his ability to sing with both warmth and a bit of dark beauty, and admire the effort that continues to make it possible, and his mentality of supporting others without being attached to being out front himself.

1:51 내가 웃을 때 누군가의 긴 밤은 사무치게 외로웠을 "때". 이 "때" 부분 헉소리나게 좋다!!

This is such a masterpiece. It isn't often you see words from the song being performed literally be brought to life with the choreography in such a beautiful and masterful way. "Circle" leaves me in tears every time and I am so grateful we have Jinki's words and voice bringing us healing and love. Thank you Jinki for the Masterpiece of a album and song that "Circle" is.

CIRCLE just takes you to a solemn sanctuary of reflection, finding comfort en healing. Onew’s delicate voice that touches one’s heart en emotions. The stunning dance choreo that is in unison with his voice and its lyrics. This is a brave Jinki showing layers and colors of his vocals en artistry beyond Kpop genre. And yes, FLEX that LIVE VOCALS ❤

The voice was so captivating.. the dancers were amazingly beautiful.. the stage is so magical!

Didn't realise my jaw dropped till partner asks if I'm not sleepy anymore. This is seriously breathtaking.

Amazing voice, amazing song, amazing choreography! You're the best, Onew! I O YOU ❤️

저 현장에 있던 나는 진짜 댄서분들이 징기들어줄때 그대로 하늘로 승천해서 올라갈것만 같았어,,,,

Oh!!! Thank you so much for letting him singing live 😭👍

His voiceee omg, the mic is so on!!i’m so proud being Onew & SHINee fans! Normally idol group tend to loose up after 10 years because no matter what they do, they already have stable loyal fans who will support them whether their singing skill starting to loosen up or they just dance without really trying to look they are into it, probably just the main dancer who still dance with all his/her heart. But in SHINee whether as soloist or group, you can see they all always giving their best, they keep evolving and never stop exploring their talent even 10 years passed and now in their 15 years. What amazing that this not just happening to 1-2 member but all of them. Seriously i’m so proud to call SHINee my fav group ❤

와 노래 진짜 잘해 ㅜㅜ 누가 봐도 라이브... 하 너무 좋아

Onew’s voice is so captivating...the visual, outfit, dancing and everything is top tier

이건 풀캠을 봐야하는 퍼포먼스네 ㅠㅠ

Onew, everything is so beautiful. Thank you for creating great music. Your voice, album, songs, stage presence, choreo, dancers, and the stage are the best! Healing and comfort. aaaah

The stage, styling, vocals, and the choreography are gorgeous! Shout out to the production crew, stylists, and other supporting staff members. And especially to the dancers! Beautiful beautiful

I can't say anything except this is onew, uri leader

멋지다 온유 연기가 좋은 연극 배우의 공연 보는 느낌이더

Wow penampilan yang agung dari jinki kami dan team. Melihatnya secara keseluruhan, kalian berhasil mengangkat lagu yang sangat indah ini dan memberikan nyawa baru di dalamnya. Ini mengesankan. Terima kasih. Kalian luar biasa

아니 마지막 온둡으로 바뀌는거 유죄ㅜㅜㅜ

Beloved onew and dancers did an incredible job and shawols sound beautiful too!

I like seeing the whole stage! The dancers work hard too. Let's appreciate everyone performing while listening to Onews wonderful voice.

What a masterpiece. The choreography and dancing is out of this world. Well done!!! Shinee pushing the boundaries again. I can't wait for Taemin's return. Well done Onew! :-D

무대를 .. 너무 잘한다.. 내 눈만 높여놔 증말

이 직캠이 진리다 온유 목소리는 언제나 들어도 공명감이 온유와 온유 댄서팀에 박수를 드립니다 A++++++작품을 만드셨네요

THE MIC IS ON! SHINEE THINGS YA'LL

Onew is no longer allowed to complain that he's a bad dancer. This choreo may not be technically difficult, but wow, is it artistically subtle! 🤯

The dancers did a fantastic job, I wasn't expecting him to have a choreo for the song but the subtle movements fit very well!

무대 너무 멋있다

노래개좋아

정면 직캠이 제대로 큰 역할하는 무대ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 세트도 넘넘 예쁘고 진기 목소리도 안무팀이랑 합도 최고임 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

Слухайте ONEW. Слухайте справжній Талант!

Circle really is that artful song not only from the song itself but also from the performance, then Onew's voice Onew's stage presence Onew's dance make it a masterpiece I'm so proud of Jinki

MIC IS ON ✨️

Art

한편의 무대 예술 그 잡채!! 써클은 무대와 같이 봐야 완성이다

Such an artistic performance! I think this will really stand out at music shows

Onew vampire version woooo claps!!! I didn't expect that dance 🤯 great choreography!!! So proud of our leader!!!

오케이 커트 하는 순간 온유에서 진기로♥️

요즘 루브르가 기술이 좋네.. 예술품이 노래랑 춤도 하고.. 생생해

Thank you for the one continuous shot of this performance. This way the viewer can see the performance as it is without a lot of zooming. When the camera zooms it cuts off parts of the performance! I want to see all of the moves full body! Thanks for letting us see the whole performance! The set is perfect, the choreography is perfect, I love how the dancers look in black. They’re usually in black but it works particularly well in this context. Jinki looks like a supernatural being, some kind of timeless and powerful wise man, which I’m starting to think he really is! What a wonderful performance of this extraordinary song!

이제부터 내 찬송가는 이거다

방송인가..콘서트인가 .. 진짜 괜히 15년차가 아니네요

온유 왤케 잘함 왤케 머시씀?

라이브 맞죠? 와...진짜 이렇게 잘한다고?

역시 진기노래는 라이브로 들어야해

역시 안무 풀샷을 봐야 해!!!!!!!!!!! 진짜 홀린듯 봤네..

The crowd going crazy is so nice

Wow the stage is so cool!!!

써클은 직캠으로 봐야해!진짜 멋져ㅠㅠ 엠카 감사합니다!

This is so beautiful.... Onew and his gorgeous voice taken to greater height

데뷔 15년차는 역시 다르다.. 새벽부터 생라이브로 무대 찢어놓는 내 가수🥹

라이브 넘 잘해

Our pride! Thanks for the great performance

IT'S BEAUTIFULLLLLLL i'm so in love with this comeback

ONEW FanCam Horizontal Ver.🦝💎💎💎💎💎💎

Keep going...onew best wishes....

so beautiful vocal king

the song and choreo really compliment each others

I wasnt expecting a performance WOW!!!

직캠 감사해여.. 삼대가 복 받으새여 피디분...

Beautiful my precious boy ❤

안무와 노래를 함께 보니까 뮤지컬의 한 장면인거 같아요🫠💗💗

Everything is so beautiful! The staging, the choreo, the song the voice!!!

How to let this man know that he's freaking talented and that shawols including myself are damn proud of him ??? Whenever i listen to this song, it gives me chills. The lyrics are so fresh and beautiful ! He is doing his best to make us happy, Thank you for that our ever loving leadernim ❤️👑

He has such powerful vocals. Such an amazing artist 🩵💎.

아름답다ㅜㅜ

love the choreo!! ♡♡

이온유 진짜ㅜㅜㅜㅜ멋지다!!!라이브는 물론이고 퍼포먼스랑 무대세트까지도!!!

멋있다

wow

퍼포먼스 진심 최고다. ❤️ 샤이니와는 또 다른 온유만의 장르로 이런 감동을 주다니. 너무 멋지다.... 넘 잘생겼...ㅠㅠ 😍

아 눈물나

Onew’s Live voice is so better than the studio version and has the power to reach deep into your soul! 💎

와 근데 진짜 안무가 노래랑 너무 조화롭다 ㅠ 너무....너무 좋은데...?

So beautiful….

Wow, the best back up dancers...

Onew's whole existence is a masterpiece

미쳤다........ 노래만 들었을 때도 진짜 너너너너너너ㅓㄴ무 좋았는데, 무대로 보니까 뭔가 벅차올라ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 이진기 실력도 도랏써어어ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 본업존잘ㅠㅠ

You're amazing Onew!!!

Proud MVP since 2010 ❤

이렇게 안무가 제대로 다 보이는 영상은 처음인것 같은데 좋다☺️ 온유 정규1집 써클 대박♥️🐰♥️

온유목소리멋지당♡♡♡♡♡♡

TU FORMA DE CANTAR BAILAR Y CONDUCIRTE EN EL. ESCENARIO SON FABULOSAMENTE HERMOSAS

Imagine him singing to you every day like this. I-

HIS VOICEEEEEEEEEE. LOVE! LIVE SOME MORE 💜

SHINee and their never ending formation of shapes 😍 the choreo from this pov is stunning obsessed with the circle twirling of arms from his dancers behind him. just IN LOVE FIGHTING LEE JINKI AND HIS DANCERS ⭕️🔥🤍

Bagus bangeeeetttt... Gerakannya bukan yang ribet gmna gmna.. tapi estetik paraaahhh

와.. 라이브를 어떻게 이렇게 하지 진짜 대단하네요

홀리몰리.. 과콰몰리.. 넘 성스럽댜...

Sangat suka stage circle

와...........😊

Onew surely one of fhe great vocalist that ever exist!!

This song loop in my head

Amazing... Jinki especially in this outfit looks otherworldly. Time stops for him when he dances the chorus!

라이브 미쳤따.

홀리하다.. 온유가 써클을 어떻게 표현하고 싶어하는지 제대로 보이는 거 같아

Love you Jinki