No.. Actually they were dieting.. You can see only Moonbyul eating.. The rest only take a bite and watching Moonbhul...

@@CrissaRain what the OP means is that the company doesnt make them diet. they diet on there own will and want.

@@ds-zd9qz Thankyou for clarifying! Thats what i really mean, have a good day!

And plus they have developed their own sense of how much they need to diet for each comeback. Otherwise, they’ll be criticized on the Internet. You know the drill.

Probably because the company felt confident in Mamamoo's self management skills, plus Moomoos are supportive of a healthy idol instead of Barbie Dolls. We like them for their personalities, their hard work and their talent. Not how skinny or pretty they look.

Why what happened to her

is it bad?

Yea she wasnt fat but she definitely wasnt as skinny as she is now. She was chubby actually but afterwards an agency told her she was needed to lose weight and she ate very little each day like maybe a sweet potato or something so her stomach got smaller and her metabolism got slower

@@elenagranger4807 this is so heartbreaking

True

It was mentioned in the previous episode that, due to her losing weight so quickly, Byul's body changed and now she couldn't gain weight. That couldn't have been healthy for her, and I hope she's doing better now.

She wasn’t fat. Her body was normal. Her BMI was 22 which is healthy. She just had a little “baby fat” but compared to now she was way better of with it. Her BMI right now is like 16 which is underweight. Being underweight is very unhealthy.

@@Noor-fx1dx yeah I know, I meant « too fat for being an idol » at a big company, imo she has always been beautiful

@@Noor-fx1dx does anybody have a pic or her exact weight at the time?? i cant find anything online she seems pretty much healthy back then??

@@Noor-fx1dx nobody said she was fat. The comment said they were shaming her

Ikr🙄

True.. And toxic society they have.

@@macarons4157 don't think about people said to u, coz it never end. When we thin they Will say we need eat more and gain weight. But when we gain weight they Will say we need diet 😑😑, my personal experience 😅,

also moonbyul was literally not born thin. I was her stan even when she just debuted and she used to talk about how she was supposed to debut in another gg (d-unit) before mamamoo and she was cut from the lineup because she was too heavy. predebut pics of her are also not super skinny. she diets a lot to look this way because she's experienced firsthand how only thin ppl have a chance in the industry. mmm was slammed all the time in the beginning for being "fat" and solar dieted SO much. annoying that the culture is so toxic that they rake over these women and then pretend like it was never a problem!

I though the same thing

Moonbyul worked really hard to diet, before debut the company told her to diet in order to debut, if u look at her pre debut photos she looks very different from now. If you have the same determination as Moonbyul, you can look as great as her. Now I think that she’s quite skinny and I’m a bit worried about her health but as long as she eats well our moon star will be fine 🥺

Thank you so much for this comment! Geez, I really hate when shows like this start talking about their weight. All of them have gone under insane diets to have the body they have now, and it isn't healthy at all. Moonbyul said she weighted around 60 kg before debut, and she debuted weighting around 45 kg. She lost 15 kg in a short period of time, that's a lot, and it's totally insane. And even so you can see that years after she lost even more weight during gogobebe era which was honestly alarming. It's not only what kind of things those crazy diets do to their bodies but also to their minds, I'm pretty sure Moonbyul felt like shit back then. If you look closely enough, now when she talks about it you can still see she's full of remorse and it makes me so sad. And it's not just her, Wheein has lost and gained weight between eras in a serious way too, biggest proof, compare how she looked during Egotistic, then gogobebe, then Hip (which oh what a coincidence that was the year she was the thinnest but when she felt the worse, mentally speaking, she had to sit out a lot of performances because of severe anxiety) to how she looks now. Now she is looking healthy again, and I'm really glad to see that, but she's doing weird diets again when she really doesn't need to. Same goes for Solar, she has pretty much maintained herself through time but looking at the amount of supplements she takes, I'm surprised her stomach is still holding on, besides the fact that even so she's still underweight considering her height. It's not a lot, but it's still underweight. Hwasa lost a lot of weight this year too, it probably has something to do with the fact that she is totally overworked, but since she's been working nonstop since María, I really can't understand why would she want to be dieting when she needs all the energy she can get right now. I remember Wheein not so long ago in this same show said that she even ended up in the emergency room once, because she took so much apettite supressants that she didn't eat at all in a whole day, worked out and ended up fainting. That's really crazy and very serious stuff. I know that some of these comments made by the MCs are not said with malice because they are so used to that craziness that to them it's normal but, I hope they could realize how truly awful they are. Weight standars in the kpop industry are seriously messed up. I hope people will learn to shut up for once and stop bothering them with that kind of thing, because it definitely makes them self conscious. Sorry about the rambling but this topic seriously triggers me and I hate to see that they are still oblivious to how much that kind of comments can affect the artists. They already work hard enough to add even more pressure about their image.

that's not how it works

It took me after *i ate Chinese food*

Oh? That explains why I always thought her skinnyness looked weird. as if she wasn’t skinny but forced to be skinny...

Actually, as an observer it's pretty slowv

@@elenagranger4807 oh sorry, thanks for correcting me👍

It’s actually quite sad. Moonbyul’s body got messed up while losing weight prior to their debut. And her appetite is still messed up til this day. So she has to force herself to eat well so that her body can absorb the nutrient she needs. Otherwise, she will keep losing muscle.

@@julinazhang8216 thanks for informing me, I don’t Stan them so I obviously don’t know most of their past, thank you for the info

@@loser4life842 haha anytime. There’s an eagerness in me to tell you go Stan them but it’s really a personal choice.

@@Flying-Chicken if you don't mind me asking for confirmation. when you say letting them starve themselves, do you mean having their own diet or actually starving themselves out of their own will?

@@Flying-Chicken actually they’re still a lot skinnier than an average person. The camera just makes them look a bit more chubbier on screen which deceives people’s perception of their bodies. Some have bigger frames than others so even when at their lowest weight, they still look bit bigger when standing next to other idols.

Welcome to East Asia.

@@ithilgreenleaf8184 it is samething for every country though

thank you for saying this so clearly. I knew about all of what you said but I'm bad at explaining so I couldn't write my own comment. I really dislike the fact that they portray her in this wrong light

@@Korea_kang Not to this extent it isn't.

@@ithilgreenleaf8184 it is for some countries in South Asia like India or Pakistan

where is model boss and gym crew?

I was waiting for boss Kim. I thought she’s gonna return in October.

Omg this is really heartbreakinf

Thank you

Is that mean she can gain weight ?? I thought she has that type of body which Don't gain weight like sunmi and lisa

@@hindosman7186 because of the extreme dieting, plus their busy schedule, her body has gotten used to burning down food without gaining any weight. I would know because it happened to me as well. There is still a possible feel of gaining weight, however it would be prevented with exercise. Considering she's a singer and has to dance on stage, the food will burn down due to her metabolism that was increased because of the extreme diet.

Thats why they have fist fight😂😂

right😂😂

yeah she's often not that considerate of her 🙃

Um what?

@@Myflopera1 Which part of the comment do you not understand?

KBS toxic

Yeah, or they could have named it "Moonbyul's way of eating,..." etc.

Kbs is just terrible yo, they didn’t even have concern when solar and wendy fell down and mow moon?!? *im fuckin done yo..* fr

Korean society* toxic tbh. The standards to be a celeb there is ridiculous

its not kbs its just koreas standards/society

Yes.

It's because MMM did that too often that the stylists are probably used to it by now. 🤣🤣🤣

I think they look cute in baggy clothing, whatever their weight is!

Exactly what a dumb title

@@getinlouiser2677 ikr 乁( •_• )ㄏ That's what I don't like about Korea, like they want everyone to be fair and thin. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ There is beauty in a chubby body and a dark skin too ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

@@mercymatteenahmasih It depends on each person though. I'm from SEA but people never judged me and hated me while I was living in Korea.. even with my skin and different looks

EXACTLY WHAT IS LIZZO

@@pitbullscrookedjiyong6269 even lizzo is losing weight like stop glorifying obesity Many people die Being skinny or healthy is good for health

How tf-

Yes

😂

Lmao fr. they think a true celebrity shouldn’t gain weight or never gains weight 😒

I know right. Wtf

yea they just wrote the title as if Moonbyul didn't suffer from losing weight how could they use this kind of title and ignoring Moonbyul's effort ofc I'm not saying that a true celeb should be thin af

Face a wall lmao

After binge watching Gamsung camping, I am having withdrawal symptoms already...

Gamsung Camping filming are her cheat days lol

It's hilarious!! I think it was filmed around the same time also haha

Gamsung Camping is basically a mukbang. I couldn't watch without drooling.

@@user-vg2vp5yr5c I agree! we will have to wait until next week's episode to see her again

no u don't understand kpop is about talent AND beauty charisma a lot but not just kpop like come on celebrities are celebrities because they look good however the problem is that they are associating skinniness with beauty but skinny means underweight in asia they are usually thinner than us however kpop idols are even more thin like how can u imagine a 170cm girl eith 40kg and they wanna lose weight like 😐 u rather wanna see a pretty person than an ugly one that is why they said that about her

am from korea but its very different in here my friends want to lose weight so do me because that is our standard sorry for bad english

Only before every CB.

They choose to diet their company doesn't force them to do it in

@@dazzlingmoo5813 not really, a lot of idols develop ED because it's always in the corner of their mind, all year long.

I thought I'm the only one. LOL

Yessssss

Very frustrating after having three kids,I thought i would gain weight,but no I even lost weight !!

Here!! It's so hard because I get full too fast compared to other people 😭

You are going to regret gaining weight. my mom used to complain about being too skinny and now after having kids, she wishes she could have her old body.

My god, i wish i can eat a lot and still lost my weigh 😅🤣🤣

I understand..i also have this issue...my body literally look like a board...so thin...i tries to eat more but the results is the same

i can feel you🥺

Omg SIS SAME! I Barely gain any weight, and when I do, it feels like I won the jackpot. I'm 24 this year but I haven't gotten past the 48kg mark.

I hope you all know that you are wonderful, amazing people with beautiful souls 🥺 I hope that you can accept yourselves because you are all worthy of loving yourself! But, if you are looking to gain weight, I think that eating in a caloric surplus and doing some weight training can help you build muscle. However, I’m not a medical professional or anything, so I don’t think my advice will be good for everyone

ALSO 5:22