jeeze i have goosebumps all over now... the line "tuesday night at the bible study, we lift our hands and pray over your body but nothing ever happens" always gets me, oh wow. It's just an amazing depiction of the frustrations we sometimes face in rough spots in our lives and having no idea what god plans for us. In fact this entire song is like that. Had to listen this twice to really digest the beauty awesome awesome awesome

oh you've covered like all of my favorite artists, from postal service to iron & wine to mgmt to this. i have no idea how I found this channel but I'm so frigging glad I did. your voice is phenomenal

I clicked away because the tears started coming but still smashed like and came back later to hear.

Been listening to your cover of this song for 10 years. Hope your still playing

Are you kidding me. this is like my favorite song in the whole world. i'm soo glad you didn't disappoint me. you're amazing

Better than the original in my opinion, your voice is to die for. I love it.

This is the most beautiful cover I've ever heard, of any song, on any website, on any day, of any week, of any month, of EVERY year. This should be recognized, and awarded, as the most beautiful performance on youtu--no...on ALL of the internet.

beautiful, absolutely beautiful.

Spectacular. Crying in the bathroom indeed.... Your cover choices show great taste and you sensitively honor the original without being chained by it. Thanks Marie.

You have the most beautiful voice, I have been listening to covers of this song all night but yours made me cry.

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING

Everything about this is beautiful.

Amazing.

I LOVE THIS SONG. AND I LOVE THAT YOU COVERED IT. YOU NEVER DISAPPOINT MREE. Keep on rockin.

Omg ... 100/100 u r piece of Diamond 💎

This is my favorite song. I m so glad. Amazing.. 🤞🏽

I cry every time I listen to this. It's stunning.

you are a gem with awesome taste in music.

i love how you keep playing all of my favorite songs

I could listen to this forever.

I did not know my antecedent was a holiday, and now also has a song? wow I surprised me every day

so i just listend to the original of this song, and i like yours better. i couldnt even listen to the whol thing. your voice suits this song much better.

Ive seen many of your videos and they are AMAZING!!! But seeing you doing a cover of this song made my life! Thank you very much and you did an AMAZING job!!

i've listned to this like 60 times now.

Hell yeah from 2018! This was amazing!

this is absolutely gorgeous!!!!

You are and amazing singer and guitar player keep it goin!

OK, it's official. I don't know how you do it, but you keep checking my iPod ceaseless. It's the only possible answer why you always do covers of my all time favourites... :DD you are awesome :D

Makes me wonder how these kids nowadays who dont have a lick of talent make it big and this beautiful singer im listening to hasnt yet.

wow this makes me cry

This is so amazing.

best female cover of this song ever! awesome!

Congratulations, girl. You nailed it.

This is a beautiful cover of such a great song. Your voice and playing are both incredible. You did this song justice. Good job.

wow, youre a real Sufjan fan! you do a very very lovely job at the covers! you have the beautiful voice! 5 stars! :)

Is there an instant replay button? I love this cover. :)

one of my favorite songs. i love your voice.

You rock girl im in love! great song to cover!

Beautiful version. Well done young lady.

Thanks so much for sharing this! I really love your voice, and your guitar skills are really improving! It makes me happy whenever I see that you have a new video out.

I wanted to hear a good female cover of this song and I found yours... stunning, truely. Well done.

Great job, you should totally be somewhere...like Holly Wood, or Los Vegas, those places

I don't think it's even possible to hate your voice. Always, always, ALWAYS lovely, Marie. I like your shower curtain. =)

oh my goodness this is gorgeous! One of my favorite songs and you sound so beautiful singing it!

I LOVVVVVVVVVVEEEEE IT !!!! you're the BEST!!!!

Ahh amazing song

Writing a lab report with this on repeat. You have a great voice.

one of my fav songs and you did amazing.

Love it! ♥♥♥

oh PHEW I thought you had erased this cover from your channel forever for some reason. This is one of my favorites of yours, really.

This song defines A Walk to Remember, no matter how cliche that movie is.

Great cover of a great song

The bathroom! Gods, that's genius!

this is such a good cover. such emotion in your voice. you have a gift girl. keep rockin' it

Looked through your channel and we have very similar taste in music. Have you thought about covering Patrick Watson or Matt Corby? Or la vie en rose by Louis Armstrong?

Come to Nashville. Please. Come to Nashville and play at the Bluebird Cafe.

amazing voice and guitar playing. good job!

great taste in music~!

lovelovelovelovelove!

Such a great cover Marie!

you are making my stressful day beautiful. i can't wait until i see you

I really like the breadth of styles you cover. Keep up the good work!

Great voice. Great job.

Your singing gives me goosebumps. The good kind.(:

YOU ARE AMAZING!

gosh you have such a great voice. love this song

Wow!! This version is amazing !! 😍 Goodjob 😊

rad song!! you sing it well

Wow...

Oh my gosh, that is my shower curtain. I'm going to take a video in my bathroom and post it as a video response. You have an amazing voice too :)

This is an awesome cover! I'm really impressed. Keep up the good work.

this is soooo amazing! i always love watching your videos because your voice is amazing! :)

that IS a cool shower curtain! ...also this is incredibly awesome =)

Your voice is so pure and crisp. I love it! c:

I was going to post a comment telling you how beautiful you sound, but then I realized that I would be the 79th person to tell you that, so it wouldn't be a special comment. So I'm making this comment special. You're amazing. [:

very nice! Lovely voice :)

well this is cool, we have similar music taste. YUS

this song is kinda sad. but you sang it beautifully

Your range is very impressive. Overall, the cover is beautiful.

WOW its just so so so beutiful :0 ive just got it on repeat :D, Pure bliss.

I'm in love- you're so talented! just in case you haven't gotten that in a while

I had never heard that song before but you did a really good job!! great voice and you are really good at playing the guitar too :D

your voice is sooooo beautiful! :) it has a very relaxing quality to it

Beautiful

Nobody likes pop stars because they sing songs about losing love.But really, they were dumped. This song is about real love, and how tough it can be to see them go, remembering them. Nobody would hate miley cyrus if she sang songs like this .

This cover made me cry.

OMG ME TOO!!

Beautiful cover! I just posted a cover of this song myself earlier tonight and figured I'd check out some other covers of it and was pleased to find yours! :)

beautiful! man that guitar looks huge! hahah

u have an amazing voice, well done!

Angelic!

haha i love bathroom songs nice job with the song :D everytime i watch one of your videos i sing the song for the rest of the day :)

OMG awesome darling!

so amazing!

awesome

If I was your father , I would have took you to a studio and made you make an album , and buy you an entire mini-studio for ur bday , god you are an awesome singer o.O =]

Love this song, very well done :)

you're voice is so beautiful!

@123rosehips I used to have the EXACT same problem. Like, up until just a few months ago. It drove me crazy because there were few songs I could sing along to, and every time I played something on the piano and played it, I had to change the key signature. So, my advice is this: Sing things right at the top of your range. You will get better at those highest notes, and slowly be able to go higher. :) As for low notes, I'm not sure. :/

NICE!!! In the bathroom. Ha Ha great job.