It's more than just a concept for her....IT'S MOONBYUL!!

PERIODT! That...YOU ARE CORRECT

YAS

PERIODTTTTTT

periodt

@j it has girl crush energy

@j please explain what is "masculine energy"

well said

it's not boyish but i dont know how wearing suits is breaking gender stereotypes. girls are allowed to wear suits. it is the double standard that guys cannot wear dresses that needs to be broken.

@@LittleB1RDY this isnt western society soooo false

Yes!! I’m so proud to say that she is the first female idol to do this kind of concept. She tried to break barriers and even though not many notice it there are probably female idols that really appreciate this because they might want to try it but since it’s a different concept/style they can’t. Seeing this is a improvement in Kpop for females.

I bet Byul-yi and Soyeon would get along GREAT! Imagine these two building a company together.

Nine million views is plenty 👀

@@chatsnoirblamo Not enough for me. She deserves so much more!

@@chatsnoirblamo not when compared to other K-pop mvs and the time it's been uploaded for though. 😔

Agreed

100% agree.

agreed! lunatic and c.i.t.t were great but eclipse still holds a special place in my heart. it's the concept that suits Byul the most~

Listen To your heart YESSSS THIS IS A MOOD

😆😆

She can top anytime

This is the first comment. I cant stop smiling

Me: BOTTOM

Syd where would she devour me tho? 👀👀

😍

moonbyul pls choke me Looking at your username, I think she’ll grant your wish instead lol

@@overthrowthegovernment7215 maybe MMTG from SBS

@@overthrowthegovernment7215 hahaha I know where I want her to devour me 👀

May I say that she multi talented artist that deserve recognition

Leggo ~

Let’s go!

Fighting!

Vamoss!!!

Made it!! 10M next goal!!!

we're trying to get 10M views by byul's birthday this month but I don't think it's going to happen tbh 😭

@@T355V same...

@@T355V I'm quite stressed about how slowly the numbers are increasing, I really hope we can make it, Byul deserves to get a lot of views as much as the others :/

​@@yazmins.2157 I know... seeing how slowly we're going makes me so disappointed. It also makes me sad because Byul will also never say if she's disappointed in us...

@@T355V exactly. All she says is that she's happy cuz she got to make the music she likes and she chose this concept but i'm pretty sure she would've been happier if we gave her a win for eclipse. Some moos didn't even stre@m the song. Sigh

We probably have to start recommending this song to other fandoms and promoting it more.... I mean, the moomoos who are streaming are incredible, but there are just not enough people 😓😓

Leggooo

Keep fighting!!!

im speechless we went from 3 million to 7 in a week i LOVE these determined moomoos

@@kelsewer9672 wait really?

YES!!!

Moonbyul : KING

i was thought that you'll end up with hotel: trivago IM SORRY-

Fact!

@@iamrealham8209 she is a girl

@@iamrealham8209 she's a queen. A queen isn't inferior to a king

Couldn’t agree more! She has it all

she hasn't "succeeded" in the industry's eyes yet since she hasn't got many views or any wins yet so we have to keep fighting. Just because she pulled it off flawlessly isn't enough for most

Amber Tirbhowan yeah I know. We have a long way to go, I was talking about the fact that she did this concept and it didn’t turned out negative. I really enjoyed it and she did well.

Boss Moonbyul YESS

Couldn't have said it any better

True

Lets make this 10M views

You are right

Yes~~This deserves

Carolina, masculinity and femininity defines itself depending on different countries and culture. I really like your comment to Moonbyul, but remember that it differs f rom culture to culture. So I wouldn't officially say that her music is masculine if its in her country. Sorry if this comment offended you in any way.

@@LuklioN44 it didnt offend me dw. And yeah I do know masculinity and femininity are very different, I’ve lived in four different cultures and the difference is really clear. But I was talking about k-pop, so I think it’s implied that that was the context I was talking about. This is probably the most masculine-leaning concept Ive seen a female idol go for. In other contexts I wouldnt say its super masculine, but in context, compared to any girl groups or female kpop artists Ive seen, yeah, its more masculine than usual. I pointed this out specifically because its something that iterests me a lot. All my favorite kpop artists, male and female, are doing something that explicitly challenges the heavy gender norms in kpop. So I really like Taemin and Moonbyul, for example, and Id say a big part of why is that they’re doing things that aren’t conventionally gendered, in context. Out of context, Im a very involved member of the lgbt community and Im used to a lot more gender challenging than what kpop has to offer, trust me.

so true like gurl i didnt know how to use words to explain this U SAID IT ALL!! good job

femininity/masculinity exists in people' heads only. using these terms = supporting gender stereotypes. strike them out of your dictionary.

@@kateraspberry7634 So I do disagree with you. I've taken a lot of courses on gender studies and lgbt studies, and although that doesn't give me any authority on this subject, I do feel like I have some idea of what I'm talking about. So here’s what I think: Gender norms and stereotypes are absolutely connected to terms like femininity and masculinity, but those terms have a function beyond that. A big part of the feminist movement and the lgbt rights movement is based on blurring the lines between gender expectations, and disconnecting sex and gender by defining sex as biological and gender as social, while gender norms are social expectations according to someone's gender. Expecting a woman to be feminine is harmful. Femininity itself is not. I understand what you're saying about the word femininity being connected to "female" and therefore perpetuating gender stereotypes. I'm trying to find a way to phrase this in a clear way... These words don't just exist in my head; they still describe relevant social things (just because something is socially constructed doesn't mean it isn't real; e.g. gender). The lgbt community has been based since the beginning on playing with gender. Drag is probably the best example. If you're lgbt you'll probably be familiar with words like butch and femme to describe lesbians who express gender differently, or bear and twink to describe gay men (femme is also a common word to describe straight men who express more femininity than is socially expected of them). Camp is something completely born out of the lgbt community that describes a theatrical expression of gender through fashion and makeup. These are all very, very important characteristics of the lgbt "wave" I guess you could call it, and I think it's fair to say that the lgbt movement has been heading gender revolutions for a while. These things are all based on femininity and masculinity, and specifically using them to do away with gender stereotypes and norms. I understand what you mean about them contributing to gender norms. But for a very very long time now, they've actually been used to specifically combat these same gender norms, and to be honest that seems to be doing the most effective work up until now. They still describe socially relevant things, specifically *because* gender stereotypes still exist, and they can be and are being used to dismantle those existing connections between gender, sex, and social expectations. And recently femininity and masculinity have also started to blur together, which is also great. Harry Styles in a dress, for example. It’s made a lot of people (including Logan Paul, surprisingly) start questioning what exactly makes someone feminine or masculine, and if that correlates with their gender (it doesn’t). If we refused to acknowledge things like masculinity and femininity, first off, a lot of people (more than usual) would be calling us crazy and unrealistic. More importantly, we wouldn’t be able to play around with gender expectations in a way that has been continuously dismantling them, as we’ve been doing for decades. This was way longer and less organised than I’d like it to be but it’s really early and I have work in a bit, so I’m not gonna go back and clean it up, but I hope it made sense anyway. You’re obviously allowed to disagree and have your own opinion

I get it, she´s azome

THAT BIG DICK ENERGY

ikrrr. this can literally be a boyband song. moonstar did that. asdfghjkl

Nah fam, she just has her own Moonstar energy

Her name explain it all *moon+star energy*

OMG, LANGUAGE SIMP?!

Preach 👏🏻

yasss go get em

Im blink army once and moomoo 👆👆👆👆

@@jacktaehyung1466 You seem to be army too

I love this fandom because there's no toxic fans, I hope it will stay always like this 🙏🙏🙏

I mean she cant rly do sexy shes flat af

@@ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE Curves are not the only thing that can make a woman sexy though?

Well that wouldn't fit the image she has in Mamamoo anyway so why would they enforce it

ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE just cause she doesn't go by your expectations and has more of a flat chest, doesn't mean she can't be sexy...

@@ZAJETANAZWANIEEEE MB is so sexy and attractive for me, as a /straight/ girl. Sexiness is something more mental that physical.

Still here to support MoonByul. I believe we can do it!!

We can 💖

@@janinemarbella9052 Fighting!!!

You put it beautifully moomoo!

MAMAMOO DESERVES HIGHER THAN BP AND BTS MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS AND TALENT SHOULD BE EQUAL TO POPULAIRTY >:( YES MAMAMOO IS MORE TALENTOUS ARMY/BLINK, THE TRUE HURTS U

@@quememirasfe4775 No, don't bring down other groups to make mamamoo look better. That's not how us moomoos act, and it makes us look bad

@@imachubbygod1121 Should I act to any specific form if I´m a fan? Then the toxic is me, wow...

@@quememirasfe4775 Yes you should, all idols work hard so to say that one group deserves more than another would be ignoring the other one's hard work. BTS and black pink made it because they released bops that a lot of people liked. To say that Mamamoo deserves to be on top on them would discard all that BTS and Blackpink did. So basically, just respect other groups' rankings and don't hate on other groups unless they did something to receive hate

@@quememirasfe4775 don't bring other groups down,to make mmm better,moomoos aren't like this,and we don't like fan wars

Gosh this is so me. I literally watched every yt video that she's in it

@@janinemarbella9052 Yeah. The more u know her, the more u deep in love with her.

My bias since 2015. She being true to herself since debut until now make me stay as her stan forever

I didn't know :o

A line of hers in the 'Passion Flower' stage was "I love you my boy!", but I can't say about the rest since I don't know korean

@@honeybeemoo she said herself that she keeps her lyrics gender-neutral in her own radio show😬

@@smile-sq7pt Maybe I didn't watch that episode. I have studies so I usually can't watch the full episodes, I mostly watch some parts. Can you give me a link for this particular one or mention which one it was?

@@smile-sq7pt Also, I just pointed out an instance where this didn't happen. 'Passion Flower' was during their rookie days, and it was an added verse in a cover. Maybe Moonbyul meant for her own songs, then this is probably true

Hidden Gem and extraordinary...

@@citrakumala7178 exactly

This is so true

Two things that many people, including her stans, do not appreciate or respect. It seems that she has been carrying something that makes her have a hard time, and it is very possible that is because those two things. 💔

@@listenmoonbyulslunatic1151 Sad truth. Even her stans always hype more about her sexuality, shipping her with other member or idol but none about her art, her music, her as multi talanted artist/idol, her as a good human being. That why Moonbyul difficult to be known as a artist and her excellent music don't get recognition that it deserves

@@justreader2526 That makes me sad because she doesn't seem important outside of those things. 💔 It would be better for everyone if people stan her because of her music, so we would all have something in common, that she does well and is happy doing her job without any extra pressure.

C'est tellement ça 😂

Oh si rare de voir des commentaires fr 😀

@@mel9178 ahah on est beaucoup de moomoo français mais pas assez à commenter sur YT 😂

Oh god ikr, even byul said it herself that she doesnt like it when people call her oppa like whats not clicking?

@@nightwalker7937 seriously, idk how they consider themselves stans and claim to love her, yet they can't do something as simple as not calling her something she already stated she dislikes being called.

We can still call her handsome tho she prefers being called handsome

@@kristinetan5326 yeah, handsome isn't exclusively used for males, therefore it isn't included in the list of "things you would call a male".

I call her handsome, cuz she said she prefers being called handsome.

Fighting!!!

She's forever a living Barbie to me

@oreo and orion you are right ♥️♥️♥️♥️

I love her, she is so different from other idols. I don’t think anyone can pull off a “rock” and “dark” concept as she can. The song makes me want to run around from excitement :3

@@lioness6995 yass🤓🤓😎😎

I think she and Dami are both the most handsome. I can't choose lol. They are both so amazing.💗💕(I'm not trying to start fanwars) Also I didn't expect this song to be as amazing. I slept on Mamamoo and this song for so long. I'm ready to stan!💕💗💕💗💕

Actually, she was the most underrated even by her agency. She gets confidence onlly this year when she saw how many people loved her solo album. Even her agency was surprised by her solo success.

@@mihailgavrishchiv7972 we can still show her some love before her birthday. Let's promote this song together with Aya and Dingga.

Exactly

@@michita7838 leggo

@@mihailgavrishchiv7972 really? How do you know that?

WE CAN DO IT! FIGHTING!!!!

Let's go!

Let’s support chico malo

You so right.🌻

Yup, the fiinal boss sksksksk

Yyyeeeeesssssssss

Yupppp... 😉

Annika Arora yes she is

So true

Oh man🤣😂

True😂

any chair of moonbyul's is a throne now 👑

Moonbyul and Throne**

Don't let solar hear that hahaha

she's not gonna repeat a concept that even her members didn't like.

She takes photos too

Too many ppl are sleeping on her 😔

Thanks for putting my feelings into words

Yeah she so talented

Wheein : breaking heterosexualism in her solo movie

@@jiapark4406 aaaaa yeah i forgot about that too thanks for reminding

@TinQuil yeahh

Don't forget when Solar ripped off her shirt in the Fire performance

Solar:being best kpop idol-ytber in korea

140k more Fighting, we can do it!

@@justreader2526 Fighting together 💪🏼💪🏼

nat natnat I’m hoping they would give her a short haircut one day

@@Otakuwonder98 As soon as byulie is comfortable with that, im all supportive haha

this is why she is my bias. i love her so much.

@Luz Maria Barradas Perez i know right?? I just hope she gets the attention and recognization she deserves.

Very much agree. We need more artist like moonbyul T^T telling people that people should be their true selves

Please delete the emoji it's gonna freeze the view

@@betty1053 Thank you! I deleted the emoji (Now I also think that the emoji freezed the view)

@@betty1053 It doesn't do that, KZfaq just does that on its own because it wants to verify that all views are actual people and not bots. The best thing to do when streaming is engagement, so keep commenting and like the video, don't be scared about what you write, just don't spam.

@@Emeraldcrystal7E is that so???? If yes then thank you, cause like my friends ( who are Kpop fans and they stream a lot) told me so. So I never use emoji on every comeback they use oops

Betty Lâm It’s a common misconception, I get it though, KZfaq isn’t the best site when it comes to communicating specs. The view stutters and seemingly random deletion of comments can make some things seem bad. Happy streaming, all!

Yes, I also love her black hair. She look more beautiful and pure in this hair colour

@@justreader2526 She slays any hair color really, but black, red, and purple are my personal favs

We can!

We can if we be consistent to watch it everyday. Let's work hard to reach it!

@@justreader2526 yes yes!

Amen

Yes!!!

Please delete emoji, they freeze vi3ws

Yes girl, i love you 💕

it's a lesbian thing ok it's not about gender, girls wish she was their oppa

U forgot grease : 100% So true tho

@@eli-uv6io stan the true queen

YG FAM Nahh 1000000000.000000000

I love you. ♥️

I listen to you every day. ♥️

You are so cool.

Here again to heal. ♥️

Queen of song.

moonbyul says screw labelling

moonbyul: chair

so is like tomboyish? just asking cuz' i just found them

THE standard, cheers !!

Hotel:Trivago :)

Well stated 🤗💚

Damn true coz I feel the same way

This is too true. And that's why Mamamoo is not like the other kpop girl groups.

@@roseblueish ye they're a WOMEN group

I still can't get over with Decalcomanie era T^T

VAMOS POR LOS 20M

WIG STILL MISSING

THE AMOUNT OF ABSOLUTE C * N T PUT INTO THIS

INSANE

Could you explain "braveness" in that one please?

@@Shiroiek She is brave because she is doing what she likes without caring the stereotyped norms about what a woman "can" do, sing or wear. She is always true to herself and authentic, and I am proud of her for that.

It gave me huge BoA and History vibes so I'm happy lol

Guys don't forget to vote for Moonbyul in Mwave pre voting ! 🌟

pls take down emoji it freezes views

Me 👋

Streaming everyone's solos :3

me 🙋🏻‍♀️

Me! Me! 🙋‍♀️

ME

We can do it if we continue watch Eclipse everyday

she is indeed

But she is

AGREE ಥ‿ಥ

Correct XD

why is this so true

wish I could like this twice

Portugal

Yo

No one cause the damm MV keeps freezing, for some reason others seems not to care about Viewing it! But oh no, HiP has exploded but not Solars or Byul’s. This is what confuses me about our fan base for those some.

China!

That would be mind-blowing. 🤯

True!!

Exactly

True

How true 🥲

Yes so true

LEGGOOO

The vi3w is barely increasing tho

@@hwasaismamamoosmaknae2400 yep sadly..

Lesgoo

Preach fellow radish, preach!

This made me hopeful! Let's goooo

Let's work hard so it gonna hit 10M this year

Want this masterpiece hit 10M ~~ FIGHTING

It's getting close 🥰

Almost there…!

Si amigo podemos tenemos la fuerza y energía

Yepp

Real

True

She's literally the BEST!

mmm isnt really a girl crush concept tho, and moon is def not either

Couldn't agree with you more🙌🖤❤💜💖🎶

Yasss

You're definitely right 💯🙌🏼

*Period.*

You are damn right.

Fighting! Let's work hard! :D

Yeahhh

Fighting

working hard everyday 😭

Yes

Amen👍🏻

Yes, i agree with you

Periodt

YO MOOBIT!

OMFG I FORGOT ABOUT THAT

I listen to Hip literally everyday so I was just WAITING

ʚ Strawberry Kiwi ɞ hahahah me too

Ksush Zolotareva I thought only Hwasa who contributed in lyrics in hip? Is Moonbyul also wrote? Because so far I know that only hwasa who wrote the lyric with kim do hoon and park woo sang

25beee ah really? I heard that Moon Byul always helps with writing lyrics so I thought like that) but anyway she’s very hard working:)

I'm so mad choreos and songs this good are always limited to boy groups to the point that it just drags down the style. Like...I've genuinely stopped enjoying BG songs because I keep thinking about that. Her voice REALLY suits this!!

Exactly, if She wants to do a certain style, that's Her, it isn't due to a pressure from the market, She gets and She does what She wants to do because it's Her artistic expression. I hope more girl groups do have things like this, heck, I hope more boy groups have things like this, where they are not limited by the industry's standard or default options if they want to go out of the norm. Moonbyul should show Moonbyul, so that's what She does. And that's what I absolutely love about Her, and Mamamoo in general. They also don't always try to go out of the norm if they don't want to, if there's something they already like, then they'll do that, no need for pressure from one side to tell you to go out of the norm, again, they just do what they want and what they like, and that's what I love about them.

I just love your comment. And yes this is a side of Moonbyul that I think most aren't ready to see yet.

I'm glad to know I'm not the only person celebrating Valentine's day by watching eclipse on it's anniversary lol

10M whennnn? :(((

@@borellaborhani3260 it's already 10 million since the mv is uploaded on two channels

@@brambillafumagalli7652 i was just streaming :)) Ik but this fandom is not that small we can give 10m in official channel,right?

YESSSSSS!!!!

yup, same. I don't think it was specifically this song but it was Moonbyul. On second thought I think it was her voice in Egotistic that made me fall.

BWHAHAHAHA THIS IS ICONIC

I feel you .....😤

@@fae91 same LOL

Please help streaming for her birthday :(

Power move

Yup

PreaCh

Exactly xD

LOL YAASSSS

I had the same problem. Her performances + teaser were the first ones on my results. The thumbnail made it hard to find too. Someone has to tell their marketing team.

Jamie Ortiz i wish there’s a way for us to notify them this thing though. It’s such a shame since this is such a good song/concept. She had a great first day album sale but her view count hasn’t even reached a million. I really hope they notice why the view is so low and does something about it.

Yep same. If i hadn't visit the channel I could not find this mv.

I'm sharing this MV everywhere, even in reactors channels. I'll not give up 😔

Why they do that?

Thanks, i dont know English, just be little tolerant

@@bdaarmy9736 ... it's 'breaks' 😂

wheein break the gender norm of love by singing to goodbye that shows lgbt love on the mv

Right! damn how I forget?!

Solar be ripping shirts off

We will support her forever

I agree except I feel like my eyes hurt after watching this. Personally was hard to keep up with

@@rachael3946 that's bcuz she slayed hard !

Wait what's the stereotype?

@@sourwatermelon " feminine " most girl groups go fr the cute or the sexy but not as such moonbyul's one which is close to boy band thing ! I hope u got me

Yes~~~and that’s so cool~~~~~

Moonbyul HIP universe continue on Eclipse

But they don't listen seriously, it's getting too much day by day And today too in vlive she said that she likes it when people say that a girl can do these concept

And daddy too

Wow someones mad😂

@@boss_n_jeans missgendering someone is not cute

Wow i love that

But for real I can't finish the video😭 the badassery is far too much

I'm not giving up on this masterpiece, I'm sharing it everywhere! (but yes actually she kill half of the fandom lol)

I just want someone with a popular comment in this section to mention the fact in their comment by editing that for a view to count u need to watch at least 30 seconds so one just has to watch 35 seconds or so for streaming. I think some r watching the whole vid while others r just continuously skipping.

@@potathoe2608 why would anyone skip?

@@amazonz8590 skip as in I mean fast forwarding it to get more views in less time

Same