My Hot Take on The 5 Year Old Riding a Bike

  Рет қаралды 156,035

Ashley Neal

Ashley Neal

Жыл бұрын

Loads of people have had their opinion on this clip and I've been asked many times so here it is!
Dash Camera Affiliate Links.
Car - Viofo - viofouk.co.uk/ashleyv10f01621...
Motorcycle - Innov - innovv.co.uk/ashley1nn0v13703...
Motorcycle, Bicycle and Equestrian - Techalogic - techalogic.co.uk/ashleyt3ck41...
Social Media
www.ashleyneal.com
/ ashleynealdrivinginstr...
ashleysanalysis@gmail.com
Amazon Links
Sony a6400 Camera - amzn.to/2xVCrn0
Sony A7C Camera - amzn.to/3JUvUIa
Tascam DR-10L Microphone - amzn.to/3M8P0fd
Sony FDR X3000 Action Camera - amzn.to/2YVoPDh
#driving #tesla #education

Пікірлер: 1 900
@ItsAllJustBollox
@ItsAllJustBollox Жыл бұрын
The child had more road awareness and did a quicker risk assessment than his father.
@PeterMaddison2483
@PeterMaddison2483 Жыл бұрын
Put him in for driving lessons, he'd probably do better than his Dad 😆
@paulpotts
@paulpotts Жыл бұрын
I'm impressed with how the child analysed so far ahead, and asked the question. Full marks to him.
@Shen-ek2oe
@Shen-ek2oe Жыл бұрын
You can even see at the start of the clip, the kid took a position in the centre of the road rather than going up the cycle path where he'd have been obscured by the cars. Whether it was intentional or instructed, it's worth noting.
@rebeccaconlon9743
@rebeccaconlon9743 Жыл бұрын
It has taken me years to get out of the minds set of, "if something happens to me, it's not my fault. And it won't happen to me, because they would be at fault"... my husband told me that you can't sue them if you're dead and that you being right isn't worth getting hurt or killed for.
@Robert-cu9bm
@Robert-cu9bm Жыл бұрын
Exactly
@kiradotee
@kiradotee Жыл бұрын
They can have "he was right" written on the gravestone.
@robg521
@robg521 Жыл бұрын
My ex girlfriend used to be a triathlete and was out running on a country road. The road was narrow, a 60MPH limit and a bendy road with blind corners. A sports car came speeding around a blind corner while she was running along the road and she had to jump into ditch to avoid being killed. [as she landed in the ditch she damaged her hip and it has never been the same since ending her sporting career] She will vehemently rant on to anyone who will listen about how some utter lunatic ruined her career, but my attitude was “what the hell were you doing out running on that road. You knew full well it was a dangerous road so what did you expect?”. This didn’t go down well because her mind set was “but iv’e got the legal right to run along that road as much as I want” To which replied “Yes you have, and the car driver was indeed an #%*^hole and should not have been speeding around a blind corner, but in the end he drove off unaffected and you were the one left lying damaged in a ditch”
@TheSebiestor
@TheSebiestor Жыл бұрын
I get why she is now your ex-girlfriend 😂
@Bullwinkle39
@Bullwinkle39 Жыл бұрын
Your husband sounds like a good man
@Bullwinkle39
@Bullwinkle39 Жыл бұрын
I'm glad you said the child was the only person with any common sense there, that was my immediate thoughts as well. Whether you have priority or not, hanging back and leaving people to do whatever they're gonna do is key to self preservation. Just because you might have priority doesn't mean it's safe to proceed
@pauleff3312
@pauleff3312 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely right.... I always say to people do you go onto a junction where you have the green light where the lorry coming at right angles is not appearing to be slowing to stop for what should be his red light? Being right but dead or seriously injured aren't somewhere I'd like to be.
@extremumadventura
@extremumadventura Жыл бұрын
Look idiots you are not allowed to kill cause you have a driver's license
@kitchencarvings4621
@kitchencarvings4621 9 ай бұрын
I used to have the attitude of the father and I'm still assertive but I've realized that it is better to protect myself and let the bad drivers get on down the road and out of my life.
@keithnorris2104
@keithnorris2104 Жыл бұрын
I am totally in agreement with you. The child was the only one who saw the danger; in my opinion, both the car driver and the child's father were stubborn and raised the danger level unnecessarily to the child.
@Rroff2
@Rroff2 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely - at least the kid was wearing high vis clothing as well, no idea on the dad. One of my pet hates lately is cyclists doing silly things in dark clothing and poor if any lights then blaming anyone but themselves for near incidents.
@I_Evo
@I_Evo Жыл бұрын
But the dad then wouldn't have had a video to post.
@iainamurray
@iainamurray Жыл бұрын
Why was the Dad being stubborn?
@Robert-cu9bm
@Robert-cu9bm Жыл бұрын
@@iainamurray Because "I'm a cyclist" mentally. He put his child in extreme danger. It's all well and good saying, but they should have stopped. They won't bring a child back to life. Cyclists need to learn a car will always win. They have rules with boats, but the overwhelming rule is you always move out the way for the bigger boat as you'll lose.
@Rover200Power
@Rover200Power Жыл бұрын
The father capped it off nicely by swearing in front of a 5 year old child.
@cgcsworld2807
@cgcsworld2807 Жыл бұрын
I agree that the kid had more sense. He obviously didn't feel safe with the oncoming car.
@cgcsworld2807
@cgcsworld2807 Жыл бұрын
Yes
@markwalton8644
@markwalton8644 Жыл бұрын
I can't believe the Dad wasn't saying Slow down ready to stop and then the kid asked should I Stop! This Lad has more sense than his Dad and the Driver put together!!!
@LeDoucheBouche
@LeDoucheBouche Жыл бұрын
His instincts were correct.
@shaunohagan1491
@shaunohagan1491 Жыл бұрын
His dad had to get he footage for youtube some how. Why is the 5 year old on the road in the first place.
@JohnM...
@JohnM... Жыл бұрын
Sorry but the dad's an irresponsible ego fuelled pillock.
@simmer484
@simmer484 Жыл бұрын
Spot on analysis. As the driver I'd had given way all day long, and probably had a shared feeling of fatherly pride in seeing a son out for a ride with his father. As the father I'd have told my child to stop. If I was in a car following behind the father and so also had to stop then I'd have had a shared sense of fatherly pride in the guided caution the father was giving his son.
@jazzx251
@jazzx251 Жыл бұрын
If it was me, that made the mistake of "entering the corridor" - I would have stopped and allowed the young man to pass. Not attempt to "thread the needle" (simply because I wouldn't want to damage the blue car! The young cyclist knew what he was doing, and did great - one of the better cyclists I've seen recently, in all honesty)
@beepbop9
@beepbop9 Жыл бұрын
It's truly unbelievable that when someone is on a bike the other road users no longer see it as another human. Compassion and empathy go out of the window. I see a child on a bike coming the other way I want to be careful even if there's no pinch points... How has it got so bad.
@Itsa-sh
@Itsa-sh Жыл бұрын
"Compassion and empathy go out of the window" we've lost those since the 90s. Most people are so selfish, self-centred and simply don't care these days. Even commentary like Ashley's this isn't going to change because the people who need to learn wont until they've killed someone. Then with pointless sentencing there's no deterrant.
@fredmercury1314
@fredmercury1314 Жыл бұрын
@@Itsa-sh The 90s..? Lol Arguably humans never really had compassion and empathy, other than for close members of their local community, but that was lost in the 60s not the 90s.
@caolkyle
@caolkyle Жыл бұрын
Sadly it works both ways as equally I’ve seen far too many cyclists deliberately put them in danger in claim of the ‘I’ve got priority’ If I was driving the car I’d have slowed down to no more than a creep since it looked like 20mph roads and it looked fairly decent rain so easy chance the child falling off the bike or taking longer to break. If I was cycling I would’ve held back and waited for the car to pass as end of the day, I’d rather be safe than barge through with the ‘I’ve got priority’
@R04drunner1
@R04drunner1 Жыл бұрын
Well said sir
@ynotnilknarf39
@ynotnilknarf39 Жыл бұрын
How typical to push the onus onto the vulnerable party to modify their behaviour. This, in part, is precisely why drivists see themselves as kings and queens of the roads and anyone else needs to get out the way or get what's coming to them. Getting out the way, having 'rules' to force you to wait to get somewhere on foot (or be killed/injured), ceding priority, wearing stupid day glow colours, having lights like a lighthouse and plastic hats has done f.all to make vulnerable persons safer. Motons take the piss and take more all the time others are told to cede/get out the way. But now you're blaming the victims because someone with huge kinetic energy won't do what the law tells them they MUST do and even when anothers life is at stake. Yeah, you stink like an entitled motorist!
@lauramoss2863
@lauramoss2863 Жыл бұрын
That kid was riding more sensibly than a lot of grownups!
@marklittler784
@marklittler784 Жыл бұрын
Probably why the driver seemed to have confidence in the kids cycling
@nearlyretired7005
@nearlyretired7005 Жыл бұрын
That's not really that surprising! Most adult bike riders are arrogant and ignorant,like a lot of car drivers. I speak as an ex driving instructor! Common sense and patience is not common! The child's father is typical! He's an idiot.
@julianmason8449
@julianmason8449 Жыл бұрын
@@nearlyretired7005 retire urgently.
@thealbagalavanter9986
@thealbagalavanter9986 Жыл бұрын
I agree
@johnb8956
@johnb8956 Жыл бұрын
Honestly says a lot about the state of our roads. 5 year old kid is a better road user than 90% of adults.
@raymondbenjamins5884
@raymondbenjamins5884 Жыл бұрын
As someone from the Netherlands, where we learn to cycle from a very young age (and you'll often see young children on the road unsupervised), I completely agree with your analysis. We have to keep a close eye on young children participating in traffic (whether it's cycling, walking or any other way). Even if they know the rules well (and let's be honest, most of them only know the basics), they simply don't have the same level of control of their vehicle that we expect from adults (and they also don't have the same level of awareness). As for this video: the motorist should have taken much more care, but the father telling the child to continue on into danger is a disgrace, especially since the child was clearly uncomfortable with the situation (considering they wanted to pull over). But what made it even worse for me, was him swearing at the driver in the presence of the child. That shows a mindset we should absolutely not teach our children ("I've got priority, so I'm going to just escalate the situation and create way more danger than their needs to be").
@hikaru9624
@hikaru9624 Жыл бұрын
After reading some comments on here I basically agree that the father should have acted defensively for the sake of the child (pulled over into the opening that was there). I can't help but get the feeling the kid would have pulled alongside the parked van which does have some degree of risk but I cannot say for certain. I agree that the motorists should have also given way too. One being that, from I could recall in the video, the road signs instructing what to do and the fact there was someone more vulnerable than an adult cyclist on the road (I somewhat doubt the driver even saw the kid). The kid definitely had the most common sense. As for the language used by the father? I do agree it was disgusting to swear in front of a kid. That said I have heard many a bad word when I was their age so I can't really comment on it (again I do agree you should not swear in the company of kids).
@davidbeakhust9797
@davidbeakhust9797 Жыл бұрын
Of course, in the Netherlands, the roads have evolved to reduce risk by design, it is called "sustainable safety", and is designed to minimise risks - even when mistakes are made. As Raymond will know, this systematic improvement started in the 1970s with the "stop de kindermoord" campaign (stop child killing). I thought of that when I saw the pathetically narrow few yards of bike lane to the left of the pinch point, that the riders rightly ignored. Had they taken that lane they may have been invisible to the oncoming car, and parked cars made that lane worthless, and increases risk. That the lane does not continue beyond the pinch points is lousy design, IMO, and would not be found much in the Netherlands. Such a "provision" for cycling is as pointless as it is dangerous. I think the dad in the circumstances shown should have pre-emptively asked his kid to pull in earlier, before the kid asked. Had he said yes to the kid saying "shall I pull in" that may have been too late to be useful. But maybe another commentary is that just as it is best to use a registered driving instructor to learn to drive, so ones dad (unless he has some lessons first to unlearn bad habits) may not be the best person to supervise cycling by youngsters!
@trueriver1950
@trueriver1950 Жыл бұрын
@Joe Lynch disagree. Morons in control of machines don't mix; and that applies to morons in cars as much as morons on bikes. If you can't handle your machine safely in the presence of other kinds of road vehicle, it is YOU that should be off the road.
@LinxyWun
@LinxyWun Жыл бұрын
Your comment is spot on!
@Edsbar
@Edsbar Жыл бұрын
In my opinion, he was far too ready to hurl the abuse at the motorist adding evidence that he was far too aware of what might happen.
@jakerockznoodles
@jakerockznoodles Жыл бұрын
Absolutely spot on. It's quite sad when a 5 year old child can display more sense and risk awareness than either of the grown adults in a situation like this. If he were mine, not only would I have encouraged him to slow and move out of danger, I would have praised him for asking the important question here. Sincerely asking yourself questions like that is how you develop good road habits imo.
@shm5547
@shm5547 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb don't be daft! They wouldn't leave the house, far too dangerous!
@pelicanofpunishment6
@pelicanofpunishment6 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb I see you've made similar comments here. And I see you make a habit of missing the point. Was it possible that the cyclists were going to be completely safe and the car would stop? Yes. Did it happen? No. So was the smart thing to do to pull into the side, like the kid asked? Yes. I could tell by then that the car wasn't going to stop. It hadn't started to slow, as it should have. Remember Ashley's words: "Priority is give, not taken." What the father has taught is to take priority and the driver is in the wrong. It's a bad habit to teach and is a really crappy mindset. Cars need to drive safely around more vulnerable road users. What you seem to think is we should be responsible for 100% of vulnerable road users' safety. That's an awful way to think. And before you think I ask victims of sexual abuse "what they wore" as you said to someone above...No, I have never been one of those people, but you have to attack the issue at both ends. Teach how to be safe around others and teach how to keep others safe. Basically, teach cyclists where to be safe in case drivers aren't doing what they should be.
@R04drunner1
@R04drunner1 Жыл бұрын
Excellent point about developing good road habits. Well said.
@jeremypnet
@jeremypnet Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb well, yes, if you think the risk of being punched in the face is significant. Do you often allow yourself to be punched in the face? Is it much fun?
@jeremypnet
@jeremypnet Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb well, yes, if you think the risk of being punched in the face is significant. Do you often allow yourself to be punched in the face? Is it much fun?
@Cream147player
@Cream147player Жыл бұрын
The adults are consumed with the politics of the situation - the cyclist seething that motorists don't give bikes priority as they should, the motorist barging through thinking he's the most important thing on the road. The kid has the most sense because he isn't contaminated by any of that, he just sees escalating danger and asks if she should take action - but is also intelligent enough to trust in his Dad's greater knowledge and experience and so follows instructions.
@derekheeps1244
@derekheeps1244 Жыл бұрын
Why do you think the motorist should give the bike priority ? The bike has much less kinetic energy to lose , and needed to restart , than any motor vehicle . It is just like when I am out in my car and am confronted by a 38 tonne Artic coming the other way ; I will always stop for the Artic ; just as with a car and a bike , there will only ever be one winner if a car and an Artic have a coming together .
@ab-jm5gn
@ab-jm5gn 7 ай бұрын
The inverse is true. The motorist only has to move their foot one inch to regain momentum, while the cyclist has to do real effort. Your arctic tanker argument is a fallacy: they actually move other stuff than the just the driver.
@tomjones1506
@tomjones1506 Ай бұрын
Shame his dad let him down, he should of agreed with his son when he asked should he pull over.
@ronniemacdonald2768
@ronniemacdonald2768 Жыл бұрын
“Here lies the body of William Jay, Who died maintaining his right of way- He was right, dead right, as he sped along, But he’s just as dead as if he were wrong.”
@Zeyr01
@Zeyr01 Жыл бұрын
"The hills are alive! Of the Twitter cyclists screeching!" 🎵
@joline2730
@joline2730 Жыл бұрын
Thank you Ronnie for this quote - never heard it all before, just "Jimmy Jay died defending his rigjt of way" which my Mum used to say to us all when teaching us road sense (walking !!) thanks again 💯✔👍💖
@ollymawson421
@ollymawson421 Жыл бұрын
Thank you for this - I feel this is a really good analysis. I will put my hands up as a daily cyclist and have 'cycled in to danger' before, even when common sense says to apply caution and not make a situation worse. The child here shows an important lesson to us all - ego can be really damaging (and sadly sometimes dangerous) and we must recognise when to take action, even if it goes against our own emotions/beliefs. Having more quiet streets and places where all ages and abilities feel they can safely walk/cycle/wheel is an integral part of our future - but as is empathy, recognition of mutual safety and looking out for each other. Thanks - I always enjoy your videos!
@ashley_neal
@ashley_neal Жыл бұрын
I enjoyed reading your comment.
@dpace2310
@dpace2310 Жыл бұрын
ALL cyclists please remember that next time you want to jump a red light
@KM-cb8ff
@KM-cb8ff Жыл бұрын
Good comment. (Also to others, please let's not make it about red lights and all the usual arguments...)
@G4WYZ
@G4WYZ Жыл бұрын
@@dpace2310 That applies to you as well when you run a red/amber light.
@hikaru9624
@hikaru9624 Жыл бұрын
As of this comment I have only had one sour experience with a cyclist in my 10 years of driving since passing my test. All other times there was no beef at all, some even waved me on to pass or even yielded to me! Kindness costs nothing.
@TheTechGiantYouTube
@TheTechGiantYouTube Жыл бұрын
Up until this 5:35 i was thinking that i am going to have to disagree with Ashleys way of thinking, but fair play you eventually said EXACTLY what i was thinking to myself. I would rather submit than risk my sons life, as there ain't no glory in saying it was your right of way when your child is in a coffin!
@markpearman2631
@markpearman2631 Жыл бұрын
When I learned to ride a motorcycle in the 80s, the instructor made the point of saying it's no good saying it was your right of way lying in a hospital bed. Giving way to someone is better than getting hurt
@CRUDEDriving
@CRUDEDriving Жыл бұрын
Great analysis, Ashley! From 5:15 of your video is the most important part in my opinion. The fact that the father was happy to let his child "carry on" was just as concerning as the opposite driver plowing through the pinch point.
@reachandler3655
@reachandler3655 Жыл бұрын
Actually, I think it's of greater concern, he's teaching his child to ignore his instincts of danger.
@reachandler3655
@reachandler3655 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb Having right of way doesn't mean you should take it regardless. You need to assess situations and respond, to ensure your safety and mitigate other's mistakes or bull-headedness. In this example the child assessed a potential problem, the father dismissed it and over-ruled his response to avoid danger. "I had right of way" is not a good epitaph. As for victim's of sexual assault? No, I blame those who commit the crime, and the mentality of 'boys will be boys' excusing their behaviour. Mind you, I'm biased, it's taken a lot of therapy to stop blaming myself. I was raised when "what does she expect dressed like that?" was a societal norm. Oh, and if you're wondering what I was wearing that so provoked a man, it was a school uniform, I was 12.
@reachandler3655
@reachandler3655 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb OK, let's clarify. Yes, the driver is at fault; he should've given way, I'm not disputing that. I'm concerned the father teaching his son to overrule his sense of self preservation, putting his life at risk.
@looneytune6955
@looneytune6955 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb The child read the danger, the dad made him carry on into that dangerous situation. He got what he wanted, a flashpoint that he could film as he has done countless times on his social media. the dad can clearly see the motorist isn't going to stop. This is where you have to be smart and the dad isn't. You cannot influence what the other driver does but you can influence the risk of injury to yourself or someone else by the decisions you take. In this instance the driver should have stopped but its clear to a five year old that the car is going to keep on going. |Because of that the father is also wrong to put his child in a dangerous situation just for his own ego. this whole 'i have the right of way' means absolutely nothing in the real world when you have two tonne of vehicle coming in the opposite direction. Easier to forget about massaging your own ego and pull over where safe. Because in events like this where you have two points of self entitlement there is only going to be one winner. And it ain't the kid on the pushbike. Smart people live to fight another day.
@damedusa5107
@damedusa5107 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb “so you’re prepared to victim blame in one situation but not your own” are you for real? Wtf is that response, using SA as a petty point scoring comment. Sick. Proper dickhead comment that. Petty as hell.
@captkidd
@captkidd Жыл бұрын
Couldn't agree more, the child is the only one with sense.
@jamesmcglough5985
@jamesmcglough5985 Жыл бұрын
When the kid asks to pull over and the father says no...as a dad that breaks my heart. Little kids voice. He even wabbles towards the oncoming car. Tough stuff to watch.
@steve00alt70
@steve00alt70 Жыл бұрын
He didnt wobble
@fredmercury1314
@fredmercury1314 Жыл бұрын
@@steve00alt70 He wobbled.
@lmaoroflcopter
@lmaoroflcopter Жыл бұрын
@Nothing The oncoming driver was to blame mate. Highway code is clear on it. Yes priority means nothing if you're 6 feet under but if we're attributing blame to something that happened. It's the driver at fault here. As Surrey Roads Policing unit has commented and as other traffic police have commented. Driver should have given way to the oncoming cyclists.
@iampongo
@iampongo Жыл бұрын
@@lmaoroflcopter that attitude is exactly the problem.
@polopowered
@polopowered Жыл бұрын
The dad has issues.
@Ad-my9kg
@Ad-my9kg Жыл бұрын
I absolutely agree with you Ashley. You should also add the risk of target fixation here, As the car approaches you can see the child start to move towards the vehicle. He sees the vehicle and he moves towards it for a split second. Thankfully he regains his line and avoids the car.
@hawk2million
@hawk2million Жыл бұрын
Fantastic analysis, totally agree. I'm especially pleased you wholeheartedly approved of teaching kids road safety instead of that knee jerk "they shouldn't be anywhere near a road" reaction.
@batking911
@batking911 Жыл бұрын
I’m not sure I fully agree. The car coming the other way was some way off when the father advised his son to continue. Perhaps some extra caution might have been warranted given the age of the child but I would have taken that gap - the child and his father reached the pinch point long before the car did. The bulk of the blame lies with the car driver, who approached the pinch point way too fast and powered through like he owned the road despite there already being a vehicle. The local police constabulary expressed a similar view to me in the twitter thread.
@piggypiggypig1746
@piggypiggypig1746 Жыл бұрын
Just to play devil's advocate, if this 5yr old had to slow down and stop, he might have become unstable and ended up placing his right foot on the ground and leaning into the oncoming traffic which showed no signs of stopping.
@ashley_neal
@ashley_neal Жыл бұрын
Agreed. That's why the slowing needed to be done earlier also.
@shm5547
@shm5547 Жыл бұрын
Exactly. In this situation, there wasn't really time to do anything different. What I would have done differently, would be to cycle alongside the child, 2 abreast, to try and manage the danger from oncoming vehicles.
@Robert-cu9bm
@Robert-cu9bm Жыл бұрын
@@ashley_neal This is why children should be allowed to ride on the pavement.
@shm5547
@shm5547 Жыл бұрын
@@Robert-cu9bm everyone is allowed to ride on the pavement with care, it’s effectively been decriminalised for years since the NPCC released guidelines.
@Robert-cu9bm
@Robert-cu9bm Жыл бұрын
@@shm5547 Rule 64 You MUST NOT cycle on a pavement. Laws HA 1835 sect 72 & R(S)A sect 129 But it's still illegal, you would effectively be teaching children to break laws. The more small minor laws you break, the easier it becomes to break bigger laws. Then people wonder why young adults have no respect for the law.
@ColinSmith2001
@ColinSmith2001 Жыл бұрын
I agree with the analysis of this as a single incident. What gives more problem is what then might begin to happen as general practice. If all cyclists go by "I should be able to keep going but if the car doesn't stop I should stop" and all drivers go by "I should stop, but if I keep going the cyclist will stop for me" then we've just created a different rule than is intended, where there is a stronger incentive for drivers not to stop. How do you then stop general practice going that way and pull things back to the intention? There's surely enough creative interpretation of the HWC as it is?
@RikAindow
@RikAindow Жыл бұрын
Thanks for not blaming the child on this one Ashley as they seemed to be the ones perceiving the danger. Just because you should have priority, it doesn't always mean it's safe to carry on regardless.
@gavinpenrose
@gavinpenrose Жыл бұрын
The kind of parent then when taking their child to the hospital, keeps saying "but we was in the right" 😡
@nizviz
@nizviz Жыл бұрын
In this situation with the child cyclist there is no excuse for the actions of the oncoming car driver.
@mrblablablabla
@mrblablablabla Жыл бұрын
"I'm very sorry dear, I'm afraid our little Billy died in a traffic accident when I took him out cycling. He was hit by an oncoming car after I told him to keep going when Billy asked if he should stop. We had priority though!"
@jackw7714
@jackw7714 Жыл бұрын
"I'm very sorry dear, I'm afraid I was held up on my way home because I killed a child on a bike. You see although he had priority, and was vulnerable, I decided I'm more important and so I wanted to go, and my car is bigger than a child on a bike anyway."
@war0nymph
@war0nymph Жыл бұрын
@@jackw7714 "the funny part tho is that the child didnt actually have priority nor enough brains to stop after seeing a car, probably because he was a 5 year old and shouldnt have been on the road in the first place, especially during that weather. only the fittest survive"
@mattlad6935
@mattlad6935 Жыл бұрын
I'm absolutely 100% in agreement with you Ashley on this one. Kudos to the child for being the only one with some common sense, if it doesn't get "educated" out of him he will go far.
@paulwilkinson3963
@paulwilkinson3963 Жыл бұрын
I’ve been cycling to work for over a year now and it’s amazing how many close calls you have because motorists feel they have priority over a measley push bike when they should be giving way. Of course if the blockage is on their side but they have nowhere to pull in to let me through I’ll just stop and let them through like any reasonable person would
@DavidFraser007
@DavidFraser007 Жыл бұрын
Maybe the father genuinely thought it was better to keep going. People, especially kids, can wobble when they stop a bicycle.
@blake-gl4wn
@blake-gl4wn Жыл бұрын
Exactly. The dad only had a small amount of time make a decision. He may have made the wrong decision, but not necessarily out of stubbornness or entitlement
@Daniel-ug3ie
@Daniel-ug3ie Жыл бұрын
Maybe you're right, but the kid was alert to the situation and would have had plenty of time to stop safely and not wobble. Especially considering how well he rode in a straight line whilst turning his head
@paulstevens9409
@paulstevens9409 Жыл бұрын
The fathers an idiot, its obvious he was just being stubborn
@DavidFraser007
@DavidFraser007 Жыл бұрын
@@Daniel-ug3ie Yep, he's a good kid, but I think his Dad knows him better than us.
@niallrichardson6798
@niallrichardson6798 Жыл бұрын
Excellent video, I totally agree. My father taught me that you "don't play games on the road" and "it's not just what you do but what other people do that can cause accidents". Whilst the driver was to blame, why on earth the father would send his son on to seemingly make a point is beyond me. Any driver prepared to do this is best avoided, it might hurt our pride but often backing down makes for a better journey.
@peebee143
@peebee143 Жыл бұрын
100% with you on this one, Ashley. I did wonder if we were going to see something horrific when I saw the car continue toward the cyclists, glad it didn't turn out that way. That young man is quite a smart kid and has obviously had some experience of cycling already.
@happydappyman
@happydappyman Жыл бұрын
Yeah as to who goes first. I'm generally of the sense that if my lane has the parked car, I wait for oncoming to pass before moving into what is THEIR side of the road. If both sides are blocked, we take turns or act like the other person will not be stopping. (Go when you know the other person is yielding). That being said, while cycling everyone is out to kill you. Though not literally true, I tend to act as though it is. The car can be completely at fault, but if I'm dead it hardly matters.
@problemchild1976
@problemchild1976 Жыл бұрын
Bikes committed first (I guess I'm incorrect) but as a general rule, I think this works. But no way would I have squeezed through and would have let them pass first no matter what. People seem unable to judge when they will come and meet The only thing I would say is that sometimes telling a child to brake quickly could destabilise them and put them in more danger
@steveh3206
@steveh3206 Жыл бұрын
I agree with the analysis. My only thought playing devils advocate would be that maybe the father of the boy was worried about him stopping. Perhaps he knew the boy was fine while moving as you said but sometimes was a bit wobbly stopping and he didn't want him to fall off into the path of the oncoming car while trying to stop in a tricky spot? Sometimes it's safer to keep moving?
@neilmartin3013
@neilmartin3013 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely nailed it right there. To stop in that situation would have been arguably more dangerous - the kid was riding a really straight line at the speed he was going
@mr.evasion
@mr.evasion Жыл бұрын
Child probably shouldn't be on the road if he can't safely do the emergency stop
@derekheeps1244
@derekheeps1244 Жыл бұрын
That just demonstrates that the child should not be cycling on a busy road
@marklittler784
@marklittler784 Жыл бұрын
The kid saw the situation developing before the adults.😄😅😄😅
@Gr1mR34p3r85
@Gr1mR34p3r85 Жыл бұрын
"Shall I pull over to the side?" At 5 years old? This kid is going places.
@waynerobertson511
@waynerobertson511 Жыл бұрын
True. The child 'learner' was the most competent road user!
@shm5547
@shm5547 Жыл бұрын
no, I don't think so, the kid was just asking about priority at the parked vehicles, which the father correctly told him it was their right of way.
@tarnmonath
@tarnmonath Жыл бұрын
@@shm5547 There's no such thing as 'right of way' in these cases. The principle is 'priority'. And if you've watched Ashley's videos, you'll know how priority should be managed.
@shm5547
@shm5547 Жыл бұрын
@@tarnmonath but when you're teaching kids cycling, they are always asking should I stop, who has priority etc. The first, most basic thing, is to teach them the rules. Only then do you move onto managing risk from rule breakers. The only thing the father could do better here, is to ride 2 abreast with his kid to do that defensive cycling for them. A point Ashley completely missed.
@josephmarsh8235
@josephmarsh8235 Жыл бұрын
Your opinions on road collisions like this are the best and most thought out well Ashley.
@jcjc7402
@jcjc7402 Жыл бұрын
Its great to see that the five year old had better risk assessment capacity that the father, "shall I pull over"
@mameli0701
@mameli0701 Жыл бұрын
What should have been a perfect learning experience was potentially ruined by the stubborn father and incompetent driver. Well done little fella!
@martinp5184
@martinp5184 Жыл бұрын
Love this break down and fully agree with every single point made as a cyclist. I do have a pet peeve for those who automatically believe they have the right of way in these type of situations and continue (we are all guilty of it I guess) but it’s those who act out in aggression either by driving recklessly or genuinely abusive. As long as either party continues to keep safe and respect those on the road whether in the wrong or not then the roads will be a safer place. Conflict causes more danger in my eyes.
@mattdavies55
@mattdavies55 Жыл бұрын
Average UK car driver who thinks the road belongs to them, cycling will never be safe in this country
@wasspj
@wasspj 8 ай бұрын
@@mattdavies55 And the dad is the worst kind of cyclist who believes that they have no responsibility for their own safety.
@PatrickBijvoet
@PatrickBijvoet Жыл бұрын
As a teacher, I am impressed with the question of the child. Further I agree with your assessment Ashley. A little point on the side and offtopic. 6 months ago you and I where talking about a Cruyff-shirt you where wearing. As a Dutchman I was proud to see that. Little did I know, sorry about that, what I found out a few days ago, that you where a professional footballplayer. Now I really understand the shirt! Keep on going with these video's. They are educational for everyone. In and outside of the UK.
@Jonc25
@Jonc25 Жыл бұрын
Agree 100% With what you say, Ashley. The Dad could learn a few things from the Kid.
@ashley_neal
@ashley_neal Жыл бұрын
....now for the headline...."Ex Foot......................
@Jonc25
@Jonc25 Жыл бұрын
@@ashley_neal 😄 I await it.
@Jonc25
@Jonc25 Жыл бұрын
@Ashley Neal I see we keep getting the headline wrong now.😄 Good to see this particular Analysis on Cc.👍
@Jonc25
@Jonc25 Жыл бұрын
@Ashley Neal I see you have been causing a stir with the establishment, Ash.😄
@JohnCasserly
@JohnCasserly Жыл бұрын
Thanks Ashley. I have commented on this on twitter and have had a change of heart over whether that child should have been on the road. I was concerned that the cycle lanes were flooded and it wasn't safe, but I taught my kids to ride on the road the same way. This is the first time I heard the child say "Shall I pull over to the side?" and I would have said "yes" because the life of my child comes before being proved right. As for the driver? Well, there was a point where he would have lost sight of that child. The very least he could have done was stopped until he was visible again. But as I said on twitter, there are some really bad "drivers" out there.
@thepianoman1010
@thepianoman1010 Жыл бұрын
John Casserly ... yes, there are some really bad "drivers" out there ... that's why a five-year-old child should not be riding on a public road!
@adrianellis2433
@adrianellis2433 Жыл бұрын
Totally Agree. This is the first time I’ve seen this clip with sound. What an amazing young man that child is going to grow into
@stephenmcmanua6251
@stephenmcmanua6251 Жыл бұрын
my tuppence worth is the cyclist reached the parked cars (not the pinch point) long before the car, therefore they were already commited to the passing manoeuvre, irrespective of whether its a cyclist, hgv, bus, pedestrian or car the oncoming driver should have given way and who the hell tries to squeeze past a young child on a bike
@monkeyfunk4910
@monkeyfunk4910 Жыл бұрын
Iv picked up Ashley's attitude to the road well over the past year and have become a cyclist people don't mind sharing the road with. It's like penguins of Madagascar, (smile and wave. )I got T,boned at 30mph a couple of months back in a bike lane when a car ran a no entry so it won't save you all the time but giving right of way does cut the risk to everyone somewhat.
@ashley_neal
@ashley_neal Жыл бұрын
This mindset change will have a bigger impact on road safety than any infrastructure you can possibly build. A good road user can negotiate through a tricky situation simply and easily.
@marcussmith6523
@marcussmith6523 Жыл бұрын
Imagine if the driver of the oncoming car was the same one as in Ashleys ' Unfit to Drive' video. Having priority and proving a point for social media clicks doesn't stop you or your child getting killed. There are lot of older drivers with very poor eyesight and no awareness of anything around them.
@manchegocheese997
@manchegocheese997 Жыл бұрын
@@mintywebb What is wrong with you?
@itisthomascasey
@itisthomascasey Жыл бұрын
Glad to see this back up. It was taken down before I had a chance to view it. Excellent analysis and one that is important to the road safety discussion.
@theweekthatis
@theweekthatis Жыл бұрын
This is your best video to date, utterly brilliant, a real clarity of thought. Superb.
@stevie-ray2020
@stevie-ray2020 Жыл бұрын
My worst experience cycling through one of those pinch-points was when a car tried to pass me, but it wasn't until I heard him that I knew he wasn't going to stop. Wouldn't have been quite so scary if I didn't have bags of groceries from the supermarket on both sides of the carrier (because my car was out of action)!
@richardsimpson3792
@richardsimpson3792 Жыл бұрын
When I used to cycle in town, I'd get out into the middle of the lane going through a pinch-point (after doing a rear ob), then pull over to the left as soon as I was clear so following cars could pass safely and quickly. With the cyclists on the country lane, providing the oncoming car is on his side of the road there is no need for him to slow down...the cyclists don't have to ride so irresponsibly close together...if one wobbled or had a tyre pop he could bring all his mates down. The can see the oncoming car and should give it space.
@unsafevelocities5687
@unsafevelocities5687 Жыл бұрын
One could say the child hasn't been 'corrupted' by being an adult road user and the attitudes that brings. The kid still has the natural tendency of self-preservation that screamed danger when faced with this situation. The father, who has probably been in many dangerous situations on the road, has become more numb to this instinct unless a collision is imminent. He is effectively teaching his son to ignore that internal scream of danger as he does himself. It does sometimes seem like something we're meant to do. I had a similar situation the other day where I could stay on my side of the road to pass a parked car at the bottom of a hill. I had just cycled down a hill and I was doing 30-40 km/h (20-25 mph), but I was about to cycle up the hill ahead. I saw the parked car on my side of the road, I saw the oncoming car, and I had the scream of danger going off in my head. For some reason I decided keeping my momentum was more important as I didn't want to start up on the hill. I was able to stay on my side, the oncoming driver had their entire lane, my speed was slowed by the hill, but there wasn't enough room for it to be safe. I've been thinking about it since, especially the oncoming driver's smile -- I wonder what about the situation amused her -- either blissfully unaware or gleefully keeping going to teach me a lesson?
@kenbrown2808
@kenbrown2808 Жыл бұрын
I fully agree with the analysis, and I will specifically say again, in my state, the verbiage of the highway code is that a motorist must allow a cyclist enough room that the cyclist can fall down without being hit by the car. I like the verbiage because it is quite clear.
@aliray1165
@aliray1165 Жыл бұрын
Shouting “what are you doing?” In anger doesn’t help prevent an accident.
@jerrysmith2360
@jerrysmith2360 Жыл бұрын
Being Devil’s Advocate, the driver might have been a little surprised seeing a 5 year old in front of him and might not quite been able to judge his speed, and got himself into a bit of a quandary and ended up ****ing things up. What I find quite worrying about this is would that child be easily spotted by someone opening a van or car door? Has anyone got any experience of that?
@TGGDrones
@TGGDrones Жыл бұрын
Priority is given not taken but should ALWAYS be given to more vulnerable road users under law. The analogy of Running around a swimming pool is horribly wrong, this is more like walking around a swimming pool while an adult runs around it in the other direction, running is wrong whoever does it and the child did nothing wrong!
@leejohnson3209
@leejohnson3209 Жыл бұрын
Calling out the father as an 'I've got priority brigade' is totally uncalled for. We're not robots, we're humans. He was expecting the car to pull in.
@davidrobinson4118
@davidrobinson4118 Жыл бұрын
Not uncalled for at all in my opinion. You say he was expecting the car to pull in. Given the fact that his five year old child was in front him and approaching potential danger, perhaps he should have been expecting it not to pull in and to be better safe than sorry.
@leejohnson3209
@leejohnson3209 Жыл бұрын
@@davidrobinson4118 The car driver makes the dad look bad, he (the dad) had seconds to make a judgement and I think he made a reasonable one. The car didn't even need to pull in, it could have made the situation better by just stopping. That's why I think any criticism of the dad is uncalled for here, the car just ploughed on through and made the situation dangerous.
@gamewithadam7235
@gamewithadam7235 Жыл бұрын
Glad to see your video is back up.
@LPCLASSICAL
@LPCLASSICAL Жыл бұрын
I am sure the father now realises he gave his son the wrong answer. Hopefully this will be a learning curve for him. I personally never took my son out cycling on a road. No matter how well you instruct - the unpredictable can always happen. We always went to parks to cycle and he does not own a cycle now he is grown. I have a bicycle which I take to coastal paths etc and I generally do not cycle on roads as I consider it is too dangerous.
@sunnyhighway1
@sunnyhighway1 Жыл бұрын
Coming from a country with 23,4 million bicycles and a population of 17,5 Million people I see this: The father missed the opportunity to have the child ride between the curb and himself. This is very common in the Netherlands as it creates a safe(r) space for the child on the road. It would als have given an extremely clear signal to the oncoming car they are expected to wait. In the event the oncoming car still barges trough, the father can always steer to the left and push/knock the child over in the direction of the curb into safety.
@MrSabretooth19
@MrSabretooth19 Жыл бұрын
so you have 6 million bicycles sat around doing nothing😉
@TheVicar
@TheVicar Жыл бұрын
I also thought that the adult should have been over to the right of his child because he would be much more visible to traffic
@TheVicar
@TheVicar Жыл бұрын
@@MrSabretooth19 Have you looked outside some train stations in the Netherlands? I'm English but I remember seeing over a thousand bikes outside of a station in Utrecht, and it would've been impossible to get to "your" bike, as they were 50 deep and all leaning against each other up to a wall So I do believe that you can have more bikes than people in a country
@sunnyhighway1
@sunnyhighway1 Жыл бұрын
@@MrSabretooth19 Not really. It is fairly common to have a normal (daily) bike and a recreational bike like a mountain bike, race bike or even a cargo bike. It is just the dutch equivalent to an American having daily driver, pickup truck and quad.
@derekheeps1244
@derekheeps1244 Жыл бұрын
The car did not barge through any more than the cyclists did .
@alanhindmarch4483
@alanhindmarch4483 Жыл бұрын
Yes I agree it is good to see young people like this 5 year old learning road craft. I did it with my children, now 39 & 34 and I am continuing with my Grandchildren 14 & 11. I think your analysing of the Clip is once again Spot On. I think the young boy wasn’t happy with the situation and possible felt in danger, that could have been the reason for wanting to pull over. Stay safe everyone and continue listening to Ashley, we are all never to old to learn something new.
@PedroConejo1939
@PedroConejo1939 Жыл бұрын
A good demonstration of why family are not always as good as properly trained instructors, whether bicycle, motorcycle, car or larger.
@aljroche
@aljroche Жыл бұрын
Thanks for this video Ashley. I’m currently teaching my son to ride on the road and have found myself in similar situations. This is very educational for me as I’ve tried to explain that although you may have right of way it doesn’t mean you can expect it and you need to be ready to stop at all times.
@philipjames3526
@philipjames3526 Жыл бұрын
As soon as the parent said - ‘carry on to his child’ despite it being clear the car wasn’t going to stop - The parent, typical. Yes, we can all hope drivers were amazing and didn’t make mistakes. I don’t understand this, why put yourself into a dangerous situation just because you know you are right.
@InBodWeTrust
@InBodWeTrust Жыл бұрын
The only additional observation I would make is that perhaps a late brake action from the cyclists may have unsettled the bikes and caused the child (particularly) to fall off just as the car approached. (Wet roads). That might have been in the father's mind too. However if they'd stopped when the child first asked then the risk of this happening would have been much lower as the level of braking would have been lower.
@blake-gl4wn
@blake-gl4wn Жыл бұрын
Completely agree with this. And it’s very easy to critique after analysing a video
@gerardmcmanus
@gerardmcmanus Жыл бұрын
I am glad you put that last bit in. Completely agree 👍 Do what's safe. They 'should' stop, doesn't mean they 'will' stop.
@martinmartin8333
@martinmartin8333 Жыл бұрын
Thank you for your analysis. You always have a well thought out opinion and explain it well.
@LeeSmith-cf1vo
@LeeSmith-cf1vo Жыл бұрын
I have to say I agree 100% with everything you say here. When I'm in a situation like this, who I think has priority very much takes 2nd place to avoiding the risk altogether. As either the driver or the cyclist here I would have yielded.
@ashley_neal
@ashley_neal Жыл бұрын
It wouldn't have happened if I was driving or riding either.
@MrSabretooth19
@MrSabretooth19 Жыл бұрын
@@ashley_neal im a hgv driver of 20 years, no serious crash, 2 minor bumps, i have learned, its not what i should do and its not whats law, its what the other idiot does. seeing what iv seen, i would not take 5 year old on road
@timregester1173
@timregester1173 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely spot in as usual. There is definitely advice missing regarding oncoming cyclists, the current advice only covers overtaking. This is especially common on narrow one lane country roads, as I cyclist I try to take secondary when faced with a motor vehicle that cannot possibly pass me safely, but some drivers don't slow down and think they have priority, when of course neither road user actually does. Relying on common sense is insufficient (as too many road users lack it).
@geoffvalenti
@geoffvalenti Жыл бұрын
Absolutely, Ashley. I saw the clip, formed my own opinion, and sought out your channel for your take on it. I was pleased to see that we were in total agreement.
@therainbowgulag.
@therainbowgulag. Ай бұрын
Social services should be involved with this.
@mdacheets
@mdacheets Жыл бұрын
The lad has shown he is very bright and capable of listening to, and following, instructions. You have to learn to ride on the road at some stage, the earlier the better. Cyclists put themselves at risk every time they use our roads as we share them with larger, faster and heavier vehicles. I don't think the parent has done anything wrong personally.
@jimg492
@jimg492 Жыл бұрын
Hey Ash. This video has almost bought me to tears. I completely agree with your comments. Hats off to the lad, listen to your kids guys. This one will go far!
@mattwardman
@mattwardman Жыл бұрын
Having watched the clip a couple of times, for me there are three thoughts: 1 - That street is crying out for a segregated cycleway, preferably as part of a combined thru-routes and 'safe routes to schools' network. Such would at a stroke remove the conflict which caused the questions raised. 2 - The cycling bypass, which is infrastructure built until I think the 1980s, is even more out of date than that, and illustrates how little attention we pay to maintenance / updating. A practice that needs to be fixed. 3 - This and Ashley's recent unfit-to-drive video illustrate the need for continuing driver education / monitoring. Two weeks ago a 74 year old pensioner Arthur Robert McGrillen was given a 2.5 year prison sentence for killing one person on a bike with his car, and seriously injuring another. He had failed to self-disclose a stroke when renewing his driving license. Two months ago an 82 year old pensioner Peter Gardner was given 6 months in prison for killing a 70 year old on a bike when he could only read a number plate at 10ft. I suggest that the current system does not work, and would not actually be that expensive to fix - very little work for a GP nurse to do a rapid go/no go check, an refer to the GP if necessary. On the clip I'd suggest that this driver will continue causing risks to other people unless educated somehow. I'd suggest a re-evaluation every 10 years when photocard is renewed, or far more widespread camera enforcement and courses. There was a startingly similar case, with a similar vid, when a 28 year old mountain guide called Jake David Tomkinson received a jail sentence when he fell asleep at the after he decided to drive home after an all night trek on Snowdon, rather than check into a hotel for a sleep.
@largeladsteve25
@largeladsteve25 Жыл бұрын
I'm glad you took this angle at the clip, I was baffled at some of the news coverage treating the father as a total saint for not giving in to a driver like that as if he hadnt also instructed his kid into a dangerous situation.
@grahamnutt8958
@grahamnutt8958 Жыл бұрын
Top notch - as always. Ego and stubbornness could easily have resulted in a fatality here. I agree - full credit to the Child who displayed more sense than the "so called" Adults. Stay safe out there.
@Jonc25
@Jonc25 Жыл бұрын
Spot on, Graham! 👍
@grahamnutt8958
@grahamnutt8958 Жыл бұрын
@@Jonc25 Respect, bud 👍
@karoln7078
@karoln7078 Жыл бұрын
That kid should be teaching his dad how to cycle 🤣
@CaptainSpock1701
@CaptainSpock1701 Жыл бұрын
This is why I'm subscribed to this channel. Ashley does not pull any punches. An accurate and honest assessment if I ever heard one.
@trueriver1950
@trueriver1950 Жыл бұрын
This sort of analysis is exactly what I love about this channel.
@TheIrvy
@TheIrvy Жыл бұрын
I agree completely with everything you said. I live in a city with an excellent cycle network, and I'll take a longer route on the cycle path if it means staying off the roads. There's an unattractive bolshy streak that's very apparent today, with so many people thinking that they're the exception to every rule and they can do what they want. As you pointed out, the only person not displaying that attitude was the 5 year old, and they were the student in the situation. The child only asked if they should pull in because they had assessed the danger and felt unsafe. I would advise that if they had to ask the question, the answer is yes, you should pull in to the side. It's very easy to get into that argument of "who has right of way", and there are a lot of drivers out there who have taken umbrage to the change in law that gives the more vulnerable party right of way. Don't they know that driver owns the road and is the only person who should be on it? I've met plenty of drivers like that out and about. It's a big part of the reason why I stopped driving and stick to cycling.
@derekheeps1244
@derekheeps1244 Жыл бұрын
There has NOT been a change in law ; only an ill conceived change in advice . In this situation both parties have right of way , and also equal priority .
@TheIrvy
@TheIrvy Жыл бұрын
@@derekheeps1244 As the video points out, right of way is given, not taken and that nobody has "right of way". The law favours the most vulnerable party in the situation, which is inarguably the 5 year old child and not your ego. You do not own the road, and you have the responsibility to conduct yourself with all due care and attention while you are driving on it. Since when did it become ok to forget your manners as soon as you sit down behind a steering wheel?
@schrbtschtaeter3367
@schrbtschtaeter3367 Жыл бұрын
I disagree with the assessment of the dad. Suddenly telling his kid to stop may cause him to swerve or even fall. Startling such a young biker can be dangerous in a situation like this. Otherwise spot on analysis!
@alihorda
@alihorda Жыл бұрын
the kid literally asked if he should pull to the side, dad was at the fault here (plus the car driver)
@IrfanButt
@IrfanButt Жыл бұрын
Beautifully and accurately articulated, thanks Ashley
@TheBreaster
@TheBreaster Жыл бұрын
Excellent analysis of this scenario.Great advice for learner drivers,qualified drivers and cyclists
@thepianoman1010
@thepianoman1010 Жыл бұрын
People who are somehow ok with a 5-year-old kid riding on our public roads are failing to realise that many of the drivers on our roads aren't that good at driving ... there are drivers who have always been poor drivers, there are old drivers whose reactions and perception aren't that good, there are drugged and drunk drivers, there are learner drivers ... there are car drivers, lorry drivers, motorcyclists etc and not all of them are what we would call good drivers .... Anyone who suggests it is fine for a 5-year-old kid to be cycling on our roads is plain stupid .. and that includes the poor kid's father!!
@th5841
@th5841 Жыл бұрын
This is basically saying car drivers are car drivers, sharks are sharks. You can't do anything about them, just hide behind them and use them as an excuse. And this is a city residential street with low speed limits and complex activity, not a road where the purpose is to get people fast and efficient from A to B. I can see your point, though. So the first step should be to clean up the parked cars along this street and then put in a protected bidirectional bicycle lane . Another measuer would be to not have any through traffic, here. This looks very much like a destination street, meaning you slow down your car and is more of a guest. I am sure this dad wouldn't let his 5 year old son bicycle in traffic with dense and fast traffic.
@thepianoman1010
@thepianoman1010 Жыл бұрын
​@@th5841 I find the whole idea ridiculous. There was a 7-year-old killed on a quadbike on a rural road near me back in 2007. More irresponsible parenting I'm so very sorry to say! "A girl of seven was killed after colliding with a car travelling in the opposite direction as she rode her Christmas present quad bike on an unlit country road on Boxing Day evening. Elizabeth Cooke and her 10-year-old brother, Jack, were each on quad bikes, following their father's car along a winding lane in Essex, when Elizabeth's bike collided with an oncoming Range Rover. Her brother was not hurt. A family friend said: "We were in the car with the children's dad and they [the children] were following us. We'd only gone 200 yards when it happened. I was watching them, keeping an eye on them. They both had lights on their bikes. "A car came past and I said to Gary [the father]: 'One of the lights has gone, one of them has come off the bike'." The accident happened in Fingrith Hall Lane, Blackmore, near Ongar, at 7pm. A spokesman for Essex police said: "A red Range Rover and a Shark quad bike struck each other. The rider, a seven-year-old girl who lived locally, was conveyed to Chelmsford's Broomfield hospital by ambulance but sadly died soon after arrival." *Nothing will convince me that I'm wrong and anyone condoning this sheer stupidity needs looking at!* _"Cycling as a family is great fun and fantastic exercise. But when you cycle with children, it's vital to stay as safe as possible. Brake recommends that children under 10 should only cycle on safe cycle paths, away from motorised traffic."_ "A five-year-old boy has died after being hit by a bin lorry while out riding his bicycle. The young child was pronounced dead following the collision in Walsall at about 10am on Sunday. The scene of the crash in West Bromwich Road was cordoned off by police as they carried out an investigation. Photos show officers examining a child's Spider-Man bicycle." (July this year)
@thepianoman1010
@thepianoman1010 Жыл бұрын
@@th5841 Any views on the two dead children I have pointed out? Had they not been riding on the road, they would not be dead! *These two dead children were not riding in "dense and fast traffic"!*
@th5841
@th5841 Жыл бұрын
@@thepianoman1010Those two cases are tragic. But how and why should I comment on them? I don't know anything about them. And are they relevant to this case? If the traffic wasn't dense or fast, what did the drivers of the Range Rover and the lorry contribute with to avoid the accidents? Nobody seems to question them or car drivers in general. Sure, it may very well be a matter of poor decisions by the parents. Something most of us wouldn't have done. But people make poor decisions. We all do. But as a car driver, in the case shown in this video, should you think "That was a stupid parent. I will just plow through to show my point". Or would you stop or slow down to reduce the danger while shouting your anger. Or would you slow down or stop and think that "the street isn't jsut for me? This is a residential area where you should expect and accept this kinds of activities". It might be that you and I live in two different cultures. Here drivers go very slowly in my neighbourhood. Small kids are out on their bicycles together with their parens, and there is no fuzz about it. In your place that may not be the case. Car drivers think they own the streets and they are like sharks. And we can't change sharks, just avoid them. I live in Oslo, Norway. In 2019 there were zero pedestrian fatalities in this city (700,000 citizens). So it isn't like we are completely wrong about these things.
@thepianoman1010
@thepianoman1010 Жыл бұрын
​@@th5841 You don't have to comment on what I wrote at all but I'd expect you to note that the tragic cases I mentioned resulted from a situation where children were riding on a public road! Pretty obvious, surely. I'd also expect you to realise that there are many different kinds of car & truck drivers along with motorcyclists who use our roads and not all are the kind to stop or slow down to reduce any existing danger and ask themselves the question, "is the street just for me?" .. Indeed, some may be travelling too fast to do so and some may be under the influence of alcohol or drugs! You assume far too much. You then assume that all drivers in your area are safe and responsible drivers! That is an unbelievable thing to say ... vehicles allow all kinds of drivers to travel all over the country, including to your area! And believe me, your area has poor drivers in it as well as drunk and drugged drivers. If you can't see any of the above, move on ... we are both wasting our time. As for bragging about Norway's low road fatalities, go onto the World Health Rankings site for 2020 and you'll see that Norway had a death rate from road traffic accidents, of 1.76 per 100,000 of population and the figure for the UK is 2.81. When we consider the population of the two countries it is clear that UK roads are far safer than those in Norway, especially when we consider the large number of cities in the UK and the consequent densely packed roads. Norway is also 33% bigger than the UK. *"15 November 2022 at **17:03** Pedestrian dead after collision at Haugenstua in Oslo A person has died after being hit by a car at Haugenstua in Oslo. The driver ran away from the scene."* (Teknomers 15 Nov 2022) The population of Norway is 5 million and that for the UK is 67 million ... 13 times as many people. You say zero pedestrian fatalities in Oslo for 2019 but there were 109 fatalities in the country as a whole and despite more than halving the number of road accidents, by 2019 there were still 4,358 people, who had been non-fatally injured on Norwegian roads. You aren't very good at logic are you? Read this .. "Police alarmed over accelerating road fatalities. July 18, 2022 "Norwegians have hit the road again this summer but danger lurks even on the safest new highways. Traffic fatalities have risen sharply so far this year, with police and other transport experts worried that drivers simply aren’t keeping their eyes on the road." "New statistics show nearly a 60 percent increase in traffic deaths through the first half of 2022. Of the 63 people killed on Norwegian roads, 50 were men and more than half the fatal accidents involved private cars. Another 14 were killed in motorcycle accidents and three of the fatalities were pedestrians hit by passing vehicles. The number of traffic fatalities had risen to 70 by this week, after more serious accidents from Tromsø in the north to Sarpsborg in the south. The national traffic safety organization Trygg Trafikk notes that more than 70 percent of the fatal accidents involve single cars or head-on collisions. Police confirm that use of mobile phones while driving, along with use of touch screens in new, especially electric, cars are often involved as well. Motorists can be distracted by them, take their eyes off the road and quickly lose control of their cars." (News in English dot No July, 2022)
@Talkathon408
@Talkathon408 Жыл бұрын
Whilst I agree with you, I think there's a tendency for cyclists to do this because as vulnerable road users they don't want to be bullied by motorists which is understandable given how dangerous the roads can be if they allow that to happen.
@programmer5855
@programmer5855 Жыл бұрын
fair enough but do that when you don't have a child with you
@torinjones3221
@torinjones3221 Жыл бұрын
I mean the kid made the most sensible judgement call out of all of them when he said should I pull over. Daddy cyclist was a knob for forcing his child to carry in when he was clearly uncomfortable with the situation.
@daveyrayner
@daveyrayner Жыл бұрын
Spot on analysis. As a driver of 40+ years, I still learn from you.
@rjones6219
@rjones6219 Жыл бұрын
Some years ago, I did a driving assessment of an employee. On our side of the road was a parked car, there wasn't enough room for two cars to pass each other alongside the parked car. Approaching us were two cars, separated by a distance. The driver being assessed, correctly waited for the first car to come through, then pulled out into the face of the second oncoming car, forcing it to brake. I asked why they had done that, their reply was "I waited my turn". Of course, I had to explain, there was no such thing as having a turn, and duly failed the assessment, on the grounds of unsafe manoeuvre.
@StefanVeenstra
@StefanVeenstra Жыл бұрын
As a dutchman, I would've pulled to the side before the white van, because at that point it's already clear the oncoming car isn't going to give way. (Doubt the oncoming car even noticed the young cyclist, considering the lack of slowing down) Ultimately the childs safety is more important than a dad's ego.
@nearlyretired7005
@nearlyretired7005 Жыл бұрын
What has nationally got to do with it? I am English!!
@rebeccaconlon9743
@rebeccaconlon9743 Жыл бұрын
@@nearlyretired7005 different mentalities and mind sets perhaps, however your comment doesn't invalidate their point.
@Jimbob7595
@Jimbob7595 Жыл бұрын
@@nearlyretired7005 Do you want a medal?
@StefanVeenstra
@StefanVeenstra Жыл бұрын
@@nearlyretired7005 Was about to write an essay on cycling culture. Point is, situation in the video are all too common over here. Children get taught to cycle very early and it's not uncommon to find 5 year olds cycle about independently. Motorists are human too, they make mistakes all the time, so do cyclists and pedestrians. It is essential that we recognize the mistake and help solve the problem. Cyclists are smaller, more agile and can stop much easier. They can easily adjust to accommodate a safe solution.
@ianmason.
@ianmason. Жыл бұрын
@@nearlyretired7005 Quite a lot when the nationality is Dutch. One only has to read the comments to one or two videos analysing cycling and you'll quickly discover that a _certain_ kind of British cyclist thinks the Nederland is a cycling nirvana and if only we did what the Dutch do the world would be perfect. Thus mentioning he's a Dutchman is Stefan's way of saying, for the benefit of _that_ kind of cyclist, "My opinion as a cyclist caries extra weight because I come from the land where cyclist's farts smell of roses". 🤣
@elontusk4863
@elontusk4863 Жыл бұрын
The parent should be ashamed
@th5841
@th5841 Жыл бұрын
And the car driver should not? Let's not focus on him/her. Or us as car drivers.
@elontusk4863
@elontusk4863 Жыл бұрын
@@th5841 the road is filled with endless bad drivers. That parent has a responsibility for their 5 year old child. Putting them knowingly in danger is irresponsible. Grow up.
@daniv7402
@daniv7402 Жыл бұрын
clear and concise, well done! I hope more people see your clip
@pappy9473
@pappy9473 Жыл бұрын
Excellent. I am so glad I listened to your every word. Despite being on the side of the dad and his efforts to teach his little son, I concur with your analysis. Thank you
@marklittler784
@marklittler784 Жыл бұрын
Wouldn't be surprised if the kid was capable of Passing the cycling proficiency test.
@davidrobinson4118
@davidrobinson4118 Жыл бұрын
Not sure about the dad though!
@marklittler784
@marklittler784 Жыл бұрын
@@davidrobinson4118 😄🤸😄🤸😄🤸😄
@ernestmfakudze
@ernestmfakudze Жыл бұрын
Ashley, I totally agree with you. Personally, I'm always terrified for young kids when they are on the road on their scooters or bikes. It only takes one entitled crazy driver to turn a family's life upside down. I would rather kids used the pavement; sensibly, of course. I know that pavements users get very possessive of the pavement, but I think if we all tried we could share the pavement peacefully. We just need to care enough for each other.
@th5841
@th5841 Жыл бұрын
The problem is that car driver are also very possessive of the streets and roads. "Bicycles don't belong here!" Car drivers must learn that streets and roads are not made for them to get as fast as possible from A to B. They must adjust to road users like bicyclists when they are in residential streets like this. And I knew that most comments in here would be on what the bicyclists were doing wrong instead of what the car driver was doing wrong, even when the car dirver is posessing a murder weapon, his car.
@chrisbarltrop2877
@chrisbarltrop2877 Жыл бұрын
If cyclists just used the pavement too many drivers would see this as a green light to continue driving poorly. We need to educate drivers which is difficult because most drivers don't believe they can be better. Many cyclists feel that way too.
@tiny19892
@tiny19892 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely nailed it. Well done Ashley neal, scoring goals for common sense
@MorrisGuy
@MorrisGuy Жыл бұрын
Saw this clip on TikTok, i watched it and had the exact same view as the kid done really well there, glad to hear you had the same view point. you really have rub off on me haha, passed in 2018 but still sub and take notes and honestly have become a better driver because of it. i can clearly say I would of stopped. On my way to work every morning I always come across a dad and his two sons who must be on their way to school, they drive on the road and a couple of times I have met them head on, I always stop and give them way as i find a kid is less predictable in riding style so i make it more safe even if by the letter i have way, but at the end of the day, sod the rules, life comes first. Keep up good work Ash.
@esenel92
@esenel92 Жыл бұрын
As a motorist passing kids (or animals), no matter if they're on the sidewalk or road, moving or stopped. you need to expect the unexpected. The kid can actually stop and lose balance and fall over, or as the speed drops their path can actually get more erratic as it's harder to stay upright. One of the big issues I'm seeing on british roads (through video's online) is that there's no respect for other road users. It's mostly "Me, me and me" and nobody or nothing is allowed to slow me down for a second. Other people are treated as objects, not humans. Generally motorists tend to pass people on foot or bicycle like they are street furniture, which really gets shown off when people pass a cyclist, and 2 seconds later take a left turn. There's no way you didn't see the cyclist, it just doesn't seem to register in their brain that they are also moving objects and they're cutting someone off by doing that. And it's not just something that's happening in the GB, but GB just stands out as one of the extremes at the moment. There needs to be an attitude change in society.
@esenel92
@esenel92 Жыл бұрын
@@zbf5h89ftb Oh that's true, but it doesn't negate the video's online where a lot of people still seem to be absolutely oblivious of other road users. It's a problem that's getting worse at an alarming rate, and steps need to be taken to counter it.
@jkdarlow
@jkdarlow Жыл бұрын
I very much agree with what you've said, when i saw the video a few days back i was shocked that when the little kid asked if he should stop and pull over the father said no carry on, clearly the child saw the potential danger (or was scared of the situation) while the father just wanted to go through regardless of it it put his child at risk because he was in the 'right' and the driver was in the 'wrong'.
@TimmmmmyD
@TimmmmmyD Жыл бұрын
Stick to the path kids. Regardless of whos at fault its not worth risking a 5 year olds life over whos right and wrong on the road.
@bugmancx
@bugmancx Жыл бұрын
I couldn't have done a better analysis than this. Every point you made also went through my mind and I came to the end of video with nothing to disagree with. Thanks!
@Bin-The-L-Plates
@Bin-The-L-Plates Жыл бұрын
I’ve commented a few time on this on Twitter, and echo everything you say in the video. I think we can all agree the motorist is wrong, but so many have ignored the negligence of the parent. I’ve seen his TV interview, and he’s oblivious to the danger he put his child (and himself) in, that for me is the scariest part of the video. Why he’d force a child into a potential life threatening risk is crazy, the cynic in me thinks it’s for clickbait reaction it’s had on social media, and he was looking for ‘action’. Just because the cyclist is right, and the motorist should have given way, wouldn’t have made his child any less dead should he have been killed. Thanks for posting this up Ashley, there’s been too many angry motorists and cyclists missing the most important aspect of the clip …….. Road safety is the responsibility of everyone.
@philipallen4230
@philipallen4230 Жыл бұрын
If everybody focused on the fact that the driver is at most to blame here, maybe it would change people's attitude that when driving a car you need to be responsible for vulnerable road users around you. If the driver had given way, as they were supposed to, there would have been no issue as to taking priority. Criticise the parent if you want to but you should also acknowledge the real fault is with the driver.
@tipple58
@tipple58 Жыл бұрын
Bang on the money! (And Ashley's comment at the end about the father just rings so true.)
@ianmason.
@ianmason. Жыл бұрын
​@@philipallen4230 Focusing on the poor driving alone will achieve absolutely nothing. What difference do you think sitting here and tut-tuting will achieve - the poor drivers aren't listening. We have got to stop this "who's to blame" thinking and start thinking about everybody working to make it safer. If they had pulled over as the kid wanted to this would have been a non event _despite the bad driving of the oncoming driver_ . One can rail against bad drivers as much as one likes, being as smug or judgemental as one likes and it won't make them better drivers and it won't reduce the accident rates. I lock my doors because burglars are a thing, I yield when I shouldn't technically have to when I'm driving because bad and inconsiderate drivers are a thing. It's been proved time and time over that telling people of the consequences of bad behaviour has little or no effect, but selling the benefits of good behaviour works. Doctors are now taught to 'sell' the benefits of giving up smoking, not tell patients off for it. "Did you know that if you give up smoking then in five years you'll have the same risk of cardiovascular disease as a life long non-smoker" is a much more effective message than "smoking increases your risk of cardiovascular disease by between two and four times".
@philipallen4230
@philipallen4230 Жыл бұрын
@@ianmason. my issue is not who’s to blame. My issue is with the fact that nearly every response to this video is focusing on the parent. Even your response is focused on changing the behaviour of the cyclist. I agree that you shouldn’t put yourself or child in danger and pulling over was probably the best action of the parent. But only focusing on the parents actions will also do absolutely nothing to change driver behaviour. I don’t care what the most effective way to change behaviour is, as long as it changes the behaviour of the people who present the greater risk.
@ianmason.
@ianmason. Жыл бұрын
@@philipallen4230 I say "start thinking about everybody working to make it safer" and you make that into "focused on changing the behaviour of the cyclist". "everybody" means "everybody". People are mentioning the parent's poor judgement because _he made it worse not better_, the driver's shitty driving is taken as read.
Driving Fail Viewers Edition #7 | Scooter Smash!
12:04
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 105 М.
Cyclists v motorists: Jeremy Clarkson and Jeremy Vine lock horns
5:04
Sunday Times Driving
Рет қаралды 138 М.
ГДЕ ЖЕ ЭЛИ???🐾🐾🐾
00:35
Chapitosiki
Рет қаралды 4,2 МЛН
WHAT?! 6 Years Old Girl Shreds a Bike Park!
5:07
Rémy Métailler RAW
Рет қаралды 991 М.
Driving Fail Viewers Edition #48 | A Smashing Right Hook
11:07
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 86 М.
Bad Wiltshire Drivers, Series 11 Minisode 8
1:35
Bad Wiltshire Drivers
Рет қаралды 1 М.
Ashley's Analysis | 2 Clips Featuring @CyclingMikey
10:30
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 93 М.
They Told Us Cyclists Don’t Actually Use Bike Lanes
6:40
Oh The Urbanity!
Рет қаралды 452 М.
3 Mistakes New Riders Make On The Highway
5:41
MotoJitsu®
Рет қаралды 128 М.
Cutting Corners | Another Cyclist Struck!
8:52
Ashley Neal - Just Cycling
Рет қаралды 42 М.
Ashleys Analysis | Inches From Death
8:02
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 101 М.
Why are people so bad at meeting situations?
8:48
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 83 М.
Driving Fail July | I Like Donuts
14:38
Ashley Neal
Рет қаралды 115 М.