What was the point of this video? Seriously it seems like this has been a video to make a spectacle out of Vigano and kick a man when he is down. You got the outcome that you wanted out of the Vatican for Vigano. What has this commentary added to the faith? It seems like a taking joy out of Vigano’s misfortune. It all sounds deeply personal between you and him. Questioning the man about his relationship with God by calling out Francis and then calling him possessed by a demon!

I was a lapsed Catholic; it had been more than 45 years since I made my last confession and received communion, but I had never stopped believing in The Trinity and continued to pray and read the Bible daily. My beloved wife recently passed and I started to pray for her and offer the Rosary, and beg Jesus that she would be forgiven her sins and she would find everlasting peace in Heaven. I felt that saying the Rosary 3 times a day, and Praying would be more acceptable to The Heavenly Father if I was in a state of Grace; I therefore went to confession for the first time in more than 45 years. Having made my Confession and attending Church on a number of occasions, I then took the courage and went to Communion, I now go to confession every week and attend Church and receive the Eucharist at least 4 times a week. Here is my problem, I am confused with the current teachings, I thought I was very sinful, but even my most wicked moments, I would have been sickened with the antics of the Vatican. I am desperate for guidance and instruction to do the things which are acceptable to The Heavenly Father, but sadly that guidance is not emulating from the Vatican. I will not let Jesus and The Virgin Mother down again, I receive so much solace from saying the Rosary which I offer to my Wife. I am heart broken with closure of Churches, and everything from the Vatican is accelerating the destruction. My wife and I were married in 1968 a RC Church, which was less than 10 years old, the Sunday Services were packed. That Church was knocked down and replaced with retirement homes. Fortunately I trust the guidance provided by my local Priest.

I’m am so so sad. My generation has not been catechized, the confusion that never ends and we want clarity and there is none and our children and grandchildren are lost. God help us.

While I do not agree with everything Vigano says and does, I believe there is a reason for his defiance. You keep saying this is not the solution. As history has shown, whoever sits as head of the DDF is a very influential person in regard to the direction of the Church in the coming years. Is the solution to just sit, let Fernandez put his influence on the future of the Church and hope the next Bishop of Rome reverses it? When was the last time a significant change was reversed in the Church? I would ask you, where is your line? What must people like Francis and Fernandez do before you become defiant and say, "That is not what our Lord and the Apostles said should be done/taught"? How has the benign and docile tactics of Abp. Athanasius Schneider given Fernandez cause to pause? How has the humble and pious tactics of Abp. Strickland caused Francis to reconsider? Throughout the history of the Church people have been called to be troublemakers in regards to the individual in the position of Bishop of Rome. Where would the Church be today if an 11th Century Italian Benedictine monk from Ravenna (who wanted nothing more than to live a quiet life of prayer and contemplation) had not felt driven to speak up about things that a blind-eye was being turned toward by his Bishop of Rome? I shutter to think. I CAN tell you, because he DID follow what he felt was his calling (I am sure there were MANY who said what he did was not the solution), it resulted in him not only being canonized a Saint but also declared a Doctor of the Church. Sometimes it takes an outlandish rabble-rouser to rise above the monotone rumblings of discontent to get people's attention. Lastly, we must be careful not to confuse discontent with the flawed sinner that is Jorge Bergoglio with discontent with the office of the Bishop of Rome.

Archbishop Vigano is a Holy spiritual man, not a renegade 🙏

Everyday the burden of spiritual chastisement gets heavier. The only thing of merit is prayer and penance. Cling to the sacraments while we still have them.

I love ❤️ Archbishop Vigano. In today’s world, St John the Baptist would have been ex-communicated.

And yet, Rupnik, is still a priest in good standing. Rupnik's art is too. The entirety of the German synodal way is still in good standing. There are countless others... Cardinals Pell, Burke, Muller punished, Bishop Strickland, and many others.... for being Pope Francis "enemies". Vigano is a whistleblower who has had to live in hiding for years. That says everything.

Bergoglio wants to retract Catholic teachings on the papacy for the last thousand years. Vigano's solution is more reasonable than this.

Your opinion is zero.

We are not to judge the Archbishops actions, he brought the Truth to the world.

Archbishop vigano was defrocked for calling out the vatican the way st. John the baptist called out herods adulterous relationship. ( oh and i just thought of this, according to the vatican now herods Relationship can be blessed just not the union itself but the individuals within the union. Imagine hearing this from John the baptist.

I have nothing to say about Vigano, but trust me the true Church is now in catacombs

Archbishop Vigano isn’t asking for ostrich feathers he’s asking for the liturgy to be corrected! The pope has excommunicated himself with patchimama pledging his allegiance to Canadian Indians and their false gods! Novis ordo ceremony is the wrong mass for the church!

Once Vigano got deeper into the Vatican issues, he came to realize that too much was illegitimate. We need a new Council as I heard a rumor there is one in the planning - we would not be at a loss to find good solid leadership. God is permitting this to happen to bring about a better good. Vigano probably knows more than he has revealed to us. Pray for more Truth to be revealed. Pax Christi!

Arch Bishop Vigano believes in God and puts God first before any man!

So now you dont think ARCH-BISHOP VIGANO is a "Bishop" but guys like James MARTIN can be called "Father"??? 😮... VIGANO went off course but Church leaders in the VATICAN have completely went off course as well my friend. I wont follow a lot of the madness coming from Rome. 🙏... We continue to pray.

God bless Archbishop Vigano, a true and holy man of God. I will continue to support Archbishop Vigano. Bishop Wliamson is another wonderful bishop, I wish we had more like these good bishops but then the 'New Order' Church is, heading to the gates, of hell.

Regarding your question whether Archbishop Vigano had union with God? Definitely, he has because of his ability to discern the Truth in what is happening in our Catholic Church. 🌹🙏💕

These are very sad and trying times. All the more reason to go deeper into prayer. For mercy, for the light of Christ to illuminate the way forward, that our hearts of stone may become hearts that love.

There are numerous people who have been ex communicated and later became Saints

I am shocked at what you are saying. Arch Bishop Vigano has a point the children to day that are receiving Baptism is not the true rite no salt on the tongue

I don’t know if Vigano is right or wrong, but I do know that Pope Francis cares about what the secular world and the Anglican Church thinks of him.Outside the Catholic Church this will just seem like proof that the church has not modernised at all. The concept of the infallibility of the Pope sounds backward and archaic to the secular world. The secular and Anglican world will see this as a vain, arrogant and tyrannical Pope abusing his power by sacking a very elderly high ranking , highly respected man, who until recently has dedicated and sacrificed his whole life for the good of the church. Most normal peoples reaction in the secular would be that Viganos behaviour of loyal servant turning into troublesome critic in old age, is obviously a sign of ageing, that he is a man who is no longer thinking clearly due to age, and who should be treated with care, love and compassion, considering his life long service to the Church. Not someone who should be excommunited, publicly humiliated, and possibly booted out of his home. If the church is so weak it can’t absorb criticism from someone’s Viganos age without punishing them, then it makes them look really bad. The outside world will not accept that Vigano can harm the Church. They will say, either the man, Vigano is right, or he has dementia, and people should be able to decide for themselves, without the Church playing Big Brother.

Without Vigano the sins of the dark vatican would not be revealed. He is a hero and what he has said is everything Our Lady has said in her approved locutions snd apparitions. As for the reconsecration...who knows, he is not a prelate who acts on impulse...he is a man of great prayer. We must pray for him...He has never had time to dive deep into what was happening until he was not actively doing his duties. All will be revealed When we meet our creator. He has sacrificed his vocation for Truth. Watch Stephen Gardners interview with Mike McCormick...Bidens Stenographer( out today)Truth coming out there too.... We are surrounded by darkness. Maybe he needed to teveal his insight before the upcoming synod. Does he know what the 3rd secret of Fatima? Maybe.

What an abominable way for a church to behave, which preaches tolerance, forgiveness, and loving our enemies. Punishing an elderly gentleman who has dedicated his whole life to the Church, just because he’s recently started to disagree with the pope, is inflexible, intolerant and barbaric. Decent human beings don’t behave like this. A Pope should be able to rise above criticism.

One word - effeminacy. Vatican II is riddled with it as is the world. Saint Padre Pio never celebrated the new mass should he have been ex-communicated too. No because he was far TOO HOLY. Vigano too has holiness.

Robert you are arguing against yourself. If you dont refet to Vugano as Archbishop youre making Viganis own argument.. that he was never an Archbishop.. if it is a valid consecration of Archbishop Vigano it dtands whethet Vugano believes it or not.. and you chosing to stop referring to him as Archbishop confirms Viganos stance

Sorry, I am usually in agreement with your views, on the whole, but I support Archbisop Vigano wholeheartedly on this, he is BRAVE and honest. Pope Francis and "his" Cardinals have done and are continue to do shamefull things, unbecoming of his/their office.

God forgive them for they know not what they are doing. Viva Christus Rex. Have mercy on us and the whole world.

Did Archbisop Vigano say anywhere that Bishop Williamson is a savior? I support Vigano . He is taking the blinders off many who have been blindsided by the institution of the new PROGRESSIVE church. Praise God!

So 260 popes teachings were negated by the last 6? Does Vat II prepare souls for persecution? "And you shall be my Witnesses in Judea, Samaria and to the ends of the earth..." Francis rejects traditional titles. So there were no disciples made in the catholic church up until V2?

I am glad you made it safely home, Robert. I hope your arm injury recovers fast. I have spoken to my former Abbot in Scotland. As an ex Benedictine I am using my contacts in Aberdeen, Econe and Rome to help me discern my own thoughts regarding Archbishop Vigano's excommunication. One thing I do know, Archbishop Vigano IS an Archbishop. He has been consecrated using the episcopal rite of consecration published by Pope Pius XII. It doesn't matter what Archbishop Vigano believes: he IS an Archbishop. ANYONE CONSECRATED AN ARCHBISHOP UNDER THE RITE OF PIUS XII IS VALIDLY CONSECRATED. You are wrong Robert: if you were to ask Archbishop Vigano AT THIS MOMENT if he believes he has received valid episcopal consecration, he would say YES. He has not rejected the grace of the Episcopate. Conditional re consecration doesn't undo an existing valid consecration. The Bull of excommunication doesn't refer to him as an ex Archbishop. He is an Archbishop and he is excommunicated. The Holy Office correctly refer to him as an excommunicated Archbishop. When a Lay Person is Baptized, it places a mark on their soul which can never be erased. Ditto for episcopal consecration. Along with my two Sisters, I was brought up attending the SSPX from day one. By the time my older Sister was born, my parents rejected the NO and went with the TLM. My younger Sister was confirmed by Archbishop Lefebvre in 1989 when he was on one of his regular visits. Note, this was a year AFTER he had been excommunicated. We still called him Archbishop Lefebvre NOT Monsieur Lefebvre. He was consecrated Archbishop of Dakar in the rite of Pius XII. This left an indelible Mark on his Soul. It wasn't erased when JPII excommunicated him. Similarly, Archbishop Vigano has such a permanent marker of consecration on his Soul. When I, along with some members of my family were excommunicated for attending the 1988 Econe SSPX episcopal consecrations, we appealed. A man by the name of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, rescinded our excommunication. I didn't have to be re baptized or re confirmed !!!!!!!!! If Archbishop Vigano is ever reconciled with the Holy See and his excommunication rescinded, he will not have to undergo Baptism, Holy Orders etc.

Where is the proof about Vigano and the alleged consecration .... ? My understanding is that Fr. Chazal made an off the cuff comment about Abp Vigano doing "something about his consecration" ...How do we know that is even accurate ?

You should take this down. You have no idea what you are saying

Straining at gnats Robert?

And Fr. James Martin is and always will be in good standing. Blasphemous artwork continues to be randomly displayed. Maybe the excommunication is warranted, but, the Church is crazy.

Unless you’ve actual proof to produce of his reconsecration rather than conjecture, it’s calumny to say that he was.

Can't disagree. Vigano's sollution is not the correct one, but I and the rest of Catholic Faithful await a solution that deals substantively with the corruption that afflicts the Church. The passive acquiescence of the remaining good bishops and Cardinals cannot be excused.

I have just read the Italian version of the Bull of excommunication. Three reasons are adduced for the Archbishop's excommunication. None of them refer to re consecration or conditional re consecration by Bishop Williamson. I don't understand Robert why you are so strongly focused on the reconsecration issue. It isn't one of the three reasons cited by the Holy Office which led to His Excellency being excommunicated. It is more urgent for me not being too familiar with His Excellency, to gain a detailed understanding of what led to the Holy Office adducing the three reasons they did for the excommunication.

What he believes regarding the validity of his Novus ordo episcopal consecration is irrelevant. We call him Archbishop because *he is* a validly ordained bishop of the Catholic Church who happens to now be in schism. We should pray for him as he’s old and his mental health has been in decline for many years now. The rot and corruption in the church clearly cracked his mental stability. Imagine dedicating your life to something and having people within your profession actively working to demolish that in front of you

excommunicated from the sons of satan... count me in...

And The Truth will set us free!!! To those who have eye see!!! To those who have ears here!!! PRAY PRAY PRAY!!! Our Lady Queen of Peace pray for us!!! God bless you my friend!!!❤JMJ+

I’ve credibly heard his re-consecration was never a thing - didn’t happen, just rumor.

"Cuando Pedro vino a Antioquía, yo me enfrenté a él cara a cara y le reprendí. Pues antes de que viniesen algunos de parte de Santiago, él comía con los paganos; pero cuando vinieron, se retrajo y se apartó por miedo a los judíos" - San Pablo en Gálatas 2,11-12 El arzobispo Carlo Maria Viganò está actuando similar a San Pablo, no igual, sino similar. La diferencia es que hoy se ha dado el cara a cara, ni se dará, entre ambos obispos, Vigano y Bergoglio.

Why attack his character? You can disagree with ARCHBISHOP Vigano all you want but you attacking his character says everything about YOU in this situation. Saying he’s possessed by demons? 🤣 There are legit demonic forces at work in the Vatican right now and Vigano isn’t it! It’s taken courage to do what’s he’s doing and never waiver an inch - good for him! Vigano raises valid concerns about the Pope. Period! I stand with Archbishop Vigano 💯 God bless him.

The human institution of the Church is proceeding to entombment. As Christ traveled the Via Dolorosa on His way to Golgotha, the Human institution known as the Roman Catholic church.Will go through the same scourging. All this is occurring under the permissive will of God. In the end, we will see the triumph of Our Lady's Immaculate Heart. Be at peace. Stay in a state of grace wesr your scapular.And pray the rosary daily.

I saw you at the ordination today!I saw someone with what appeared to be Free Masonary tattoos I don't know it I'm over reacting but should I have told someone?

I ask you to please pray for the healing of the wound between Ireland and England. And please pray for the sainthood of beloved Margaret Pole.

I don’t support everything he does or says but I support him over the imposter on the Papal Throne.

Thank you for your insight. The Synod is more than infuriating. It feeds no one with the spirit of Christ.

If à priest doesn't believe his Sacrament is not valid, isn't it still so? Many Catholics don't believe in the true presence...that doesn't make Christ not present. Vigano can err, but he has still been Archbishop, Robert

You are SO Absolutely WRONG, Robert!!! WRONG, wrong, WRONG!! 😢

Try to see the cause of things. This is what is rooted in Francis and he love it too much. Francis has sowed the seed of division and disunity. Vigano is never excommunicated or a schismatic. All are false. Vigano took the bull by the horn. If excommunication, it should start with Francis and all the German bishops and all the bad eggs and demons in cassock. A thousand of those in cassock are afraid. Many good bishops never believe in what is coming out from Rome and they're just silent. Vigano is NEVER excommunicated. It's a lie, the bishops you mentioned might be in great support in secret. The situation at the moment seem extremely tricky and risky. Only sincere prayer and penance is Our last resort. Anyone who sees vigano as excommunicated is never a Catholic. He/She must have been caught in the net of these demons in cassock. Ave Maria!

The argument that Archbishop Viganò was reconsecrated seems to be not solid. The fact that he has not denied the rumors does not prove their validity.

Our Church is in crisis! However, Jesus is the Boss! Pray hope and don't worry!

The time for Ireland to return to Orthodoxy is coming

There is a profound question as to whether post-Vatican II ordinations are valid; so too with the Novus Ordo. We just cannot be sure, but surely the quickening pace of atrocities out of the Vatican make the questions ever more burning and complicated.

Thanks so much for showing the way that Vigano got lost along the way. He needs prayer. The light on this has cleared all my confusion.

How is he ex archbishop?

Didn’t know that. Wow 😮 keep praying 🙏

Who is your source regarding Archbishop Vigano's re-Consecration? Is it reliable? Does Archbishop Vigano know of this accusation so that he can respond? 🙏

What are we supposed to do when the anti Christ seats in St. Peter's Chair? What if no bishop denounces him? But if one denounces him, shall we disregard his voice? And if the anti Christ calls him to Rome to face excomunion, shall we lower our heads in submission? "Better for us to obey God rather than any human authority!" (Saint Peter in Acts 5,29) "When later Cephas [Peter] came to Antioch, I CONFRONTED HIM SINCE HE DESERVED TO BE BLAMED. Before some of James' people arrived, he used to eat with non-Jewish people. But when they arrived, he withdrew and did not mingle anymore with them, for fear of the Jewish group." (St. Paul in Galatians 2,11-12)

If every Bishop acted like Archbishop Vigano then there would finally be unity and they could clean up this mess !!

I agree with the possession part. There are so many falling away :( so sad . We have to pray for our présidas and religious

Have you read the Vatican report on McCarrick re: Vigano?

Thank you for clearing the confusion on Vigano. I would love to hear what you think of Mgr.Roux of France he is also pré-VC2 and performs the TLM, but his words sound very legit too. ( his channel is on KZfaq )

Bishop Williamson is awesome. You'd have no confusion if he was preaching Christ from St. Peters.

He may know something we do don't.

The Answer is Also Our Lady Appearing in Medjugorje🌹,and Her 5 Stones for each of us to Beat the Goliath in our lives,God Has Granted this Time of Grace,also Praying the Divine Mercy Chaplet at 3pm🙏🌍🙏🕊️Each day,YES the Synod is NONSENSE 🙏🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️

Is Vigano’s “reconsecration” by Williamson in evidence?

I stayed for some months at the seminary in winona mn sspx (thomas Aquinas) - it was a very positive experience for me, and at the time, i marveled at the obvious intelligence and self discipline of Bishop Williamson and i spoke to him many times during my stay. My heart broke and keeps breaking when i hear news of bishop Williamson and the stances he has taken after, say 1996-ish. If vigano was convinced by Williamson that his consecration was invalid, that makes me sad. More and more we need to back away and say Jesus i trust in you.. i wish i could say something more insightful or profound but there just isnt anything besides sit on yiur helmet and pray

"We can fall off one side or the other side" - wise words. We need to be careful not to split ourselves off from the church, on EITHER side. Left or Right. Progressive or Traditionalist.

God bless you Mr. Nugent, you are the wisest, and most common sense person that I follow. Keep the faith. Again, God bless you.

Love your clarity

If a dark cloud is over head how do you expect to see the light

God Bless ArchBishop Vigano a Man of great truth and courage

9:44 I don't think it is fair to say that Vigano 'never believed he was an Archbishop'. I think he did believe and that he believed in John Paul II also, but he (and the church) has been pushed to such an extreme by the present occupier of the seat of Peter that he has lost faith in the events that led to this situation, including the second Vatican Council.

Anyone, but especially a priest or bishop, who unmasked the pure evil going on in the church would become so angry that he or she would risk becoming unbalanced. Vigano may have PTSD. There are many who appear very angry and confused about the process that began in the 1960s, calling it satanic and denying the validity of the subsequent popes. How can you pray when you are angry? How can you grow in faith when you are dragging other people down with your anger? How does that help the uncatechized and the victims of abuse ? I think the clear teaching of Strickland ,Schneider, Zen and Mueller is the only way to respond. I pray for Vigano to find peace. I agree with you that we should Give them GOD!

if he has been excommunicated, is he still a member of the catholic church?

I don't have a full understanding of this issue, in part, because I separate myself from the intrigue, because I don't think it is healthy for me. But I think there is a lot of wisdom in what you are saying here. We can object to the trajectory of the Catholic Church without throwing the baby out with the bath water. And I think contemplating why we are really here, the Union with God, is the most important thing we should be doing as Catholics.

It didn’t start 2018‼️ It started in 2014 when a false pope was selected. God knows the truth and Bergoglio is the false prophet (or one of them) the Bible talks about. 1. He is false because he is a prophet who promotes Satan, not God (Revelation 13:11). 2. He promotes the worship of Antichrist (Revelation 13:12) “He exercises all the authority of the first beast on his behalf and compels the earth and those who live on it to worship the first beast, whose fatal wound was healed.” (Revelation 13:12, HCSB) 3. He develops a ministry of religious deception (Revelation 13:13) 4. He deceives people to follow Antichrist (Revelation 13:14)“He deceives those who live on the earth because of the signs that he is permitted to perform on behalf of the beast, telling those who live on the earth to make an image of the beast who had the sword wound and yet lived.” (Revelation 13:14, HCSB) 5. He promotes a false gospel of economic salvation and security (Revelation 13:17-18). Bergoglio is the “False Prophet” because he manipulates, persecutes and controls people.

The extreme divisions are coming from the extreme fringes. You can critique, seek understanding, and PRAY. You do not draw huge lines in the sand and condemn Vatican II and every Pope after that Council. You are right . Vigano is not the solution.

This is devastating news imo. I cheered VIGANO on for a long time. I’ll keep praying for him to repent and return to Mother Church. Thank you for sharing this sad news 😰🙏

You can see just by reading the comments how divided the church is, too sad. Take heart Robert, the Lord is close.

Please pray for the UK now that Labour have taken over.

Totally agree with you Robert

Vigano is right.

💡I think he has seen the light now!

PRAY PRAY PRAY FOR THE CATHOLIC CHURCH THE POPE CARDINALS BISHOPS PREISTS AND THE FAITHFUL 🙏🕊️🙏❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Does this mean he will go to hell if he doesn't repent?

I remember a few years before Summorum Pontificum a few priests I knew saying "the Latin Mass is not going to come back." So, I'll keep my hopes up that the Sedia Gestatoria will be brought out of the mothballs and the nonsense stop.

JP2 was worse than Francis bro- ecumenism???

I know that ex-Bp. Williamson is a sedevacantist, so I’m gravely concerned about Abp. Viganò. However, I have questions about this reported reconsecration for which I haven’t yet found answers, so I’m reserving discernment until I get those answers.

Come on, "demonically possessed"? Or maybe it could be his position and behavior changed as his knowledge and wisdom grew

He’s still a bishop. Francis may break off communion with him but he can’t make his ordination go away (either one). Also… whether or not Viganò _believed_ his 1st ordination was valid has no effect on its validity. And it’s quite possible that he had some doubts (not certainty) and therefore decided to get a conditional 2nd ordination. No one’s perfect, but I prefer Viganò to Francis. No one’s talking about ostrich feathers. It’s about doctrine.

Also, I dont know if Vigano is correct or not, but remember, no Bishops supported Thomas More or John Fisher, either, nor indeed LeFebvre.

I’m praying for you 🙏

Agree 98% (2% = Pride, not demonic possession).

Thx. Wow. Consecration by JP2. Exactly. What happens is the scandals got to him. Unable to forgive his superiors for their patience with sinners. Pied piper trying to separate others by invalidating his own ordination....oi. Not the first to jump ship.

Just seeing your video now Robert and I'm sad at your lack of charity 😢