inviting ethnic Armenian to the DW and show him as independent expert must be German way of true ?

Your expert is more Armenian than Pashinyan😂😂😂

That moment when the "expert" was slapped with the statement by Prime Minister of Armenia "no civilian is harmed" 😂

This guy Safarian (he is armenian) talks more like consulate of Armenia than independent researcher 😃

Where is the azeri side of the story? 😂 why everyone talking is Armenian?! Your expert "the independent researcher" is armenian lol

Your expert on South Caucasian Region, Nareg Saferian is Armenian. Why don't you involve also opinion of experts from Azerbaijan? DW news requires a fair and balanced representation of different perspective to provide an objective view of the situation. Relying solely on experts from one country may introduce bias and lead to an incomplete or skewed understanding of the conflict.

Imagine having strangers Army in The Germany? Well that is Armenia doing!

How can Russia help Armenia on this when in Yerevan Pashinian himself had said on several occasions that Nagorno Karabakh is Azerbaijani territory?

Why can we all just live and let live and work together for a better world for our children? We are all members of the same race the Human race.

There is no more fish for fishing to you. So disappointing to Armenian allies ?)

An independent researcher Seferyan!!! An Armenian person, what do you expect him to answer??? wow very independent. Bias as always

How can you call this "expert" independent? Are a joke?

There are old churches there,who is going to protect them,these are innocent people

Prayers 🙏

That's wrong. There is an agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia which was mediated by Russia. After the surrender of Armenian separatists forces in Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan announced that the agreements (including Armenia's recognition of Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan) are already fulfilled and they will recognize Armenia's sovereignty and territory.

Armenia was not part of the negotiations. The negotiations were between the ethnic Armenians in Azerbaijan and Azerbaijan.

Russians are peace keepers only according to there mandate. They can’t enforce peace, Azharbijan must enforce peace and security. When the situation got out of hands proper actions were taken Azharbijan and it’s peaceful now, Russians are still there and doing there job. There are 30 to 40 thousands Armenian citizen in Karabakh Soldiers-and there families Azharbijan Government with Russians are arranging for there fighters return to Armenia.

When DW repeatedly announces "with ethnic armenians", don't forget to add why only they are there.

So, are you suggesting that there should be international involvement for Azerbaijan to return its own territory? Whatever you are smoking .... give me some of that. If there should be international involvement for Armenians to stay safely in Karabakh, then there should be international involvement for Azeris to return to Zangezur and Irevan Khanates. Do you agree to that?

Karabakh was an autonomous oblast with self governance! It’s not a separatist region!

what if one day ethnic minorities in germany become majorities in certain areas for instance in berlin?

This is an independent researcher? Shame on you dw. Such a one sided view of things

International law and Armenia itself have confirmed that Karabakh is the territory of Azerbaijan...and Azerbaijan has restored its sovereignty and constitutional structure according to international law...30 years ago, 700,000 Azerbaijanis were forcibly displaced and lived in unbearable conditions in tents, barracks, wagons.. life was like a boomerang.. you don't die without experiencing what you experienced...In 1992, Armenians committed the Khojaly genocide in this area. 613 Azerbaijanis were killed in one night. Considering what the Armenians did, Azerbaijan behaves very mercifully towards them.

THEY CERTAINLY HAVE RIGHT TO LIVE IN KARABAKH BUT THEY MUST FOLLOW AZERBAIJANI CONSTITUTIONAL LAW, THERE ARE MANY DIFFERENT NATIONS LIVING IN DIFFERENT PART OF AZERBAIJAN WHO ARE AZERBAIJANI CITIZENS INCLUDING 30,000 MORE ARMENIANS WHO HAVE BEEN LIVING IN AZERBAIJAN SINCE 1994.

DW blatantly acts like Armenias moutpiece and they dont even pretend to be objective. Way to go..

The Armenians lived there centuries before the lslamic hordes arrived.

Bringing an activist posting as an analyst... This is not journalism...

Reported invites "independent" researcher on the South-Caucasus and the resercher is armenian origin Nareg Seferian. DWis a joke :D

No other solution other than peace. This is not your annoying neighbor, from which you can move to another building. 2 way exist: This 2 nation can completely kill each other or live together like before 80-90 in peace

Last time i checked Armenia has Russia as it's security Guarantor so....

Where is the Azerbaijani Turkish opinion. Deutsche Welle is too biased in some political issues.

How armenian can be independent researcher on Azerbaijan and Armenian conflict?!

How the guy can be called independent if he is armenian😅

How can DW use ethnic Armenian to comment on this issue. Terrible journalism

Of course.. from spiritual leaders to scientists, to common people, almost everybody understands that the current political method of "leading" the world today is stale. This must change.

Yes it is mostly Armenians, but because Azeri were kicked out from region 30 years ago. No one reporting that! Why?

В рамках военного союза с южной Кореи, Корея в безопасности. С Японией хотят заключить военный союз с Израилем не могу сказать но с ними деловые, партнёрские, демократии.. взаимоотношения и там где конфликт запад выступает за союзника, не продает оружие агрессору , не создаёт хаус. Израилю тотальная поддержка и военном конфликте с тремя государствами. Южна Корея в 48 году перешла под аннексию Сша 🇺🇸 а северная Корея под РФ. Результаты давления или роста это очевидно между разделением Кореи после ВОВ . На мой взгляд запад в своей истории не предавал союзников, оказывал помощь, поддержку, военном союзе между странами может рассмотреть как базу, военного округа в рамках безопасности союзника. И да! возможно рассмотреть о возможности вступить в альянс Нато. В целом кто с Западом в союзе динамику роста вы очевидно видите сами как результат взаимодействия между собой в общих интересах. Удачи.

Karabakh is recognised internationally as part of Azerbaijan. Imagine armenian people in France decide to get independence and form their self-government inside France by force, supported by foreign governments, and then balme French nation on genocide

At last Armenians, who committed genocide of children and women in Hojaly, will be arrested and prosecuted. You channel is biased and unprofessional.

Why WD ask only Armenian and pro Armenians ?. Where the Azerbaijan side ?

at least try to get an impartial observer, this guy might as well work for the Karabakh armenians

Good. Karabakh is Azerbaijani!

DW News really unprofessional, only showing side of armenians and interviewing armenian peopele.

💯

Why don't Azerbaijan finish the military operation? They already committed to this course of action.

Dont Forget that Armenia is how they say Russian Sister,Brother and Mother! They Love Putin and they doing same thing as Putin,ocuping Azerbaijan Country!

Logically artsakh should be part of Armenia, as it is exclusively inhabited by Armenians and was contiguous with Armenia. Crazy how international law rules one way for kosovar independence but another for artsakhs.

Your so called expert Seferian should know, that there isn't a region named arzach😂😂😂😂😂, there is a territory named Azerbaijan

It will only end either when Armenia integrated Arakash into their nation or Azerbaijan takes Nagorno-Karabakh & Southern Armenia (if not all of it).

Why can't Armenians in N-K leave and move to Armenia itself?

How pashinian screwed things up ,

Armenia will prevail

No peace for Europe unfortunately 😢

DW specifically whenever cover topics about Karabakh invites armenian "experts" and of course depicts everything one-sided. It's the same if you were justify russians invading ukraine. And don't tell me these are conflicts are different. It's 100% identical

Peace negotiations? Arménia lost part of territory this shouldn’t happen!

Should join Russia as a state

It is good to see Russia does not take care of issues of other countries same way it does for itself. Russia invaded many neighbours using the phrase saving Russian speaking people in those parts.

DW news can you please visit the Indian Kashmir and show the whole world whats going on there ? would you please ???

😂😂😂 Armenian prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said no direct threat to the civilian population of Nagorno-Karabakh, so do think he is mistaken there 😂😂😂 And now you ALL trying to find something there, good luck yall 😂😂😂

Dancer in the Dark

These days everybody want war to migrate to west 😂

Choose Peace not war. I hope Armenians, will not have to suffer again!

Think about people why would 120 thousand Armenians would want to live in the land that surrounded by 9 million hating Azeris when their dictator aliev spent 20 billion oil money on weapons from Russia Turkey and Israel. It’s their homeland for the last 3thousand years

LOVE AZERBAYCAN 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇦🇿🇦🇿

Dont you have any objective guest except from an armenian diaspora guy who is extremely biased and one-sided what he said about the ongoing problems?? such a shame for you DW

Armenia is a poor country with no natural resources . Azerbaijan is a country with huge oil,reserves backed by Turkey . Who backs Armenia ? The Armenians had better negotiate a good deal and move on unless they want to end up losing time, money and people .Those who don’t want to live in that area can leave and go to Armenia . Unfortunately unless you have lots of resources , money and a strong well trained army with modern equipment , it’s difficult to fight wars especially against opponents who have money and resources . But maybe I’m wrong , let’s see…..

This announcer consistently speaks out of the side of her mouth and can never seem to decide if she wants to smile or sneer. It is impossible to watch her and not feel uneasy, as she visibly wavers between emotions and ends her questions looking dumbly into the camera with her mouth hanging open.

But the cacuses mountains have hold isis nations for a long time and should be rewarded for this defence which protected free will

Just like pro azerbajani spiking

Azerbaijan is not only agressor but alos coward lier. Whatever he committs he denies! If it is sure he does everything right why it doesn't take responsibility for own actions?

This is a biased news.

Ziemlich einseitige Berichterstattung, einen Armenen zu befragen... soll der gut über Azerbaijan reden?!

This guy is pro Armenian. Why he have riight to speak about this conflict. Where he came from?

Russian peacekeepers must be replaced by INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPERS! We, Armenians, pleag INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPERS to protect Karabakh Armenians. Please do not believe those, who try to show that everything is ok in Karabakh.

Absolutely, 100 per cent, they will live normal life like they had before, it is just that the territory is Azerbaijan and they live in Azerbaijan like many other different nations living in Azerbaijan, Tattar, Kurd, Avar, 30,000 Armenians, and Talis. They will have their own school, new hospital, National Health Service, much better pension scheme, high pensions that Armenian government is offering them very minimal, the city will be built all new, updated similar to European standards, Please look at Baku and other Azerbaijan cities, Armenia is NO MATCH to Azerbaijan wealth. Please wait and see, If they cooperate they will have excellent life and Azerbaijan will prove this to the world.

DW is wrong, as always..

Very biased news against Azerbaijan.

Пашинян должен объявить чрезвычайное положение ,установить комендантский час в Ереване, иначе эти враги простых армян колобаранты могут свергнуть власть , Нельзя повторить ошибку Президента Украины Януковича

Lol. It is Azerbaijan not Armenia. You should ask it to Azerbaijan. Respect our borders. Russia and EU have a same tendensy

I've got to say, there is a tremendous sense of entitlement with Armenian foreign policy, the west should be helping us, Russia should be helping us, why are they more special than other ethnic groups? There are numerous examples of ethnic groups being treated very very poorly, the Kurds for instance, who is listening to them?

if civilians being brutalised is not warcrime what is? sanction them!!!

Ну что, ждём санкции к Азербайджану, арест активов, отключение SWIFT. А, не, это же другое... 1000+ армянских семей остались без отцов, сыновей, братьев и друзей. Мерзкий Мир

You are more like an Armenian media, where is the representation from Azerbeycan?? Classic west being two face as usual.

Armenians lost the peaceful solution option keeping Azerbaijan cities until 2020. It seems power is the only solution for Armenians and Minsk group.

Pashian is going down!! 😉

Azeri like to chase armenians out of Nagorno and invite azeri people in Nagorno Karabah

And where is the representative of Azerbaijan in your show? Why the Armenian ethnic cleansing that virtually emptied the land and created Armenian majority mentioned? You need to be even handed in your coverage.

All protesters you see in Yerwen are those whose men are in Karabagh fighting with Azharbijan Army. These fighters are in trouble cause they have lay down there arms and surrounded where they are. The main discussions is for these fighters 😂 what to do and how to. Culprit will be arrested and others bussed and sent back to Armenia.

Десятки тысяч азербайджанцев просят политического убежища в Армении и Украине. В Азербаджане диктатура и голод.

20 millions of Azeris

Armenians shall trust north koreans !

Just another example of Turkic people conquering ancient Armenian land. These conquests and ethnic cleansings have been going on for 100s of years and it will never stop until ALL of Armenia has been incorporated into Turkic nations - or some foreign power is capable and willing to stop them. For over a millennium, Nagorno-Karabakh, where ancient Armenian churches still stand, has been a cherished Armenian homeland. After World War I, there was a proposed independent Armenian state that included Nagorno-Karabakh in the Treaty of Sèvres, but it was never realized due to political factors. During the Soviet era, Nagorno-Karabakh was placed under Azerbaijani authority, by both Lenin and Stalin for their political advantage.

TÜRKİYE ❤ AZERBAYCAN ❤️🇹🇷❤️🇦🇿

✌❤🇦🇲 мира и процветания Армении

at 8:30, the old armenian lady speaking in English was amazing. Pray for armenians

Funny news ))

Armenians have surrendered. A shameful people.

This is the reality: Armenia invaded Karabakh and with strong backing Russia massacred thousands of Azeris in their own territory in the 90s and forced out the rest who were forced to walk with their babies on their hands during the winter. Then Armenia refused any kind international solution to return the land they from Azerbaijan but instead destroyed all the towns and villages since they had no enough people to populate them and they later mined every metre of that land. They know their crime is unforgivable that is why the idea of living under Azeri rule sounds so absurd to them. I think they should give peace a chance and stay but I don’t think it is a bad idea to go to Armenia either because were are talking about 120,000 compared to the 700,000 that Armenia displaced in the 90s who still live in Azerbaijan as internally displaced people in their own country.

That land belongs to Armenians.

Sometimes I am totally confused, we have a situation in Ukraine which is an internationally recognized country and is under the occupation of Russia. Military aid is arriving from all sides to Ukraine to preserve the integrity of its state. I see no difference with Azerbaijan, Nagorno-Karabakh is a territory that is part of Azerbaijan and internationally recognized sovereignty. Can anyone explain what is the difference between Ukraine and Azerbaijan? Either we have consistency or we don't, with such attitudes the world will not find a solution but a continuation of eternal conflict and wars! All emphasis is placed on Armenian civilians, in Ukraine there are also Russian civilians who are in war zones. Can the same principle be applied at least once without double standards? Not to mention where are the Azerbaijani civilians who were expelled from Nagorno-Karabakh? Azerbaijan must also understand that it is not always necessary to use military force but to talk, negotiate and seek a solution. Since I stopped believing what the media reports a long time ago, everyone has a different explanation for the cause of the latest military conflict. Of course caring for Armenians in Azerbaijan is necessary, but I'm sick and tired of hearing that the media gets involved with one-sided support for one side, in this case the Armenian side. There are enough videos of Armenians burning their homes and leaving for Armenia after the conflict in 2020 that gives me the impression of how much hatred there is in a man when he burns his home that he worked hard to build. Pure nonsense! I think that journalism no longer has a sense of existence, I am a middle-aged man and I have heard enough lies and deceptions depending on who is being talked about, you choose who to defend and who to attack in the media. As soon as there is no honor and constancy, cease to exist!