Ваша пгавда, good sire!

Что-же вам сказать , по этому поводу , сударь ?

its because french speak english and french also but russia speak russian its because its english version

@Tristian Declanscammer

@Tristian Declan Guys don’t trust this

Not a movie - BBC tv show called War and Peace from a few years ago. Was brilliant, and launched a fair few careers

But the canon balls blow up at impact, which is unrealistic. Canon balls could only mow down people, not blow up.

@@irov5884 Not really. This series showed both smoothbore cannons firing standard cannonballs through the ranks AND a variety of ordnance used by the French. The "exploding" things are presumably mortar and howitzer shells. The shell that land and fizzles on the ground should be a delayed shell fired by smoothbore cannon. Those vertical "explosions" (no fire, just earth thrown upwards) should be mortars or howitzers. BBC wouldn't spend all that money on correct uniforms made with authentic fabrics, breeds of horses appropriate for Hussars, recreated weapons, cannons, used pyrotechnics to show a bloody cannon recoil just to f**** up with a random explosion.

@@SlavicSpring " _Those vertical "explosions" should be mortars or howitzers_ " Mortars were alsmot not used, it was about like 1 mortar per 100 canons, while on the scene about 90% of the explosions are vertical explosions. And about howitzers, their canonballs never fell vertically but a rounded way. " _BBC wouldn't spend all that money on correct uniforms made with authentic fabrics[...] just to f** up with a random explosion_ " Why they wouldn't ? The 1970 Waterloo movie spent so much money on similar authentic stuff, with dozens of thousands real people and horses, just to fuck up on canon shots and recoil. Their canon had no recoil and all aimed at the sky like WW1 artillery.

@@irov5884 Its expensive to hire stand-ins. Cannonballs rarely been covered by contract.

Those were the Napoleonic tactics of the day and they were the tactics of the day are all militaries of the world that was brutal

A lot of other people have those balls. It’s just you who doesn’t.

We have brains they didn't have, I hope.

@@jonnyzuma6884 u have know idea

@@jonnyzuma6884 i wanted to join marines but couldnt for lack of highschool diploma

It’s Beautiful

@@mapleaviation2 ikr

@K I R I N monke war 1

@@kunbox4053 its real right?

When you press N

Dont worry,it'll all be over by Thanksgiving Pierre.

zaho87 a. Nothing on tv anyway

At least theirs this potato liquor to keep the Grand Armee warm for its winter withdraw.. A little stronger then the wine frenchies r used too.

Meh it should only take a few months 👀

he would have been fine if 1. he didn't push to moscow and probably been fine if 2. he didn't spend an entire week in moscow letting the russians regroup

Imagine getting slaughtered by a platoon of Light Cav, or Hussars because you weren't in formation and wasn't backebup by Battalion(Line) infantrymen. This comment was made by Linear warfare gang.

@K I R I N monke war 1

@@proudfirebrand3946 Imagine getting rekt by lancers This post was made by cossack gang

“Look at how it spiiiiins”

*S H E L L S P E E N*

A French Napoleon war veteran would do the same these men were fearless and most ennemies that faced them either surrendered or ran away.

Tell me you don’t know a thing about War and Peace

@@pyatig "Is this death.."?

@K I R I N War and peace afaik BBC

“Civil war veterans” LMFAO

Marching in such synchronization, only to be mowed down by Cannon balls is definitely a hellish skeptical I couldn't possibly imagine.

I Wish war films were more honest....... but they probably wouldn't make a profit

Why don't they run?

Enis Ektem Because there’s quite a lot of distance between them and cannons. It’d be unwise to run at those cannons since, by the time you reach them, you’ll be tired and exhausted.

@@retardcorpsman Thanks for a logical response. Well, what is the range of the cannons, got an idea?

More like, they didn't have a choice

@@enisektem What run? They could break their information and then got destroyed by cavalry.

I agree, he even made Napoleon lead cavalry charges lol

​@@Tar.oGenerals and monarchs did in fact lead charges, although extremely rare and risky such could boost morale & organization upon ranks as a last resource. Napoleon did it too in his early stages although much later as emperor, specially at Waterloo it still a heated matter of debate. Possibly swinged & slashed the sword on horse a few minutes luckily to a not so lucky foot soldier. Then ran back to the rear! But still unlikely...

@@travelertuber9487 I know they used to, that Napoleon did the past doesn't count as he wasn't an emporer by then.

Yeah, it's shocking they made vastly better battle scenes with 1% of his budget.

A decent Napoleon war movie needs a Stanley Kubrick.

Find soviet movie "war and peace" , its without hollywood special effects, the original one

@@user-ru9np7hu3w ok

This is a tv show. A mini series

@Toby Perris Currently reading the book, it's fantastic!

@Toby Perris I have just reached Part Three so page 821

Yeah, fuck America cans just pack their trash and go home.

Peace is for the women and children ☝🏼

@@MrDinglin2694 not all men are asshole buddy

@@adityapratap3725 agree

@@MrDinglin2694 ..

La versión rusa antigua es simplemente épica .

@@Shinigami4245 es fantástica bela!

Gracias héroe

El problema de esta versión es que toma un poco de la estética de combate de Hollywood enfocado con muchos soldados peleando de forma individual en lugar de enfocarse en muchas formaciones cerradas como la historia dice y la versión del 68 siguió.

Que risa..........yo siempre pregunto eso..... de donde sacaron????

One does not simply sweat in the Russian winter ;)

Sweat becomes ice

One does not simply...Invade Russia...

the rat from your favorite movie only in summer

Freezes in French.

@K I R I N No clue

You mean Moskova battle.

@@nerevarindoril3435 Moskova (river) or Borodino (village) same battle, as Antietam/Sharpsburg (USCW).

@K I R I N monke war 1

@K I R I N You’ve literally asked that question to the comment that’s answered yoy

But, if canonball would acctualy explode, isnt better to lose no one or wait until explode kill around 10 people?

officers usually do it to encourage their men

That was a Grenade. Not a Cannon shot.

@@baine1985 I'd consider it a shell. grenades are thrown by soldiers (except this era funnily enough), shells are shot by howitzers.

Spoken like one who has never been in combat. 🤫

Sweden in 1708 (northern war): Let's invade Russia! To Moscow! Russia: ...

la Grande Armée was the biggest of the world to dominate europe and the world.. President Putin said he had napoleon and de gaulles as his favorite military genius .. hitler was also inspired by napoleon for his wars.... military genius like napoleon to win so many wars are few..; alexander the big, gengis khan, jules cesar,

The genius, of course, just did not know about the words of the Russian prince, so he barely escaped from Russia.

Alexander Nevsky was the first to say "Whoever comes to Russia with a sword will die from the sword"

@@johnlenin830 but the majority of the grande armée died from disease

@@thepny_chasseur_de_tricera5361 What difference does it make? Winter, disease, the resilience and determination of the Russian people. Also, disease was a problem for all armies of this period, not only the french one.

A French specialty hehe

Yh

.

That's why you have corp, divisional and regimental commanders. It's impossible and detrimental for a general to micromanage an army, like we do in Total War series. It would be really cool to see a game about realistic field commander experience of the line tactics time. Instead of glorious cavalry charges and valiant infantry stands in the bird's eye view, you might see an insides of a dirty shack a few miles behind the front. Bedridden by dysentery, near delusional due to the chronic sleep deprivation and stress. Only information about the battle would be distant cannonade and conflicting and confusing messages from couriers, that would arrive always late. And you'd judge the situation mostly by your gut, and your personal knowledge of your commanders' virtues and vices. Of the constant requests for reinforcements some you'd deny, knowing, that this corp commander is overly cautious, and probably reacting to some cossacks, demonstrating on his flanks. And some you'd regard as an immediate call to action, knowing, that this commander is so proud and stubborn, that this request probably means, that your whole flank is already being overrun somewhere over this distant hill. Or behind this forest. Or somewhere over there - you can't really see because of the fires and the smoke. Anyway, you have to make a decision and you have to make it now. And look convincing for everybody to write home about.

That's exactly why they have the Core system and every Core has it's own high Marshall and it's like a small army that has musketeers cavalry and Cannons.

@@KidoKoin it wouldn’t be the most fun thing to play for many but I’d sure like it

Can't lead from the rear old chum.

It looks like shit

Borodino

Hello Lafayette and Rochambeau

I see you egerywhere

Join my regiment the 75th pls

pourquoi?

@@Davout86 chofa

@@fireandblood8142 Oui

A emperor and a general thats actually joined every campaign battle instead of sitting in a throne drinking wine

He was from Corsica, actually

@@odakenji4351 yes a french region in the sourth

@@odakenji4351 Still best ruler the French ever had

@@thepny_chasseur_de_tricera5361 ...

"force his way out' - desperately and frantically running away ...

Count Platov and his cossacks don't share your appraisal of the situation. 😉

World War I trench warfare was this with machine guns.

Russia lost all the batlles against France,and France took many cities including Moscow,. The cold and the fact Russians were hiding was the reason why Napoleon decided to retreat not mentioning starvation & the sickness of Typhus since the french army passed Poland..

@@Majestic8573 poutine is a very dangerous men

@@Majestic8573 absolute shit, just read about the battles of the Russian campagn and see which ones Napoleon's army lost

Perhaps, but then it would have been the French that had to deal with American settlers instead of the Mexicans in the coming years. Either way I imagine it ends up annexed as part of the United States.

Some of the French colonists were killed by Spanish and Native raids.

ppl talk to much

Lol

@@RamonRodriguez-hq7vn they did get their ass handed to them in The Crimean war.

@@11bsavage64 I thought the Crimean war was with Great Britain. That's where the poem, charge of the Light Brigade came from.

@@RamonRodriguez-hq7vn I never said anything about who they were fighting, I said Russian got their behinds handed to the in Crimea. I wasn't implying that France beat them I was merely stating taking Russia is possible.

@@11bsavage64 Oh - OK. Cool 😎.

I am French and seeing French speak English hurts my heart 😂

Vive Napoléon, la batterie de homme sur pur!

Vive la Russie et la France 🇷🇺🤝🇲🇫

@@JesusChrist-wh2gd Hey Jesuis, I didn't know you were French

Go to hell macron!

@@Ludwig_Perpenhente Jesus is every nationality

Actually it's just a big piece of land. Very strong but their size and weather have been a reliable strategy to lean on. Saving it vrs (recently) Sweden, Germany in the early 18th century. 19th century agency Napoleon being able to retreat after Borodino 1: Napoleon lacked cavalry. 2: Napoleon made mistakes being too conservative. Stayed too long jeopardizing supply lines and get obviously looked of retreat against winter and massed troops. Obviously WW1, and WW2 (Soviets lost over 6000000 troops in just one campaign but replaced them due to land long distance Germans had to cover, enemy or no enemy), where they lost any after any DVD the Russians are very tough and always some of Europe's toughest and most dependable to show up though

Well this aged well

Bet you hate them now

Still love 'em now?

Je ne t'envoie plus de canon 🤣🤣

Здравствуй, меня вообще смущает тот факт, зачем Наполеон брал брошенную Москву, когда столица была в Петербурге, и Александр там же находился)))).... Или история ложна))) Hello, I am generally confused by the fact why Napoleon took the abandoned Moscow, when the capital was in St. Petersburg, and Alexander was there)))).... Or is the story false)))

Napoleon was far from an evil conquerer.

@@freewal Inded. Napoleon, tho being an opportunist, still cherished the ideas of the Revolution and wanted to export them. After all, he is the only reason why the majority of countries believe in freedom and democracy nowadays.

на счет Гитлера... Гитлер планировал сделать огромное искусственное озеро, как следует из дневников генерала Франца Хадлера. После полного уничтожения многомиллионного города Гитлер рассчитывал раскрыть шлюзы канала «Москва - Волга», чтобы затопить столицу СССР.... Но Между тем, осенью 1941-го, как и осенью 1812-го, уничтожить город собирались не только захватчики, но и его защитники. Защитники Москвы всерьез были намерены уничтожить город, взорвать метро и затопить город чтобы он не достался фашистам. Время идет, а методы не никогда не меняются, что показывает, что русские никогда позволят врагам получить желаемое. _______ Hitler planned to make a huge artificial lake, as follows from the diaries of General Franz Hadler. After the complete destruction of the multimillion-dollar city, Hitler hoped to open the floodgates of the Moscow-Volga canal in order to flood the capital of the USSR.... But meanwhile, in the autumn of 1941, as in the autumn of 1812, not only the invaders, but also its defenders were going to destroy the city. The defenders of Moscow seriously intended to destroy the city, blow up the subway and flood the city so that the fascists would not get it. Time goes by, and methods never change, which shows that the Russians will never allow the enemies to get what they want.

@K I R I N "War and Peace"

hmmm B&I in rblx?

@@xvesk5364 yes.

@@TheRealFocalors i play that too

@@xvesk5364 I always lead a Marching Band.

Long live the tsar!!!.

@@DimaGrassGamer the tsar was a coward that fled his palace and burnt his lands

@@adrien437 ?

@@adrien437 He was in Saint petersburg.

@@adrien437 The problem is the serfdom isn't abolished until the reign of tsar alexander ii.

И на нашел его)

Pas toute la France ni tous les Français. Le combat a continué ailleurs. La bataille de France est une défaite certes. Mais les Français ont combattu encore et jusqu'en 1945. Monté casino, Alsace, Bertchesgaden, JKoufra, Bir hakeim etc etc... Perdre une bataille n'est pas perdre la guerre ^^

Because that's the most embarrassing moment in the history of France. People love to talk about that

Big talk from somebody who'd be eating sauerkraut and speaking german if it werent for the UK, the US and Russia.

@@ocharni fr

Glory to Holy orthodox Russia

Oui vive la France !!

Actually Napoleons army suufered main losses in summers advance and he began his retreat in October because by that time his army was almost exhausted

As mentioned by Dice Shard, same goes for Wermacht. They lost most of their experienced men before winter.

Keep retreating while scorching the earth until the enemy's supply line is stretched to the extreme. Winter is an added bonus, but the sheer size of Russia is its biggest strength imo, you can't safely supply an army 1000km deep into enemy territory.

@@1ena585 yep. Happened to Napoleon,Hitler all of them

Только столица была в Санкт-Петербурге

Both were defeated by winter

@@seanweston2907 А Карл XXII? А монголы? Тоже зимой? Русские тоже воевали ЗИМОЙ, условия были одинаковые. What about Carl XXII? What about the Mongols? Also in the winter? The Russians also fought in the WINTER, the conditions were the same.

@@seanweston2907 мы не Белые Ходоки и тоже очень мёрзнем зимой. Но дать по башке можем в любое время года. Не веришь? Попробуй.

Meanwhile the Mongols in a bit coughing and chuckling for the 1223, 1237 till 1242 😁😁

@@khaiophirgrad7717 они в в европе куда дошли всем наваляли,а германскому королю башку отрубили и на пике возили как пугало😂😂😂

Let me know if u find out would u lop

BBC mini series War and Peace , this is the battle of Borodino

Yes. It’s a series not a movie, however