Yea I didn't expect it to be perfect but wow, the passenger side is horrible. The newest one I just got is the same brand as the drivers side and it fits great. That's the difference between a "cheap" fender and a "premium" fender.

Jeez. There’s a lot of this in my future I think

Sorry to say bro a lot of aftermarket parts are very not so good better buy a junk vehicle just similar to yours they might be up by here but not that bad