Hello Nick, this is flat-out the best photo critique video I have seen yet! Not only is your analysis spot-on and covers all the important aspects, but you also give awesome editing tips! PLEEEAZZZE, do more of these!

What I’m getting out of these critiques, is the fact that it gets me thinking more critically about the photos that I’ve captured recently and to revisit them again and as not be satisfied with “…well, that’s good enough…” thanks for the motivation Nick!

Yes, please! I love these critiques and seeing the tools and tricks that you use to enhance the submitted photos.

Love your thought process. This is the perfect example of how to do a critique like a professional. Excellent video 👍🏼👍🏼

Hi Nick, it´s always great to hang out with you . Admittedly, I also saw the weaknesses but also the strengths of the pictures fairly quickly, but if only it comes to my own pictures I'm kind of blind, and more sessions of this kind would be great.

Love that very first tip about colour casts. Thanks for this vid!

Great stuff, Nick! I love that not only do you point out issues, but you take the time to show how you'd fix them.

Great critique session - would love to see more of these! The honest feedback together with the suggestions for how to improve the image is a super useful combination. Thanks Nick!

Alberto's shots were amazing! Not that the others' were bad, but this guy is on another level. Great editing tips too, thanks! Hope my shot get's picked next time :)

Fantastic video review and advices. The trick of the adjustments with the curves is masterful. I am very grateful for your comments on my photos. For me it is a true honor and I am very happy. Looking forward to see your next videos. Greetings from Zamora

I love these. You are so constructive and respectful in your criticism. Even if none of these were my images, I found the video really inspiring and helpful to what to look for when I try to compose/edit my own photos.

I absolutely love this, and would love to see you make this a regular series. SOOOO helpful to go through critique exercises. plus I missed the chance to submit and would love to have an opportunity to hear your thoughtful feedback to push me to improve!!! Thanks, Nick. You are real gem.

I love critique videos. I very often go back to my own images afterwards and look at them in a new light with a new eye on how they look and how I can improve next time. These types of videos are so educational not to mention the tips on how to remove things like halos and colour casts as in this one. More please!

I really enjoy these kind of videos. I mostly use Lightroom when I edit my photos, but seeing this makes me wanna spend more time in photoshop. Thank you so much for sharing, Nick. You're one of my favorite photographers and you make photoshop look so easy :D Amazing!

I love these! Getting to see new people's work and learning something new every time. I have a lot of the same critiques of some of my own shots, but didn't know how exactly to fix them before. I always get excited to go edit after watching these. Thanks Nick. you're the man.

Can't wait for the next episode! Great images and great tips Nick!

Great video Nick, please do more! Your perspective and critiques are very educational. However, I think that one of your great strengths is the magic that you can do in post-processing. You have a real skill for maximizing the impact of an image through the subtle sculpting of light, color, and contrast in a very sophisticated manner. For example, your tips about differences in handling foreground vs mid/background shadows and linear gradient in the sky vs a vignette. I am trying to move more of my editing from LR into PS so, I really appreciate seeing how you use PS to affect these changes. The odd repair tips are great as well such as the sharpening halo repair and cloning bright leaves to cover hot spots in the forest. Keep these coming!

Nick, you are the man! Keep up the great work brother; I learn something from you every time I watch one of your videos!

Fantastic tutorial, Nick. Please do more. And kudos to the terrific shots submitted.

Nick - totally agree and would like to see more of these. You do a great job of explaining your thoughts on each image. Your video actually sent me back to check some of my own for color casts. Definitely enjoyed hanging out with you!

I always enjoy watching top photographers critique other photographer's photos. I learn so much frrom this. Cheers.

Great video Nick! I really love this type of content, it really helps everyone trying to improve their editing skills in photoshop (which is so much more powerful than Lightroom) and things to think about when editing a photo. Please make more! 😁❤

Great session, Nick! Would love to see more of these episodes. If only I had the courage to send an image or two!

Thanks Nick. That was a really useful tutorial. Quickly fixing colour casts with a curves layer was quite a revelation to me. I'm looking forward to you critiquing some more of the 300+ images

Packed full of awesome insights, advice, techniques and wrapped up with a honest viewpoint too!! Bravo to all who submitted their shots also !! Well done Mr. P

Love it, more videos of exercising your critical eye would be awesome. Great critique and showing solutions to making some beautiful images even better. Thank you.

Hey Nick, thanks a million for taking the time and analyzing my images! You gave me some great ideas on what to look and why some creative decisions can be too much at times (like the color cast). Thanks again (Mikel from Spain)

Super useful video. So much information that really helps me with my own photography. Amazing Nick, thank you

Im all for these! Loved the little nuggets of knowledge thrown in.

Some fantastic photos! I really enjoy these retouching episodes. I leaned a lot. 👍👍

You're one of my favourites whether it's tutorials like this or out in the environment. I hope you can continue to make these. I have supported you a few times in the past. I hope to see you around here.

Hey Nick, thank you for taking the time to critique my image. Its a huge honor. All your suggestions are really spot on and I find them extremely helpful. I especially love the idea of reducing the complex foreground to create a simpler image. With that in mind, perhaps I will go back some day to take another shot.

I would like to see these as a weekly video. I get a lot of things to improve on my photos from these critiques.

Thank you for taking the time to do critiques! Your way of commenting and adding tips and tricks to repair some of the image issues is awesome!! I would LOVE to see a weekly series but I also know that it takes a lot of time to do these. The fixing blown highlights with foliage was mind blowing for me, I have fought with blown highlights in trees for years and OMG I felt dumb when you fixed that so easily LOL. The neutralizing colorcasts is a method that I have never seen before and will be SO helpful. I am now on my way back to my most recent work to relook at all of them with a better eye. Thank you, this is one of the most informative critiques that I have watched.

wow what a great critique and really helpful for dealing with colour casts. I will definitely be able to apply this to some of my own images. Thanks Nick 👍

Yes please Nick, more critiques. This was so helpful, on really looking plus PS techniques. Brilliant! Thanks.

I've been a photographer for many years but never have done post-processing other than cropping, because I wanted to hone my craft as part of the *experience* of taking a great photo, not how to edit one. But I can definitely see how it can help images I was sad about not being able to "perfectly" capture the lighting, or what-have-you. I've always been intimidated by Photoshop, so I use Lightroom to cull/crop my images, but you definitely make it look easy. Great vid!

Thanks Nick, that was a very informative and interesting video! I always learn something from you and your videos. I had no idea about the curves adjustment layer trick about holding down Alt while clicking on the Auto button. In fact I paused the video, opened up Photoshop and opened up some random shot of mine from the archives and tried it out. A few shots it seemed to do nothing, but on some it made a big difference. Yet another tool in the tool box I can pull out and try from time to time if I need to. Thanks again, Hope you're doing good!

Love the critique on several planes, all of which are noted in prior comments. I vote YES for MORE, and once a week would be a delight!

This critical eye series helps me tremendously. Please continue, it has already changed the way I do my post processing.

That was what I call a real positive critique, was able to apply to my photos 👍 Hope you repeat this

always as nice to see how you look at other people's pictures but above all you take up and show and take up how to make a picture look better. But also which pitfalls to avoid, such as the fact that halos can occur when you sharpen an image a little too hard. So personally, I want to see more videos where you critique other people's photos, it gives me and others knowledge

Brilliant, all very helpful. Looking forward to more of these. Much appreciated Nick.

Definitely hope it becomes a weekly thing! Thanks for that "alt/opt +Auto" trick!

This was really useful content. I love that you combined the critique with the editing advice. I'd love to see more videos like this.

Love this...super helpful! In the workshops I have attended, I always learn the most during the critique sessions :-)

I think the photo in the 6:29 minute is the best. He who took this picture is very creative guy. I want to appriciate him. Nice job. Altrim.

One of my favorite videos of yours. Thanks for this!

Yes, this is very useful. I'd like to see more of this sort of critique. And I particularly appreciate that the suggestions for improvement are generic enough that they can be adopted even if one is not using an Adobe product for editing.

I love it, we miss you Nick. Please give us more of your content.

Love this segment of your channel, very insightful. Thanks

Really enjoy this sort of video Nick and learn so much; please keep doing them!

Love watching these to help develop that eye. Thanks Nick, great stuff

Great video Nick! Very insightful and informative! Definitely would love to see more of these type videos!

Super!! I've always appreciated critiques of images, whether it's mine or another photographer's. I live in a very rural community that is limited in the amount of additional photog's who would be willing, or brave enough, to allow their work to be critiqued. So, I use youtube as a quasi-photo club. Honestly, some of what's being offered tend to put me to sleep(including a few of yours) but I'm wide awake and alert when critiques are given. Your critiques are very informative and impressive, so; DON'T STOP!!

Thank you Nick! I agree with other folks! This was most helpful! Please, PLEASE do this type of content weekly! Thank you as always for being such an incredible inspiration!

This is the best video critique I've watched. I just subscribed to the channel and look forward more of these 🙏🙏🙏

I love this photo critique! I will create an action for your curves layer technique and use it often. Thanks and looking forward to seeing more critiques from you!

Very useful - not just getting the critique, but also learning how to deal with the issues in post-processing. Thanks, Nick!

Hey Nick, loved your input and quick and easy fixes. (but then again, love all of your videos) THANKS!!!!

This was very helpful. I didn't have an image here but I do have many of these issues. This will really help with all your tips to correct the color casts and halos for sure. Thank you so much!!

Definitely helpful Nick - would love to see more of these!

Please keep up videos like this. Really interesting - and it helps a lot to hear other peoples analyze of a photo. Always a lot to learn :)

really really really enjoyed this video, not only were the picture superb but i learned so much. Thank you, looking forward to seeing some more.

Thank you, Nick. This is really helpful. I need this type of input right now. Job well done. Many thanks to those who submitted photos; some beautiful images in the mix.

Thanks Nick, great idea to make it as a weekly videos, I've learn so much from this, and by the way guys you have shoot stunning photos for this photo Critique.

Halos... "They are the devil Bobby Boucher" 😂 Love it. Great video Nick, and awesome images everyone. Beautiful

Wow some really great pics for you guys that submitted...good job. I would LOVE to more of these videos. Learning all kinds of things here.

Once a week review will be awesome. Love this .. thanks Nick

Hi Nick, thanks for this video and for this opportunity, I do think it helps all of us to develop a critical eye and improve our next shots from the beginning down to post processing them, as well as learning few tricks in PS! Thanks again, keep them coming!

love these critiques! Definitely should do more of them!

Please, keep it up, it's a wonderful idea, even though I have not yet sent any images I'm looking forward to doing so at some point. Tks so much Nick, you're one of the very best in the field!

I love watching these videos! I learn so much about how to look for the flaws in my own post-processing.

Wow! Excellent information and tutorial Nick. Would love to see more scenarios - Thank you so much from NZ

Thank you Nick for doing your videos, all of them. I'm always learning something, mostly on photoshop.

I need more of these! It it so helpful in developing my photography and editing skills. Thank you!

Thank You! Always learning something new from your channel. Appreciate you sharing your knowledge.

Thanks for doing this Nick, I got so much out of this video. I would love to see more!

Terrific image reviews. Love these videos. Thank you.

Just watched this and I learned so much. Please consider doing more!

Really helpful video Nick! Immediately incorporated the curves hack to deal with color cast. A definite "sure wish I knew this earlier" moment for me, Thank you

Lots of good tips here, Nick. Thank you!

Super useful, Nick! I did not know about the auto colour correction trick. Nice one!

This was quite good to see some new techniques and perspectives. Keep it up. Some of the photoshop tips alone were helpful. Thanks.

Yes, more! Very interesting and helpful.

I loved it! I hope to see more of this! 👏👏

Nick, This was very informative. I learned a lot from this. Please do more videos like this.

Thanks Nick this was great, informative, fun to watch and useful!

Fabulous stuff Nick. I learned a few new photoshop tricks. The composition thoughts are always helpful. Thank YOU.

Thank you for this! Brilliant tips! Damn I missed this session but hopefully you’ll do another 🙏🏻🤞🏻

Thanks for sharing your knowledge, Nick. Great lesson.

Wealth of knowledge. I didn’t NOT know about the Photoshop Curves embedded option. Thank you Nick. That is super helpful and makes a HUGE difference in photos. Wow!

Hi Nick, love this video, your style and your wisdom...please do more

Yes, more please. Really helpful both for the critique but also the excellent processing tips for fixing /enhancing.

Great review Nick, really thought your insights on these images helps my processing and what to look for. Thanks Rick

I love this type of video Nick. I wish I would have known about it sooner. Maybe next time.

Nick, the photo critique video was awesome! (really anything involving post-processing from you is)

really, really good video and many great practical tips on how to improve images. thank you sir! please do another one when you can as i learnt heaps from this.

This was wonderful. Yes. Please continue to do these.

Really enjoyed this video. Yes please do more. Thank you Nick.