Me to my friend. There's not a week that goes buy I don't listen to tracks from the two albums she sings on. And they felt more real back then ? Just felt like a really great band.

@marklayton5374 yea as good as they are still, there had so many line up changes and also changed lyrical direction, they are really just a different band now

The lyrical writing and composure is why I ultimately prefer the older NW songs, the newer ones well lyrically-speaking, are just like someone switched on AI and let it roll. Not what I got used to, or expected from NW. Bands change artistically, I get that, but I like what I like and when the sun starts to set I accept that and just cherish the memories.

I absolutely agree with you. She really gave it her all on stage.

nobody hated her...I dont remember anyone hating her,everybody just recognized that Tarja was way better singer, nothing personal I believe that she is probably very nice lady its just that not as good singer as Tarja was, her vocalrange is way smaller and her voice is unstable in Live performances also I cant hear her very well Live because music is playing over her voice most of the time but thats just a fact...peope dont say this because they hate her I remember people hating on Tuomas way more than Anette, people were mad at how disrespectful Tuomas was at that time but thats past and Tuomas has recognized that he treated Tarja horribly as well and everything is fine now I just enjoy the music they do today,their recent album is one of the best ones they have released inmy opinion, only album that comes close is "Once" in my opinion

Anette and tarja has they're own great voice,,the different character of voice,so we can't compare it each other

I love Anette. I think she is the most amazing singer ever.

@@HK-gm8pe People mainly hate her because she's vastly different from Tarja which Nightwish army were used to, and her voice is lower. Secondly, both Tarja and Anette are equally good. Anette's voice is full, warm, robust , well projected and focus, her lows are literally the best within the genre, and her highs are piercing. However, she's a lower centered voice, and with female singers, people glorify high voices way more than lower or middle voice, even if the lower of middle voice are stronger. Furthermore, she's overworked with having to sing materials slightly higher for her voice, with Nightwish most notorious tours. Higher parts of songs are the only part she's inconsistent while middle, low and everything else work tremendously well. Put the best singers in her position where they need to sing materials too high or too low with heavy tours with little to no rest, they would crumble. The fact that Anette held on and becoming even stronger over time, showcased her prowess while, other singers would've tapped out or succumbed. In regards to her not heard in videos, you do realize many of Anette's videos are in lower quality, but there are lots of ones with good sound out there if only people search. Never underestimate her, many female metal singers wouldn't match her stamina and support. People love to hate on her because they're ignorant on voice evaluation.

It was Amaranth that gave me a first taste of Nightwish and I am forever always thinking of Annete if I hear Nightwish mentioned, all 3 singers are powerful in their own right, but yes Anette couldn't hit all the ranges the way some of thr Tarja songs could go but Anette is a strong contemporary singer and she still brings a strong aspect to the Nightish Era

+Miss Charlie Brown i totally agree

Well said, i agree...👌😁

She finally found the right tone to sing without straining her voice. And then she gets sick and had to be replaced. But she finally got the right tone to sing this song.

wow bir türk yorumu:)

She was an amateur singer before joining NW....After the DPP tour she got professional singing coach

Annette is good.. the thing is she can’t hit notes as high as tarja or floor… it’s just that her voice isn’t for that..shes more pop than metal.. beautiful voice tho…even on this song u know shes way better singing songs that are softer

@@predatoria_aquaticaactually it sounds like her vocal range is just lower than Tarja or Floor. Most of songs prolly in wrong key for her.

I totally agree, but floor still owns it :D

Floor spits on tarja's and anette's face.. \m/

She mastered it already in her demo tape where she was applying to Nightwish. But sometimes she was too high energy to sing it soft and peaceful, like she does it here. For the demo tape she sings it even softer. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jLmEfbuEp9LKnY0.html

@@jorgekarp a little respect for 2 fantastic singers. You are not NW fan, unfortunately you are Floor's fan. Yep..

@@dreamflight5637 No

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I m dead 🤣🤣🤣

You say that like it's a bad thing

@@exoticmaniac3024 That hat is still giving me nightmares. Her stylist was crazy.

@@filippocumino4344 Honestly, I like the hat thing she had going on. It's up to everyones personal taste, but don't get me wrong. She's had some questionable outfits over the years, but most recently (especially ex-nightwish) she's had way better outfits.

naaa

@@agustinmanyari NIGHTWISH SIN TARJA ES COMO LOS STONES SIN JAGGER, DEJEMONOS DE JODER...........

@@blusero67 banda aburrida

Gollum? Because its the wrong precious? (couldn't help myself :'))

Hihihihihihihihi

***** Laugh .........

HHAHAHAHAAHAH bad joke

Ich finde die beste Version ist von Floor Wacken 2013🤘

😍😍😍😍

She didn't sing the Melody lines, she sang the Harmony part which was a better part for her voice. The Melody is the hardest part to keep up with. The Harmony lines above the Melody and below it are much better and richer for her style of singing. While Marko sings the Melody at the end, it shows how much singing the Harmony parts improve your voice.

@@CavemanJesus4Life The funny thing is, several singers don't even bother to look at the harmony parts that much and they prefer to stick to the melody. Due to many reasons that are honestly irrelevant right now, but a good example are those choir sopranos who stick to that section because they don't want to bother with the whole sight singing thing lol. I really think deciding to sing the harmony parts was a pretty smart choice that made Anette truly shine.

I’m sad to bring the bad news... he just resigned last week.

Damn this comment didn't age well...

Infelizmente saiu :(

you jinxed it....

La perra se fue con Tarja

***** is that the demo/audition she did to get into nightwish? that was good, tho i would to hear her at this stagewith nightwish, she really started lifting her game

You're right. He was soooo out of tune, trying so hard to harmonize with her.

No you're right it's really Marco who sings very wrong on this line of singing and it was on each song ... Anette is a very good singer ... but casting error for Nightwish

The same happenned in Over The Hills and Far Away. A song that Anette should slay but the way that they both sing together at the chorus is a total trainwreck.

Marko is now singing the Melody while Annette now sings the Harmony parts

Yeah. If they were a little nicer to Anette, I think Marko could have conceived the idea to practice with her one on one beforehand on this part..... Or sing a little more softly with fewer words in attempt to harmonize in the background, instead of trying to be seen in the foreground.

For the first 36 seconds I agree. After it she sounds IMHO far to poppy.

Amaranth con Annete is insuperable.

A mí no me gusta floor Jansen. Es buena cantante, pero no marco época, Tarja y Anette si.

Sorry, pero Anette no puede con los altos. Tarja es sinfónica, Floor es rockera y la linda Anette es popera

I just have correct one thing: Her name is Anette.

That's because opera isn't thought of in an English tongue. Tarja and Floor are high sopranos with English as a second or third language. Anette on the other hand, has a story telling voice with a contemporary and feisty feel. And that's something us native English speakers tend to relate to.

Marko at least made his ending harmonize with Tarja despite their differing vocal differences. With his voice, if it's unplanned, it's a hit or miss. He probably noticed Anette struggling in the end and tried to help her, but just complicated it more 😆.

Danilo Carrazco You're right and Scaretale is much better with Anette than with Floor. Anette feels Scaretale and makes a beautiful version.

δε μας χεζεις ρε φιλε λεω εγω?

Concordo plenamente com você, Floor é cheia de "Não me toque" muito diferente de Tarja e Anette!

Ligeia Noire You obviously might like anyone trying to touch your butt, kiss and hug you, while most of the women don't. Personal decision and attitude. Makes you special :)

SuperNecrophobe was reading your comment and then saw your nickname.

13thSign i am talking about social touching, such as handshakes and hugs of course, don't be ridiculous.

Agree!

en wacken 2013 se superó, como bien dices mejoró con el tiempo

I have my own style and don't give a fuck what people think I 'should' be wearing????

Stolen fron captain Bartorelli

True, Anette sings it better