I don’t care what anyone says, from now I’m pronouncing it “edgie” . That subtile note about the feedback top taking only the resolution info from its input cleared away my oldest confusion about how feedback works! Thanks, Noto!

You're english is great, and your tutorials are even better. Well done man! Keep it up, we all appreciate it.

My boss has a saying: to teach is to learn twice. You are probably learning TouchDesigner better than most people by going through the effort of creating these videos.

That chill floating ball thing goes perfectly with your soft accent. I've never even heard of this software before and I'm enjoying these videos.

The level of effort you put into your video’s is incredible. Thankyou

Dude! Your tutorials are fun and very professional. 10/10! Keep doing this!

There's crazy material preparation in this video - everything is so well made! Thanks a lot for supporting the TD community

You're doing a great job! You introduce the concepts in such a simple and clear way with excellent illustration. I watched a long introduction to TouchDesigner workshop but I didn't feel like I fully understood this topic until now.

This was the best explanation of feedback I’ve ever seen. You have a great skill of breaking down complex concepts!

This is the first time for me commenting on a KZfaq video ever. I very appreciate your creative way of doing this tutorials! Haven't seen any well done content recently as your tutorials. Please keep going!

THE BEST TOUCHDESIGNER TUTORIALS! Its like im meditating while I learn, Thank you NOTO!

Absolutely excellent work - fast paced but easy to follow. Can’t wait to play with this now!

This is so well-made, it’s amazing!

I'm learning about touch and your tutorials are helping me a lot! thanks for the great work noto!

Thank you so much! I'm very new to TD and your tutorials are very helpful and inspiring. Keep up with the good work!

I really like your tutorials. I follow each tutorial and I do it myself. I am from China, looking forward to more tutorials, thank you

Don't worry about your English, it is more than understandable. Thx for making the effort to use a foreign language for your tutorials.

Incredibly concise, informative and entertaining tutorial! thank you :))

Thank you so much for the lovely explainer! All the efforts 🙌♥️

your videos are amazingly good!!! thank you for this, i love noto the talking ball

Your tutorials are soooo cool, thanks for making them!

this is an amazing tutorial and explained so clearly. Also, your English is really good! Thank you so much it was so helpful

Really appreciate your work man, keep it up, thanks for providing knowledge to the community

This is so well done! The channels gonna blow up soon!

wow, this left me in huge excitement to learn it. thank you Noto

is this my new favorite channel? yes i think so ☁️

Another illuminating lesson. Thank you!

best tutorials ever! Thank you so much!

oh my. that video is So good!! I really enjoy your work, thank you :))

멋진 설명입니다. 감사합니다.

The Art of making a tutorial! ありがとう

Thank you so much for this video!

BANANA! Thank you for this lovely tutorial~

Your videos are so fun and helpful! I'm just starting out and you explain everything very well ( :

Incredible! Thank you for this 👍

This is a very fine tutorial. I am just starting out and it helped me a lot. Thank you.

This Tutorial is so amazing Noto, thank you!

I love this tutorial so much!!! 💖 I laughed so hard when the footprints changed to a duck hahaha

Благодаря ти за хубавия урок! Да си здрав!

You inspired me!! Amazing videos!! Greetings From Holland :3

Dude this is amazing. Thank you!

awesome explanation!

Love what you do. Please make more tutorials :-)

lovely vid and very well explained thankyou

perfect tutorial. Thank you 😊

awesome video my friend, love the music too

This is great! I like you

te amoooo♥️ gracias!! thank youuuuu.

This is an amazing tutorial - thank you

so good!!!! thank you!

this video was so much fun to watch thnx!

i love your videos!!!!!!!!

damn the way u talk plus the video tutorial is both cute and satisfying

the way you talk in English is so cute....

감사해요 덕분에 이해했어요!!

super clear 🙏

ok cute mascot + korean accent is soooo BMO-core from Adventure Time / 어탐 but really really great tutorials, Noto!

Your videos are pretty good! I learn a lot from them. I can see you have put great effort into your video, even the details. I am actually curious how do you make the talking ball. Would be nice if you can make a video showing how did you make the talking ball with the moving mouth in sync with your video audio :)

감사합니다

This is unreal! Thanks

Thank you, you're pretty damn amazing.

I love you and your content

wtf I've never seen a tutoriel that clear !

Thank you!!

Thank you Noto! Generative art tutorial next please.

another fantastic video! #fandom

thank you, you legend!

This video is amazing!! Also can you do a tutorial on how to make the invisible man's footprint in a feedback loop please ? Thanks !!

You are great!

I thought I knew everything about feedback before this.. BTW Thom Yorke FTW ✊✊

is there any way to make the feedback "blend" together better when something is moving? When I have a circle moving too fast it turns into a bunch of smaller circles instead of a steady tracing of the movement.

Hi! I have a question. I've built a setup with a graphic tablet for drawing. It works like in your tutorial 2:40, but instead of Noise I use graphic tablet input. The problem is that when I draw fast, the line consists of separete circles. Do you have any ideas how to deal with it?

Hmm... I have a question :) For example, with the visual reference of 3:49, which TOPs should I use if I want to do that the feedback only works for a specified number of frames? So if I set level at 100% and a 'window' of 200 frames (then it 'clears' the feedback frames above 200), it will look like a 'snake' with the length of the 'window'. I am pretty sure that there is a way to do that but I just don't know which TOPs use.. 감사합니다 !

2:40 에 끌어다가 놓으면 적용이 안되고 오류가 뜨는데 혹시 어떻게 드래그 해서 붙여넣기 된건지 알려주실 수 있나요, 그리고 chop 뭐 이런 옵션도 안떠요

Is there any way of exporting feedback animations as geometry?

Sry if this is a complete noob question but which parameters on the noise top do you modulate to get it moving/changing and how? At the start you used noise chops for the movement of the circle and now some commands?

Amazing tutorial! Soooo are we going to get a tutorial for the animation we see at 43-46 seconds?? 👀👀

Feedback runs at FPS rate. Is there any way to slow it down though? Cache on the connections between feedback and composite or something?

How did you do the thing where you applied the noise to the circle's position with your mouse?

I LOVE U

Thanks1 What the song on background?

Can you tell me how the noise was made before the feedback call at 5:45?

HI im newww, may i know what is the functon of NULL?

Sweet😋

Wonderful videos! Since you want to learn; "grammar" is spelled "grammar," not "grammer." Don't feel bad; it's a common mistake, ❄

❤️

2:00 "like this" mind blown

Could you please tell a little bit more about how you did the audio spectrum circle in 7:45? It's really interesting, and I already have the vertical audio spectrum that you showed just before the circular one. It would be great to know how you've applied the spectrum to a circular shape and how it reveals little by little. Thank you very much for your tutorials :)

💞

omg YOU ARE SO CUTE!!!!

Generative art. yayyyy

YAAAAAAA

The goat cloud.

Yeah Generative~~

Hi, at 8:41 there is a room with a kind of tunnel. Can you explain how its done? thank you. Love your tutorials.

It's a tutorial for the effect of the 8:26? I really need To learn how to make that... Looks like a Lot of fun :)

DH 파이팅

@4:46 greatly approve

Hi, I find your tutorial very helpful. I just started to learn TouchDesigner and want to create sth myself one day. May I know where can I find the whole basic tutorial for TouchDesigner? THX

when i link noise to the circle,right in the beginning, i am getting error message: float argument must be string or number, not noise.what am i doing wrong?