Eddie, I love your videos and always look for new content. Loved this series you talk complete sense unlike all the younguns trying to be like you n them yankee clickbait vids grrrr! Here's looking at a rebuilt hopefully in my/our lifetimes! As a side note and as a fella geordie (sandancer) The way you put yourself across as a geordie is brilliant! well spoken, intelligent, vocally and gramatically impeccable! It's awesome to see n hear a true geordie doing so well, keep it up mate

I'm not a Newcastle supporter, I'm a Chelsea supporter, but I am old enough to remember Bob Moncur and Wyn Davies playing for them. I have always had an interest in the great historic clubs, Newcastle, Wolves, Sheff Weds, etc. So I regularly watch the uploads. I just wanted to say how interesting and informative they are. I have never visited Newcastle, and since retirement a few years ago ill health has so far ruined my plan to do so. Sadly I doubt I will be around to see the new Stadium, but certainly Newcastle deserves a World class one. I find your uploads really interesting and enjoyable. They are a helpful distraction for me. Obviously they are aimed at Toon fans, but I just wanted to say thank you as a lover of football in general. I think it would be nice to spend a few days in Newcastle and its on the to do list. In any event I hope you get the Stadium you all deserve.

Thanks Eddie for the factual updates, always appreciated and keeping us upto date 👍👍

Great video again Eddie always make lot sense & love how you do research before making the videos

Another good one Eddy, thanks for your insights and hard work

An incredible series of videos that are newsworthy and of a very high standard. Lucky we have you Eddy and some famous journalists are not comparable when work compared. Totally concur with your summary, as well.

Good to see you back Eddy.

Great video Eddy, loved the series. Really looking forward to see what you cover next away from Nufc .

Great research as always I wouldn’t go anywhere else for information on the ground so thanks for the work you do. Very much appreciated

Eddy, I’ve seen so much stadium clickbait on this platform the last couple of weeks. And it’s been doing my head in. Thank you so much for this well constructed piece of content. Puts all the rumours to bed. Excellent delivery and can see how much research has gone into this. Well in. 🤝⚫️⚪️

Great informative series Eddie. Cheers for putting all the time and leg work in with the research to give us a better idea of what the actual crack is. So much of the stuff that comes out elsewhere seems to be heresay that is repeated so many times that it becomes valid somehow. It's nice to hear some proper well researched info.

eddie, again great content,all i will say is, watch this space, and get ready to go [ forward that is ] cheers

Excellent series Eddie. Well researched and very plausible and likely outcome

Good to see you mate enjoy your videos

Top video as always Eddie

As usual great video. Food for thought

A lot of time and effort put into this Eddie. Excellent work and hats off to you.

Great stuff, Eddie. Really informative and insightful, as always.

Class Eddie just watched your Byker wall video as well on the way to work really interesting learning about the city through your videos Keep up the good work mate Big fan

EFC blue here. I get you so much. I really hope you guys get what you want. We have waited years to get our new stadium. It is nearly complete. Yous will win at Bramley Moore one day. Up the Toon! coyb!

Great bit of information, Benton lad joined the Royal Marines aged 16 in 1977 , lived in Plymouth ever since and obviously follow the Toon. Thank you for the great videos and information best regards George Richardson

Best one of all the Relocation/Rebuild series Eddie 🎉

Thanks Eddie for this video series and your research.👍

I found this video through a comment on a The Mag article. Absolutely first class, the best discussion I've seen yet on this subject.

Nice one Eddie, another informative insight, well done mate

As always Eddie an excellent video and many thanks as always for taking the time to actually look into this issue as opposed to simply jumping on the bandwagon of the popular rumours doing the rounds on social media. I follow several Toon vloggers for various reasons, but when I need a balanced and honest view you're the man to come to. Another point I always think is integral as to why we have to stay close to where we are is the sheer amount of money that is spent in the city centre on match days. If Newcastle were forced out to the city outskirts or even beyond the backlash from merchants would be too much for the council.

Good stuff Eddie you've turned into a bit of an inspiration to me mate through this channel and your other one always an enjoyable intresting watch and educational 👍

When Hall and Shepherd were trying to build a new stadium in the 90s the capacity of 55,000 was only for when it opened but it would have eventually gone to 70,000 by filling the corners in so pretty sure 70,000 is still possible now.

Brilliant explanation Eddy. Well done.

Excellent coverage and informed information. Thank you and well done fella. 👍

As an Arsenal fan I would love to see a new stadium for Newcastle United. Their fans are some of the best and will bring a brilliant atmosphere to their new home.

Top video Eddie. Let's see what happens next.

Thank you Eddie!! Love your posts mate 👍💪🌟

Great vid as always👍🏻

Not blowing smoke up your ar*e here Eddie but although I also enjoy many other channels on KZfaq, yours is my No 1 that I go to for your factual honest views. Fully researched and no bulls**t. Love your content and wish you, Helen and the lovely doggos well my friend. 🙏 👍

Great video series mate. Think you're definitely on the mark with your idea. Shame to see the old Cathedral go but we must now look to the future. Onwards and upwards to brighter times

Thanks Eddie very comprehensive as always!

Well Eddy, this is a really good video, and after watching believe that you are spot on. Good to get a well thought out video, with so much detail. This has been a fascinating series of videos. I guess for whatever reason in my head I had been hoping for a new stadium, nearby. But the points you make and reasons make me see that a rebuild is the best option. I had imagined an 80000 new stadium was the best option. But I guess it's making best use of what's there, optimising things and having first class facilities that will serve the cub best.

Fantastic assessment- so well researched as always and totally agree with planting the 🗡️ 👍 I’m absolutely sure that that will be the eventual decision and is indisputably the best solution without doubt. Yes, its not going to happen anytime soon but it will be worth waiting for and secure a great future and new heritage/ legacy for the club, fans and city. Thank you Eddie!👏

I love watching your videos Eddie keep up the good work 👍

Thanks Eddy. I always enjoy hearing your educated perspective.

Great video. Thank you.

Whether your ideas turn out to be right or wrong many thanks for presenting them. It’s been an interesting series and I appreciate the work you’ve done to present these videos.. #HTL

Great video Eddie! I've followed NUFC for nearly 60 years, from standing in the Popular Side with my Dad up to the present day. For me, SJP is NUFC and long may be so!

Think you’re absolutely spot on, great factual video too 👍🏻

From a fan of another club, that was a very interesting video. I always thought that you’d bring up the four stands to the same height (which would look amazing having been to St James’ in the away end myself), but never realised that those buildings needing to be knocked down were listed. Good work sir 👍

Another well thought out and considered report. You’re absolutely correct on the current state of SJP regarding the concourses and facilities, in the case of the East stand they hark back to the 70’s. The stadium is lopsided and showing its age, I would love something like the Mercedes Benz stadium, how we achieve that is another matter.

Class and very informative thank you

Way to go lad, wow going to take years but when it's done I'm sure it's going to be a belter 😮

Another class video Eddy difficult decisions ahead mate

thanks for all the information, good show

Great video Eddie. Nice to see you yesterday.

Brilliant video, agree completely. Finally someone talking sense!

I’m a Leicester fan always love going to Newcastle away. All the pubs near the ground I do actually love the design of the ground and the old school modern design of it. Really enjoy watching this video mate 👍. Newcastle is a great city would love to live in Newcastle one day

Thanks for this, well set out and you're probably right. Nothing will be done for 4 years, and then it'll take 4 years to build the thing and start playing there, so I'm not going to worry too much about it now!

Cheers Eddie outstanding information as usual

Superb research, thank you , I hope it gets built.

Thank you Eddie.

Great work Eddie, I totally agree a rebuild is without doubt the best option, but won’t be without some pain while being built. But a rebuild might not take so long bearing in mind the foundations are already in place

Great video Eddie 👌🏻

Fascinating andcwell researched piece

world class stadium this, world class facilities that i think your videos are world class mate i could watch them for hours and hours 🤜

That's a brilliant informative video most likely the only option TBH to improve that capacity and quality of st James park eddy 👍👍👍

That's a very interesting theory, it's starting to look like we are going to stay where we are, despite most fans that I've seen anecdotally on social media seeming to come around to the idea of a new one. Given all of the facts you've presented, this would seem to be a strong option. We already have the land. The question is how do you build it. I'd guess it would be done in stages, much like in fact the original redevelopment from 1992-2001. Good video Eddie, enjoyed it!

Great video Eddy!

Thanks Eddie for great and informative video.

Love all your vids eddy

That's beautiful. I didn't know there was a lovely green park next to St James. I've not been to Newcastle but you don't want to ruin that. Hope you expand St James. Newcastle finally a top club again.

Cracking series of videos well presented and researched answers a lot of the questions people talk about in pubs n clubs. Should have moved it over the road When the S&N brewery went . 😊

Love your content Eddie, helps the hours go by at sea also :)

Great information Eddie.

Great video Eddie! 👍 top content

The optimise v maximize capacity part of the video was very well explained by you Eddie 👍I do think whatever happens in the future regarding the stadium they are interesting times ahead for the Newcastle supporters.

Love it Eddie. Great series. The “Giant Yorkshire Pudding” gets my vote🤣.

Top fella. I really hope St James Park is rebuilt. One of my best memories going there as a young buck!

Fantastic video great insight into a move or development

As Everton fan I came across your video .. Which I found to be informative and well thought out .. I only wished our new stadium had a least 55,000 capacity instead of 52, 888 ( pass why it has been set at this capacity) .. But it can increase to 62,000 with standing if the Government approve standing again in English football .. Anyway thanks for video and I'm sure you Newcastle fans can't wait to see what the plans are for St James' Park ..

Excellent work Eddie 🤛

Very interesting and well-researched video. I'm totally with you on the Leazes Terrace, to even think about moving that beautiful structure is madness. Apparently the interiors are just as impressive. A football stadium is just steel and concrete, knock it down and shift it a thirty yards.

I do have to correct you about the Grade 1 Listed building. After the Winsor Castle Fire multiple Grade 1 building of the same period were deconstructed to provide building materials for the reconstruction. More than half a dozen period correct coach houses across the North West and Cumbria were taken apart brick and slate by brick and slate and went to the Winsor project. However, this is a pedantic point as it has no baring on our need to expand SJP. Just wanted to be accurate. Great work all the same Eddie, keep up the great work. I whole heartedly agree with your conclusions. Best wishes for your future success mate

Great series Eddie.

Great info. Thanks, Eddy.

What a great and considered video. I’m a proper stadium geek especially after my beloved Spurs did the necessary and currently watching and hoping my local at Luton break ground at Power Court. It is about that sweet spot with capacity and bringing in revenue. I’ve never been to SJP but there is a vibe on the 21st century fan experience vs what I first visited at the old WHL and the stench of the urinals in the bastardised Shelf. Taking my sons to their first match at the Lane next week so I’ll be intrigued to gauge their experience especially as they’ve visited The Kenny a couple of times (and that’s as old school as you can get)

I really do hope your right they knock it down and then rebuild,it would be fantastic

Excellent video and I’m 100% sure you are correct Eddy. I’ve been saying for a long time that this would be the preferred and only option

Very Interesting and a good summary. It's where do we play while a new stadium is built.

Only thing I have seen or heard that makes any sense! 👍

Great research. Saved the best video to last on this saga. You've got me joining you on that hill

I applaud you Eddie for such a considered assessment. The time you've taken to present rational arguments is there for us all to see. Now,...on your proposition, I love your idea of a new stadium being modeled on a Yorkshire pudding,...being a fan of that delicacy it would appeal to me. Nevertheless, I believe simplicity of solution/outcome will most likely be the priority for NUFC;...probably around the 70-75k capacity mark; because that will be the most economical. I also wonder if the news that the Halls of Residence on Castle Leazes are being re-built presents an opportunity for a collaboration. So,...based on your wonderful information, I'd paint this picture, a new stadium on Castle Leazes, St James sustained until the new build is complete, then replaced with parkland in front of Leazes terrace. I think this approach brings sooooooooooooo many benefits for all agencies. I also believe Leazes park will be refurbished as part of the new stadium build. We are United PennyXxx

Always brilliant journalism fantastic research hard work just top class videos! Cheers Eddie.

Cracking vid eddie

Excellent Eddy.. Another great presentation. I hope I'm still around to see the phoenix SJP arising..

Well laid out sensible fact based arguments there Eddie. Excellent work.

Well, I dont think you could have made that any clearer! Appreciate the work and research you put in to bring honest and constructive information, even when it's not always good news.

Another great watch now I believe we are staying for a while.CHEERS EDDIE

A brilliant video.

Thanks for the reply

Class video mate.. 100% spot on with everything you say and felt the same myself throughout the paper talk of plans etc. knock down rebuild seems the only option tbh but relocate for a couple of seasons to anywhere near available size we need wouldn’t be possible

Eddy, Once again you have produced a professional and comprehensive series of videos. You research and analyse all aspects and deliver your unbiased, balanced views with aplomb. Keep up the great work and, I am sure, we are all eager to see the next series. Roger NZ

Excellent. I agree 💯