this is one of the only songs where liam HAS TO SING IT

when you are this deep in youtube you just found brilliant things

Liam for the swagger,attitude version. Noel for the chilled banging version. Absolutely Bloody brilliant.

love his style at 2:24 to 2:29

sounds like the demo of the song with noels singing style

Enorme ! Joue seul Noel ! Je ne pensais vraiment pas que sa voix irait aussi bien avec ce genre de titres. Fabuleux.

KING NOEL GALLAGHER!!!! LONG LIVE THE KING!!!

He tried... don't get me wrong Noels a good singer, just hasn't got the power of Liam. Well Liam's voice isn't what it used to be, but you know I mean XD

This is the best thing i've ever heard in my entire life.

It’s not bad, like if you hadn’t heard liams version you’d think it’s an okay song. It’s liams rough edge in the 90s that makes it

Noel the beast !

Oh man, this rendition makes me respect just how much Liam brought to Oasis 10x more. I love Noel but this has none of the raw attitude & swagger only Liam can bring.

Couldn't imagine Noel singing this at all but he done a bloody good job. I think Liam done it better but had Liam never sung it I think Noel's version would still be very well regarded.

They actually did three consecutive nights at the point that December, and Liam sang at the first one.

un vero peccato non poterti incontrare, vivendo tu nei bassifondi...

Liam singing this song irritates me, while Noel makes me love it

o forse perchè Gem Archer (quello 1966 non il bimbo 1983) ha detto che le canzoni sul suo album solista non sono state scritte da Noel... Non una novità...

Tem o espírito de Marc Bolan. T. Rex. puro! Imagina Marc e Noel fazem uma dobradinha nessa música. Seria lendário.

when theres fuckall worth working for!

Yeah I mean Noel is apparently a better singer in terms of technique than Liam, its just that songs of oasis need Liam's vocal

At least he reach those notes

Bluesy angry mank until know I preferred the trex version get it on

dont get me wrong, noel is amazing but this song needs liam's voice !

I have to say that this is almost better than Liam's version

ma che linguaggio usi? chi ti credi di essere, Noel Gallagher? un fan di Noel Gallagher che parla di CLONE?!?!?!

...the only thing that is missing is king Liam.

oh oh chi c'è qua, Mister Napoli Calcio, l'eroe 1983 di internet. Stai seguendo intensamente l'Americano Noel Gallagher? Basta parlare di stesso e della tua spazzatura, tutti già la conoscono

Liam had a throat infection, that's why he wasn't there, and that's why the crowd were shouting for him. Nothing disrespectful about that, they paid their money to see him.

@Sgtpepper212 you must be blinded... this perfectly shows that NOEL needs Liam. Noel wouldn't have made it without him. at the end the people even say: Liam! Liam! Liam!

Is it worth the aggravation To find yourself a job when there's FUCK worth working for lmao I love noel

2:24 is sung much better than Liam

NOEL MADE THE TEXT , OK? MUSIC WITHOUT OASIS DOESNT EXISTS, WE ALL AGRREEEEEEEEEE ON THAT, BUT WITHOUT NOEL THERE IS NO OASIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! EVEN THOU LIAM IS ONE OF THE BEST SINGERS FUCKING EVER, AND NOEL IS ASWELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! EVEN BETTER WHEN IT COMES TO "REAL" SINGING, LIAM USES HIS THROAT TO "CHEAT" SO HE CAN SOUND DIRTY, DRUGLORD AND RUSTY

Wow, what a disrespectful crowd.

Waaaay too heavy for Noel. He should stick to the acoustic stuff!! This song belongs to Liam.

Noel sings like a pint glass collector at a dodgy karaoke night 🇬🇧

LOL

ma come mai hai cancellato Napoli Calcio? ti vergognavi? devi essere orgoglione delle tue idee. il tuo presidente e allenatore complessati che odiano Milano, non puntano più alla Champions?

2:23 aaaaarghhhhhhhhh terrible

Completely agree, but as far as 'stepping in' goes you can't complain. Noel always seems to do a good job covering Liam, apart from a very limp "Go Let It Out" I found a while back.

FACT: Noel doesn't needs Liam

better than Liam lol

he sounds like a drunk man😂😂😂

I love Noel but this is terrible without Liam singing it

His ego its to big. Clearly he can't sing most of Oasis songs Oasis was big cause of Liam's voice