A few more words from Robert Wyatt about this cover : "i should emphasise that your own arrangement of the song for alfie clearly transcends my original, in my opinion, as you may have guessed.. . . .you and your brilliant band- plus, the wonderful video… really moved me.."

La classe internationale, déjà il faut oser se confronter à une telle composition et ensuite être à la fois avec et un peu à coté, respecter l'œuvre et se l'approprier, toutes choses que vous réussissez parfaitement, merci.

nice to hear this wonderful song is not forgotten and performed so brilliantly.

Oh my goodness - I'm speechless. Bravo, bravo, just bravo. 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

Très belle interprétation, je retrouve l'émotion d'origine.

Once walking inside Victoria Station I heared this long-lost melody. It was a cover of Robert Wyatt's jewel sung by some anonymous busker. I stopped in the running crowd and - smiled.

One of the greatest songs Robert Wyatt ever wrote. Although the text makes no sense I deeply understand what Robert wants to say. This song makes shudders running down my back and makes tears flow. I’ve listened to many covers of this song but no one had the magic I thought only Robert can express. But when I first listened to this song from Odeia the magic was there with the first tones of the guitar. And then this fantastic voice which also brings new colours to the song by bringing it to a climax. The solos of the violin adapt themselves exactly to the mood of the song. Thanks to Odeia for this beautiful cover, thanks to Robert for writing this song and for his recognition that he paid these four young musicians

Robert Wyatt's song and album it's from has resided in my head over 50 years. This performance of a song I thought uncoverable is sublime. Bravo e brava, Odeia!

I've been listening to Rock Bottom for 27 years. And - wow! What a truly amazing version! Beautiful musical arrangement and performance! I hope Robert Wyatt sees this video. Thank you, Odeia! :-)

My favourite album, my favourite song from that album and now y favourite version of that song. This is simply extraordinary and perfect. They have posted the man's admiration of there version and frankly there is no higher praise. beautiful and thank you smooch to Odeia for having the vision, talent and skill to deliver such a treasure

I can’t forsqueak this. a stunning adaptation of a classic tearjerker ❤️my larder indeed

À propos de cette vidéo, Robert Wyatt nous a envoyé ce mot qui nous enivre : About this video, Robert Wyatt says : "I am so moved by this . everything about it : a great film for a start . and the variations so interesting ,original but also , exactly understanding the harmonic feel i was after . And then , Elsa ........You : Perfect" Robert

Sublime Vous pouvez mourir en paix !! Avec un tel retour de RW

Magnifique. Bravo.

Very nice rendition of one of my favorite Wyatt songs. Look at the bass! He apparently tuned the bass in a way that he could play the song with only one hand.....

Magnifique reprise d'un titre du plus grand album de tous les temps, Rock Bottom de Robert Wyatt !!

This is true ART. And I highly recommend all the other uploads from this band, as you will get the same quality and depth whatever they do. A true gem.

Beautifully played by the musicians. Beautiful voice. Beautiful girl. Watched and listened with pleasure. Thanks. Greetings from Russia . city Rostov-on-don

One of my all-time favourite songs done beautiful justice ❤

My deep admiration to Odeia & Band. Such a great arrangement. In case anyone is interested, here below are the lyrics to this so beautiful song: ALIFIB Not nit not nit no not Nit nit folly bololey Alifi my larder Alifi my larder I can't forsake you or Forsqueak you Alifi my larder Alifi my larder Confiscate or make you Late you you Alifi my larder Alifi my larder Not nit not nit no not Nit nit folly bololy Burlybunch, the water mole Hellyplop and fingerhole Not a wossit bundy, see? For jangle and bojangle Trip trip Pip pippy pippy pip pip landerim Alifi my larder Alifi my larder

ouaw, je suis un grand adorateur de l'art de Robert Wyatt, et je suis ici profondément touché. Musicien moi-même, flûtiste, je vous félicite et vous remercie pour cette version extraordinaire et inattendue, sensible, tendre et si profonde... Merci

Your interpretation is gorgeous and deep! Thank you for doing his work justice!

Il y a ici davantage de passion que dans la version originale, qui était beaucoup plus "distanciée" (dans l'esthétique de R. Wyatt). Merci de faire vivre cette chanson, que je croyais complètement oubliée.

Fantastic-no other song makes me this emotional. It makes no sense.........but complete sense !!!!

Bravo ! Quand on adore la version originale......et qu'un cover est du même niveau ! Bravo !

What a wonderful cover - opened out the original, which I have always loved. Glad Robert likes it so much too.

Très belle interprétation où la voix n'est qu'un instrument de plus : Bravo Elsa , Bravo aux musiciens pour cette sensibilité à fleur de peau : un plaisir !!

Di solito non amo le cover ma, porcodio, questa è magnifica: temperamento vocale stupendo, chitarrista preciso e caloroso. Arrangiamenti che restituiscono un Alifib soavemente rude, campagnola, verista, da festa di paese. Bravissimi tutti

Voilà ce que devrait être une reprise. Réinvention et respect aussi , étrange alchimie qui ici est parfaite !

Une interprétation toute en finesse de cet intemporel classique de Robert Wyatt. Sobriété et musicalité.Merci pour cette magnifique version.

just so brilliant

Je connaissais déjà cette perle, mais en vous écoutant, les frissons ont été tellement forts que ça m'a presque fait mal. Bravo aussi pour votre courage.

Je suis musicien, flûtiste, et grand fan de Robert Wyatt de longue date. Et je vous félicite, car votre version est absolument magnifique, créative, touchante, sensible, envoûtante et profonde! Merci à vous, j'espère vous entendre jouer en live un prochain jour, certainement un jour heureux.

beautiful . stunning , actually . perhaps the most remarkable extension of this piece imaginable. + beautiful also, the film itself

Olá! Além de dar a curtida de numero 1.000, estou ouvindo essa musica todos os dias há um mês! kkkkk Muito a linda a versão de vocês! Beijos enormes do Brasil!!! Salve Wyatt!!!

Merci à vous quatre pour votre interprétation de ce monument Wyattien! Couleur, esprit, rythme et nostalgie!

Alifib (Rock Bottom) est dans mon Top10 depuis sa sortie. Cette version-ci est de toute beauté.

pas simple de reprendre ce morceau , légendaire .. et pourtant , le résultat est là , superbe !!!

Brought tears to my eyes, so beautiful, such a plaintive song.

Awesome!!

Splendide, suis envoûté, je vous remercie.

Elle m'a rempli d'un nombre incroyable d'émotions cette cover. D'abord, bien sûr, on pense à Robert, son patrimoine culturel, et son pouvoir sur son auditoire. Vos empreintes/identités musicales sont fortes et vastes. Vous vous êtes appropriés ce titre et l'avez élevé vers une autre sphère. On en oublie toute votre virtuosité, tellement l'écoute est bénéfique. Merci à vous, pour votre force d'interprétation, si authentique/humaine. Ivry, n'est pas à l'autre bout du Monde, je suis certain qu'on pourra vous découvrir en vrai, ou un jour, en Lorraine, si vous le voulez bien. Explorez et développez votre voie. Continuez à nous faire voyager. Pour tout ça : M-E-R-C-I.

Les plus belles choses ne gagnent pas toujours à être revisitées. Là, si. On en aime encore plus le “Rock Bottom” de Wyatt, comme un désespoir où Elsa Birgé et ses musiciens auraient trouvé la part d'espoir.

Wow! Bravo!

suonate cantate questa meraviglia mi prendono i brividi dalla prima volta che lo udita dall'album ROCK BOTTOM

Joindre le voir à l'ecoute... Le passé rėcent au présent nostalgique ! Merci Odeia pour cette trés belle reprise... de ce trésor du rock

Wow this is amazing ! This is how a 'cover' should be done.

Outstanding

Brividi!! Grande esecuzione di un capolavoro assoluto

La formidable surprise du jour : cette magnifique (ré)interprétation du sublimissime Alifib. Bravo à tous les quatre !

Splendid piece of both respect and creativity. Bring tears, as the original does.

Beautiful. Tremendous cover.

Splendida versione del capolavoro di Robert Wyatt! Complimenti veri!

superbe!

Beautiful. So moving. ❤

Tout simplement parfait, bordé d'émotions fortes. S'approprier un tel morceau... Chapeau bas !

Excellent, merci !

Magnifique reprise du grand Robert Wyatt.

Brilliant. Hard not to chuckle at the glorious arrangement of this playful piece. Rock Bottom has always been one of my Desert Island Discs!

trop beau l'écouter à nouveau.

Amazing!!! Well done!! ❤️❤️❤️

truly wonderful, inspired

Fantastica&Magnifica interpretazione!!!! 👏👏👏

Very beautiful version! Great vocalist, fine ensemble.

molto bella.bravi ragazzi

bravo pour cette version magnifique

Just...WOW. Merci à vous !

Un cover émouvant et sensible qui respecte tout le génie contenu dans l'original. Bravo et merci pour la mise en ligne.

Merveille... Merci !

Magnifique

I'd long been an admirer of Robert Wyatt. I saw him with Soft Machine. Then there was Matching Mole. So I bought Rock Bottom as soon as it was released. I've listened to thousands of albums since then, but it's always stayed with me. To try to name one's favourite album is an exercise in absurdity, but, if really pushed, I might say Rock Bottom is mine; and Alifib is my favourite track on it. The algorithm threw this up when I was watching some old Hatfield and The North videos. I clicked on the link with a mixture of curiosity and trepidation. It's such an intensely personal song - like Joni Mitchell's A Case Of You - it's hard to believe anyone would be foolhardy enough to attempt to cover it. I watched the video six times in a row, in tears; not just misty-eyed, but with tears running down my cheeks. Not because the song may seem melancholic, especially with the grim hindsight of Robert Wyatt's fall between writing and recording it, but because these four immensely talented young musicians know the song after all this time, they wanted to record it, and they cared enough about it to come up with this beautiful arrangement. From the first notes on the guitar, it's clear this isn't just any old cover. It's hard to imagine the song without Hugh Hopper's glorious bass, let alone Robert Wyatt's singing, but they've managed to bring something new to it while remaining faithful to the original. The instrumental work is wonderful, making every note count. And then there's the singer. I've listened to this song hundreds of times, and I know it by heart. Her phrasing is impeccable. She has a gorgeous voice, and she sings with great simplicity and sincerity; as did Robert Wyatt. I was six years late to the feast, but it's a sumptuous one. My respect, admiration, and gratitude for moving an old man to tears of bittersweet joy.

Waouh …..superbe reprise ! Je suis bluffé

Magnifique chanson très bien interprétée. Bravo !

siete più che mai degni di suonare e cantare le sue canzoni wyatt grande voce odelia

Merci pour votre merveilleuse interprétation. Frissons...

Degno omaggio al grande Roberto Viatti. Splendida versione!!!

wow, magnifique!

Magnifique et si émouvant

Simplement magnifique...

Well done, lovely. Rock Bottom is a masterpiece, woefully unknown!

top class@ Great playing and great vocals.

What a nice surprise, I love it

Fantastic!

I love your voice and your ensemble, but I've just been told to stop looking so happy by I woman I am about to leave. C'est la vie. bless you all.

Beautiful in many ways!

STUNNING!!!!

Bravo! Bulls eye!

Just wonderful !...

Fantastic, thank you

Splendid version!

This was so beautiful.

Simply beautiful

i catched a similar soul with Shannon Wright in this song. Thanks for good music and soul. Greetings

Amazing!!! you have to send it to Robert Wyatt

Fantastici

Beautiful...

...really wondeful rendition of a great song

Merci pour cette soirée à Beaumont le 19/03.

Complimenti, grande omaggio al grande maestro R.W.

Brought tears to my eyes 👍👍👍👍