Remember how we saw Rapunzel for a split second in Frozen 1? She's the Sundrop, and in the Tangled Series, there's also the Moonstone. That's light and dark accounted for.

The Samantha part is a good theory, but I’m almost 100% sure the line he said was improv by Olaf’s voice actor

"Olaf told us who the 6th elemental is" My brain: Olaf didn't even know the sun would melt him, I don't trust anything he says.

There are 5 elements: Earth & Wind, Fire & Water, and Spirit, which binds them all together Everything else can be made from various combinations of those original 5. Lightning = fire + wind Ice = water + wind Light = fire + spirit Dark = water + spirit

I would actually argue that the opposite of ice would be energy, in the form or lightning. Here's my reasoning: Fire and water have always been traditional opposites Earth and air are in a similiar boat (one in the sky, one on the land) Light and dark is kind of obvious So that leaves ice and lightning. If you inturpret ice to be a sort of halfway point between water and earth (a solid form of a liquid), then by that logic lightning would be a halfway point between fire and air (a burst of heat thats spawned in the air).

it has been basically confirmed that tangled is the same universe as frozen, so Raps and the sundrop and moonstone must be the light/dark elements, right?

Hmm, interesting theory... I wonder if 'Samantha' fell into the same trap as Elsa of going too deep into Ahtohallan, and therefore is still suspended (presumably in a way related to her powers, a little like how Elsa was frozen solid) somehow in the bowels of Ahtohallan? My other idea was perhaps Elsa and Anna's parents weren't looking for a "cure" or answers relating to Elsa's powers - after all, Iduna was part of the Northuldra, she would have known about the legend of the spirits, and would've likely guessed that to be the cause of Elsa's ice abilities. Perhaps there was an older sister, or a relative of Elsa, called Samantha, who went missing after being born with the ability to control lighting etc.?

I would like to know more about Kristoff's family in the third film. I thought it was interesting in the 2nd film when he met someone else who could speak like the reindeers as he does. I was wondering if his family have some kind of connection as in the beginning of the first film, we saw Kristoff as a young boy with the men cutting ice. So be good to explore Kristoff's history also.

Sense Rapunzel has the power of the sun, which counts as a light element and Cassandra had the power of the moon, which counts as a darkness element, I would love to see Frozen 3 and find out if they are the 7th and 8th spirits

2 things to add: The reason why Elsa could tame the water spirit could be because water and ice are two sides of the same coin. She is not able to fully calm it down but since she found her opposite and shared a bound with water, she could give it some relief. And you can see lightning happening in the background of her encounter with the Water spirit. lightning is a energy discharge so there could be a connection there... Could it be trying to call the lightning spirit by summoning a storm?

Ice and fire ( one can put out the other) Dark and light( without one the other can't exist) Air and earth ( one from land, one from sky) Water and lightning ( lightning can go though water) The middle spirit is love cause in the end that's what rescue everyone and tames the other spirits which is represented by anna and elsa.

Honestly, I would think that the 3rd movie is going to focus on one final sister-sister conflict between Elsa and Anna -- specifically pertaining to their roles as rulers of their realms. The first movie was about the conflict of their separation. The second was the conflict of their identity. Now, Anna is Queen and her dedication is to her people, while Elsa is the 5th Spirit and her dedication is to the spirits now. It could be possible that each of their roles, much like what happened in Frozen 2 with Agnar and the Northuldra, could come into conflict between competing needs that will require them both to make the choice to fully bring their realms into harmony with one another.

The Fifth Spirit was a bridge between humanity and the magic of nature. This was clearly stated by Honemerren when she first introduced the concept of a Fifth Spirit and repeated by Elsa herself when she pointed out that a bridge has two sides and Idunna had two daughters. When team Elsa first reached the Enchanted Forest, there were exactly four pillars, each with a sigil depicting one of the four elements. For the purpose of the Frozen franchise, there are four elements and a bridge between them and their human friends and no more. When Elsa restored Olaf he asked if putting them in mortal danger was going to be a regular thing and she replied that no, they were done. Some people, myself included, think that she was speaking to the audience as well as Olaf and that the creative team have calling it quits while they're ahead.

A few things that are just weird and wrong in this video + theories: 1. "Smantha" was apparently confiremed to be improvised (not completely sure, but it would also be kinda weird) 2. You first show the elements in a circle that makes sense (except for the swapped fire/energy, don't know where that originates from but I'm pretty sure the four original elements are supposed to be a square?), and then suddenly Elsa is supposed to be Brunis opposite? Bruni is fire, which is the opposite of water, Nokk. Elsa would be the opposite of Energy in the case of 8 elements. 3. Nokk was guarding the glacier that agressively because only "worthy" people are supposed to get through. That's just the way of the water spirit. (I'm pretty sure that was confirmed as well) Nokk was never out of control. If anything, Bruni was the wildest, becasue it caused fire damage, but it was simply nervous and could be calmed by Elsa's cold, just like how Elsa could gain Nokk's trust. Elsa was also able to tame Nokk just as well as Bruni, which we can see in the scene you literally included in this video, when she freezes Nokk. The spirit is calm and at peace and takes her to Arendelle. 4. Just to add onto the Theory of 8 Elements, Sun and Moon would be the Sundrop and Moonstone from Rapunzel (the series), since they were in the beginning of the first film and take part in the same universe. The only one missing would be energy. 5. More theory: If the last one is energy and Elsa is the opposite, her element wouldn't actually be Ice but more of an Anti-Energy sort of thing. Which does make sense, since if you take thermal energy away from something, it gets colder. Though I'm not sure if that adds up with the canon, especially since she doesn't just freeze things in some instances, like making her dress.

Just hit me- Kristoff has a backstory we still have not heard, which seems to include a possible relationship with Northuldra (reindeer life...) and magic (raised by rock trolls). I'd suggest Frozen 3 could include HIS story, the wedding, and their firstborn girl (why not call her Samantha?) with likely powers (why not electricity?) and sent to be raised by her aunt with light/dark critters in Ahtohallan (because as scary as ice is, lightening in the house is even worse).

im pretty sure the "samantha" line was just improv, but heres my theory: elsa was born with her powers/as a spirit because her mother did a noble deed and took her father out of the forest. they were rewarded with elsa's gifts. anna saved the forest by breaking the dam and balancing the wrong her grandfather made towards ther north uldra people, so it is likely that she could be rewarded when her and kristoff get married, and eventually have kids. their firstborn could represent another element, as a gift from the forest for freeing the north uldra people (and arendelle soldiers) from the mist. if we want to roll with all the samantha stuff, the future child could be named samantha and represent an element, most likely energy/electricity. in the first frozen movie, we saw a glimpse of rapunzel attending elsa's coronation. rapunzel could represent light/sun. in the tangled series, we also meet cassandra, who could represent the dark/moon element. this would also balance the scales completely, with all 8 elements present, 4 are more ethereal (giants, gale, nokk, and bruni) and 4 humans (elsa, samantha?, rapunzel, and cassandra)

I noticed in the movie that when we first see the water element she seemed to only appear when we see lightning strike. The lighting strike almost seemed like the thunder/energy element was helping Elsa to see the water element so that Elsa didn't die- this is just my theory so...

I thought Olaf saying "Samantha?" Was improvised. The creators have also said that Anna is the element of Love

@Rumplestintski has a good point, and while reading that it makes me think on an even better theory. Yes, there might just be a 6th spirit, the lightning spirit , making the spirits a mess again, but who has that control over that spirit you may ask? Anna's daughter/son . I feel like after Anna becoming queen, she would like to have a kid because all she went through was alone and without power. And YES it was confirmed that Anna will be pregnant in frozen 3. And also, I searched loads of things after this vid, and one of them is that rapunzel is their couzin ( anna and elsas cousin ) On her dads side so maybe it is possible that rapunzel is the sun/light. Since Anna was hit by Elsa, and Anna carried the baby, the baby will have a power that conects to elsas, leaving the baby with Electricity/lightning, and then there is 1 element left, moon/dark. Who likes this theory?

I love the little salamander, he's so CUTE

I KNEW Olaf was more than just a sidekick, even in the first movie. He's one of the better Disney characters and a good role model, keeping a bright outlook on everything but of course being his innocent little self

If this were all true, it’s revealed in frozen 2 that the “northuldra people are the people of the sun” it’s said right after they sing their song.

I'd say light and Darkness maybe already taken care of in the Tangled movie/ series. After all Frozen and Tangled seem to be settled in the same universe

Actually one of the directors of the movie was named Samantha so when Olaf said Samantha it was a reference to the director Samantha. You can actually see Samantha in the credits

Since arendelle and Corona(from tangled) are in the same world, i think the light/sun drop and the dark/moon stone belongs to repunzel and casandra😱😱 Edit: Wow so many likes😱

We need more Rapunzle and Elsa interactions, that whole part about light being an element just made me think of rapunzle- i mean she’s literally part of the sun cuz her mom ate that flower-

When Olaf says Samantha it was the voice actor wanting to improvise a line or had his own

Elsa almost made Knokk feel lightening when she runs ice through his body. It feels Knokk loved that.

Just a little something I thought up while watching this theory, reading some comments, and using what I remember from the movie. What if the opposites aren't really so much between the elements exactly, and more to do with order and chaos. The main four elements they feature throughout the movie could just be their own thing or a group with Elsa just the one bringing order to them (which I believe is something Honeymaren explains to Elsa and the 5th spirits purpose in a way). Now, it could just be that she happens to have ice powers or it could add to the other element theory. And if the 5th spirit does count as another element then the others could apply in a couple ways. I was originally thinking that if Elsa is what brings them together, or bring order, then maybe there could be another, maybe energy/lightning, that could bring chaos to the four elements. The other option I thought up while writing this, is that maybe energy/lightning might not exist as an actual being and it's really light and dark that are what makes up order and chaos. Whatever the case, this chaos could be what influenced her grandfather to turn on the Northuldra, had a hand in killing her parents, and/or possibly adding to the fear of her powers in the first place all in an attempt to try and stop order. I feel like by the end of the movie she returned everything back to what it was, so I think something will need to come along and try to disrupt that peace... or be so extremely powerful as to take on all the spirits together somehow. Anyway, this is all probably nothing, but one thing I'm wondering now thinking back is, and I don't think is fully explained - was there always a 5th spirit? Or was it all just a prophecy about Elsa? Because in the movie they mention how Anna's scarf/shawl was from one of Northuldra's oldest families and belonged to their mother well before Elsa was even born. And as Honeymaren shows, it indicates there exists a fifth spirit that brings them together. So, was there others that carried the mantle and it just got passed on? Everyone seemed to have no knowledge of anyone possessing magic in the past (Arendellian or Northuldra), but they have shown that altering memories is a thing. Even her own mother didn't know what to do with Elsa and she seemed to have a very close connection with the Air Spirit. The only ones that seemed to know about anyone else possessing magic were the trolls, especially when they asked if Elsa was "Born or cursed" with her powers. Leading me to believe that both have at least happened once before. And the tie-in to Tangled could have something to add. So, maybe this could be a brand new theory or add to my thoughts from before, but the next enemy could be someone/thing else that was either born, or even cursed, with a power like Elsa. Maybe even someone who was the fifth spirit before and had their power taken away for whatever reason... So many possibilities!

As for light and dark, this could mean the sun drop and moonstone in Rapunzel. A crozzover maybe? But the Tangled Adventure series does give the ending as to those two…

Great theory! I never would have figured something like that out

Wow this was an amazing theory!

If the theory holds true then it could potentially fit with Anna being confirmed as the element of love, making her the ninth element. The thing is that would possibly imply a tenth.

The clothes are so well made and detailed that they are a caracteristic apart that add to the animation . 🇧🇷

I love the way you say Arendel

This would be an interesting theory. As a Samantha myself and a lover of horses it would be cool if my name was the one that would balance and calm the water/horse spirit.

Fun fact: the boom you hear after lighting strikes is actually really cool. When lighting strikes the air molecules it hits are brought back to there molecular form. Leaving a small gap in the atmosphere. The thunder is the atmosphere filling the space, like a giant clapping sound. The thunder is louder depending on how large the lighting bolt was. So it’s like the whole world is clapping in a way to keep up from just loosing all our atmosphere and keep us alive.

Gosh Gad who plays Olaf confirmed in an interview that when he said “Samantha” it was completely improvised and the directors liked it so they stuck with it

I litereally laughed when olfa said "Elsa? Anna? Kristof? Spen? Samantha? "AHAHAHAHA" Me:AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA LOL

I feel like the Nokk is supposed to symbolize in it's chaotic mood how the sea is and especially how it was viewed in earlier ages. The sea has regularly been written of as wild and uncontrollable, though some can ride it, none can tame it. The creators also probably took inspiration from kelpies for it's design and kelpies, in some tales, kill/drown people and even eat them. I don't think it's wild and uncontrollable due to a lack of an elemental being, but because that's how the sea is

This is awesome I would think Rapunzel is the sun elements of light. Think about it ?

Sorry to ruin this but in Disney's short film 'myth', it was confirmed that the fifth spirit was humanity, not ice. It would make sense, seeing as the 'compass', which has represented all spirits has the main four (fire, water, earth and air), light, dark, energy and ice bing the smaller points of the compass, while humanity is at the center

I think the 6th element you say will be Anna's first born child like how elsa was a reward/gift for their mother saving their father. Anna helped saved the forest so it make sense that she'd be gifted the same/similar way.

these videos blow my mind I think they're awesome

I thought Rapunzel and Cassandra were light and dark.

There is going to be a Frozen special on Disney+ second annual release called Olaf Presents in this special were Olaf explans all of Disney classic films like he recap the first Frozen film in Frozen 2. That does sound exciting doesn’t it? And I don’t about you but what i’m exciting the most is Olaf singing his cover of Hakuna Matata.

Light- Rapunzel (Tangled) Dark- Eugene (Tangled the Series) it makes sense, Eugene is the lost prince of the Dark Kingdom and and they married each other which kinda looks like balance to me..

I think that Light and Dark are, respectively Rapunzel and Cassandra (and we know as a fact that they shares the same universe as confirmed in Frozen). As for Energy I think is the Trolls, they have strong energy and healing powers

This is totally off topic but I love how they made Nokk a horse. Not only it was extremely convenient for the story (Elsa going to Atohallan) it also matched the Greek myths: in Greek mythology, Poseidon (God of all water bodies, earthquakes, seas and their tempests) created horses out of the sea foam. He is also Pegasus' father. Nokk is a horse and the embodiment of the water spirit and that makes total sense to me. And I have a theory (now in the video's topic). We see in both the river and scarf (idrk what that is called) that there are only five elements, being that one of them was presumed a myth for a long time. I wonder, how is it possible that the Northuldras knew about it before Elsa was born? Shouldn't Seh be immortal? Do the embodiments of the spirits keep changing? If yes, how so? Probably past lives. Joining the Olaf and Samantha thingy I came up with this idea: What if the fifth spirit is something like the Avatar? All the four nature spirits that lived in the forest before frozen have permanent bodies and eternal lifespans, but, the fifth spirit, just like the Avatar, keeps dying and being re-born having the same powers each time, being able to put at ease all other four elements each life. This way Samantha could have actually been the embodiment of a spirit (probably a Northuldra) and she made Olaf too. When she died, he disappeared but since water has memory he was made out of the same water he had been made out in Samantha's lifetime and remembered her, even though subconsciously. If you don't know what I am talking about when I mention the Avatar it is a simple. It's part of a series where there are four element nations: water, earth, fire and air. Each nation has their people and some of those people have the ability to control the element they were born in, those people are named the benders (waterbenders, earthbenders, firebenders and airbenders) the Avatar is a person that keeps being re-born that has the ability to master all four element bending arts. Each lifetime he/she is born in a different nation keeping a certain cycle (water, earth, fire, air). Only the Avatar can keep everyone at peace. Same goes for Elsa. She was the one to master all elements (a little help from Anna ofc but still) and she was born in Arendelle. Samantha might have been born in the forest as a Northuldra and be Elsa's past life. Of my theory is right next life, Elsa will be reborn as a Northuldra again. Who likes the theory? Pls add ideas and porminors in the comments

Light:Rapunzel Dark:Cassandra

Ooooooooooooo nice video this is my first video from you but I like it

"Samantha" was improv by the actor btw and they kept it in the movie But there is a possibility the writers might use that name in the future

The reason. Why I I think Anna is the sun spirit is because her light known hair and her personality, her personality is a strong kind and happy personality she always looks up at the s7n and mostly she’s a sorce of heat and energy the sun also give some off energy so it is possible that Anna is the sun spirit

I guess Rapunzel is the sun spirit 😀 Because of her power

When I first saw the rock giants I LITERALLY shouted in the theater "AYO! Marshmallow's cousin! That you?" and everyone was laughing for some reason-

I want to say that another possible reason NOK isn't always happy with the people and because of this the sea isn't always calm, might also be because of the amount of pollution that people had started then as well. It had crossed my mind when you had brought up the different thoughts and reasons that explained his anger and why so much to it

I didn't even know there's gonna be a frozen 3! This is new news for me

0:46 Oh don't think I missed the Skylander Elemental symbols here... You can't hide that kind of nostalgia from me.

I still remember Olaf saying smantha (my childhood classmate) I laughed so hard lol 😂

I really hope they tend the add all 3 elements not just the 6th because here’s what I don’t get every element has to 1 opposite? The 2 elements 7 and 8 don’t seem to have opposites as 7 and 8 don’t act like opposites they more act the same

1. It was confirmed that Samantha was improvised 2. Gale was very clearly calmed by Elsa pretty sure that rampage during Olaf's song was nowhere near calm and the rock giants were only calm because no one would let them see them 3. not all cultures use 8 elements and 4 happens to be the most common 4. In 8 element wheels the extra 4 elements are usually combinations (ice is in between water and earth because it is seen as a combination of the two) 5. We are clearly shown by a member of the Northuldra an elemental symbol with only 4 elements and the 5th being the center 6. the element wheel used in this video happens to be from a video game weirder things have happened in the past two years but I doubt Frozen's writers are going to use battleon as the basis for their magic system

I'm guessing that we will have another horse character that is light. One for Anna. Also I'm hoping that Hans will come back, but with his brothers this time

some people (like me) put lightning in the category of fire or something and ice with water. Then discluding light and dark from the elements to end up with the main 4

I need to rewatch this, but for me Frozen has always been about how we need balance in all things since we know what it's like to deny your power and then let it consume you now we need a film where the elemental is cut off from her element. If the light spirit went into a cave on the glacier and got lost, because she cut off from the light that would explain why the water spirit would try and keep people away from it, he doesn't want them to get lost. It would also explain why the horse was so wild, it is frantically looking for it's lost elemental.

the samantha theory is quite bs, but everything else sounds legit

You cannot know the dark without the light, and you cannot know the light without the dark!

Daughter Speaking: What if Samantha died and Noc was only trying to protect her soul? It was called "The Dark Sea" for a reason. Perhaps she and he were goofing around while patrolling, making sure everything's okay, then she decides to play with her powers. He, obviously plays along and wraps himself around her, just being playful. Then she zaps the water, and because he, The WATER Horse has wrapped himself around her, connecting her to the water as well, the now Electrified Water has now Electrified her to the point of death. I think Noc's how Elsa was when she accidentally hurt her sister, but worse. But, then again, Samantha is connected to the Lightning, so it's all probably a misunderstanding and Noc just doesn't know it yet. He just misses his spiritual mate.

Fun fact I found a few days ago: at the end of the song “Show Yourself” you can see the deleted seen in “All Is Found” if you look close enough, idk if I explained it well but yea, pretty cool.

Weird question “why is Elsa’s make up not gone when she is under the water ?” 😁

Nokk is based on Nøkken, a shapeshifting water-spirit of Scandinavian folklore. Like the Kelpie, it would try to lure people to the water, where it would drag them under and drown them. It could take the form of a horse, a handsome man playing the violin, or a beautiful woman singing a song.

This blew my mind

They did an interview with Josh Gad and he was goofing off before recording (or so he thought the recording was off) and when they played back and heard it they decided to keep the Samantha bit because it sounded very Olaf.

Rapunzel could be at the element of light because her hair glows and if you tie into the series she also uses the moonstone that makes chaos and destruction

The elements light and dark could be the golden flower in tangled and the moon stone in tangled series. Just saying knowing that rapunzel really was at the time of the coronation.

Im curious to see if there are more elements out there. I watched another video and it said there could possibly be a hunter (elsa's possible love interest) he could be something to do with the animals spirit or something like that.

I think the fifth element and was in the same thing as Whillock attacked outside with a sore thumb funner😊

I feel like Anna is ether the light spirit or the moon spirit

samantha literally means god-

My guess would be that the "Energy" spirit, if it exists, is Elsa and Anna's mother and Frozen 3 will follow her life in the past.

We only missing lightning because of the way rapunzel is sun drop and has the moonstone which she managed to balance and tame. Also u think about it, when rap touched moonstone it gave her, her magical hair back (balancing her again).

I have a feeling I know the dark and the light elements. In the first movie there is a clip where people saw Rapunzel. Rapunzel also has the powers of the sundrop. Later in the Rapunzel show they introduce the moonstone. But that's just a theory.

So I know in some places energy is known as quintessence and is considered most powerful of all 8 elements. Like one lore or whatever you call it energy was quintessence which stood for life force behind all things including the earth itself. But I know there are different versions.

i know its been an year since this theory has been out, but about the light and dark (sun and moon), it is actually described in the tangled movie, as it is now pretty much obvious that tangled is in same universe as frozen and rapunzel was shown in frozen 1, she is the embodiment of sundrop (sun) and its counterpart is the moonstone, which was temporarily held by a character named cassandra is the tangled series, and then it was also told that sundrop and moonstone are both 2 pieces of the same thing, they belonged together until a mysterious event in the heavens caused them to break apart and fall on earth. anyways, the theory on samantha is pretty good, i hope they tell us about that in frozen 3.

Yo I just got a fleeting thought. What if Samantha turns out to be Elsa and Kristoff's daughter. Like they have a baby after a few years and name it Samantha because Olaf liked the name and the little girl is the sixth element in Part 3?

I don't think this is exactly true because I'm German and in the German synchronization Olaf says Hildegard instead of Samantha if I remember correctly. Sooo either Samantha isn't that important or the 6th spirit is going to be named Hildegard in Germany😂 (in case you don't know it's a really old German name so it would be quite odd)

I thought Samantha was one of the producers or one of the workers for the movie (idk what job)? Am I wrong, but the explanation about the spirts were great! If they do, do Frozen 3 that would definitely be a great movie if they do!

nokk at the end of frozen 2 seemed to be fully calmed when elsa called out going for a ride nokk was happy and he liked being turned to ice so elsa kinda fully calmed him down so i hope in frozen 3 i hope the story tell's us more about the spirits.

We've already seen the light and dark elements. They both played heavily in the Rapunzel TV series they weren't people they were objects imbued with the 2 elements power. The sun drop and the moon drop. The sun drop took the form of a flower before it was used to heal the queen and the moon drop came in the form of a gem stone that was hidden away.

Josh Gad literally said in an interview that it was an improvised line that he threw in to be funny.

I am literally watching frozen right now that is so epic

You have made a really good theory about Samantha

I was thinking Bruni would be Knock's opposite or am I looking too hard into things?

Favourited excited frozen 3.

In one of the last scenes shown in this video, Altahallen was showing Elsa the other spirits and after water comes the energy spirit, the energy spirit however, in the split second I was able to glimpse during the video, seems to be taking a form similar to Elsa’s, thus making it seem logical that that’s the 6th element.

Cool. I never knew there were 8 of them.

I think it would be an AMAZING idea, that Ana has 2 kids, an older son and a daughter. Ad the daughter is the 6th spirit, like her aunt, or SAMANTHA (which could be her name lol)

Rivers of ice are called glaciers

Yeah, that Samantha line was just the VA improvising, he did that a lot, especially in the second movie

I liked and subscribed

Well she said Anna isn’t the sixth spirit, but what if the sixth spirit died and transferred the power over to Anna?