I like how the fallen hero’s are like: “Hey, we have power. Let’s create chaos.” And the ancient hero’s are like: “Hey, we have power. Let’s save the world”

Original prologue: In the distant past, *after the chaos of iron & flame subsided.* New trailer: In the distant past, *when the chaos of iron & flame still reigned.* So, one possibility is that there are different kinds of Witches (good & evil) OR something happened to the Witches during the end of the chaos of iron & flame that turned them bad.

Old prologue: Peace of the cookies but bad witches New Prologue: Being nice to cookies and create a world for the cookies to live in peace but many bad cookies abuse their creations

I like how one witch wants to create chaos but one just wants peace and prosperity but failed 😞

The soul jam have their own will and ideals don't they? Like Pure Vanilla's Soul jam defines truth, Hollyberry's defines passion and so on. I wonder if the original holders had different ideals assigned to them, the only thing I can grasp is how Shadow Milk's design is a jester, which contrasts to Truth, they define Foolery and Lies which is completely the opposite of Pure Vanilla's Soul Jam's ideals.

Simple fix: Be the Pure Vessel from Hollow Knight. Then you can't be evil

I imagine that sometimes when Pure Vanilla looks into the mirror,he can see White Lily somewhere within the reflection as just a mere shadow.He’d turn around,thinking she was back but would see nothing.I’d also imagine that White Lily since she's now Dark Enchantress,she roams within the reflection of things,but disappears the moment she’s seen,seeing as Dark Enchantress has taken her over and maybe that’s just her soul roaming around.

Shadow Milk Cookie - Pure Vanilla Cookie Eternal Sugar Cookie - Hollyberry Cookie Mystic Flour Cookie - Dark Cacao Cookie Burning Spice Cookie - Golden Cheese Cookie Silent Salt Cookie - White Lily Cookie

The lore is so different the witches are now evil but they weren't before!? Or are they the good witches?And the most important question is will my data survive!?

I need more lore about the wizards.Imagine witches vs wizards

Witches be like: help my afternoon tea is starting a war 😭😭

My theory is the witches are seperated into two camps, the first camps is the white witches wich is the good witches, in the other side there's the second camp, Black Withches wich is the bad witches and thats why there is a witches that want to make chaos upon the earthbread and the other one want to make peace and harmony upon the earthbread

My theory: Since White Lily Cookie knew cookies were meant to be eaten she became Dark Enchantress Cookie and decided to go to Beast-Yeast and then, she saw the 5 fallen heroes emprisoned. She decides to free them in order to beat the Witches and came back in Earthbread with one only goal: take the Soul Jams. In fact, the fallen heroes manipulated her just to became what they used to be. She then proceeds to take their Soul Jams and fly away. Unfortunately, the journey to Beast-Yeast took too long and the Soul Jams came back to their "owners." Now I answer some questions I might get: How does she knows The Beast-Yeast Continent? White Lily studied at Blueberry Institute and found out about the Beast-Yeast continent. Why "owners"? Since the current Owners of Soul Jams are derived from The fallen heroes' First Soul Jams. Like Pure Vanilla's Soul Jam is from Shadow Milk's Soul Jam, Hollyberry's Soul Jam is from Eternal Sugar's Soul Jam, Dark Cacao's Soul Jam is from Mystic Flour's Soul Jam, Golden Cheese's Soul Jam is from Red Spice's Soul Jam, And White Lily's Soul Jam is from Silent Salt's Soul Jam.

I like how dark enchantress cookie is the narrarator of the original prologuw

0:22 linzer cookie's necklace thingy

THEORY The original prologue is the second phase, the new trailer is the first phase. As said when chaos still reigned AND when chaos has subsided. The first witches were good, wanting to extinguish the flame and chaos into the world. So they made cookies; the first five or The Fallen. The Fallen did their hero stuff, saving worlds, building kingdoms, but one by one they became infected in a way. They became chaotic, tyrants, destroyed everything in their path. They became corrupted and destroyed everything. That’s because they were the first creations, they are bound to have imperfections and some defects. With the witches seeing what their creations have done. They locked them up, of course with leaders being locked up. There are still the people right? The other cookies or the Fallen’s followers. The corrupted things that the ancients fight in the original prologue. You can’t really lock up EVERYONE right? IK, it’s fine be a wild jump but I think the witches ate the others. HERE ME OUT: Now the witches wanted to attempt again making powerful cookies, using the soul jam of the fallen/former five. They made new, powerful cookies, the ancients. And now yada yada, building kingdoms, leading others. But as the original prologue stated, chaos emerged. Which I suspect is the remaining followers of the fallen. The ones that didn’t get eaten. Cmon knowing that your leaders dies, then replaced by new people? That’s got to make them fight the ancients right? A revenge sort of thing. Now with one of the ancients, white lily cookie. She may have become corrupted as well. Because we know she is kind, and gentle. Unlike the other ancients which have strong wills. That’s the problem, SHE IS TOO KIND AND GENTLE. She may have been convinced by the followers of the fallen. Maybe she spoke to them, talked them to stop the fighting. But instead they managed to convince her to join their side. Telling her that the first Five were imprisoned, and the others were eaten. That’s how she knew and came to conclude that cookies were made to be eaten. So she rebelled against the ancients and joined the darkness. Now note the difference of the narrators between the two videos. First was an old female, second was a male. The female narrator may be dark enchantress cookie, painting the witches in a bad light since that’s what she thinks they are. They are gods that made cookies just to be eaten, when in reality. That’s not the case, they HAD to eat them to STOP THE CHAOS. For a clean slate. There are no bad witches, only good ones. Dark Enchantress cookie only makes them look bad. Now dark enchantress cookie, believing that she is right and everybody against her is wrong. Is now on her way to free the fallen or the first five. Pure Vanilla Cookie knows this, because they USED to be classmates, USED to be so close, USED to be the bestest of friends. He knows what white lily cookie is plotting. That’s why it is shown in the new trailer that he is aboard an airship. Trying to beat white lily cookie/dark enchantress cookie to the locations of the first five. Trying to stop the first five from being freed so that the world won’t turn into chaos again. I called the first batch of cookies the: First Five or The Fallen NOTE: I KNOW my theory has a lot of holes, like what about the wizards? but I think it’s pretty plausible seeing what the game showed us lore wise so far. Remember friends, that’s just a theory. A GAME THEORY THANKS FOR READING

I’m excited for (possibly) getting new anicents (the old five), and white Lilly. but of course, if we do not get those cookies, I’ll be happy either way knowing more lore and to their designs! I always get goosebumps while listening to the new trailer.

What we need is some good lore about the Witches.

Omg guyssss I have a theory: what if the witches are actually the gods of the crk uni and they created the 5 beast to control their people(cookies) but those beast got corrupted and the witch had to seal them away and and transer them to the new ancients, but because of that they also got corrupted and started eating cookies, tragically white lily saw them, so maybe the final boss is the witch Or another theory: like the black pearl one, learning what the beast has done to what the witches created they started to hate the cookies and began to eat them, then the soul jams tried to make things right. Thus, finding new owner which is the ancient heroes Idk i just followed the events but maybe there are some plot holes😊

I just noticed, before it said the fallen heroes were evil shadow milk looks different? And then after ir said they were evil shadow milk went back to their jester form. What im saying is i think shadow milk has 2 forms. Like at 1:08 look at shadow milk, dont they look different from the first time we saw them? Like at 1:27 they look different, compare 1:08 and 1:27. Dont they look awfully different? Another way to prove this is by the way the soul jams were put, the first one was on a staff thing, then for the jester one its on their neck or smth. idk why im saying this all lol

Old prologue : real witch voice New prologue : man voice?

Iwant to know that whoever voice acts on the new trailer, is probably gonna be the same va from one of the fallen heroes. Just like how the same voice actor from the old prologue is Dark Enchantress herself.

How am I so early The old one makes the witches look evil while the new one makes them look nice

love how in the old one the witches are pictured as an "evil deity" while the new version picture them as the good one 💀💀

Only one has corrupted this time. What a great improvement 👍

The fact this whole world the cookies live in could just be the witches messy counter they won’t clean

I thought this was a hazbin hotel video comparing the opening for the pilot and the show

This part 2:50 helloo?!! It’s so fire and it’s literally my favorite scene In the whole trailer

What if the new male narrarator is the voice of the Fairy King?

I feel like those 5 Fallen heroes will live again, if gingerbrave and the others go to the continent, it's always possible something bad happens.

wAIT ISNT THE PINK OLD ACIENT LYCHEE DRAGON COOKIE FROM OVEN BREAK?? THE ONE THAT YAWNS AT 1:42 REALLY REMINDS ME OF HER AAAA

I want the chameleon in the title screen to not be in a timeless loop and finally make it to the top

Ok soo its like a, One story And Two narrators thibg? Because we know that the old one was narrated by Enchantress cookie, and we have yet to find out sho narrates the new one, soo maybe they habe diffrent views on the story? Or is it "just" two story's two narrators type of thing?

2:44 holy shi bro I didn’t notice pure vanilla’s soul jam had 3 circle things and a sharp end and the sharp end pointed at white Lilly also btw the other 4 ancient’s soul jam is pointing towards the middle

Im going crazy for the lore 😖

This is pretty crazy lore for a game about cookies.....

I’m pretty sure the original prologue was narrated by Patty McCormack (the English voice of Dark Enchantress Cookie) while the 3rd Anniversary prologue is narrated by some unknown male (presumably the voice actor of one of the upcoming Cookies, most likely Elder Faerie Cookie) Edit: I think I’m right about the new prologue’s narrator! That narrator’s voice sounds just like Elder Faerie Cookie!

by what can be seen the soul jams had a different shape back in the iron and flame era but their wielders got corrupted by the power of the soul jams probably doing the opposite of what the soul jams represent it can be seen by the fact the previous wielder have their soul jams in a opposite position like holyberry soul jam being inverted heart and the current ancient were pretty much capable of resisting the power of the jam and there's white lily cookie who was like the rest of her friends but she saw the horrors that their creators did to poor cookies although is possible there were multiple witches interacting with earthbreadc, and my theory is that the white lily that was with the other ancients was probably a fragment of her conciousness that hid in the soul jam and tried to stop herself from causing pain and suffering in the end all of the soul jams got fragmented so it's possible that DE is going to ask for alliance in beast yest with the previous ancients

Theory: I think the story will end by gingerbrave and his friends maybe holding the soul jams instead of the ancients like think about it gingerbrave and his friends resemble one of the ancients at least personally wise Gingerbrave: Pure Vanilla Wizard: Dark Cacao Chillie Pepper: Golden Cheese Custard III: Hollyberry Strawberry: White Lilly But maybe it remains a possibility

here my theory so narrator said 5 cake create by witches i think there 2 or 3 witches there other where create old ancient so the story 1 witches create cooke for peace while 2 witches create of chaos basiclly 1 witches create sweet cookie 2 witches made evil cookie

I wonder if White Lily Cookie sees the other side of the witches (good) and the wizards.

So for me the new prologue is way before the old ( in the crk timeline)because the old one said after the iron and flame and the new one said during or in

The witch seems nicer aww

Can’t believe that the fallen heroes are evil… They look so kind and loving…. I feel bad for one of the witches. She only had good intentions unlike the others..

is like the earthbread history has been updated.

To be honest I think I’ll always like the old one more,but new one is definitely more smooth and well made

I saw a cafe called chateaw cafe today 😂 lol

Im getting chills and im craving to play this game once again after 2 years

I pieced these theories from multiple different ones. The theory is that these are witnesses. The voice for the old prologue? Dark Enchantress Cookie. She saw them eating cookies, which is why they are depicted as monsters. The voice for the new prologue? The old guardian cookie from beast-yeast. (I forgot his name.) Who saw the witch’s as hero’s because they trapped the beasts. They are the same witch’s, just told from differing perspectives.

My theory is that, the reason the old prologue shows the witches being mean is probably because is being told by Dark Enchantress cookie so it’s from her perspective so she’s telling what she knows and the new one is told by someone else (we don’t know who that someone else is..) but it could be some one from Beast yeast so who knows

I CANT WAITTTT

But how tho isn't white lily cookie make a promise to pitaya dragon to make 5 ancient heroes, and pitaya said in the story that his prime power was 5 of the soul jam and TILTHEND/hollyberry soul jam was just 1 of them. Im really confuse pls explain to me is the story change or it's just me that didn't read the story right.

Current Ancient:🥰🙏🎉🩵❤️🖤 💛💚💐 Old ancient:😱☠️💔💔💔💔💔👁️👄👁️💀⚔️🗡️🔪

2:03 2:04 i heard it as "guardian's of peace have rizz"

I have a feeling that that's the same witch but the fallen ancient changed the witch, wanting have peace but failed, turning into wanting to eat the cookies

2:35 - 2:40 the way all the soulstones changed colors except for pure vanilla's (shadow milk's) making me think about why? and maybe more lore?? because thats suspicious...

Maybe what happened to white lily cookie (transform into dark enchantress cookie), had happened before to the corupted heroes?

This is quite interesting

had no clue what this was when it got suggested to me-then i realized this was COOKIE RUN

The new lore just made me a question, how many continents in Earth bread?

I think the very last battle in this game should be the ancient heroes vs the fallen heroes

there always be conflict in many generations to come

The first cookies : hey guys, y’all wanna go create chaos? Cookie one : yea let’s do it why not First cookie: OK time to murder Five quadrillion years later The second cookies : let’s use this for good

I noticed that pure vanilla’s beastras still had the two separate eye colours, maybe it has something to do with the soul jam?

I am guessing the old trailer was went the witches started to become evil by eating cookies and the new trailer was an old time where the witches care about the creations they created and when a world of the cookies. Something must had happened to the witches that turn them evil now that I think about it..

why does the previous owner of the heart jam reminds me of that one pink haired character from honkai impact.

У меня мурашки бегут по коже... 😮

Why am I only now realising dark enchantress is talking in the beginning prologue

“ITS THE F-- WITCH OF THE EAST!” -that one audio I heard

1:43 doesn't she looks like lychee dragon cookie?

Is it weird that i can see this made into a tv series by the same team that did the MLPFiM?

The one who's reading the new prologue was elder farie btw

me after spending 9.99*10^9^9^9 years clicking cookie clicker finally found out that cooke has lore.

Can wait

So hype for these new ancients

the old trailer sound like dark enchantress cookie so mb its her POV

so the old prologue happened after the new one, because of the "after the chaos of iron and flame subsided" in the old one, and the "when the chaos of iron and flame still reined"

Cheataw, please tell me what happened to the fallen ancients, please!

It's like history is repeating itself :P

I love how the witches knew when they messed up

At the menu at the end, the cookie on the upper right is calling, "✨️She was a fairy✨️"

I honestly prefer the Fallen Heroes over the current Ancients. They're designs seem more interesting! And with our expedition to Beast-Yeast beginning, there is so much potential to discover why the fell to the darkness once given their Soul Jam!

I can visualize the prologue we know of is the present day And the one told new is the past Way before white lily became the dark enchantress, she and the others were the new ones who inherited what the fallen ones forsake and abused

I leaved crk like 2 years ago did the lore changed?

Pure vanilla cookie: white lily cookie?

These animations has this madoka magica feel

Old one: Good cookies, bad witches. New one: Bad cookies, good witches.

Im getting a hazbin hotel origins vibe

Теперь я хочу видеть первоначальные версии этих печенек, как отдельных персонажей, чтобы их можно было использовать для создания своей команды)

Well, to be fair, so many witches have so many covens, and moralities.

Old cutscene: about the current cookie world New cutscene: about the histoy of the cookie world

My theory is that the fallen heroes power affected the witches in a terrivle way and caused them to be bad

Its fitting while pure vanilla is the first White Lily is last

what are the chances that i get a crk ad before watching this video

I thought it was just more lore to the game not a replacement of the old lore

Why does eternal sugar cookie remind me of lychee dragon

Wait a minute. So the ancients are going to Beast-Yeast with their Soul Jams in tow??? This is gon get good

Also aren't the old one and new one connected somehow

I always wondering where life powders comes from since it's origin is unknown and the dark corner of my brain goes, My brain : What if the life powders were sucked out from a human children to make one? Me : 👁️👄👁️

Ngl the old version of dark cacao looks like ceruledge from pokemon