Unlike many Ukrainian opportunists and tools of the bourgeoisie :P

Вы понимаете о чем поют то песня Гимн Казаков Последний где она была популярна Армия Нестора Ивановича Махно Анархист и интернационалист Где Украина не стала выше воли народа

Pinguin Joe actually you can't choose if youtube will put ad on your video or not

@Seltnyt others can claim your videos if they have the copyright and force ads on your videos from which they get the money then. Better alternative than having your video taken down.

@@denxero You mean the National Fuckers? Those are Fascist Militias

Rest in piss

@@employee962 How's it hangin', Mussolini?

@@employee962 hello the protector of islam

@@employee962 hai la pfp al contrario fra

@TEST Testen vor 5 Jahren TEST vor 5 Jahren I am the protector of Islam

Ancaps: about that

@@drageben145 Also ancaps: Maybe mother anarchy is 13 as well

@@reagansmith5288 ancaps too: well if she dont say anything she consents

Communo - Capitalists and Communo - Minarchists : guys, what the fuck?

Mother Anarchy won't betray.

You just Google translated it did you

@@rockhard6699 N

More accurately it is "DEATH TO ALL THOSE WHO STAND IN THE WAY OF FREEDOM FOR WORKING PEOPLE"

And it's not an Anarchist slogan. It's probably by free cossacks (at least according to Makhno) and those committed progroms against jewish people.

@@Kuhmuhnistische_Parteiwhich Mahkno detested greatly and treatened hid own suicide is they comtinued

Pelo visto sim.

Yes.

Its was written for musicle using his poetry

@Сергей Филатов А в видео не на русском?

Isn’t it an adaptation of something written in Ukraine? The lyrics are in Russian. Edit: it was originally in Russian.

Luckily, in mexico, the zapatistas (anarchists) have autonomous control.

@@cooldownboi3890 even the zapatistas don't call themselves anarchists, stop appropriating anything.

@@mkt170 yes but in a lot of ways they are *similar* to anarchism

The colonisation of space leaves us with two possibilities: 1 The vast distances of the cosmos will allow for people to organise themselves away from governmental tyranny. 2 Space colonies just become corporately-owned hellholes where Elon Musk and his dynasty enslave who generations of people

@@ZephLodwick It's probably gonna be the second :/ After all, how will we, the Anarchists, get into space in the first place? Either you'll have to be rich, or sign away your freedoms to become a slave like in The Outer Worlds.

Sauce "Death to all who are in the way of the working people's freedom" would be an approximate translation of the whole phrase

Did not know that, cool!

@@mafia2boy33 +Noodles=Spaget

@@Urgaas precisely

And that flag and that parole were actually disapproved by Makhno. The bolsheviks used that picture of the soldiers and that flag to defame the Black Army and to accuse them of pogroms against jews. In an article in 1927 Makhno commented the picture with: "NO es una bandera 'majnovista' y ellos son soldados 'petliuristas'." - "It is NOT a 'Majnovista' flag and they are 'petliurist' soldiers." Refering to the soldiers of Symon Petliura, the first president of the Ukrainian People's Republic. To be fair, the Ukrainian People's Republic under Petliura had full rights for Jewish people, but his militia will later commit multiple pogroms against Jewish people and he will try to stop it, but he will fail, so his soldiers killed a lot of people against his order.

Indeed he was comrade, indeed he was.

I dishes with makhno very much,but his bravery and stand against the Bolsheviks earn him my undying respect.

Bijî berxwedana YPG !

very mutch like the ypg/ypg today it's amazing when you read all the things that he did that he did the right thing so often.

terrorist fucktards.

Now this is beautiful.

The flow is a little difficult but I applaud it regardless (:

Beautiful.

+Dilon Richatdson He means if the revolution had survived

Александр Хирешев можно по русскому

Daniel Neumann yeah especially when red army generals turn on anarchist movements

Says the guy literally listening to songs from a successful anarchist country.

British Comrade you really didn’t know that trotsky invaded the free territory of ukraine?

Submit. We win.

Yee!

Glendon Slavens no problem!

I like your name

One day!

@Glendon Slavens It would be my pleasure

Underrated comment

We're approaching the final crisis of imperialist capitalism. As the ecosystem withers, we are running out of time to prevail or perish.

@@lada4200 Ratio

@@Swagbigail yo mama

@@lada4200 аргументуй, чому він не може підтримувати погляди Нестора Івановича, будучи при цьому французом? Напам'ятаю, що сам Нестор Махно не підтримував ідеї національних держав. Також напам'ятаю, що перші сучасні анархо-комуністи, представником яких був і сам Нестор Махно, виникли у Франції: Жозеф Дежак, Сильвен Марешаль та інші.

@@lada4200 что за бред вообще?) Махно так-то стрелял за тот же анти-симетизм - ничего?) он был против деления на национальности. Не подмазывайся "справа" к левому политику и вождю. Да и образование человек получал в рассеянской тюрьме. В чём ни он, ни его наставник, ни, например, я проблем не видим. Завязывай со своим землячеством)

@@elpavlovsky8966 я бы тоже хотел назвать тебя братом, но, увы, в силу событий, которые прямо сейчас происходят в моей стране, это будет немного лицемерно.

TNO moment

Syria is a tankie-dictatorship bullshit. Rojava is much closer to what communism is.

Geras Al-Aqras Assad is a Tankie tho. Kind of like Xi Jinping. As far as being an Arms dealer for terrorists, wouldn't that be the Free Syrian Army, Tahir Al-sham, and Turkey?

Stalin wasn't a communist, he made the USSR much more state capitalist than any form of communism. Not trying to undermine all the good stuff he did, but he never worked toward communism.

The ba'athists are not socialists in the same vein as Xi Jinping at all... Ba'athists are "Arab socialists" which does not inherently insinuate Marxism. "Arab socialism" is opposed to confiscation of private property (nationalization) for instance, and instead focuses on unifying the Arab world and creating social progress and secularization. Vanguardism is a part of the ideology, but that's more of a way to achieve power and maintain it than how to run a state.

Im sorry comrade I wish I could help but I cant't

А батя фашист дочерей своих ненавидит

Зелінський (тато) і Джо (мама) передають свої привітання

No he really doesn't

AND NESTOR MAKHNO

AND KROPOTKIN

WHY ARE YOU GUYS SHOUTING

BECAUSE ANARCHY MAKES US STRONG

AND BERKMAN AND MAKHNO AND KROPOTKIN AND CAMUS GOLDMAN AND

People who have Ukrainian coat of arms on avatar is enemy for anarchy number 1

Glory to Anarchist Ukraine

@@thotslayer9914 Nah enemy as well

дв?! брэшишь, у вас с августа месяца получали политическое убежище белорусские анархисты, сейчас Европа за этим не следит и вы их обратно сюда кинули, у нас в Беларуси с анархистами никто не размауляе, адразу спыняюць дзеянасць самым зверским способоом, Украина небезопасное место для свободных людей

@@user-kw3ju5iv5l why is that?

nestor will protect us!!!

@@jerrysmith7533 Nice sentiment but hero-worship is very counter to anarchism

@@tora9915 Good thing I am not an anarchist.

@@tora9915 It’s idolisation of the founder.

@@jerrysmith7533 then shut up about makhno lol

I can offer a translation for the "Song of Liberty" at 23:53 ("Дума про волю" - Duma pro voliu, literally - "A thought about freedom". Duma ("thought") is an epic genre of Ukrainian folk song. Please see below Oh, you, bat'ko, our youthful bat'ko! Won't you, bat'ko, come back to your land? As the time of pain Sweeps over Ukraine, Won't you bring us freedom again?” - Oh, you, fellows, my Ukrainian fellows! I was breathing freedom, but I breathe no more, There's no strength to save, For I'm in the grave, For so many years, in the foreign soil. Black is the soil, green is the grass, Blue is the sky, white clouds above us, Yellow's the sun, red is the blood, All mixed together - to end and to start. "Oh, you, bat'ko, bat'ko just and fair, Nothing is the same now as when you were here, Cast off your tombstone, Make our foes be gone, The miracle of freedom is yours to give!” - Oh, you, fellows, you my reckless fellows! Freedom came to those who were fighting for it There’s no magic I wield - People made it real, All I did was hold high the flag for the free. Black is the soil, green is the grass, (etc....) “Oh, you, bat’ko, our forgotten bat’ko! When you are not here, there’s no freedom for us! Must it be our fate - Forever to wait Till we people have our freedom at last?” -Oh, you, fellows, freedom-loving fellows! Who can give you what you already have got? Freedom’s never granted, Freedom’s always conquered - By those who let freedom live in the heart! Black is the soil, green is the grass, Blue is the sky, white clouds above us, Yellow's the sun, red is the blood, All mixed together - to end and to start.

I need the Ukrainian written out in English lettering. I want to be able to sing along.

long live Anarchy but for CNT-FAI please stop your extreme mass killing of clergies, this only make Franco rose to power easier

Muerte a los Oligarcas Españoles, a los Narcos Punks, a las feminazis y a los judios de Barcelona... Un saludo. Viva la Anrquia.

@@MiguelAngel-vn4xz contra toda autoridad, no contra etnias ni géneros

Salud camarada!

​@@MiguelAngel-vn4xz "Feminazis"? "Judíos"? Vaya anarquista.

I'll probably have "любо, братці любо" played at my funeral

Good luck! Ukrainian is a beautiful language

bažaju udači ❤️

Песня на русском если чё

@@yyyyyy55554 большинство песен в списке на украинском (most songs in the list are in Ukrainian but a couple of them are in Russian, most people in the Free State were Ukrainian speaking)

желаю удачи правнучка Карпо Махно

Niech żyje!

Niech żyje!

Niech Żyje!

Niech żyje!

Niech żyje!

Что ты сказал про Анархию?

@@user-iu2jh6km2oон сказал, что это не продается? Я думаю, он имел в виду, что Мать Анархия не продаст нас

I agree. I would like to now it's name actually.

@@user-or7mh5we2k It's in the description

@@tiagorochagoncalves9140 thanks comrade. I'm not sure did i notice it before or after your comment but either way i appreciate your help. Together we shall win.

Gives the atmosphere of sitting in a Ukranian field someplace, near a lake.

that's song from Mahno army)

Down with the four monopolies!

Tu parle français ??

VIVE PROUDHON

On dit vive l'anarchisme

Vive l’anarchisme et la commune de Paris

L'anarchisme*, camarade.

Sometimes Fascist and Absolute Monarchist music too it seems the worst ideologies have the best music

@@calenskyes Fascism is far-left

Anarchists aren't left. In fact, most of today anarchists are ancap, wich is far-right

So how did that work out for you?

@@totallyrealnotfakelifeadvi7547 currently NC with the entire family!! 😂🙏🏻🏴

@@middlesidetopwise OMG! Guess it had an impact

Are a lot of Ukrainian protestants anarchists?

@@ZephLodwick No, not at all. They are SUPER CONSERVATIVE 😂🙃

He would’ve been pro-Russia contemporarily

@@proudsubhuman Russia is a textbook hungry imperialist bully, not anarchist you absolute buffoon. They're so anti freedom that not only do they want absolute control in their own already massive country but also in other independent countries tbat want nothing to do with them. Also who tf is "he"?

@@proudsubhuman absolutely not. He's a free Ukrainian

@OVOD.net тогда было чуть ли не 4 Украины: УНР, ЗУНР, Вольная Территория и УССР. И все, кроме УНР и ЗУНР, враждовали друг с другом!(УНР и ЗУНР пытались союзничать и объединились , вроде как)

Слава анархiя Украïнi

@OVOD.net Правильно делал

@@user-lq1nb7ke3v + еще Всевеликое Войско Донское, КНР(Кубанская Народная Республика), ДВУНР (Дальневост Укр Нар Республика) или Зеленый Клин - все украинские. Органы власти были сформированы по результатам выборов еще при Временном правительстве. То есть это прямые легитимные правоприемники Вр Правительства. В отличии от большевиков, 5 колонны Германии, набранных из китайцев, венгров, и каторжников, после Мировой войны, перешедших под контроль Антанты. Или "Белых" - изначально созданной Антантой силе. Антанта не желала появления нового серъезного игрока на мировой арене - Украины, и фактически создала СССР. Но в учебниках такого не напишут.

@@user-lq1nb7ke3v ээ, а зелёный клин?

There are actually two versions of the song. There is the Cossack prayer version and the Cossack recruit version, and the folk version is about the nature of Ukraine and all that is experienced The version you know is the prayer after Adamant Terrick left the soldier in the snow to die, and the soldier was convinced it was his fault and is apologizing to everyone he knows for being a failure.

batka is a name makhno was referred to as by his soldiers and comrades , it means father roughly .

Indeed

Shut up

@@yes4041 no u shut up

@@gfox-ck5xx No you

@@yes4041 no u

Venceremos Allende agreed, Comrade.

Bourgaisie has tried to divide us. It has worked, but todays socialists are arguably much less sectarian.

@Justin 12O16E26 How does it feel to be a tool of the capitalists, my dear sectarian friend?

@Justin 12O16E26 With your 12 years of age and 5€ of weekly allowance.

@@ZivkoSkobic Time and time again the Communists have used and spit on Anarchism. For anarchism to succeed as it has in Chiapas, Anarchists need to distance themselves from Reds. An authoritarian is an authoritarian, no matter the color of ideology they wear.

no.

Zaraki Kenpachi what's the second one?

I always knew Kenpachi was an anarchist, you're my favourite Bleach character taijou xD.

Zaraki Kenpachi yeah what's the second one?

Interestingly the Paris commune was predominantly influenced by the French anarchists too.

wait till you hear about USSR and China

@@aitorherrera5937 they actually aren't communist, just neo-fascists

@@PinkyeBoy famous facist Vladimir Lenin

@@aitorherrera5937 famous fascist Stalin

Where is the freedom frontline?

@@canadian_cranberry we keep having to push back on the big public event because shit is shit and the timing keeps getting fucked by unforeseen events.

Ok thanks for telling me

Someone made a song with lyric a year ago.if you search it you'll find it.i would give you the link but i do not know how to do that in cellphones. The channel name is "i made you read this"

Yes, it's "I made you read this" channel, and the link is kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jb53qd1lp5mpnXk.html

Another video with this song : kzfaq.info/get/bejne/q8-mZrmFlpmlk4U.html - this same recording, repeated 3 times head-to tail, superimposed onto video sequences from 2006 TV series "Nine Lives of Nestor Makhno" :)

genius.com/Mongol-shuudan-free-song-lyrics

its called mother anarchy loves her sons

Teknolojinin geri olduğu zamanlar herhalde :)

Yes, sadly the Makhnovist movement was hijacked by the nationalist youth that believed too much in the Soviet propaganda films about Makhno. I may be the last Ukrainian to be a real Makhnovist and that speaks Ukrainian.

They are referring to the Bolsheviks as communists to not create confusion.

Danger Floof Maybe, but the artists are Bandera supporters.

Oleh SZTUL are you sure?

Yeah the guy who formed the band that does Eh Yablochko, has a Facebook post where he's on Bandera's grave and his post says "glory to the heroes".

When you are a weeb but also a communist

@@Dwarfplayer As a Japanese communist, I am sorely offended.

Sergei Buff Bolshevik bastards stole lot's of songs and remaked them to their propaganda, like Machnovčina, they remake it to Partisan's Song

"propaganda"

There are only 2 songs in russian. And all of them are Ukrainian partisan song. And 1 parody on red army anthemn.

Some songs are in Surzhik (Russian-Ukrainian mix :)

@@nukethemall4826 imagine being an anarchist and believing in "stealing songs" 👁👄👁

Talendril Silverleaf I would certainly be cheerful if I lived in an age of human freedom, even if it only lasted for a little while

@@khaz1568 I would recommend some if this comment wasn't two years old. Seems I'm pretty late to the party.

What?

Peace Was never an option?

Song of liberty is one of the best IMO.

Dude no this war wouldnt exist then because makhno would have destroyed nazis after nazis broke the ceasefires(if he would make ceasefires with the nazis at first) and there would have been a larger support for the USSR, meaning todays russia might still have been the USSR

FYI, Nestor's chaps weren't anarcho-communists specifically, the French and Spanish ones were. Machno's black army didn't really see any difference between communists and monarchists, same old tyrrany either way. Needless to say, before the World War, Machno was like number one bogeyman for Bolsheviks, they hated him almost as much as monarchists. But Nestor would be proud of us today nonetheless! Communist or not, Russians always the same.

@@BIGESTblade That's not true at all. Makhno and various Black army members very specifically took influence from Peter Kropotkin's works and the remnants after the war would go on to draft up platformism which went on to influence modern anarcho communist organizations such as Revdia which is currently active in Ukraine fighting the Russian invasion. You can go read Makhno's correspondence with Malatesta on the anarchistlibrary where he very explicitly refers to himself as a communist anarchist.

@@michealruth8925 So? If someone gets influenced by the works of Aristotle that means they are a classical philosopher? Nestor didn't care weather it was communism or capitalism, he was a soldier. He was fighting a war and allowed other people in his controlled territory to think about how they want to conduct business. Kind of goes against whole anarchist idea to try and enforce some arbitrary *better model of economy, doesn't it?

Lmao if he was around today he would be pro-Russia, fitting right in with the rest of the criminals and outlaws amongst in the DPR/LPR militias.

Search up Вольная Песня (Vol’naya Pesnya), it’s by the Russian band Монгол Шуудан (Mongol Shuudan) & should pop up fairly quickly

Do you still have it after two years? I want to read it haha

@@baxterbarns6112 you cant, sorry!

@@shruk4 haha thats alright, hope you're doing well after two years btw :)

@@baxterbarns6112 doing fine, cheers

Try tipping in "Internationale ukrainian lyrics" in google.

Also I just started playing the Siberian Black Army in HOI4 with the mod The New Order

HEROYAM SLAVA !

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/mM-Xepx8vq6xZmQ.html

Here it is, if you didn't find it earlier

@@Taki_Svoi_Chelovek Thanks I forgot I was trying to find that but now I have it. Stay safe

@@y1bfnf5z1j3 Погоджуюсь.

Same