"How about we score him a 2 for carrying the pizza?" -absolutely LOVE the ball-busting from the owner. Classic!

“Old people… they’re too close to dyin’ to waste their time with bad food.” Amazing quote

The "What are you guys gossipping about??" killed me. HAHAHAHA

Dave stares at the name on the box and still calls it “Palmero’s”. 😆

Who else gets super happy for these restaurants when they score highly? Love seeing this.

Julio stepped out of the door, told him the deal, and made an 8.5 on one shot himself on time to keep it in the same video. He stepped up and now his business will benefit from it. I love reviews like this.

I used to deliver for Palermo's. This is a family owned spot, with great ownership and leadership. The food is exceptional, and they take good care of the staff and their customers. People who come here just don't come once they are lifetime customers. I live about 1 hour 30 mins from there now and if I am in the area I stop in for a tomato pie, and always say hi to the brothers.

I’ve been going to Palermo’s since I was a kid and I’m in my mid 30’s now. Pie has never changed, always great. A well deserved review for Palermo’s. Go Prez!

As soon as Pres dropped it, he was so embarrassed he didn't know what to do only start to eat another slice 😆

Haven't seen Dave go in panic mode like that in a while. That tomato pie looked incredible though

I love that he said “the old people are coming” four feet away from an old woman 😂

“How about we score him a 2 for carrying the pizza” lmfao amazing

The tomato pie looked like it absolutely deserved an 8.5, my mouth is watering.

That was a classic all-time review. Dropped pizza, two different reviews, and two pizzas in the 8’s.

8.2 and a 8.5 is incredile. The owner Julio seems so humble and down to earth. One of the few owners you don't care lingering around which is rare!!! If im ever in Bordertown im going out of my way to go here!

Congrats to Julio. After this review gets out there, he may need to start offering an early-early bird special to accommodate even more customers.

I'm about ready to fly across the country to try that. Everybody knows Julio will be driving a Bugatti by Monday.

8.2 and a 8.5?! That's fucking monumental. That owner is going to talk about this forever. His grandchildren will hear the tales.

Julio is such a cool guy, I hope he benefited greatly from this review he and the family obviously deserve it. He was so cool I can’t say it enough super nice and great hospitality ❤

"Old people are too close to dying to be wasting their time on bad food." Realest shit ever said in the Pizza game

Dave's inability to get any name right is hilarious😂

That tomato pie looked absolutely spectacular!

*Gives a 4 second death stare* “What are you guys gossiping about?” LMAO

Possibly my favourite non-contentious review of all time. Nice owner, polite kids, great scores, Dave on point, rain noise, cars rushing past, community vibe … but why can’t he say Palermo?!😂

One bite, Dave screwing up names and dropping pies, everybody knows everything is back to normal.

The owner seems like honestly one of the coolest owners in any of the reviews. Respect to Julio

YOU FINALLY DID IT, YOU FINALLY DROPPED THE PIZZA LOL. been watching you for a while waiting for it to happen haha. its almost anxiety inducing when you one hand hold in any weather LOL. Keep it up bro, love this.

Dave is the man, I love that he brings business to local places.

Its absolutely mind boggling how youve turned a 3 minute pizza review into an empire. People respect your POV so much on pizza. Cant help but admire what youve done.

This is probably a 9.3 for me. Crispy, good cheese ratio, chunky sauce so you can taste the tomatoes, smoky char, and the gilfs.

Just got back home from Palermo's a few minutes ago. For reference, I live 65 minutes away in Pennsylvania (Turnpike trip) and i started eating the tomato pie in the car in their parking lot. HOLY BLEEP is this amazing!! Super thin, crispy & light. I am usually done at 3-4 slices of regular pizza in my area, but since this is so light, I ate the whole large (5 slices out in NJ, and brought the last 3 home, and popped back in the oven (275° for 6 minutes). This pizza was DEFINITELY worth the drive. If anyone who watches this review is close to Bordentown, don't hesitate, just get in the car and GO! I left at 9:30AM to get there just after they opened and it was everything Dave said it was. Going back next week with some friends to try both the cheese and have my friends try the tomato pie. 👍👍

I'm from Bordentown but live out of state and I have to say that it has become a tradition whenever I visit family and friends in NJ to not eat anything until we get to Palermo's for two tomato pies (shared, of course). Yeah, it's that good!

"The old people are coming" was a perfectly delivered line.

New Jersey is absolutely kicking New York's pizza to the curb at this point.

Well done, Julio 👏 You managed to fleece two high scores in one review and made a second pizza to Dave’s likening

owner chilling in the rain watching his pizza get scored is the best part lol

MONSTER SCORES. this place is going to be jumping even more now if it wasn't already.

Dude, that pizza looks absolutely fantastic. This is the first time in my life that I've ever been sad about not being close to New Jersey.

I usually ate pizza once a month until I started watching this shit. Your giving folks business and making people realize pizza is the number one meal in the world when it all comes down to it. Good for you Dan! Thankyou!

Wife and I are from a Gloucester County in South Jersey.. We’re going up this Sunday to try this! Thank you for the recommendation Dave!!

Those kids seem so polite lol. Good on them

One bite, one owner correcting Dave on the pronunciation of the shop and we all love it. Everybody knows the rules.

Laughed so hard at the pizza drop! 🤣😂 This is what happens when you tease karma with "Palmero this, Palmero that". 😆🙃

The fart noise the editor added at 5:05 when Dave stood up was perfect. I can't be the only one that caught that. P.S. their frozen pies are sold at a lot of retail locations and they're very very good as well.

That tomato pie is one of the best looking pies I have ever seen.

Tomato pie looked spectacular. Well deserved score

I love what Dave is doing for the small mom and Pop restaurants. True American!

The Brooklyn pie from this joint is the best pizza I’ve ever had

a month or two ago i didn’t know dave, you could even say i fell into the fake media and disliked him. but here i am, his biggest fan now. can’t get enough of this guy

Dude, I love the reviews, never comment, but this review 100% the best. The scores, that dude, everything. Warms the heart

I LOVE THAT HE HAS THE "TRINACRIA" SYMBOL/FLAG ON HIS PIZZA BOX REPRESENTING PALERMO, SICILY. VERY BEAUTIFUL TOUCH.

I love it when the pizza has a crunch, so satisfying.

“Well this one’s clean” takes the biggest bite of life I started crying laughing 🤣

I've been going to Palermo's for close to 15 years. I ONLY ever get the Tomato Pie (sometimes two or three). It is the absolute best tomato pie around!!! 8.5 is an accurate score!

This has to be in the top ten reviews. I love the owner, so authenic and the pizza is top notch excellente!

5:29 when Dave pretends to wipe up the pizza I died

One of my favorite reviews in a long time and huge score relative to the last 1-2 years.

One bite everybody knows it's a good review when it's 8 minutes long

That tomato pie looks like my absolute ideal pizza

New Jersey has amazing pizza not going to lie, NJ pizza always get high scores!! Dave gotta show more love to Jersey !! 🍕🍕

Wow! Great Monster scores. Palermo’s is now on my pizza list to visit.

That's second pizza looked amazing, looks like it's worth the trip. Jersey here we come lol!

I just watched this particular review for the first time and it is now my favourite.

"the old people are coming that's how you know it's good". Lol I love it

the fact Dave is calling it Palmaro's and not Palermo's is making my Italian blood boil...

I teared up when that pizza hit the sidewalk.

I've been 10 minutes away from this place for 15 years and never been there. I don't know how, but I'll be there soon!

He is the clumsiest person I’ve ever watched. It’s remarkable how little dexterity he has.

Wow what a great review. I think Julio is going to need more staff

WOW - 2 different pizzas and wish they were in my neighborhood!!! Looks right at the box and pronounces it Palmeros - lol

Been going here with my family since I was a kid. Only pizza place around that area we like. I used to love their wings too but they changed them.

Gone to Palermos my entire life. Can confirm its great.

That tomato pie had one of the most mouth-watering looks of all time.

This was a great example of a good solid ‘basic cheese’ pie, that is exactly Dave’s go to i.e. crispy crust, not too strong a flavor, and the owners were sweet and non intrusive. Lessons for future folks in this once in a life time predicament: slightly over cook your pie (thin crust is essential). Try to make sure the pizza is fresh out of the oven and not in the box very long. Pretend you only slightly know Dave, unless you have a beautiful story about how you and your family survived Covid. DO NOT stand on the street while he scores; you’ll easily lose 0.3-0.5 points because of that.

I have no idea how Dave is not sweating his as$ off. Especially with that rain. Humidity has been crazy in Jersey.

8.2 & 8.5, those are insane numbers for one spot. Guess I'm going to Bordentown Jersey

Dave shows up in his jammies. He's been sober for nearly 3 days. And then he drops his 8.2 on the sidewalk.

The moment Davey understands Gravity...now he knows the rules 🍕👀

This is going into the greatest hits of Pizza reviews

Julio was a great dude making great pies!

Amazing how the owner took over the review in a good way 👍🏽

Another legend ascends to greatness. Stand tall, dear Julio.

Dave, You have to admit that this area of New Jersey and generally across the whole state is as good as New Haven or NYC overall - This place, DeLorenzo, Conte’s in Princeton, Papa’s, Star Tavern in West Orange, Napoli in Frenchtown, DeLucia in Somerville immediately come to mind. The pizza here is specular! And your reviews are great. Regards, Peter Roselli

That tomato pie literally made my mouth salivate...holy shit.

I’ve been waiting FOREVER to see you drop a pizza! I’ve always wondered if you have. I mean I seen you spike a pizza, and fumble one during football references. But now I’ve seen you do it and I am satisfied!!!!

This is our local go to place. Glad to know he stopped by Bordentown as there are some good places. Owner here is nice. Tomato pie for sure over the pizza but we always get one of each and both seem to go.

I love this guy Julio. “Says he doesn’t wanna be on camera” 😂

Imagine getting an 8.2 for a football style, then you swing in a surprise upper cut and get an 8.5 on the tomato... I'd crush 2 whole tomato pies, that thing looked insanely delish.

Once again Jersey showing we can go toe to toe with the best.

Grew up in Bordentown, live in California now. Everyone here and back there knows whenever I visit home, first thing I do is get a soft pretzel, hit up a Wawa, and head to Palermo's to get a tomato pie. About time Dave made his way to the 🐏

Lol!! "The old people are coming, that's how you know it's good." Dave says they don't waste time on crappy pizza. 🤣🍕

Finally Pres drops a pizza . I've been waiting for this day . Shame it was a quality pie though 😥

One bite you can almost guarantee there’s amazing pizza pretty much anywhere in fabulous NJ! Oh yes! I wish all of youse guys good health and prosperity! - Gary. 9/15 6:01pm EST

I like how nice and respectful you are to shop owners... your a class act. THANKS, will always remember how you helped out the industry during the plague. You're an awful nice guy for such prick.. 😆 good for you brother

I hope palmero’s has a lot of dough, because there’s about to be a lot more than just old people there at 530

That tomatoe slice omg looks amazing

"I Don't Want To Be On Camera📸" Stays On Camera In Dave's Way For 4 Minute's.

Been eating paleremos tomato pies since i was kid. i can clean a whole large and still be hungry its so light and amazing. my family used to buy 3 pies for the 4 of us. Would drive 1hr round trip to pick it up. legendary

Palermo's will need to hire more manpower. Things just got real for them....

Palermo's made him a believer of the non-crisp pizza? Damn, hundreds of other places couldn't even do that.