I thought they looked cute in pictures but now seeing them in this video I'm blown away at how pretty they are!! Especially their hair!!

These dolls definitely represent the 2000's not the 90's vibe. Wish they would have based them around 1995.

As someone who is their "peer" (I'm two years older than they canonically are) I chuckle every time someone's dissing the shirt+vest combo. It's not "laziness", we were all wearing pieces like that back then😉. I honestly really liked them as a kid and had a lot of sweater/vest+shirt tops like that. I guess it's quite early to do a '90s historical dolls because a lot of those fashion trends aren't very recognizable as "historical" yet.

I love them! I do wish they had more unique names 🙄 but as a 10 year old in 1999, I’m completely obsessed with these dolls. They are perfect! I do plan to give Nicki green eyes to match her sister. The Book It set was a must have for me - I ordered two right away! It brings back a lot of memories from elementary school.

I couldn’t wait this morning, and ordered Nicki, Isabel, their accessories, and their pajamas from the website.

Wow, Nicki looks so much cuter in your video than she looks in the pictures! I wasn't planning on getting anything from their collection, but you're making me want her!

If Mattel was SMART they should have based them on 94'-96' and done a whole event celebrating the American Girl of Today/Pleasant Company and re-released a portion of the popular 90s outfits and brought back the old facemolds they retired like jly 4 as a best friend to the twins. Then gave Nicki and Isabel outfits that resemble the old 90s outfits (and not the cheap fast fashion outfits they gave them) that would have been AMAZINGGG but unfortunately..that is asking too much of Mattel

As a person born in 1999 I don’t know how I feel about it being a historical doll. I feel old now 😂

I just got Nicki, and my sister got Isabel! It took us a while to find good dolls with no defects, especially Isabel! It was a nightmare, but at least we have them now!

i absolutely hate the journals, give us the books back

The “articles” section on the AG website has an interesting article on Nicki and Isabel’s personalities, interests, and relationship. Their journals were also written by twins who worked together. One twin had Isabel and the other had Nicki. They are interviewed in the article.

I just wish they would have used different names 😭

Loved your reaction to the twins ♥️ definitely cannot wait for your full review on Saturday. I need all the tea to be spilled on which twin I should purchase! It’s hard being a broke AG collector in your late 20s 😝

"They're American Girl's new historical dolls from 1999." Me, born in 1993, aging and turning to dust as they type this: B-Booyah!

I just purchased both today as well and they are absolutely gorgeous! Nick’s hair is so beautiful and thick. Isabel’s hair is beautiful too. All of the accessories are awesome! Love love them both. Thank you so much for sharing your awesome video. I always enjoy them.

Your enthusiasm is infectious 👍🏻 Like your review ❤

I definitely identify with Nicki, but after seeing how lovely they are I want both of them! Though it seems that Nicki's outfits are more versatile than Isabel's. Lots more mix and match pieces, as opposed to everything being attached.

The twins are just adorable!❤👍👍

Im so happy that American Girl had up the quality of these doll's and their colloction.

I wasn’t a fan of their face molds when I saw the leaked pics, but they are gorgeous! I’m in love with Nicki!❤

Congratulations on your two new baby girls. They’re beautiful!!❤❤ Thank you for always bringing high quality informative videos!!! ENJOY❤❤❤

I like isabel a lot more now that I've seen people's videos and not just stock photos but I think I'll wait a bit to get her. Nicki I'm getting asap she's just so pretty

OMGGGGGGG guess i'm not going to work because I gotta watch this full vid!!!! what a huge slay.

Mattel take the rest of my birthday money

It's giving Y2K, not the 90's.... I mean where are the butterfly hair clips?!

I thought I like Isabel best but now after seeing Nicki I have changed my mind. Nicki is stunning!

I REALLYYY love them both!!! ❤ I was worried about them being twins but they look different enough and I’m in love😅❤

Omg bless up on you posting this IMMEDIATELY!! I was wondering when we would get your video hoooooo weeee.

Im a 90s kid 😀 im so excited that they came out with the twins

Not getting either one of the dolls but I'd say Nikki is definitely my preference from her outfit to her hair color and I'm glad that she at least has a nice quality wig and I hope this isn't just a one time thing AG is doing. I just ordered the Pizza Hut set. I feel like it's a bit overpriced and I'm still bewildered as to WHY they didn't include TWO cups instead of one. However...it feels the most versatile out of all the items in the collection and can fit perfectly in any set up. I always hated the weird girly heart shaped Pizza AG likes to sell. The Pizza Hut set is more realistic, more authentic. It's also the most nostalgic thing for me (and I LOVED pizza as a kid. Still do.)

Yk Kris is a good KZfaqr when he comes home and films the second he got the girls. I’m such a huge fan.

The 1 piece shirt and sweater is how it was made in the 90's

Isabel is so Cher from clueless and Nicki gives me Alex Mack vibes!

I’m so excited to get the twins this weekend!!!!

The dolls are very pretty however I think I'mma just wait until Christmas to get Isabel and it's mostly having to do it with in regards that they release the dolls during Black History month this should have been claudie's time to shine and mind you she hasn't even been released for that long but I would definitely change Isabel to at least a clothing style reminiscent of the '90s because they look like the early 2000s

I cannot WAIT for mine to arrive!!

Thanks for showing us the set ups at the store!! I had the pleasure to go to the Mall of America store looong ago, and I've been curious on the set ups at stores when they get new dolls and items since I don't have easy access to the stores 💘

Been waiting for this ❤

Thank you. Very informative and they look great in your video. I love the overall outfit. 💕

Super awesome review I love them both and will definitely be purchasing both ASAP!

I adore Nicki! She's my favortie, I love her personality!

Thank so much for the video! Looking forward to the upcoming one! 😃 I want to buy Isabel, glad you mentioned about the difficulty of finding a good one. Yours is totally adorable! 💖💖I hope to get a good one using a PS as I don't have a store close by 😪 So cool to see your footage in the store!!! 😍

I just ordered Nicki for my collection!! I'm so excited for her! Although I'm partial to the original book styles, I do kind of like the journals. I have always struggled with reading, and when I first started getting into AG it was hard to read the books. I feel like the journals would be an easier read, especially for kids who may have reading/learning disabilities like myself.

it’s giving new york minute

I definitely prefer Isabel. I am not planning on buying either of them at the moment. I wish they looked like 9-10-year-olds instead of teenagers, but that is my opinion. I am sticking to buying older dolls.

Honestly I think american girl should have used the Caroline eyes for Isabelle vs the felicity eyes, it would have been different yet closer to nikkis eyes than the super neon green eyes lol but it still looks good. Nikki is my favorite how ever

Love them both also Nikis lips look darker thanks for sharing

I kinda don’t like that both dolls have repetitive names… nor do I care for the constant “julie” face mold AG does all the time anymore. I have a soft spot for the classic mold and other molds should have the spotlight. Overall they’re cute dolls. But I dunno, i have conflicted feelings about them. Maybe they’ll grow on me!

I love Nicki's overalls my mom will go crazy for me to get that skateboarding outfit

I wish I could just buy their shoes alone and that’s it lol

Just went for the first time today to American Girl Dallas. I am a adult collector and have wanted Josephina for my collection forever and my husband bought her for me. I saw Isabell and Nilki in person and really felt drawn to Nikki she was great quality and i relate to her. And of course that Pizza Hut set, that was my first job. Thanks for ur videos

I think both dolls are beautiful but I really wish their story took place from the early 90s. They seem more 2000s to me. I also don't like that they don't come with a real book. If I get them I will rename them Ashley and Jessica.

i love nicki and isabel is okay. i like nicki’s skateboarding outfit but her overalls aren’t as cute as kits. still love it though! i don’t love the skateboard because of the clear pieces because i prefer the other skateboard from like 2012 (i have it). i feel like that older skateboard is better if the doll is jsut holding the skateboard if that makes sense. i’m sad that isabel’s tennis outfit is a dress not two pieces. i wish her meet outfit was not a one piece shirt as well. they are both cute dolls though! I loveee nicki’s hat i think it is so cute and i love the color! i think that nicki’s and isabel’s pajamas are sooo adorable and definitely something that reminds me of the 90s.

also love the set up!!! its giving

Nicki is among the characters I would consider getting, if I was going to get an American Girl doll. I wish I could visit an American Girl store, but alas, I currently live in a rural town in central New York state.

I'm getting both of them

I love them both and love that they are geminis cuz i’m a gemini but I HATE that they are repeating names… there are so many girl named they could’ve done

Joss has a skateboard in her collection it came with her surf bus!

Thank you for reviewing the Pizza Hut set! I bought it this morning online and then started thinking that the three pieces of pizza may be stuck together, stuck to the pan, etc. I am glad you clarified that they are not all glued together!

I'm disappointed you have to buy the skateboarding/tennis court to get the helmet and knee/elbow pads for Nicki.

I really wish that the dolls were early 90’s, so that there would be a 2001 doll. My favorite is Isabel. I don’t like the journals. Because, I can’t buy them. Besides, I like chapter books better. I don’t like that the sweater and skirt are together and the shoes shouldn’t be pealing off. I love 💕 the dolls so much. But, I can’t get them right away.

Historical, I feel offended lol

I am so happy my birthday is in 1 month so I asked my parents for both dolls and there. Accessories

What are the defects that Isabel has? Wonk eye? Wig issue? I'm debating on asking for the twins for Christmas

I know I’m late to the show on this, but what were the issues you found that made it hard to find ones in store? Asking because I’m also super picky and want to know what defects to look for when I order Isabel 👀 thanks!

I feel like Niki got better outfits and details, more money was spent on her. Her things weren’t sewed together like Isabel.

Thanks for the heads up for the Isabel issue i think I'm going to get the twins until AG fixes it.i always order my dolls by phone.

I’m going in the morning to get Isabel!! What should I look for in terms of do’s and don’ts?

This is random but I was wondering what you meant by the symmetry of the faces. How the older dolls are more symmetrical while now they’re not. Could you maybe do a video showing this up close? Maybe even in store? I’m curious to see what this looks like, especially side by side

A lot of people are saying that these dolls look a lot more like from the early 2000s Then the late 1990s but I think they look like both to me I think the look like there from the late 1990s to early 2000s era

They look nice and all and there is absolutely nothing wrong with their characters but I was really hoping for an Asian as a Historical doll for the 90s and/or early 2000s. Asian characters are so underrepresented in American Girl outside of the GotY line. Z was barely out an entire year before the contemporary line was cancelled and Ivy is incredibly hard to find and literally the only Asian historical doll we’ve gotten and it’s only for part of one decade when Chinese people have been coming to the US since the 1800s and have their parts in other decades too and she was in a side line as a secondary character doll. There are already four black dolls in the line, Kaya seems to not going to retire anytime soon as she represents indigenous peoples of the US who have always been a part of US history even before it had begun, and Josefina as a Latina girl in a part of the US that has a rich culture and history. Please just give us *one* Asian doll that is a Historical Character with her own book and collection that isn’t part of anyone else’s!

You are NOT being dramatic. Regardless of doll price, when you purchase new, you have a right to expect perfection. When you pony up how much an AG doll actually costs, even more so.

I really like Nikki

Me and my best friend want to get themmmm

Why did I get a perfect isabel and I didn’t even look for defects..

Been waiting for this video! Would you recommend Isabel or Nicki for a first time American Girl owner?

My AG store just closed permanently :((

Does the store let you go through their inventory in back or just what's out on display?

Ha wish you would’ve played the dialup sounds on the computer

I was born in the 1990s and now I have to wonder if this is how my mom felt when my sister got Julie.

I just wish things weren't so expensive. But other than that I love watching your videos and I hope that everything's going well for you and that you are doing well and that you're doing okay. Install is one of them looks like you know like she would be a girly girl and now their own looks like she would be the type of girl who likes guy stuff but doesn't want to be a guy but you know. Which I can relate I'm kind of a little bit like both of that. And I see there's nothing wrong with you know being like both browser you're a girl or a guy it's just more important to be you than something other people want you to be. Also I love watching my favorite streamers on my bday today is my bday.

Is their a certain order in reading Their books? Do you read Nicki's book first or Isabel book first? Just curious because I'm going to be getting both

Is it just me or does Isabel’s face seem thicker than nicki’s? I know it’s the same mold but nicki’s just seems slim

🎉

Nicki needs ty beanie baby's They need rugrats halloween costumes.

After buying Corrine and seeing the drastic reduction in quality I decided then not to purchase any current AG dolls.

Isabel is basically Cher 2.0

What do you mean you had to find a “Good Nicki or Isabel”??? Are they not all the same?? (I had an AG doll or 2 as a kid and I found a tiktok of yours and now I am hyper fixating)

I have nickki

I am going to jet Nicki

😂

All these American girl dolls have the same face molds

I had that slumber party book when I was a kid! I also participated in the Pizza Hut book it program. I need that set! And you’re making me want Nicki!! 😂🫣

I think Isabel is an icon and Nicki is like not an icon