what do you mean? sorry I cannot understand

+劉瑞琳 SM removed Jessica's voice from the OT9 version of Twinkle, but it still shows her singing it

+magicmike191v2 when was the ot9 version published?

+劉瑞琳 the OT9 version was filmed in 2013, the dvd was released in late 2014

+magicmike191v2 but why her voice isn't in it

Andrea Otti yet people doubts about her debut😒😒

Same😍

They will need to pay more

sunny's voice is underrated. 'even sunny' is so demeaning towards her.

@@TechNerdNetwork ikr. idk why she's in the vocal line but never gets enough line. Even Sooyoung, who has a soft smooth voice.

E

@@TechNerdNetwork lol “demeaning”. I wonder if u will think “demeaning” if i say she cant sing this song alone

I love Sunny but no she wouldnt slay this song alone.

*uploader

+난 멀티 팬덤 입니다 I did edit her voice from a fancam into the song

tayswift 13

sssparks fly SM do that too, Jess sing live ,but SM Put Lipsync.. Bcs SM want to Keep Jess image as Main Vocal

true.....

Maybe because thhey are matured now

5 SOSHI Of SONE SNSD 4ever yeah they matured and bec of all those issues they tend to be more careful now i think look what happen to ty before announcing baekyeon dating issue she became too careful bec she think she may dissapoint sones in the future on what she will going to do. Thats what i see ...

MissSaintG Sunn 💗💗

Jaxx Ongpauco ikr! Hate it whenever they take out Jessica's voice! No one can replace her

Yeah that’s very low to do stupid SM just because she left doesn’t mean that they can do that !

They can't put her voice in twinkle live because when she left, the song is not part of their prior agreement voice usage ☺️

+Steffany Han yes :D

isn't Jessica one of them too? why they removed her?

+SuhailiMalik Because SM entertainment's directors are a bunch of assholes..

its true

+Steffany Han this is a complete shit, the original dvd version has her voice clearly, so the person who edited this did it just to start fanwar. Do you actually think they would mute a part of a song, this is ridiculous

YEAHHH😭😭

xolovesme _ ofc SM should.! she have a nice voice

Actually it was originally TaeTiJess or TaeTiSica but then idk but they said Tae didn't want her in.Can't find a different one.

+Brielle Ong Nahh, actually TaeTiSeo said in a show that the TaeTiSeo unit even came out in the first place is because in 2012, other Soshi members wanted to act and do other things but TaeTiSeo are the only members that wanted to sing so a Soshi unit was made. Other members had their schedules packed with other activities that year like Jessica who was acting in a KBS drama.

+Nur Qamarina Oh, what I saw in the post was that after Jess was done filming she'd be in a sub unit but someone didn't want her in and asked for Seohyun to be in it instead.Interview?They might be lying though.I don't have a link but maybe you can search it.

+Brielle Ong As if. Dont be so naive and believe anything. SM decided who's in a unit, the members don't have any say in it.

+Brielle Ong lol that is not non of taeyeon's business. If Tae kickad out Sica the members Would hate her and leave the group, cuz they maybe think some day she maybe want to kick out you or something and if they didn't leave the group IT would be ver AKWARD betwen them

I see it

Omg it did happened 😂😂

Ew hell no

Sooyoung is not a bullier 😒

sooyoung honey im so so sorry

:)

What the..

trur

true

50% YES, because they suck. 50% NO, because they have Girls' Generation, Super Junior, TVXQ, SHINee, EXO, f(x), BoA, Kangta, The Grace, Red Velvet, Trax, NCT and few more artists that aren't mentioned. I just hope they change the CEO into someone who has a real heart.

Franklin Babia The head sucks. But honestly , they produce quality artists. I mean GG and RV are great examples.

It was originally like that... JTS (Jessica, Tiffany and Seohyun), but idk why they debuted as TTS (Taeyeon, Tiffany, Seohyun). You can hear JTS Oppa Nappa

Golden Star Number 1 I think she was trying to say Jessica instead of Tiffany (Taeyon, Jessica, Seohyun) but then if that happened their voice ranges would be too alike idk why people hate TTS trio, I think their voice ranges fit more than TJS honestly

Jimin's tears I know he/she meant Jess instead of Tiffany, what i said is just curiosity because people dont know that it was originally JTS. Some people say Jess doesnt fit TTS songs, but if Jesa were picked instead of Tae, the songs obviously wouldnt be the same, remember that the person who picks the song for the group, picks the song according to their voices, or simply, Tiffany and Seo would just have different lines in the songs :p personally i am Still curious about JTS... :( or TaeSica subunity (that obviously would have never been planed)

oh hahaha, oops my bad. And yes I am curious about JTS too D: so sad they didn't get to have another song...

No jessica have a sub group along with krystal so she replaced by seohyun

pinkvelvet biased af she's as shaky as an earthquake lol

박다니엘 fyi, I'm not even a sone and I only stan Taeyeon there then I just like the rest of the members, nothing else. I'm not really biased. I'm just giving my opinion, I'm not telling you a fact alright?

박다니엘 and I think Sunny did a good job singing that lines.

pinkvelvet just add "in my opinion" cause you look like saying some facts there

Sunny has a reaaally soothing sound to her high notes. I love listening to them.

Thank you!!

honestly idk why they are saying jessica’s voice is better. To me, it’s seohyun. Jessica’s voice is great and unique but for not this kind of song

Thats why its shocking that she isnt given more parts and treated like a subvocalist most of the time

KPOP IS LIFE People are still believing that snsd kicked out/bullied sica? That was old drama that’s not even true at all. The girls have long said that if you are not snsd, you’ll never know how they feel about each other. Friendship of more than 8 years is not easily broken with a simple quarrel or disagreement. SM made her leave the group and the company, not snsd. Even if snsd wanted her to stay, she couldn’t. SM has and always will be the decision maker and their artists have no rights to control their management.

@@JS-wj1cs true.. I really don't understand until now already 2021 people still believe to that theory that makes no sense at all.. But still jessica departure is really mysterious cause no one really knows what happened except sm, snsd members and music industry people..

thanks