One Sweet Day not even making the main bracket is a….. choice!

I choose My All because it showcases perfectly the reason why she became THE Mariah Carey, her voice. Dreamlover sure gives vocals, but My All is just clean, sophisticated, classy, RnB but a power ballad, it's everything I want from Mariah

One sweet day. Period. One of the most beautiful songs to ever exist

To be fair, Mariah doesn't hate the song Someday, just the music video because she had no creative control over it.

Saying the vocals on "One Sweet Day" were "lovely" is BLASPHEMOUS. Please see all the ladies trying to screlt the song at karaoke and realize they slayed the F out of those vocals. Still love you though. #JusticeforOneSweetDay

It truly is crazy how so many of her number ones could be her best. Her catalog is crazy. Always Be My Baby and Fantasy are quintessential Mariah imo even though Butterfly is my favorite album of hers.

20 minutes of why Daydream is Mariah's most evergreen era.

“Vision of Love” is my absolute favorite Mariah Carey song. The undulating beat, soulful vocals, and contemplative lyrics are perfect for warm and lazy summer days. It’s perfection. ✨✨✨

Whole heartedly agree with the winner - “always be my baby”. This song is timeless.

My personal choice would be Fantasy. That song encapsulates EVERYTHING about Mariah: vocals, amazing runs, melody, catchy hooks, great sample usage and that mixture of Pop with hip hop... How could a track simply top that? ❤ I find My All to be her best ballad. You guys pointed it out everything but the lyrics which are stellar! It's that great balance between emotion, sexyness and longing without being cheesy. Honey it's amazing! Can't believe Matt overlooked it SO badly lol I Don't Wanna Cry is my favorite song from debut and that Tokyo Dome performance is out of this world. Even though I don't like certain aspects of the production (which I think Mariah doesn't either lol) it's a very beautiful song. I find Always Be My Baby to be really overrated. Maybe because it was overplayed a lot recently but I barely come back to it still, I think is the 3rd best track on Daydream behing Fantasy and Underneath the Stars 🤔

Saying telephone is better than one sweet day? JAIL! Lol JAIL JAIL JAIL … but omg thank god I found you I do hate but the remix is AMAZING

Don’t Forget About Us over One Sweet Day is a hate crime omg

Yeah… always be my baby is the right choice! Y’all did it

I think it should be My All.. On the writing, vocal, production?? and its on its own level. Like many can sing always be my baby but noone can ever top how Mariah sang My All, like they can do their own lil version and sing it on their highest capabilities but it will never ever touch how MC sang My All. I rest my case. You can all go and @ me. I'll fight. period.

THE PASSION! OMG this was a trip.

In her 12 years on earth lol the words of a true lamb

while i can absolutely say with certainty that "My All" might be Mariah's best #1 (for me), that doesnt mean it's my favorite #1 lol I think Fantasy is my favorite #1 from Mariah

#1s edition best upbeat - Dreamlover best ballad - My All

Can you guys make more videos like this for Mariah’s other songs? I could watch them all day!

Ouch! Love takes time is a nostalgic one for me so sad to see it out so fast. 😢🤣

predicted the results right from the beginning 🤣 lambstinct is real

Oh... Not liking One Sweet Day is a big choice, BUT I will say I think I prefer the Chucky's version!! And those acapella moments from the 30th anniversary EP collection were exquisite imo. What do you guys think?? Great video btw, I always enjoy watching someone else do song brackets cuz I couldn't do it myself lmao. xx❤

It’s my All, no question for me.

tbh this was such a close final two bc these songs are very similar down to the range and everything but i think that always be my baby is just so influential to how i feel what i do and sometimes how my day goes

Ahhh I did my own bracket of this a while ago and am so excited to compare my thoughts to yours! P.s. speaking of Thank God I Found You Remix, my controversial opinion is that it shouldn't be called a remix but instead a cover. It doesn't really keep any of the original elements of the song (apart from the short 'thank god I found you, I was so lost without you...' part at the very end), so I don't think it carries enough over from the original to be called a remix. And then if you listen to Keith Sweat's Make It Last Forever, you realise pretty much everything from that song is used in this song. The only real differences are the added Nas verse and the slightly different production - even the runs/ad libs are mostly the same. I'm surprised I haven't seen any other lambs talk about this. Wondering what you think about it Matt Palmer?

i 100% agree on one sweet day!

Is such a bless for a musical theatre fan plus a Mariah Carey fan to find your channel❤❤❤? SO INTO THIS VIDEO PLEASE DO THIS MOREEEE

I Don’t Wanna Cry at Rotterdam is even better than Tokyo Dome! I swear, I was changed when her debut came out so to see Love Takes Time and Someday gone so early- it hurts!

I remember Mariah doing something like this on tiktok and never actually finished it because picking her 1 favorite song is hard for her!! Hahaha but I would've let My All win

Gasp thank god I found u the original version was a childhood fav of mine and it’s HIGH on my ranking

Love this ❤

I agree that Always be my baby is her best song. In fact it is my favorite song of her. In ABMB you get all the elements of Mariah and her Pen game, along with her great vocal abilities. I have always seen Mariah like this light type of girl who wanted to conquer the world and be in love. It's kinda her shtick and what she represented in her career. And you hear Always be my baby it gives you the same feeling nostalgia, lightness, joy, catchiness with great vocal layerings. In my opinion it is her trademark song and her best song! I have to add that I disagree on One sweet day. That song was huge and remarkable. A few mariah songs that are great but I never really cared for are Heartbreaker, dreamlover, Honey. Like there are better songs that should have made the bracket like Breakdown, Can't let go, The roof, I know what you want

WE LOVE YOU TWO GAY MATTS GOD BLESS YOU FOREVER THANK YOU FOR SHINING YOUR BEAUTIFUL AND BRILLIANT LIGHT

I let One Sweet Day slide because it's beloved more for sentimental reasons, I believe, than the incredible technical skills.... BUT WHEN YOU CUT HERO. Hero is the greatest song she ever wrote/song.... it's Anointed... it's a gift from GOD. And to think you left in Don't Forget About Us, which I wholeheartedly forgot was even a song. 😟😤🤣😭😒

#JusticeForFantasy

My All is my favorite Mariah's single. And it will always be. There's something about this song that just hits different.

Oh my god a Mariah video (i am still sick but i am gonna be back on patreon too miss the Cathy's) Wow one sweet day didn't make it 😮 how on earth

Underneath the stars is my favourite

One Sweet Day already garnered it's glory days, it's a good time for other songs to shine more. Fair enough

Rock Paper Scissors came through with the right answer. Loved the discussion overall and agreed with most of your picks. Glad that "Don't Forget About Us" won the initial round - underrated song, and I think everyone who loved radio in the 90s knows "One Sweet Day" was overplayed to death (when so many other Daydream songs were better).

Aww I really enjoyed this battle. 🎉🎉🎉❤

I need you guys doing a collab with The Mariah Report Podcast ♥

This is such a great video! I'm sad that Vision of Love got dropped so soon. But agreed with almost all the choices. The last one had to be Always Be My Baby! Definitely like making Sophie's choice!

The fact that Fantasy didn’t make it to the final round is so unserious 👀

My All for the vocal and the MOOD which is why it's #1 for me. ABMB is about the bop and NASTALGIA. 2 things I find battle uncanny: 1. WBT and ABMB were the biggest MC RADIO hits of their decade. ABMB spent the longest running for her in the 90's and WBT broke radio and listener records. 2. AIWFCIY and Fantasy have been in multiple movies.

Lezzz goooo, dahlingsss! ❤️🥰🤩 #Lambs4Life

Imagine these two with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang + Kelly Clarkson just stanning over Mariah for a whole hour. Ugh

For me fantasy will always be the top girl she was the first song i fell in love with

Justice for Fantasy and VOL

lol y’all legit got down to my favorite two Mariah songs. My all and abmb

Always be my baby is my favorite mariah carey song I'm 😅pleased

TGIFY, OSD, DFAU and Someday NOT EVEN MAKING THE BRACKET?!?! Y'all are about to catch some hands!!!!

That wasn't Whistle Register that was head voice trey used D6 note.

All i want for christmas iss you out of the top 4 is a crime. If you played it right now you would regret yout decisions. You will wish it was christmas everyday!

Oh God no emotions vs fantasy . I couldn't do this challenge.. but yeah fantasy. How van you make me choose darling. Lol

I paused this video several times to listen to the songs in the bracket.

imo the best mariah song is and will always be we belong together

Cutting Fantasy! Be serious?!

I kinda Spaced Out after hearing that Matt hasn't heard some of the most AMAZING REMIXES 😧😦😮😯😲😳🤯😫😫😫

ABMB at number 1 is well-deserved. One of the best pop bridges of all time!

Yea id pick dont forget about us over one aweet day too.

One Sweet Day not even making the bracket is a crime. It being her longest #1 should make it automatic advanced.

You should do this type of video solely on REMIXES! Haha. Because while all the songs are classics, some of the remixes are actually improvements; to me, at least. The ‘All I Want For Xmas’ SoSo Def Remix has some of her most creative whistles. ‘Thank God I Found You’ Make it Last remix w Joe & Nas is amazing… and ‘My All/Stay Awhile’ with Lord Tariq & Peter Gunz is something ELSE! ‘We Belong Together’ remix is almost better than the ballad! With Jadakiss and Styles P… ‘Always Be My Baby’ remix with DaBrat and Xscape! Kandi and Tiny!! Haha. Even the Soso Def HONEY remix (with Brat) is so much fun. It’s kind of a mess but in a good way. Also underrated is the ‘HATEU’ remix with Big Boi and Gucci Mane. Less sad and depressing than the original!

it's honestly so hard to pick between My All and ABMB. but i give it to ABMB because while being a fan-favorite, it is also more popular to the general public than My All.

How could you pick Always, over we belong together 😭 Just screamed at my phone!

Do you have any other bracket videos I can watch after this? 😆

I preferred My All, but Always Be My Baby is a CLASSIC!!! Loved this video guys, y’all showing why being a Lamb is iconic, great content! 💕

can we get an in the cuts version for all the major lambs that know all her gems :)

If I only had one song to listen to ever, My All would be it... I've gone through about 5 iPods and its always been the top played song in every ipod.

My All is truly something special.

Love u guys for this. 💙✌🏻 My take on her number ones: "Someday" & "Vision of love" the live versions are MUCH BETTER than the originals. "Thank god I found you" the climax is kind of annoying and the song is kind of forgettable. The remix is a KILLER though.

OSD not even making your top 16 shows just how strong her discography is... for me it will definitely be in my top 5. Can we have one for her non number 1 singles too.

Queen Mariah Carey

Great content gentlemen. 🏳️‍🌈

My favorites are not even #1s. Fly Like A Bird, Butterfly, and Breakdown!!!

My All ftw!!!

#justiceforfantasy She has sooooooo many, this had to be hard, but fun! ❤️

Between the final two, for me, it's Always Be My Baby, and it's not even close. NOT. EVEN. CLOSE.

I hope Mariah has seen this video ❤😊

i agree with my all over fantasy although IT WAS PAINFUL

There were some moments of this video that truly felt homophobic. Like, certain songs should have been pitted against songs that a little bit more distinct from the ones selected, but ultimately, the right song won: "Always Be My Baby" is peak-Mariah Carey. It's got phenomenal vocals and stellar background vocals, brilliant production, a magnificent composition, stunning lyricism, and it's just fucking catchy as all hell! Once you listen to it, you never forget it. That's one of those songs that you remember where you were physically, mentally and emotionally in your life and recall everything. It's pop nirvana and R&B heaven rolled into one. Most artists at that time in her career would have just floated by on celebrity and she just kept getting better with each release. ("Daydream" is to Mariah as "4" is to Beyoncé, a stellar album that changed how we listened to pop/R&B that got its flowers later on and shows its influence over time.) We stan!

Always be my baby all the way. Hunny yes

Someday is honestly in my top 5 but it’s impossible to choose

More Mariah!

I’ll be There was the first song in which the original and the cover both hit #1. How is that underrated??

I have always not really loved one sweet day

HONEY OVER VOL JAIL

can we talk about the VH1 Divas performance of my all??

From one LAMB to another You got it RIGHT 😂😂😂😂 I disagreed with 2 songs but u got the WINNER correct. DO DO DO..... OH!! LAMBILY ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ HAPPY PRIDE ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

SMH Emotions is her strongest song.

Nope to almost all of this. I love all these songs, but Always Be My Baby has never been my favorite and (in my opinion) is more sing songy than One Sweet Day. Played it for my 22 year kld foster son and he was not impressed at all, meaning it doesnt necessarily resonate with the younger crowd. His pick was Fantasy and We Belong Together. Oh and My All.

This was waaayyyyy too difficult

I always hated One Sweet Day. It's maudlin.

Nahhh Dreamlover tops

Love the idea of the video, but I think is disrespectful to knock off some of them. She busted her butt since day one composing, performing and producing to create her unbeatable body of work for 33 years almost non stop. It's not fair for her, you can completely dislike her music but it's undeniable that it is top of the top and what other singers aspire to at least have a 1/ 5 of her success. It's not OK to reduce her accomplishments and legacy to the industry. Mariah disses someday because they forced her to change the production to make it more radio friendly with the h3lp of Ben Margulies but that's not even close to what she envisioned for her song. One sweet day was recorded because Mariah reached out to them for a song she was work8ng on because she had lost a dear friend to her from AIDS and what was cool is that Boyz II Men were working on a very similar song because they had just post their manager I think it was. If you listen to a version acapella there a few verses before the original released song status and that's the part Boyz had worked and then after that it switches to Mariahs lyrics alternating both their lyrics. The song in my opinion and popular opinion as well is that I lived up to the heightbI mean it was the 4th song ever to debut at #1 and stayed atop for 16 weeks holding the reco4d for 27 years

What kind of Mariah stan doesn’t love One Sweet Day?! 😭😭😭

I disagree with every choice they made in this video, smh 🙄

Meh, for me; My All and We Belong Together are not my fav.... Not live for them, their good though but not really my thing....🤔 Meh!!🤷🏿‍♂️

It's My All. Argue with the wall.

Next vid...her #2's?