Paul is baaack🙌🏼

Biggest crime I have committed in commander was when I played mono green and a friend sent his giant creature over at someone else and he blocked with a 1/1 to chump block and I cast poison the blade on the 1/1 giving it deathtouch…

My biggest crime in commander was two counts of vehicular manslaughter

I don't think it was mechanically a crime, but while playing my Mr. House, President and CEO (dice rolling) commander deck that I made, I convinced a player to let me hit them so that I could get treasures to deal with the "problem." The problem was, of course, my best friend playing Rin and Seri, Inseparable who had built up a massive board state of cats and dogs. After I hit the first player, I used the treasures to cast Reckless Endeavor: Roll 2 d12, pick one result and make that many treasures, then deal damage to every creature equal to the other. I rolled a 12 on the first roll (obviously took 12 treasures) and a 6 on the second roll, dealing six to everything and almost wiping the board. Then, with the 12 treasures, I re-casted Mr. House as well as a Wand of Wonder, with just enough treasure left over to activate its effect. They both exiled cards from the top of their libraries until they hit an instant or sorcery. I rolled a d20 and not only made a robot and a treasure off it, but I also was able to cast both of the spells they exiled, both of which happened to be removal spells. So I wiped their last two creatures. I passed the turn with a big grin while my best friend scowled at me.

My biggest crime probably was playing hullbreacher post ban 😂

That's a nice table. No artwork to distract and large enough to be comfortable.

The Big Score (on 27:17) shouldn't have been copied since by the time Galvanic Iteration resolves, Big Score had already been cast therefore still not being the next instant or sorcery Esmond casts. But if anybody thinks I'm getting it wrong please let me know!

Playing Thieves Auction in a 6 man pod. Was fun resolving. For those who haven't had the pleasure. All cards are exiled. Starting with me, each player chooses one of the exiled cards and puts it into play tapped. Repeat until all cards have been chosen. Its just a really fun way to balance out the things in play.

17:39 Stella triggers after casting radical idea as it's the second spell. Great game, guys

My biggest crime in commander was countering my friends commander on his first time casting his commander. It was such a great play, that no one seen coming. It is still funny years later

Welcome back Paul. Congratulations! My biggest commander crime ever was getting Heartless Hidetugu out on Turn 3, Casting Neheb the Eternal on turn 4, tapping HH to cut everyone's life total in half, then dumping 58 R in to Comet Storm and wiping out the table. The point was proven, so I immediately took HH out of the deck. lol.

Biggest crime was definitely a windfall and a hullbreacher into a kicked rite of replication on a sakashima copy of vial smasher

The frustrated "Bro. I feel like everything that I stole has been taken away from me ..." is such a good comment.

Day is always made when I see a new Quintessential commander! Love your content thanks for all the hard work!

Giveaway ends Sunday 28th April! Winner's comment will be replied to with instructions :) Watch our top picks from OTJ/OTC/BIG --> kzfaq.info/get/bejne/nr-lppuEs9Gnm6c.html

Biggest crime not seeing Paul more

Very late to this, it's been a busy month! Man, I love these Precons. The outlaws and gonti steal decks especially seem interesting and fun to play

Biggest crime I ever committed in commander was ten years ago. LGS wanted to try something crazy. They pushed all the tables together and had us play a 17 person Commander game. I played Daretti STAX.

My biggest crime is turn four we got all of our basic lands out in the field because someone played collective voyage we all payed and fetched and I mass land destruction while I had Malcom on the field to make treasures .

Would love to see an updated Lathril commander vs video !!

Niv Mizzet does work here, lol

the biggest crime i committed in commander was finally finally finally doing my 1 shot malignus combo! i run xenagos god of revels commander who doubles a creatures stats and gives them haste during combat, malignus power and toughness are equeal to half the highest life total rounded up! i have never 1 shot any1 with malignus yet, but i finally finally finally pulled it off!!

I played the pirate precon from lost caverns. I had the pirate that steals stuff until end of turn when I play a pirate. I was steal maybe 2-3 creatures a turn. I killed someone with their own commander’s commander damage. Felt good. Fun crimes

biggest crime i committed was accidental mass land destruction with one generous gift and the effect of a plane in planechase copying the spell for each permanent it could target xD

I guess my biggest commander crime is not having bought any of the Thunder Junction precons yet... They look like great fun, espescially with the bounty cards🤘

Biggest crime recently was scute swarm with impacts treamoure combined with lots and lots of landfall triggers. The math is pretty hard at one point 😂

GG! Greatest sin in Commander... Hrmm... Having the minerals to play a Nekusar wheel deck with narset/notion thief... I have changed a lot since those days!

My biggest crime is in a three pod me and another player had an alliance agents the third. The third swung a 10/10 that they could not block and I casted a tainted strike giving it infect.

Biggest crime was building a Tatyova deck that ran extra turn spells, with a loop that let me play infinite turns. My friends and I were playing and when I was about to pop off, my legit 25-or-so minute turn happened and I think one of them went for a smoke break, only to return to me still going on my 5th or so turn. I won that game... but at what cost?

Does galvanic iteration from mizzix mastery actually get to copy big score? It says next spell you cast but big score is already cast at that point

My biggest crime with MTG was during a pre-release party of Scars of Mirrodin. My friend pulled out a Sword of Body and Magic, which hyped us till I saw my pack which had a Sword of Body and Mind but foiled! Then I proceeded to play with it unsleeved, getting comments from everyone.

My biggest Commander crime would have to be Strip Mining five times in a single turn due to play lands from GY and extra land drops

My biggest crime is probably me somehow always drawing into Windfall + Narset, Parter of Veils every time I play my Jhoira deck lol

My biggest crime in commander was flickering Fall of the Thran with Aminatou every turn with Polluted Bonds on the Battlefield.....

biggest crime was probably taking an almost 40 minute turn against my friend storming just to past the turn

New Studio??? great video again!

My biggest crime was playing my Baral, Chief of compliance" deck while teaching my two friends to play... I had to teach them about counter spells too which was my justification... 😅

My biggest crime i had done back in my EDH days was KO'ing one of my opponent out with Lazav copying their Consuming Aberration that was in their yard and winning the game.

my biggest crime (embarrassment) was, having only seen massacre girl (old one) on arena i was soooo convinced that what it did was "-1-1 all creatures and only if at least a creature dies you give another -1-1". So when it was played in EDH, i called the store owner/judge cause i never conceived that it actually gives a -1-1 for EACH creature that dies on each wave . ups...

My biggest crime in commander was building a Tinybones, Trinket Thief discard deck as my first deck build. Somehow I didn't expect to get targeted as aggressively as I did lol

My biggest crime was making 65 waves from master of waves, then attacking everyone and turning them into 4/4 dragons with flying.

Biggest crime is doing 3 removal spells in a row for three turns against one player's commander in a pod (we were both playing precons)

My biggest crime was winning by preventing 164 DMG with Selfless Squire to then top deck a rogues passage that made him unlockable the next turn.

Biggest crime I did was killing all my opponents with Light Paws for commander damage in a 5 player game. How? I cast Winter Orb, and once my opponents was able to scrouge up a removal for the Winter Orb, I cast Static Orb. I gave them hope, only to snuff it out right before their eyes.

My biggest crime in commander is between either drawing my entire deck twice in one turn (basically) and making people sit through that 5 year long turn oooor building a Voja deck. That card itself is criminal

Biggest Crime might have been one sided Board Wipes with Hinata as Commander, so noone was able to have anything except for me

My biggest crime was using Magda, Brazen Outlaw to tutor a Reaver Titan to the battlefield on turn 3 - definitely could have been worse, but the deck was built with a $50 budget

I’ve countered my buddy’s command 3 times in one game. It was a cascading Eldrazi, so if that makes me a criminal then I don’t want to be a lawman.

Crime..? Probably. I tuned 2 Boros Charmed a sol ring. This was a commander game at work and haste was in order 👿.

Everyone’s biggest crime “my deck is a 7”

My biggest commander crime is when I first started playing I countered someone’s commander on turn 2 and got targeted the rest of the game 😂 didn’t realize it was a rude thing to do!

My biggest crime in commander was waiting too long to start playing :D

My biggest crime in commander was copyright infringement by copying my opponent's commander to win the game with Orvar. Basically, I had a faerie artisan on board and managed to make a token copy of Narset, Enlightened Exile and Kykar, Wind's Fury over two turns. Normally, the token would be exiled when faerie artisans create a new token copy whenever a creature ETB under an opponent's control. However, with Orvar on board, I managed to create permanent copies of Narset and Kykar and the rest was history.

Biggest Crime I have committed in commander was just playing my best mono-white commander Khemba, Kha Regent and going ham with commander damage Hammer-time style while just pumping out that cat-army

I cycled Decree of Annihilation for free with Gavi, then cast Teferi's Protection in response. It's not technically a Crime, but it certainly felt like it.

My biggest crime was probably stealing a greater gargadon with captain n'ghathrod in a precon battle, was very funny to mill into a 10 mana creature even if it's not that game ending

My biggest crime is having Grave Pact and Dictate of Erobos on the table at the same time in my Meren deck. My Playgroup has locked up those cards in solitary confinement!

Best pod!!!

My biggest crime playing God-Pharaoh's Statue turn 2 with my Belbe deck.

I pulled a Terastadon off of a Kinnan activation and blew up the only three lands one of my opponents had... I still feel bad about it to this day

the biggest crime i've committed in commander is playing and continuing to upgrade Tergrid lol

My biggest crime? I made someone rage quit and leave the store in the middle of a commander tournament by being petty. Once upon a time, a teenage boy played commander with people he thought were mature adults. One of these people mental misstepped my sol ring and then strip mined my land in the first turn. I did nothing that game until I died. I was pissed. I understand countering sol ring, but the strip mine had no good reason to be done. A few weeks later, I'm playing a game with said adult and a friendly Canadian. The friendly guy played insurrection and could only kill me (I was the problem and needed to die). However, I wanted payback and would rather have the friendly guy win. So I flashed out a creature that gave everything doublestrike, killing us both. I felt very vindicated.

Biggest crime was when i filling for a 4th person in a pod while playing my Wyleth deck and no one told me everyone els was playing stock precons when mine definitely wasn't... Feels bad

why am i not surprised esmond is on stella lee xD tbf i thought gonti but this works well!

My biggest crime in commander was stealing a man’s midnight clock when it had 11 counters 😅

Biggest crime is talking someone out of playing a wrath and then proceeding to kill them with craterhoof

My biggest crime had to be letting my friend tutor 3 cards to the top of his deck only for me to -1 Ashiok Dream Render making him scoop because I milled and exiled his infinite combo

Paul 'Yep yep yep yep yep yep yep"

My biggest crime was playing Malcolm alluring scoundrel to play omniscience for free into ulamog kozalek and Jin-gitaxis

My biggest EDH crime was stealing a voltron commander with Reaver Cleaver attached, hitting the owner, then pinging down the table with Agent of the Iron Throne & all those treasures (doubled by my partner commanders).

My biggest crime would have to be when playing my rakdos chaos deck, I had endless whispers and confusion in the ranks out at the same time.

My biggest crime was using theft effects to steal all my friend's new, expensive cards so I got to try them before he did lmao

The biggest commander crime I’ve ever committed is to keep a one land hand and still ramp out to 6 mana on turn 2

My friend pulled an ancient Bronze dragon in a draft and i sent it back to his hand on his etb, then exiled it the second time he tried to play it.

Would you still have to discard the extra card for copying big score?

My biggest crime was getting an Opposition Agent with a Wishclaw Talisman .

My biggest crime is casting windfall while having a notion thief on the battlefield.

My biggest crime in commander is playing Malcolm monoblue extra turns

My biggest crime i commited is where i wanted to help with a treat onboard and did make a deal to chaos warp a token for the chance of an answer. I hit Phage, the untouchable and my partner in crime died instead. Ups 😅

there's a commander from LCI called Inti, Seneschal of the Sun... it kinda sounds like Qu(Inti, Seneschal) MTG 😂

My biggest crime was probably killing someone on turn 3 with my Killian deck with infect. 😂

My biggest crime is killing my friends commander every single time it hit the battlefield 6 times in a single game. He was playing hakbal of the surging soul. I used so much target removal lol

Biggest crime was attempting to play windfall with shabraz and brallin out

My biggest crime was playing a relic of progenitus in a pod full of graveyard decks (I was satisfied)

My biggest crime was focusing every counter spell I had on one of my friends ( high salt level) and forgetting the rest of the table.

Biggest crime I committed in commander, I destroyed someone's permanent which really has a huge benefit to that player and conceded, cause I need to leave right away hehe.

Test of endurance in a life gain cleric deck 😂

My biggest crime was killing my 5 man pod by turn 8 or so with Neyali and some phyrexian mites.

Definitely telling my friends my deck was a 7 and then unintentionally popping off too hard

Biggest crime I've commuted in commander was when I blew up someone's sol ring on turn 2

My biggest crime has to be last saturday. I stole all my opponents creatures with Reins of Power, then after attacking him and leaving him at 4 HP I gave all his creatures away with Coveted Falcon to another opponent.

My biggest crime in commander would definitely be playing decree of annihilation after world gorgeous dragon resolves!

My biggest crime in commander was stealing my opponents abomination of llanowar in a changeling deck and killing him with his commander damage using rogues passage.

Biggest commander crime was putting 100 scute swarms on the board.

My bigggest crime in commander I think it was decimate turn 3 to my opponent, I target this ones: ancient tomb, mana crypt, bird of paradise and Concordant Crossroads; he hates me so much jajajaja, but I did what I had to, because I was scared of guishat dino xD

I made a deck with as many board wipes as I could. ...only got to cast 4 before I was HORRIBLY MANGLED. I'm writing this now from Valhalla. At least I went out swinging....and wiping...

What's my crime? Had a game someone using Slicer from the transformers set against me. He hit me with it, passed it to me. I proceeded to Imprison it in the Moon while under my control. I paid for my crime though. 3 mana for one colorless....but he was locked out of his commander 😂

Never committed a crime

My biggest crime was stealing Marit Lage from one of my opponents to then kill the Korvold player before he could pop off.

the biggest crime i've committed in commander is destroying all the attractions an opponent had just played with aura shards and grand crescendo