Hey Robb, you are right everyone does start with 2 water tokens. And yes the Dice are returned. The rules never indicate where the sold out perfume tiles go, it is implied on the Board Game Geek forms that you can just leave them in the players perfumery, (which is what we do), or return them to the box, since they are not put back into the bag, since one of the end game triggers is the fragrance note tiles running out. Thanks for watching and catching and clarifying those 2 rules. Mark aka Tiets

In Setup (pg. 2), each player starts with 2 water tokens. Also, after completing the 2nd phase ("finished product"), all aroma dice are returned to the market (pg. 6), thus are available for the next player. One question, though: What happens to the fragrance notes (tiles) after the perfume is sold out?