I think Taeyeon the only one who fit to sing this. I thought IU voice would fit in this song but I feel like her voice is too light if that make sense like Taeyeon did it with depth. I stan Queens Edit: 6.6K wow how to handle fameee 😂😂 but anyway stop fighting guys like everyone has a different opinion and of course my opinion is Taeyeon is the only one who could really do justice with her song and the only person who I think who can give a little bit justice is Eunji

At this rate, all artist will sing this song except Taeyeon herself

I have to agree with Sooyoung. She once said when Taeyeon sang an OST, it felt like the main female character was singing. That's the one thing that differentiates Taeyeon from any other singers. Even I feel like Taeyeon's version is more Jang Manwol ish than IU's. That's not a bad thing, tho.

I feel like Taeyeon set the bar too high that all the other singers don't impress me as much as Taeyeon did when I first heard the song. They're all great singers tho :)

Wow wendy. She is the best since like she covered the song without any difficulty

As a Taeyeon's fan. I can tell that Wendy got the best cover of this song

Wendy’s cover was the best imo. She has really great control and her tone actually suits this song. Also she sang the high part 0:23 (original) 2:35 (wendy’s cover) soo smoothly without pausing.

Wendy did the best cover. She did not seem struggling with the breathing while singing in high notes.

Wendy and Punch seem to be the most effortless ones, kudos to the rest. That Seungsik guy has good emotions and control. Miyeon could do muuuch much better.

Doyoung actually harmonized with taeyeon. Damn the talent on that kid

For me, only Wendy did it like how Taeyeon sang the song

I want to see taeyeon and wendy singing this song live😭😭

Omo Wendy Can Sing like Taeyeon !!.. 😍💕 same Agency maybe Same technique !!!... Love Both of you ....

I really like when wendy singing that song, her voice similar to taeyeon😍

Wendy's voice stand out among all the girls in this video also Eun Ji. I agree with comments. Woojin & Do young for the boys. The vocalist of Melomance have a very unique voice I feel like he can make the song his own. Taeyeon queen

A perfect example of how a song can be technically challenging without crazy octaves and belting. The breath control required for this song is pretty intense and as shown how many artistes ended up sounding breathless or airy because of incorrect technique.

00:30 IU 01:10 Punch 01:40 Eunji (Apink) 02:12 Wendy (Red Velvet) 02:43 Hyunjin (Stray Kids) 03:02 Yeoreum & Dawon (WJSN) 03:33 Wonpil (DAY6) 04:04 Yooa & Seunghee (OH MY GIRL) 04:34 Seola & Soobin (WJSN) 05:06 Lyn 05:40 Seungsik (VICTON) 06:11 Miyeon ((G)I-DLE) 06:41 Gyuri (fromis_9) 07:12 Mia (Everglow) 07:41 Doyoung (NCT 127) 08:12 Eunwoo (HINAPIA) 08:43 Seoryoung (GWSN) 09:13 Sunghun (CIX) 09:49 Jiwoo (KARD) 10:20 Yuju (GFRIEND) 10:51 Minseok (Melomance) 11:25 Elkie (CLC) 11:55 Bora (Cherry Bullet) 12:27 Woojin (Stray Kids) 12:58 Chaewon (APRIL) 13:30 Sohee (ELRIS) 14:00 Binnie (OH MY GIRL) 14:48 Byungchan (VICTON) 15:08 Jin (Lovelyz) 15:30 Donghun (A.C.E) 16:02 Haebin (Gugudan) I don't know why I am doing this. It's late night tho, many mistake there hehe.

I didn’t know so many singers covered this song!

다 좋지만 그래도 태연 노래는 태연이 부른 게 진짜 제일 너무 좋다ㅜㅜㅜ

Wendy, Seungsik, Yeoreum, Haebin, Seola, Doyoung, Chaewon and Gyuri did a good cover of this song.

Tbh Wendy did the best cover for this song.. I heard it on her ig live and she was so humble saying that she need to improve on her vocals

For me, Wendy is the best. Her voice suit this song.

Shows that Taeyeon's voice is really perfect for the song. Wendy's version is the best for me out of all the covers. I also like Punch, Seungsik, Gyuri, Mia, Seoryoung, and Donghun's cover

I think iu, wendy, seungsik, wonpil, punch, woojin, Lyn, but of course taeyeon still legend

Wow wendy’s cover was really good. Her control is amazing!

I like it how doyoung chose to sing in a different note/key (idk how to say it in english) instead of singing with the same note/key like taeyeon In simple, he harmonized.

Wendy did an excellent job. Her emotions as expected is always on point. Truely a great vocalist.

Wendy has the Unique quality of a Vocal Chameleon. She has so many hidden voices in her body that she can summon it just like that. She sang along Chanyeol in 'Stay with me' at SMTOWN stage and she sounded nearer to Punch and performed it so beautifully without overpowering the male singer. Same thing happened here :)

My favourite: wendy and wonpil Addition: seungsik

Honestly Taeyeon's emotion in the voice surprises me everytime when other singers sing her song... Really you need to be VERY talented to cover Taeyeon's songs

Taeyeon sings with a tear drop in her voice. So effortless and crisp. I could listen to her sing all day.

Wendy is clearly the best out of everyone that covered this song. Everyone else were either short of breath and/or their techniques were nowhere near Wendy or Taeyeon’s. IU, Punch and Lynn incorporated their styles but I don’t know if they’re a good match. Taeyeon and Wendy have this thickness(?) to their voices regardless of how high the notes they have to hit. I think that’s a unique advantage

Taeyeon as mother and Wendy as her daughter 💙

Our Son Seungwan. 💙💙💙

If you talking about who sing this song so great, of course Taeyeon, since this was her own song 😄 if we talking about who is best covering, i think all of ppl who covered this song are best. They sing with their own style and their vocal colour. But i appreaciate to Seungsik Victon an Wonpil Day6 since they are men who sing like this are their own song.

Only Punch and Wendy did a good cover. I was hoping IU would do a good job since i like her voice alot but it didnt match with this song . Taeyeon's voice really suits this song ive been listening to this song non-stop after watching hotel del luna.

am I the only one who really like seungsik cover??

taeyeon(ofc), wonpil day6, wendy rv bessstttttt for me😭👌🏻

Damn Wendy! Those effortless vibratos are so good 😭😭

Gyuri gave this song a whole different feel and perspective. Like a daughter longing for a father instead of longing for a partner perspective.

wendy and doyoung really suits the song ♥

Wendy❤❤❤

Female:Wendy Male:Doyoung Like literally ya'll expected that coming from SM! I love sm artists so much not sm itself tho lmao

I respect everyone who covers Taeyeon's song with wonderful voices. But let's face the fact.... The only one who can sing Taeyeon's song is Taeyeon herself

every singer deliver the song differently but everyone did their best covering the song! really love them all, esp taeyeon💜 edit: wendy is indeed the second taeyeon in this generation. just saying.

Wendy The Best Cover 💙💙

Taeyeon voice still the one who fit this song well😌wendy's cover the best among them

Seungsik from Victon actually did pretty

I can't really imagine someone singing the original song other than taeyeon. Like everytime I hear her voice I feel like crying, it's just so beautiful. Btw, I like Seungwan's voice the most out of them. It's more stable when hitting those high notes and is so nice to hear just like Taeyeons. Well, what do you expect from SM artists.

Wendy did an excellent job. Her emotions as expected is always on point.

Wendy! 😍😍 that’s why I’ve been a fan of SM artists for years 🥰 Edit: forgot to write the word “fan of” 😅

SEUNGSIK MY BABY DID SO WELL OMG!! THE EMOTIONS IN HIS VOICE AND CONTROL IS INSANE

Taeyeon we r always proud of you and your voice♥️😭😭

They’re all good but only king taeyeon rock this song

There's something about that third line until the end of the chorus that makes it so hard to replicate and Taeyeon did it even better in the live performance (that crescendo was an eargasm), plus the volume control this song requires skill. For me Wendy, Punch and Chaewon did well

I love Wonpil and Seungsik covers the most. Wonpil's tone is just so satisfying and Seungsik definitely had the best vocal control

KIM TAEYEON your best👏👍👍😍 Wendy and Doyoung👏👏

As expected Taeyeon 💓💓

They all really nice but honestly wendy delivers it the best here. I think taeyeon and wendy are really good at putting the right emotion and controlling between emotion and technique. They sounds like they’re singing while delivering a message but without overdoing it.

wendy sounds like taeyeon!! 🥺💓

Wendy my seungwan

I hope Taeyeon will perform this song on Seoul Music Awards 🙏

0:31 IU 1:09 Punch 1:41 Eunji (Apink) 2:11 Wendy (Red Velvet) 2:43 Hyunjin (Stray Kids) 3:03 Yeoreum, Dawon (WJSN) 3:33 Wonpil (Day6) 4:03 YooA, Seunghee (Oh My Girl) 4:34 Seola, Soobin (WJSN) 5:04 Lyn 5:40 Seungsik (VICTION) 6:11 Miyeon (G)-Idle 6:41 Gyuri (fromis_9) 7:10 Mia (Everglow) 7:43 Doyoung (NCT) 8:13 Eunwoo (Hinapia/Pristin) 8:42 Seoryoung (GWSN) 9:13 Seunghun (CIX) 9:50 Jiwoo (KARD) 10:19 Yuju (GFRIEND) 10:50 Minseok (Melomance) 11:25 Elkie (CLC) 11:55 Bora (Cherry Bullet) 12:26 Woojin 12:58 Chaewon (April) 13:29 Sohee (Elris) 14:00 Binnie (Oh My Girl) 14:48 Byungchan (VICTION) 15:08 Jin (Lovelyz) 15:29 Donghun (A.C.E) 16:02 Haebin (Gugudan)

Seungsik Victon.... His voice is so beautiful and pretty

Wendy red velvet & miyeon (G) idle ❤❤

Wendy,Eunji and Seungsik..My oppinion..

I like Wendy's version the most❤

no one talked about gyuri? she's a vocalist with pretty face and has angelic voice. and also fromis_9 has vocal line are so great, especially park jiwon. if you want to watch more about gyuri singing, you can watch flaylist (fromis_9's cover songs)

So many did a cover of her songs, but the universe create the song for taeyeon only, cleanse my ears Taengoo

Taeyeon the best❤️❤️❤️❤️

Many of you already said that... they all sang pretty well but i think taeyeon's voice really makes this song so different and so magic

kim bora omg i love her voice, so angelic and calming…i hope more people appreciate her group (cherry bullet) and her as a member too

As expected, Wendy 💙

I think idol's singing to AAY has become a TREND! I'm loving it ♥️♥️

Listen to wendy ost "goodbye" you'll like it too❣️

BoA mastered the technique because Lee Soo Man wanted to replicate BoA, it is the same technique used to teach future SM female singers. Such as Taeyeon and Wendy.

is it only me who liked LYN. Her version has the emotions and she gave it her own version. but for suitability with Taeyeon I think wendy is the best.

Taeyeon’s singing is just so effortless. God, I LOVE that woman🥰🥰🥰

i like how wendy's and miyeon's voice fit with the song

The best covers were from LYN, Wendy, Wonpil and Seungsik. Doyoung was very creative tho ❤❤❤

Wendy Seunghee Seungsik Eunwoo Wonpil Sohee

Wonpil's cover was amazing

i honestly think wendy did the best cover since most of them sang it with their own rendition. Hence, singing with only instrumentals which means they can shift with the key they're most comfortable with. But dang wendy sang it with taeyeon's vocal as background and keeping the same key, range and feelings as taeyeon's tone. Do you know how hard that is? and she still slayed it. I like to hear a stage cover from her now.

When i saw Wonpil in the thumbnail i was like: *cLicK*

never listened to victon before but seungsik is really good 🥰

Damn that vocals of oh my girl. I was like😱 Also seungsik of victon. Nice vocal

Wendy and Punch 😍😍 Blue.D also made a cover of this and it sounds like heaven.

Wow. 16 mins of covers and I think there are still clips that are not included yet because after years, this song is still touching a lot of people. I really like Wendy, Eunji and Punch. They seriously know how to deliver an OST. The emotions and the vocals.

Seungsik (victon) is amazing

Taeyeon is a legend for a reason and no one can copy that no matter how they're trying the same technique.

Our Seungsik did wellㅠㅠ I cried when he posted the cover

oh no no wendy seungsik make my heart melt

Wendy🥰👍

THE MAN FROM VICTON. I THINK HE REALLY DID WELL AMONG OTHER ARTIST

Wendy's voice fits this song apart from Taeyeon But all of them are all talented

I love it when doyoung used to be the backing vocal😍

I love the song wow even amazing one of the best vocalist like Wendy ,Eunji ,IU & Punch cover the song

I love and respect all of these singers but this is why Taeyeon is the one and only Taeyeon.

2:13 My Ultimate Bias Wendy Heavenly 😍💙

All of them did great job 👏🏽👍🏽😍