True, but homie prefers jim tho and the ship should know that

holy shit

kalsoba en la fandasa?@@fanto978

you typing with periods like that looks hella aggressive smh

I think I had a stroke reading this😂

right? They could've litteraly had an R2D2 like robot right next to the manual override for reactor vent thingy that would sacrifice itself to hold the door open in crucial moments

or even a way for any passengers to contact an engineer or someone higher up if something goes wrong

I was looking for this comment! How do you have cryo pods auto docs and a whole ass bartender but you have absolutely 0 maintenance protocol while everyone sleeps. And you shot the damn ship at an asteroid belt?!?! There wasn't a way around that? The space x rocket redirects 25000 times on its way to the space station but future tech can't do the same?!

@@Vancev99x The ship has counter measure to protect crews. It has a shield that deflected most of the asteroid. It reset the systems when it crash mid flight. The problem is what happened is a freak accident, a lone asteroid that shouldn't be able to pierce the ship left alone do any serious damage able to hit the computer of the reactor. That is like unforeseeable event, I mean space programs spent millions on space flight and they still got crash from time to time.

​@@jozokrstanovic9040yeah, the robot would have to sacrifice himself because he wouldn't have the same level of plot armor as that guys _"heat shield"_

As a CS major I was thinking the exact same thing

yeah that had to be one of my biggest annoyances with this movie. It doesn't matter if its supposable fail proof you still have it wake up crew members if the ship cant resolve the errors and have facilities in place to re-hibernate people.

Spaceship made in china 💀

Hey, by that time ESG/DIE (DEI spelled right) mandates had gone a long way. It didn't just fubar the Boeing 737 Max, it moved on the spaceships.

yup, what more you need

I saw that too, I don't agree that it would have been way better, it would have been a way different type of movie. If you wanted a space suspense/thriller type of movie then you got that. The problem with the rearrange, was how much of the movie was Jim being alone at the beginning? Are you really going to have that much worth of flashback scenes in the movie? That would probably ruin the pace, and while having some would be ok, there'd need to have other footage thrown in there and at that point you have a completely different movie not just in the type of movie but also have considerably different footage that is used.

i think that would make jim the clear antagonist and make it much harder for the audience to sympathize

Yeah. The guy watched a video, online. Nerdstalgic is the OP I believe

Another idea for a more interesting ending: Keep the whole movie the same, apart from Jim dies at the end saving everyone. Fade to black. Fade up again, we get some shots are showing the bedroom and hallways a mess again with food packets and stuff like when Jim was depressed. The final shot is Aurora (maybe visibly 3 or 4 years older so we can see a bit more time has passed than Jim managed alone given how angry she was about being woken up herself) sat at another guy's pod, with the toolbox just as Jim did. Staring at him, struggling to decide whether to wake him up or not. Cut to black.

@@sorenkair Then they could have still kept the ending with Jim dying to save everyone, after Aurora thought he was a villain, and then jump to like 3 years later and it is just her sat outside another guy's pod, with the toolbox, struggling with whether to wake him up or not.

ISTG i was like i thought he already did this

same🤣

oh damn me too and i didn’t even realize

@@ankushkar3364​​⁠​​⁠ ​​⁠

Sometimes

Maybe it was like 55 years for his message atm but in that 55 years they travelled farther than when they sent it so when earth sends their reply it's a handful of years before it get back to the ship

@@kolourmecute6618 yeah right it would take another half century to do anything. still, would've been cool for movie closure to see how people on earth react.

@@kolourmecute6618 surely such an advanced civilisation that has the capabilities to colonise another planet would program the computer to take into account the distance the spaceship would have travelled from when he sent the message to when a reply is sent back. But then again, they had absolutely 0 maintenance procedures in place for the spaceship.

Wonder if the massive bill he incurred for that transmission got transferred to someone he left back on Earth if he has anyone left there. Depends on how bad the capitalism is in that future.

The message got to Earth, and they launched a rescue ship with its new design which could travel four times faster than the old ship. The rescue ship got to Homestead 2 twenty years before the old ship was due to arrive. This gave them time to establish a colony and have it all go to batshit, so the sequel will be the old ship landing in the middle of a Mad Max situation.

Yeah it's just bad Hollywood slop writing. Having something go wrong to cause the plot is fine, without it we don't get a story, but the reason has to be consistent with the internal logic and setting of the film.

It has pointed out also several times that the ship has a shield, strong enough to get hit by large asteroids and withstand star corona, but not astroid the size of the ship so some chunks got through. The procedure *might* be that although ship cannot wake up a passenger before reaching the destination, because it might just kill all the people, since humanity is a plague... Anyway, it malfunctioned the right pod, which happened to be an expandable engineer...

no i can believe this, my work is somewhat complicated, and with each passing year it gets dumb down and the efficiency drops as the people in charge have no idea how it works or is suppose to work. people used to repair there own cars, toasters, pluming, etc... now practically no one can. even professorial mechanics will rite off a car for a fender bender. the more advanced a peace of equipment is the more computers are relied upon to build and design it and the less redundancy it has. the slop writing for me was that they where able to repair it at all.

@@robgilmour3147 That's a fair point, I can believe that. Another big issue I had was how it was revealed later on that the medical pod could be used for cryosleep, and I was just wondering, "why don't the both get in?"

1 atmospheres worth of pressure, about the same as a coke can vs the air i hear. Ez

I think on the ISS there are holes that are only sealed with duct tape😮

Nerd

@@dennisarazny455 fuck is wrong with that

🤓 *this is a joke*

maybe the hibernation thing has to be triggered by someone outside the thing, but there are still multiple. if they really do just have the one then yeah thats fuckin stupid

house md scene

​@@SpahGaming?

@@machrx5 "he doesnt even know your name, he calls you jim" talking to a guy called james

Jimothy

What I never understood is why Jack is short for John. Makes no sense to me.

We must keep this guy's comment at 69 likes.

Minute movies:

You guys didn't listen.

@@Aidon.Knowles mission failed, we'll get em next time.

@@aqaman1212 you are just objectively incorrect

Exactly this. 1 atmosphere of pressure difference is not a lot. Also I wouldn't be surprised if they actually made the pressure even lower, as it would probably help with a lot of engineering stuff. Also fun fact they would probably have not pressurised most of the ship as everyone's asleep anyway. Also the pressure difference between crew quarters and mechanical should probably constantly go down a little, so that in case of fire, the smoke is directed away from crew space.

@@TheWinjin 1 atmosphere of pressure difference is 1 atmosphere of pressure difference. A lot or not a lot depends of the area the pressure pushes onto/through. 1 atm on a square meter hole is over 10 tons of force (101325N).

sure but that idea falls flat when bish is flying half way through the room just from the pressure. That much pressure would snap you in half too.

Yeah. Rapidly resurfacing from 10 meters, while not pleasant will not kill you. And that's almost the same pressure difference(for simplicity it is considered to be exactly a 1 atm/100000P difference)

As a molecular biologist, automating medicine like the autodoc is WAY easier than life extension. By miles and miles. The only ways we currently know to do it would need to be implemented in utero, for one, and would come with an EXTENSIVE risk of every type of cancer. Like, it wouldn't be an "If you get cancer" kind of deal, it would be a "How often do you get cancer?" It would occur in every organ in your body, regularly. Whether your immune system could kill it before it mutated past immune suppression would be a coin flip. And I don't care how advanced medicine is, a biological organism just can't keep up with that kind of chaos.

Yeah man some studies says that by 2050 we will probably have amortal people. Besides on space people age slower than normal, so 90 years could go by just fine.

Also, only one medical capsule on 5000 people?

​@@RochelleHasTooManyHobbies wait, fucking legit?

they could have used the autodoc 1 year and switched…

In my understanding this doesn't work, the movie tells you you can only put into sleep if you have some medical preparation which are can't done on the ship. The only exception is the autodoc which can provide the prep work for one person only

​@@wertz9976 They had spare parts for everything but not a spare autodoc, aaaargh

Which, in common sense would be one of the critical component to support life.

@@u1zha If they literally have every spare part, they could technically make a second autodoc

5k people 1 autodoc is already stupid enough.

Also why the fuck is there only one med pod on that ship? One med pod for 5000 people seems waaaay to low for future medical emergencies on Homestead 2. If they had multiple pods they both could've hibernated in them, using the android to press the buttons for that.

they probably sleep in the quarters he cant access

He tried to access the crew pods but they're locked behind a bulkhead he couldn't get through. Which doesn't make any sense at all. The guy managed to rip up the deck and plant a _tree_ in the floor, but he can't activate something that's meant to be opened? The dude just gave up and started thinking with his dick. There was no guarantee his plan would've even worked - what if she simply wasn't attracted to him at all? It would've been smarter to wake up another engineer type to bounce ideas off of. Maybe someone else could've figured out how to override the doors and food systems.

Fingers don't help an underdeveloped ai to figure out technology outside his coding

they do explain that it isn't just a button that needs to be pressed on the outside of the capsule (because if it was you could just design the button to be on the inside) They say that going into stasis sleep requires a medical operation, like anesthetic. What doesn't make any sense, and is bad writing, is why the ship doesn't have such a facility onboard, just incase any passengers do get woken up.

@@p-__ ...thems fighting words. One time High Boi farted so hard I smelt it over here. Never happened with your farts.

How would a robot with no legs, running on a short track behind a bar get to the sleep pods to push buttons?

Bruh chatGPT today could handle it and you're telling me future spaceship AI can't push a button

no - that would b cringe

Yes!

​@@adamahmed366Found the dudebro.

Eric said the same thing on Pretty Much It. I agree it would have been more interesting than what we ended up with. Other versions were that it showed a hole happy life of Aurora and Jim together, but in the end you find out it was actually Jim just imagining it, and the last shot is everyone waking up to find a rotten corpse sat outside her pod with candles and drawings of her using it as a shrine. Or that it should have been a horror film told from Aurora's perspective, with her slowly realising that he woke her up and being about fighting him off at the end. Similar chance for her to consider waking someone up for that classic "the villain wins" ending where it's like the evil has shifted into her now...

@@siobhannoble8545 It's like where's waldo in every comment section but waldo is wearing yellow and everyone else is in blue lol

there’s also not many to choose from

@@user-rh7wp4oo8v yeah true

"one of my favorite characters" bro there's like 4 😭😭😭😭

nah my favourite character is the endless vacuous abyss of space@@Crimson03Ghost

@@Crimson03GhostThe asteroid at the start is the GOAT of the movie🔥🔥🔥

So that dude casually went blind in space, somehow fixed it and figured "aight it's cool, lemme get back to work" ? What the fuck

@@nimyron3536 Gigachad

@@nimyron3536 One word: Astronauts

@@nimyron3536 that's to be expected honestly. They have been chosen from a lot of people so to be able to troubleshoot a problem and solves it probably the minimum

Yes! Chris is truly amazing… He has a lot of great content

Also are you ever going to do another "picking on your comments" video? (this totally has nothing to do with the fact that i wanna know your opinions on the stupid shit i post while thinking i'm clever)

I felt like the only reason they sat around examining the pods was to set up that there was only one workable pod. Now it just seems weird the crew guy wasn't like "hey we can rig up the auto doc as an extra pod."

yeah, once they have the crew hatch open...like that kinda resolved the original premise right there. i guess the writers forgot about that.

@@sgx9874 Nah, the movie would be 15 minutes long.

@@einstien2409 The problem is the film was re-drafted so many times. Probably in one version there was an explanation on why he can't get into the crew flight deck, but that was probably before elements like being able to re-wire his band to make himself a luxury passenger to get straight into the luxury room got added in. Which now leaves us with the question on why can't he re-wire himself to be crew? If the only explanation is "because then the film wouldn't happen" it's bad writing. There needs to be an internal reason, people might not like it, that's subjective. But no reason at all is objectively bad writing, because it just meant the writer didn't think about it or didn't care. I have a similar issue with a lot of Lord of the Rings (and other high fantasy) where there are about 100 different ways you can solve the plot, usually because magic exists, but the only "reason" the author can ever write in as to why this wouldn't work is, "weeeellllll actually magic just....doesn't work that way..." which is basically the same unsatisfying "I didn't think of that, I didn't like that as much, with that I didn't have a story" explanation. More interesting versions of the story would be: *to make it a straight up horror film,* the same events but we see it from Jennifer Lawrence's perspective, and the ending is about trying to fight off Jim when he's spent years on the ship alone, going insane, learning where everything goes and even building new ways around the ship and traps and stuff. A full on stalker body horror film, where he doesn't necessarily want to kill her (like a slasher villain) but instead wants to KEEP her, to use for his own pleasure etc, maybe a bit of trying to kill her at the end as she fights back, obviously you'd have to set up some plausible way for her to beat him, then maybe she could find out he was lying about not being able to go back into stasis and she manages to go back in? *OR keep the whole movie the same sort of romance/drama,* apart from Jim dies at the end saving everyone. Fade to black. Fade up again, we get some shots are showing the bedroom and hallways a mess again with food packets and stuff like when Jim was depressed. *The final shot is Aurora (maybe visibly 3 or 4 years older so we can see a bit more time has passed than Jim managed alone given how angry she was about being woken up herself) sat at another guy's pod, with the toolbox just as Jim did. Staring at him, struggling to decide whether to wake him up or not. Cut to black.*

@@esmeecampbell7396 Since when were you an expert on fuckin magic? You're argument would make sense if prior Tolkien had written a scene of Gandalf actively doing very very impressive things with magic and we don't, we get him making impressive fireworks, making small balls of light, etc. If you actually read the books you would know that during Elrond's meeting about the One Ring they had a massive debate over various different methods of transporting or keeping the Ring from Sauron and each one was very clearly explained as to why it wouldn't work or had a worse chance of failure than the plan that was decided upon. Don't try and smear Tolkien's work because it doesn't fit with how you *think* magic should work. You're idea boils magic down into a 'get out of jail free card' and is infinitely more boring

@@andrewmeyer3599 That is exactly my point, magic does boil down to a get out of jail free card though. Magic is either: Interestingly written in the plot to be useful, but then very open to "well why didn't they do this" meaning you have to be incredibly clever in how you write it. Or it's written like that, a damp squib that may as well not exist for all the actual IMPACT it has on the plot. And to be clear I AM as much of an expert on magic as Tolkein is...because it doesn't exist. But there's never any point trying to have a sensible discussion with the kind of Tolkein fanboy that thinks the sun shines out of his arse.

yes, this is called the SlingShot effect

SHHH you're ruining the writer's need for romance

maybe it's some kind of latent procedure from when the ships weren't as advanced and had a more tourist setting that was never fully removed from the modern programming and since the ship detected people awake (they were using the recreation/dining and the assimilation class was automatic even though no one should have been awake) it announced the sight-seeing event

how so ? the computer probally saw in its logs or something that there were some pods awoken so maybe thats what made it think it should send this message

Let's be honest, computer is kinda AI enough to "accidentally" wake up an engineer with an abstract mind to fix the ship after unforseen circumstances happened. It probably has a protocol to NOT wake up people in case being aware the disease is infesting another planet, but may cause malfunction to right statis pods.

Food for over 5,000 people for a few months, those last few months before getting to the planet. In 40 years would he eat up all that food?

there is but it cant fix phyical things

Indeed, the Stars has aligned again.

Your lucky my content just gives accidents, mistakes and uglylooking children and abortions 😢

Imma be honest, this sounds like a love poem. And I enjoyed reading it greatly.

They could both be alive in their 70s or 80s if they took shifts in the medical pod while also spending time together. Plus I wouldn’t be surprised if they woke up more people over the 88 years. I think if they took turns in the medical pod and spent no time together they would both be alive in the end in their 60s