Pat Anderson reveals the truth behind length of Uluru Statement from the Heart | 7.30

  Рет қаралды 8,042

ABC News In-depth

ABC News In-depth

9 ай бұрын

The Coalition used Question Time today to challenge the Government about the length of the Uluru Statement from the Heart - the document produced after lengthy consultation with Indigenous people asking for a Voice to Parliament.
Pat Anderson is an Alyawarre woman. She was co-chair of the Referendum Council and one of the architects of the Uluru Statement from the Heart. She speaks to 7.30’s Sarah Ferguson.
Subscribe: ab.co/3yqPOZ5
ABC News In-depth takes you deeper on the big stories, with long-form journalism from Four Corners, Foreign Correspondent, Australian Story, Planet America and more, and explainers from ABC News Video Lab.
Watch more ABC News content ad-free on ABC iview: ab.co/2OB7Mk1
For more from ABC News, click here: ab.co/2kxYCZY
Get breaking news and livestreams from our ABC News channel: / newsonabc
Like ABC News on Facebook: / abcnews.au
Follow ABC News on Instagram: / abcnews_au
Follow ABC News on Twitter: / abcnews
Note: In most cases, our captions are auto-generated.
#ABCNewsIndepth #ABCNewsAustralia

Пікірлер: 189
@barbaraepye3895
@barbaraepye3895 9 ай бұрын
All Australians need help with Education, Health and Housing not just the Aboriginal community. We have homelessness in Australia that we have never experienced before. We also have alcoholism, and drug addiction all these issues need to be addressed.
@andreaconnelly3799
@andreaconnelly3799 9 ай бұрын
You are part of Australia and you are not excluded. It’s a choice to live in the past or bring yourself into the moment. History is meant to be learnt from not to be used as a weapon. Please remember all cultures have a dark past . We all bleed the same colour.
@TheSilmarillian
@TheSilmarillian 9 ай бұрын
Well said indeed
@ijoyner
@ijoyner 9 ай бұрын
True, but we live with the mistakes of the past which are now up to us to fix. That is the real bringing ourselves into the moment.
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
The lunatic-right are proven masters of weaponising history. 🤔🙄🙄😒😏
@grahammooney7420
@grahammooney7420 9 ай бұрын
the son should never have to pay for the sins of the father. @@ijoyner
@frankjohnson-em8ir
@frankjohnson-em8ir 9 ай бұрын
My DEAREST Mother always said don't bring up the past it will come back to bite you
@entershikarii
@entershikarii 9 ай бұрын
I think it’s ultimately an academic point. Several months ago, prof. Megan Davis did say it was a much bigger document than the first page, and Pat Anderson did not contradict her then. The other pages provide context to the introductory statement. That was seven months ago at the Sydney Peace Prize Lecture, prof Davis was with Pat Anderson during the question and answer portion 🤔
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 9 ай бұрын
Exactly!!!! Even Pat Anderson said it was more than a one page document. And now she is saying it's not?????? It's s NO from me! This Voice is insidious!!! We are all equal as Australians
@ctrlaltdelete200390
@ctrlaltdelete200390 8 ай бұрын
​@@gjhomesYou're being side tracked by a media hell bent on selling their click bait papers. Listen to what was said - yes there's an expansion that records all the dialogue, but the statement itself is one page. She literally said that. Please use your own neural networks, not the ones pumped into you by a Murdoch machine that turn you into a drone without an original thought.
@jazzdobey7941
@jazzdobey7941 7 ай бұрын
​@@gjhomesall equal unless you're an ATSI person
@raymond613
@raymond613 9 ай бұрын
The only gap that needs to be closed is the funding gap, welfare funds should always be needs based and not race/ancestry based. Everyone has the equal opportunities in modern day Australia but when certain groups are so used to receive preferential treatments, equality feels like discrimination to them.
@user-fp2sy5rl9p
@user-fp2sy5rl9p 9 ай бұрын
dang well said
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
One Nation-based rant.
@kristionpenny1910
@kristionpenny1910 9 ай бұрын
Yet another uneducated comment made without looking to historical policies and legislation that affected only one peoples in this nation. We've never had equality in the eyes of government, nor media.
@ctrlaltdelete200390
@ctrlaltdelete200390 8 ай бұрын
The needs aren't equal at all, so yes they need more funding. What they don't need is an advisory body that has its funding chopped and changed with every change in government. Hence why they asked for it to be included in the constitution. Don't worry, the advice will still remain advisory, not binding, but the body itself can't be abolished anymore and hopefully less politicised therefore
@jazzdobey7941
@jazzdobey7941 7 ай бұрын
The idea of having the Voice is to hear from the remote people & communities, and what they need, how it should be implemented. Instead of just throwing cash at some business set up, with highly paid execs, admin, etc, then having bugger to get to the cause. Funds allocated to direct implementation of the needs. Would save a lot of money.
@dg5433
@dg5433 9 ай бұрын
There needs more scrutiny on the distribution of funds by the ruling clans within the land councils?🤔
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
There also needs to be close scrutiny of the false information put about by devotees of the Murdoch Media, known in some quarters as "Skynuts." 😮😊
@12lb.toothbrush11
@12lb.toothbrush11 9 ай бұрын
Who is this white lady to speak of native people ?
@Jopacob
@Jopacob 9 ай бұрын
She is a citizen in a free and democratic democracy, her colour, religion, gender, age, etc have no relevance nor censorship. Look up The Racial Discrimination Act 1975
@trevormillington813
@trevormillington813 9 ай бұрын
The Voice will split the country not bring it together that is THE TRUTH......
@jamesmorrow1646
@jamesmorrow1646 9 ай бұрын
Division is being driven by the LNP and the Murdoch Press.
@GordonPavilion
@GordonPavilion 9 ай бұрын
Actually, it’s you Trev that is doing the splitting. Stop tuning into Sky News.
@Reginaldesq
@Reginaldesq 9 ай бұрын
@@GordonPavilion Maybe Trev is watching Sky and the ABC to try and get balance..... are you?
@youbigtubership
@youbigtubership 9 ай бұрын
I brought home my groceries, and put some things in the fridge and other things in cupboards. I physically divided the groceries into two categories and did different things with them. But I'm not divisive. It's the people who point out that some things are in the fridge and some aren't who are divisive.
@enigmaticx326
@enigmaticx326 9 ай бұрын
@@jamesmorrow1646 The LNP doesn’t have to do anything here. The yes campaign has been an disaster of its own making.
@MichaelForth
@MichaelForth 9 ай бұрын
No to dividing our country, that's no to the voice, we are all Australians. This is my country too, I was born here.
@beautifulbanknotes
@beautifulbanknotes 9 ай бұрын
The vote is NO to the voice, and YES to accountability, responsibility and truth telling in relation to the billions spent per year towards aboriginal affairs without the desired results. Australians need to be united, the voice is dividing us.
@typetersen8809
@typetersen8809 9 ай бұрын
@beautifulbanknotes Well written.....and accurate. And thank you for educating THEIR ABC commenters in your post!😊
@marcusluciani1620
@marcusluciani1620 9 ай бұрын
​@GordonPavilion prefer the ABC propaganda provided at taxpayers expense do you?
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
The Voice Referendum is only dividing off those who through their own ignorant intransigence refuse to acknowledge the truth in front of their eyes. Get back to wallowing in lunatic-Right Murdoch media lies and propaganda. 😮😊
@jazzdobey7941
@jazzdobey7941 7 ай бұрын
That's the problem, why isn't the money getting to where it's needed. That's a huge reason for the Voice to Parliament and a YES vote, to stop the waste, neglect, and rorting of allocated funds.
@thearmchairjournalist566
@thearmchairjournalist566 9 ай бұрын
It doesn’t matter the race of the parents if you are not good role models and neglect your children they will be severely affected and will automatically be at a disadvantage in society! I was severely poor as a child but was never taught that being delinquent or abusive was allowed! I was given a whopping if I ever behaved like that! If you look at the youth today they have no respect for others or their community at large, that’s a awful way to be behaving and a bad sign of the future for them 😢 This happens in all states and cultures but unfortunately the decades long feelings of ‘woe is me’ has caused people to not even try to aim for better. Everyone has a opportunity to make a better life for themselves and their families but many people don’t even bother to try, which is abysmal. If you can’t raise yourself above the mindset of being oppressed you will never change your outcome in life.
@Wasabitheband1
@Wasabitheband1 9 ай бұрын
🎯
@Ralph_Baric_PhD_C2019
@Ralph_Baric_PhD_C2019 9 ай бұрын
Constitutional change should benefit all Australians. ESPECIALLY AFTER OUR RIGHTS TRASHED DURING COVID.. BILL OF RIGHTS FOR ALL BEFORE A VOICE FOR SOME.
@sherraleewoods3668
@sherraleewoods3668 9 ай бұрын
Thankyou. Well said . @thearmchairjournalist566. The whole "we were angry" dribble was just that. Why didn't She address what's in the other pages.
@KingComputerSydney
@KingComputerSydney 9 ай бұрын
In her 2018 Parkes Oration, Dr Davis said the Uluru Statement 'isn't just the first one-page statement - it's actually a very lengthy document of about 18 to 20 pages, and a very powerful part of this document reflects what happened in the dialogues'.
@historychannel365
@historychannel365 9 ай бұрын
Where have the 30 billion bucks a year gone? What has their fictitious minister for indigenous people accomplished? Please vote "NO"
@Blackhart50
@Blackhart50 9 ай бұрын
It's all b.s
@GordonPavilion
@GordonPavilion 9 ай бұрын
Is that something you hear, whenever you open your mouth?
@flyonthewalltheatre
@flyonthewalltheatre 9 ай бұрын
VOTE NO!! It's not one page, she said previously was 18 pages!! Liar!
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 9 ай бұрын
She did say that but it's not convenient anymore!!! How can we these advocates when they lie?
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
Please get back to viewing lunatic-Right Sky News and cheering on Bolt and Credlin in your comments there. 😮😢😊😅
@stuarthaynes1737
@stuarthaynes1737 9 ай бұрын
My question is why did Tony Abbotts government pull the half a billion dollars ? I hear there's been an audit done by the auditor General this year that showed discrepancies in the 85 million Dollars given in 2020- 21 . Land Councils aren't passing on the money to their countries and this is one reason why so many oppose the Voice . Is the Voice just gojng to be another land Council scenario and just more money goes to the few ??? I'm sure there's a slogan somewhere that says "Keep the problem going so we keep the money flowing".
@davidthrift7593
@davidthrift7593 9 ай бұрын
If this full document has been so publically available how come in all my online searches trying to get more informed it has never surfaced untill now?
@Indonesiansurftravel
@Indonesiansurftravel 9 ай бұрын
Even on the official Uluru statement website its very hard to find its tagged on the end of the Uluru statement report PDF. Why its not a seperate file is known but we can make our own assumption's
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
@@Indonesiansurftravel you are replete with certain assumptions that are all too evident. 🤔
@jazzdobey7941
@jazzdobey7941 7 ай бұрын
When did you start searching and why?? Did you ever put in an FOI request?
@davidthrift7593
@davidthrift7593 7 ай бұрын
@@jazzdobey7941 The day a few months back when i decided to further educate myself on what we are voting on. Inital looks on the official Uluru Statement site doesnt really highlight this documents existence very clearly. Having watched countless times the narrative from the Yes camp change to suit the audience, including the length of said document. How the labour party jokes and carries on when a question is raised in the house. How Linda Byrnie cannot give an unscripted answer on anything and is quiclky protected when questioned. There is an actual FOI document I have on hand (i can send you a copy if you like) that also has a sligtly different wording that has been ommited from the documemt that appears online - reference to potential paymnet of percentages of GDP being thrown around in the dialogues as an example. The agenda behind the statement is made very clear by these supporting documents even if the 'statement' is only the 1 page referenced. Do you generally judge a book by its cover? Why have we not had a decent public debate or constitutional convention on the matter before us? Rushing this through on emotional blackmail and how the Yes side inc the PM continually gaslight the nation. I understand that exact policy detail is unknown due to the nature of the constitutional change process but that is still an issue and red flag in this instance. A public debate/conventioln would help resolve any of these concerns but that obviosuly does not align with the current left agenda because facts get put up for proper open debate.
@mrman1536
@mrman1536 9 ай бұрын
No.
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 9 ай бұрын
I disagree with the voice. Its sets one group of people above all other Australians and that is fundamentally wrong!!!! I do agree that there should be no racism! I agree with concept that every Australian must have equal opportunity. I do not agree with the concept of providing unequal treatment to one group over and above others, whether based on race or religion. I cannot even believe we are talking about this. All Australians must have the same opportunity. Its up to US what we choose to do or not do with that opportunity!!!!!!! If we choose to live in remote areas, we cannot expect the same services, healthor education outcomes! But you are free to choose that. Just dont blame us for the poor outcomes! Personal responsibility and choice is what we should each be accountable for to help ourselves.The concept of The Voice is fundamentally wrong and i totally disagree. I also agree that our first Australians need to be recognized in the Constitution.....nut not via a voice that provides unequal treatment to others!!!! If this concept is acceptable, then what about a viice for women and another one for people with disabilities, and what about non-white people? Wake up Australia! I migrated here to escape inequality and shocked that this is on the agenda here. ALL AUSTRALIANS MUST BE TREATED EQUAL AND ENJOY THE SAME OPPORTUNITY. No more and no less! 0:06
@dhiquobgnaloo
@dhiquobgnaloo 9 ай бұрын
The history of this country is bloody, bitter, and full of pain and anger and distress and we have done all the heavy lifting, no positives in Australian history ? talk about bitter , angry and self intitled.
@johnhamilton1791
@johnhamilton1791 9 ай бұрын
Each one of these people denying the Uluru statement is more than one page has been caught out saying the opposite on video. Why try and hide the truth ?
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
Are you missing having poisonous Peta Credlin on Sky News tell you the truth, the whole truth and nothing but.....? 🤔
@chrismiddleton9088
@chrismiddleton9088 9 ай бұрын
Because they know that it is not politically palatable. I have read the full document and am not impressed by its content.
@John-kv7jo
@John-kv7jo 8 ай бұрын
Because all they want is money, land and a percentage of GDP. They want to tax the rest of us for living on their land.
@typetersen8809
@typetersen8809 9 ай бұрын
Incorrect, Pat. It is 26 pages, and that is that! With the "one pager" LIE.....I'm sorry, misinformation, doing the rounds, it'll be a NO from me.
@Ritzer168
@Ritzer168 9 ай бұрын
The statement is 1 page, with the rest being history, storytelling etc which makes up the rest. Google exists you know?
@rmac3217
@rmac3217 9 ай бұрын
​@@Ritzer168 The story of receiving double the funding of every other citizen already? Most Australians can't afford their own rent, let alone pay your rent then pay you rent again.
@andreaconnelly3799
@andreaconnelly3799 9 ай бұрын
I didn’t realise history and historical events included treaty, land rights etc. wow there forefathers where extraordinary extremely illuminated to include this in truth telling of the past. History in all cultures have a dark reality not sunshine and rainbows.
@lesblack413
@lesblack413 9 ай бұрын
@@Ritzer168 The statement is seen by the PM to be the extent of it, but the workings behind it are massive. In my opinion from what I have gained from listening to various speakers, is that the one (1) page referred is actually a concise summary or precis. The meaning of PRÉCIS is a concise summary of essential points, statements, or facts. ) The real damage will come from what is not shown in the one page statement!
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
​​​@@rmac3217Tremendous to hear from a real live frothing and ranting Skynut. Are you sure you can afford to take any time at all out from the unhinged ravings of Bolt, Credlin and Dean? You must be having severe withdrawal symptoms already. 😮😢😊😅
@Coops777
@Coops777 9 ай бұрын
Yes its difficult to get consensus because the Aboriginal community is so diverse. There is no need to insert another complication into parliament, especially one that can't prove to have a majority agreement amongst the people it claims to represent. There is no need to introduce something that separates people by race into our constitution. What's been presented here is an OPINION from a certain SECTION of a diverse society. Lets do something that brings us all together.
@jazzdobey7941
@jazzdobey7941 7 ай бұрын
The voices will come from those diverse mobs, to hear them, then take their needs to the politicians who make the decisions. The Constitution excluded First Nations People. It was written to represent the Crown, White man's policies.
@scottgrieve5950
@scottgrieve5950 9 ай бұрын
Why did she not ask her about reparations$$$?
@marcusluciani1620
@marcusluciani1620 9 ай бұрын
Voice now. Invoice later.
@empresswu7059
@empresswu7059 9 ай бұрын
Hmmm well that didn't change my mind.
@glennduncan6843
@glennduncan6843 9 ай бұрын
Contrary to what PM Albanese and other Yes campaigners have said, the Uluru Statement FTH is a full 26 pages long, and you can call it "our story" or whatever, but no-one can fully understand the "single page", being referred to here unless you have read the other 26 pages as they go to great length to put the body of feelings and directions that the Voice will take into context. And particularly as the other 26 pages also go on to state that the Voice will be the Makarrata Commission, already part funded by PM Albanese, and also includes all the sections on Truth and Treaty that goes on to prove how many mistruths and deceptions are being put forward by the PM, his government and Yes supporters. Everyone has to read the other 26 pages to understand how the Voice will change our country forever and segregate all our peoples along racial and ethnic lines as well as do away with the majority of the voices of the entire 342 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Nations by having only 24 so-called representatives on the Makarrata Commission supposedly representing them all. The Voice is divisive, and I ask all to vote NO.
@pablovalentine8976
@pablovalentine8976 9 ай бұрын
LMAO they want truth telling but they cannot tell the truth themselves.
@bigboy9693
@bigboy9693 9 ай бұрын
The answer is simple, take responsibility for your own actions, take advantage of the culture that the white culture bought with him, educate your children and stop playing the victim, Political isolation Pat, you have 11 representives in the senate the house while Burnie said the same thing, whet is burnie doing in her position. Crying about what is wrong while doing nothing.
@Indonesiansurftravel
@Indonesiansurftravel 9 ай бұрын
100% correct
@darrenoleary5500
@darrenoleary5500 9 ай бұрын
“A much more equal type of democracy” All people would be equal, but some people would be more equal than others for ever….NO !
@jeffford181
@jeffford181 9 ай бұрын
I got kicked off the dole...... for being lazy and not accepting a job...... thats my story, I need to have an Australian Statement from the heart///
@user-fp2sy5rl9p
@user-fp2sy5rl9p 9 ай бұрын
So now the Uluru statement is 1 page + 20 plus pages connected to it? It does honestly sounds like The PM has been deceitful in regards to it. I think what makes matters worse is that other well know representatives of the Yes campaign have said its 20 something pages long and there is a road map towards the end of the document.
@StuartBarclay-rm3cj
@StuartBarclay-rm3cj 9 ай бұрын
The most insulting aspect is the simple fact that thanks to reverse racism no one except Aboriginal can actually walk on Uluru formerly known as Ayers Rock. South Africa and Zimbabwe is the direction that the left is taking us.
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
Murdoch media "NO" campaign propaganda. 😮😊😅
@Indonesiansurftravel
@Indonesiansurftravel 9 ай бұрын
@@Tyronepeader The legal creator Megan Davies has clearly said a number of times in the past its not one page, the NIAA Gov file shows its clearly as one document Doc 14, you really think they spent so much time and money for one page?.... the other 25 pages are the detail, and thats where devil is.
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
@@Indonesiansurftravel More "NO" campaign propaganda. Thanks for coming out so unashamedly as an avowed opponent of the Voice. You are sounding more and more like Peta Credlin with your devil reference. Instead vote "YES" for a better future for all of us. It's time that we included our indigenous people in our Constitution.
@TheSilmarillian
@TheSilmarillian 9 ай бұрын
Have you read the full document?????
@terredaniels3858
@terredaniels3858 9 ай бұрын
Uluru’s paragraph 3. It says: This sovereignty is a spiritual notion: the ancestral tie between the land, or ‘mother nature’, and the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples who were born therefrom, remain attached thereto, and must one day return thither to be united with our ancestors. This link is the basis of the ownership of the soil, or better, of sovereignty. It comes from Fouad Ammoun, Vice-President of International Court of Justice (ICJ) from 1970-6. Those words, with a minor modification, are taken from his ‘separate opinion’ in the ICJ’s Western Sahara Case of 1975, though the Referendum Council’s Final Report (again) wrongly attributes them to the full court. In place of the ‘materialistic’ doctrine of terra nullius, Ammoun had commended an alternative ‘spiritual notion’: …the ancestral tie between the land, or “mother nature”, and the man who was born therefrom, remains attached thereto, and must one day return thither to be united with his ancestors. Ammoun and his brother judges were not addressing Australia or the status of her indigenous peoples.
@Jopacob
@Jopacob 9 ай бұрын
thank you so much, I have been searching for this, it seems to have vanished in the ether of the Internet and post Authored Wiki.
@rongt859
@rongt859 9 ай бұрын
Theres an old saying , Be careful what you wish for
@Marina-tx2ok
@Marina-tx2ok 9 ай бұрын
The problem I hear correct me if I'm wrong this lady keeps incuating its them and us why can't we all be one ?
@VK6AB-
@VK6AB- 8 ай бұрын
The Voice is part of a six stage strategy, the Voice itself is stage 5 and stage 6 is Makarrata. The aims are clearly stated "A TREATY could include a proper say in decision making, the establishment of a TRUTH commission, REPARATIONS, a financial settlement (such as seeking a PERCENTAGE OF GDP), the resolution of land, water and resources issues, RECOGNITION OF AUTHORITY and CUSTOMARY LAW" (from page 19 of a 26 page document released under FOI (FOI/2223/016) from the National Indigenous Australian Agency, page 1 is titled Uluru statement from the heart [centre justified]) "Makarrata is the culmination of our agenda" from the Uluru Statement from the Heart (page 1). So its very clear not only is the Voice a planned assault on democratic principles, not only does it introduce race/cultural identity into the constitution, its part of an agenda that the Prime Minister himself promotes VOICE - TREATY - TRUTH. He even has the T - shirt. The National Indigenous Australian Agency (under Linda Burney) has had executive authority to close the gap since 2019. (e) specify the functions of the National Indigenous Australians Agency be as follows: iii. to lead and coordinate the development and implementation of Australia’s Closing the Gap targets in partnership with Indigenous Australians; (Federal register of legislation, C2019G00474). Moreover the three clauses to be inserted into section 129 of the constitution do not include the words advice, advisory or advise: - i There shall be a body, to be called the Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander Voice. - ii The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice may make representations to Parliament and the Executive Government on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples. - iii The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws with respect to the composition, functions, powers and procedures of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice (AEC). Clearly unique access based on race/cultural identity to all levels of government. Vote NO "it is a ruthless con job" (Greg Craven, The Australian).
@jeffstorer
@jeffstorer 9 ай бұрын
It is almost impossible to prosper in today's world,if you cannot read and write,,how then in modern Australia ,do children get through 10 yrs of school without learning basic life skills,,all children black white and brindle, that's a gap that needs attention ,all parents need to be held to account, you had em raise them properly
@davidmorrison2739
@davidmorrison2739 9 ай бұрын
A one-pager? Why have Uluru enthusiasts been saying again and again that it's 18 pages or 20 pages or whatever?
@johnphelps9788
@johnphelps9788 9 ай бұрын
Including herself, she is on record as saying it's 18 pages long.
@entershikarii
@entershikarii 9 ай бұрын
It was several months ago, prof. Megan Davis did say it was a much bigger document than the first page, and Pat Anderson did not contradict her then. The other pages provide context to the introductory statement. It was at the Sydney Peace Prize Lecture and prof. Davis was with Pat Anderson during question and answer portion.
@roselewsley4125
@roselewsley4125 9 ай бұрын
" Maintain that level of funding " Apparently $35 billion last year was given in funding ....in the 2021 census. 812,728 people identified as Aboriginals....how much more funding is needed ? And if enough is not given for health and education, why not ? Accountability is needed here!
@user-hz5qn8po4t
@user-hz5qn8po4t 7 ай бұрын
If we agree with the 20 percent of the ostensible 813,000 indigenous population which is deemed as the proportion marginalised, and it has been those who have received economic support, that works out to have been $163,000 spent, per person, for results which are wanting. Sorry aunty Pat, money has not been the missing piece. Perhaps the “ gap” will remain until aboriginal culture becomes a culture for which some can celebrate, whilst taking the advantages on offer, to obtain an education, and become part of a modern economy, and as a taxpaying contributor to Project Australia. Join the other 80; percent of the indigenous population who are doing as well as the average Australian, fully , rightfully proud of their cultural heritage. The two aspects never need to be mutually exclusive. The hair went up on the back of my neck, when I first drove across the border in Scotland, from where my grandparents came, however I remain a proud Australian, who is proud of my family heritage.
@peterbowden9453
@peterbowden9453 9 ай бұрын
"the problem is we've been going to Canberra after every election to explain to Gov what we want" Host: "How will the voice change things, Response: "We will go down to Canberra and tell them what we want"......This woman makes no sense....
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
You'll find much more of the particular sense that you are after over on Sky News with Bolt, Credlin and dear old Cory Bernardi. It's all lunatic-Right sheer consistency, you'll be sure to love all of it. 😮😊😅
@entershikarii
@entershikarii 9 ай бұрын
Yep, ‘The Voice’ is superfluous and unnecessary for its supposed intent, at least the purpose that proponents are telling us.
@johnlane7080
@johnlane7080 9 ай бұрын
What an absolute black lie
@jewellive2819
@jewellive2819 9 ай бұрын
Aboriginal have been allocated billions of dollars over many years, why haven't the problems been sorted out by aboriginal committees communities and leaders in the Parliament? I hope there will be a look into all of this funding and where it went.
@karate4348
@karate4348 Ай бұрын
Because like for all indigenous groups being colonised...creating dependence, use of reward and punishment..destroying the nature and ecosystems which ONLY people indigenous with it know how to live... because people are given money but not allowed to live with culture on their own land long enough to heal from the INSANITY which is culture not from this land leading a show. Australia is unique...(as is every ecosystem of nature..but this is REALLY different to other places on earth. The sustainable way to live on this land is how it's grown out of it over 75,000 years +. The quick kill and gain(but lose not long after) is to turn us all into shoppers and sellers. No need no... Country provides all and we get on with learning how to live with that enough is enough. Living high and low...that's stuff of post colonisation-big- trauma...unhealed impact and division...from nature and each other. Healing and slowing down, noticing how many babies we can actually provide for... That's nature guidance... Not all this money and clock talk.
@owspeed5006
@owspeed5006 9 ай бұрын
So where are the dissenting voices? I know there is at least one delegate who wasn’t in agreement because I heard her say it on indigenous radio. I’ve been listening for a long time, they predominantly focus on the past. Except when dissenters ask questions then they focus on slippery words.
@Johnninham-ur1dr
@Johnninham-ur1dr 9 ай бұрын
'The Uluru statement is modelled on an African statement from their culture.....word for word, down to the last comma! There has been no acknowledgement by 'The voice. The voice is someone else's voice from a different land!'
@lesblack413
@lesblack413 9 ай бұрын
have you got a reference to this information. I'm sure your are correct, but would like to see for myself. Thanks.
@Johnninham-ur1dr
@Johnninham-ur1dr 9 ай бұрын
common knowledge@@lesblack413
@Johnninham-ur1dr
@Johnninham-ur1dr 9 ай бұрын
'Journalist Chris Merrit - 'The Australian' date Friday March 1 2023 'Uluru statement from the heart....of Africa.'
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
@@lesblack413 you are going to love this little tidbit from the Australian. Right up your far ranting lunatic-Right alley. 🤔🤔🙄😒😏😊
@Johnninham-ur1dr
@Johnninham-ur1dr 9 ай бұрын
funny how it is!@@Tyronepeader
@Hero1inDarwin
@Hero1inDarwin 9 ай бұрын
Very well scripted. By not having a voice pat still has done very good for herself, she received an education and got qualifications. What I would like to know how will a voice make parents send their kids to school? How will it stop drunks fighting in the street and urinating on walls? how will it stop all the ngo's and others that are making a fortune out of aboriginal people from ripping them off and feeding them BS about what the government is not doing for them? or will all the ngo's and aboriginal corporations and councils be scrapped? It wont help any of them as they are all for them-selves... Vote No to a voice that will not do anything to help.
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
Raving, frothing, ranting lunatic-Right Skynuttery. You are missing out on good Sky News viewing time with fair-minded operators like Bolt and Credlin. 😮😊
@Indonesiansurftravel
@Indonesiansurftravel 9 ай бұрын
@@Tyronepeader You know posting abusive name calling garbage under every comment doesn't change peoples mind's.....and you wonder why the yes voting is crashing in polls
@paulg666
@paulg666 9 ай бұрын
It’s funny how she said in November 2022 at Melbourne uni (on video) that it was not 1 page but 18 pages. Changed her mind in the last week ?
@garyjohnstone6422
@garyjohnstone6422 9 ай бұрын
How do you tell a communist? Well, it's someone who reads Marx and Lenin. And how do you tell an anti-Communist? It's someone who understands Marx and Lenin.
@bobbymacindoe2884
@bobbymacindoe2884 8 ай бұрын
Thats a Ronald Reagan joke and it’s : a Communist is someone who has the books of Marx and Lenin and an anti- Communist is someone who’s read them.
@richardburian2516
@richardburian2516 8 ай бұрын
Lose $34 billion EVERY YEAR, really, for how many ??
@richardtravers8772
@richardtravers8772 9 ай бұрын
This same woman also said the Ayers Rock Statement was in fact 26 pages long, so which is it???????
@Shamshiadadd
@Shamshiadadd 9 ай бұрын
Ahh... the ABC of Albos propaganda department... What happened to the other 17 pages of the document...? People, please, please, for your country's sake vote NO to the voice.
@paulrowell256
@paulrowell256 8 ай бұрын
Are we not all Australian equal or does she want the indigenous to be more special why do they more money than the rest of us
@grahammooney7420
@grahammooney7420 9 ай бұрын
Sorry Pat but you have changed your tune and we can't believe a word you utter. I have seen and heard videos of you saying that the Uluru statement from the heart is more than just one page and that you urged people to read the whole document. If you said that then and now your saying it's only a one page statement you couldn't be trusted to have a voice. It's obvious that Albo has pressured you into changing your tune so what pressures would you buckle to if given a voice? I have read all those pages and the way you are trying to describe them doesn't sound how I read them to be. Sorry you have forsaken your integrity to save face for Albo but it just doesn't wash.
@mariasevdalis2988
@mariasevdalis2988 9 ай бұрын
Hopefully the racism stops but it never will. The indigenous voice will be overrided by the government, which is not fair anyway
@lesblack413
@lesblack413 9 ай бұрын
So why spend around $400 million just to say YES or NO? All citizens of Australia are currently featured in the constitution. The Voice is not necessary if politicians, agencies, organisations etc., would just do the job they are paid to do. Linda Burnie is the Federal Member for Indigenous Affairs on $450+ 000 per year. What is she doing about the problem??
@zuricrqsatlz9145
@zuricrqsatlz9145 8 ай бұрын
One pager? You mean 26 pages? The PM said he is committed to implimenting the full document - not just one page.
@youbigtubership
@youbigtubership 9 ай бұрын
Most people understand the anger, bitterness and distress, but sadly I think it's a common experience of all of humanity. There are very few saints in the world who understand human powerlessness and are able to rise above it, and I think their path is the way forward. All Australians want to feel their part is special in Australian history, because it's a special country formed at the beginning of an amazing era in human development. This era has awoken humanity, but modern leaders have left many behind. The result is widespread anger, bitterness, hurt, and distress in a time of miracles. This is a long distance call: there can be no hope for any of us without forgiveness and learning to love, and coming to terms with the greater forces of the world released through science. Consider that the theory of evolution hadn't even been proposed in 1788. Longitude was only just measured. Now, we have transistors and satellites and nukes and alot to learn. Peace and Love, as Ringo says.
@youbigtubership
@youbigtubership 9 ай бұрын
@Jim-zd6mn He's not an Australian so I suspect he wouldn't get involved.
@timinthesun
@timinthesun 9 ай бұрын
bs bs bs
@MentalLapse09
@MentalLapse09 9 ай бұрын
Australians arent buying this anymore. This is all cope.😊
@owspeed5006
@owspeed5006 9 ай бұрын
There are significant issues created by European colonialism that I believe need to be addressed urgently. ‘The Voice’ people have more ambition than ability and this needs to change, and until it does there can’t be positive change. It’s up to the First Nations to decide if they want this ‘voice’ to represent them. Speaking for myself, I think the ‘Voice’ is all about self importance, media influence and causing hurt.
@TCM215
@TCM215 9 ай бұрын
Isssues like, running water, dentistry, hospitals, health services, power, hygiene, transport, shelter, heating, refrigeration, increased life expectancy, antibiotics, emergency services, showers, tooth brushes and toothpaste, police services, fire services, anti venom, lol
@sharynwillis8920
@sharynwillis8920 8 ай бұрын
Document 14 pages numbered quite clearly 1 - 26. Then there are 13 documents of minutes.
@ozskipper
@ozskipper 8 ай бұрын
The voice is Nothing that the NIAA cant do and isnt already doing..
@alistairdancepmm
@alistairdancepmm 9 ай бұрын
So it's true then, the first peoples deserve (need) to be treated differently (better) than the rest of us in order to thrive
@entershikarii
@entershikarii 9 ай бұрын
How did you get to that conclusion again? Thanks.
@Tyronepeader
@Tyronepeader 9 ай бұрын
Not treated better, treated equally. One of the biggest killers of young indigenous people is rheumatic heart disease. It has largely been eliminated from white Australia. However, in places like Cape York it is an acute health problem. You'd think that the local LNP member of Parliament for the division of Leichhardt would speak up and urge that it was a public health issue that had to be addressed. A check of hansard reveals that Warren Entsch has never raised this matter once in parliament over his long career. Voting "YES"for the Voice Referendum will ensure that it will become a top priority hereafter and young people's lives will be saved far more effectively than in the past. Vote "YES" for a better future for all of us. 😮😊
@entershikarii
@entershikarii 9 ай бұрын
I read that heart, stroke, and vascular disease (HSVD) study Gardiner et al 2021 and it is clear that the gap here is not about being indigenous or not but remoteness is the key factor: “Remote Australians were found to have higher prevalence of HSVD as compared to non-remote Australians, with Indigenous status and HSVD prevalence significantly influenced by remoteness.” The study also states, “Remote Indigenous Australians have a high hospitalisation rate for HSVD than either non-remote Indigenous Australian or non-Indigenous Australians. This is coupled with significantly worse outcomes. Equity interventions to improve HSVD outcomes may need to be different for remote compared to non-remote Indigenous Australians.” I really don’t think ‘The Voice’ will alleviate this (besides it doesn’t have to be enshrined in the constitution), this is not solely the responsibility of the local MP (although he should’ve been advocating for it), the Indigenous Affairs minister is also responsible not only for raising it but consulting on the ground and consulting experts on the best way to address this. There is just no evidence that voting ‘yes’ will provide “a better future for all of us” if anything the constitutional risk and the entrenchment of elites in the community will be detrimental to all. So I can understand why many, including our indigenous brothers and sisters, are voting NO. 😔
@mikenicholas9017
@mikenicholas9017 9 ай бұрын
The best thing about the Voice for most of us is that if they have to tell the Voice what they are up to, we will all find out. That is what really scares the LNP. Like where theyll put the waste from the AUKUS subs. OR anyone else's nuclear waste we can take for cash. THE uS and Uk have no permanent nuclear waste facilities of their own and their voters dont want them.
@mikenicholas9017
@mikenicholas9017 9 ай бұрын
@@marcusluciani1620 They don't have any permanent uk or us facilities for waste, even after 80 years. That's where we will come in.
@rmac3217
@rmac3217 9 ай бұрын
@@mikenicholas9017 While we are getting involved in Russian first nations ppl reclaiming their land in Ukraine and sending 100's of millions in military equipment, we better get some firepower to defend ourselves.
@mikenicholas9017
@mikenicholas9017 9 ай бұрын
@rmac3217 we have never been invaded by anyone except the British. We were attacked by the Japanese to defend their oil resources but even they were not invading, as Tojo forbade it. We have also been nuked several times by the British... in secret. To defend us? Ha. Those subs are to ensure we are compliant to extraction industries and waste storage proposals.
@paulhopkins6377
@paulhopkins6377 9 ай бұрын
Australia is heading for division
@AussieRoos
@AussieRoos 9 ай бұрын
The ATO welcomes me to Country every fortnight 💸💸💸💸💸💸
@S.Carrick
@S.Carrick 9 ай бұрын
And lies 24 hours later, for the PM, on realizing her FU! Vote No
@johnmckenzie-rm3jh
@johnmckenzie-rm3jh 7 ай бұрын
Why do u tell lies Pat? 😢
@cyrilsimmonds5625
@cyrilsimmonds5625 9 ай бұрын
Highly convincing. Nothing to see
@robertcunningham35
@robertcunningham35 9 ай бұрын
it is funny how all these people are going on about the voice to parliment all seem to be white with european ancesters so if the europeans hadn't colonist in Australia they wouldn't exist
@ThomasAllen90
@ThomasAllen90 8 ай бұрын
So is the Indigenous representation not elected?
@andrewduffin9216
@andrewduffin9216 9 ай бұрын
Now see, this is well articulated. Best I've seen so far from the Yes side. This is what needs to be said by the government. There are still questions mind you, but well articulated explanations by the yes side has been lacking.
@typetersen8809
@typetersen8809 9 ай бұрын
26 pages.....26 pages.....NOT a "one pager" at all! These people cannot even count.....and they want us to go along with their divisive policies??? The vote for THEIR VOICE is NO.
@Ritzer168
@Ritzer168 9 ай бұрын
​@danielkienzner5845 we can't trust, or you can't trust? 😶‍🌫️
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 9 ай бұрын
Misleading! Vote NO
@diodoruscronus
@diodoruscronus 9 ай бұрын
Thats fine. But vote no
@richardburian2516
@richardburian2516 8 ай бұрын
Bin Albo cover ups, dial a disaster
@ingridpempeit1180
@ingridpempeit1180 7 ай бұрын
... not my AUNTY🤔
@richardburian2516
@richardburian2516 8 ай бұрын
PDF is it
@rossevans1774
@rossevans1774 8 ай бұрын
From what I heard Pat Anderson say all the $billions of taxpayer money spent over the years on supporting the needs of black indigenous Australians has been wasted. She now believes that this 'voice' will change things, enabling the ever increasing $billions to be better directed to the black indigenous people most in need of assistance. Is that what I heard?
@kevingrace7428
@kevingrace7428 9 ай бұрын
Is she one of the fake Aboriginals
@Indonesiansurftravel
@Indonesiansurftravel 9 ай бұрын
mixed race
@Reginaldesq
@Reginaldesq 9 ай бұрын
First time I have heard somebody coherently state what benefit the voice would bring for Aboriginal people.
@Reginaldesq
@Reginaldesq 9 ай бұрын
@@royce3859 So, the part where she says that they have to renegotiate funding etc, every time there is a new government. The fact that they would not have to do that would actually be a benefit to them.
@FionaEm
@FionaEm 9 ай бұрын
Pat Anderson is always so quietly impressive.
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 9 ай бұрын
She just contradicted herself saying the statement is one page when she was on video saying it was 18 pages. Glad you are impressed!
@ctrlaltdelete200390
@ctrlaltdelete200390 8 ай бұрын
​@@gjhomesDid you listen to what she said in this video? Why are you being led astray from what the point is of this referendum, into having arguments about semantics? Is it because you thrive on the exact click bait Murdoch wants to feed you to distract from the real debate?
@gjhomes
@gjhomes 8 ай бұрын
@@ctrlaltdelete200390 I did! I listened! Did you ? I mean really listen to what these activists are proposing? Why aren't you thinking about the risks of this proposition to ALL Australians ? When is something based on race ever right? The end does not justify the means! The vibe and emotions is not enough! Use logic and rationale as well! Think about how divisive this is on principle! The previous referendum for indigenous peoples was fair.... they wanted the right to have the same opportunities... to be treated EQUALLY. Not to disadvantaged by race. . This one is about having the right, based on race, to have additional priveledge beyond all other Australians!! How is that right?! Thankfully, unlike you, most Australians are fair and just and this will go down!!! It does not make sense!!! That's why the polls have dropped!!! Let's see what all the funding and hype will do!!! I hope not much for the sake of ALL Australians.
Referendum 2023 | The Voice to Parliament Debate | Listen to both sides!
1:33:33
Centre for Independent Studies
Рет қаралды 161 М.
Why we need to mine the Moon | If You're Listening | ABC News In-depth
15:46
CAN YOU HELP ME? (ROAD TO 100 MLN!) #shorts
00:26
PANDA BOI
Рет қаралды 36 МЛН
1 класс vs 11 класс (неаккуратность)
01:00
БЕРТ
Рет қаралды 4,8 МЛН
Celebrating the Uluru Statement from the Heart with Professor Megan Davis and Pat Anderson AO
1:27:12
The Voice: A Distraction from Real Problems | John Anderson
5:28
John Anderson
Рет қаралды 33 М.
Pauline Hanson makes speech ahead of Voice referendum bill vote
5:23
Sky News Australia
Рет қаралды 39 М.
Jacinta Nampijinpa Price says 'we don't need a voice, we need ears' | 7.30
13:14
How Has Sunak’s Campaign Gone So Far?
8:20
TLDR News
Рет қаралды 186 М.
CAN YOU HELP ME? (ROAD TO 100 MLN!) #shorts
00:26
PANDA BOI
Рет қаралды 36 МЛН