Not to mention that She said that she was sick before starting to play.

She is a very emotional singer to start so having to do this was to much for her i think.

It made me start bawling when she broke down 😭✨🖤

She said once that it would kill her if she sang the song live, I doubt she will do it again any time soon, but who knows.

I don't think it is a "fear" of performing it, but may be a hurtful point in her life that brings back some of the memories and pain. How would any of us like to re-live a truly sad time of our lives. I love the song, brings tears to my eyes, but I completely understand that she has a reason to keep it personal.

@@joebryant5793 Ok, so "FEARs" is not the best word, but I didn't want to write as mush as you wrote to explain it. Just replace FEARS with what you wrote. Thanks

@@JesusVillanueva I understand. It's just some people think it's her duty to sing it. Let her(or the rest of The Warning) decide what they sing.

@@joebryant5793 When this song came out, it was clear it was so emotional. Even listening to it brings back memories of a serious dark time for myself. I can't imagine how dark of a place you'd have to be in to actually write the song. I completely agree with everything you've said.

I think they have. Ale had tears telling her feelings about her life around her sisters and this band on the video during the show. We saw it twice with Pau. First time was when Rudy told his clients (DPA) they were going to open for Muse (Mexican leg). Pau was the one who broke down. Not Ale. Plus here performing *Breathe.* Hearing the audience singing her emotional song back to her. And she had that moment in time to reflect in front of strangers who loves that woman. Dany had her time back after the long Mayday Tour to remember a friend who apparently passed away a year earlier. When she got on line to share her grief to her fans with two songs. A cover & theirs *"Show Me The Light".* Plus her solo *"Heule a Melon"* the first night of these special shows.

​@@kevinthetruckdriver353That's cool, thanks for sharing!

Yes they truly are.

....and must be protected at all cost.

I want Black Holes!!!!

Es parte del rock 🤘🖤

Me recordó cuando mon laferte transmitió ese sentimiento. Son grandes los artistas mexicanos.

Hay muchos que transmiten

@@jaissonandresparradocely7956 pero solo el rock es profundo hermano

@@Freak_on_a_leash_ ok. Entiendo que usted le gusta el rock, pero hay mucha música que es también profunda

And the audience sang the song in a language not their own.

Very well said. Yes, we don't realize the amount of pressure the girls have undergone since they were kids.

Bien dicho bro, totalmente de acuerdo, larga vida a las The Warning ⚡🤘🏼🇲🇽

I'm thinking both. It must be so cool to hear the fans sing back your song to you!

As much as I love Breathe,it isn’t one I can go back to and listen to frequently. There are not tons of reaction videos for it and I think it has the lowest view count on KZfaq for a Lyric video from Error. This is not because it is the least liked/appreciated/resonating, quite the opposite. It is hard to digest and with her as the producer, played on the home piano and all of it pure Pau it really hits hard. We all know Pau doesn’t just “play” music, she opens up a portal to her soul , which for many also is reflective and is a mirror that we can see in ourselves. That is a real harmony. People can tell Pau that they they love it, tell her how it impacts them and an artist can rationalize the “low statistics” for views/listens, but no metric could have been more validating as an honest measure of the fan appreciation as that crowd knowing every word and their total reaction. Standing ovations in classical music are great when they last longer than they should, but to be the composer, lyricist, producer and performer of this “Bonus” track and have this huge audience know every word… I can’t imagine an equivalent level of validation and show of love from fans/friends/family then what happened here. I would think that even for Pau that took courage and felt risky. You set expectations. It looked like there were uncontrollable smiles from her - reminding me of when they first performed Revenant, and her look towards her sister near the end, but this was so much more. I don’t think I can even watch this video again for sometime. I just woke up and it was a pop-up notification so I HAD to hear it, but the emotions are so tangible and in such raw undiluted form that I feel both what she gave with her soul and knowing even how I would feel to receive the overwhelming impossible to fake evidence that her song really connected really hit me hard. It definitely is a good cry, but it won’t be a performance that stop eliciting such an emotional impact from me, forever.

Great coment 👍🏽

Well said

well said ..bro

I completely agree, man. Just the way you said it: It's her song and it's an expression of deep personal pain. But, it's also an universal thing. And many of us can easily relate to it on a very deep level, myself included. And being there, last Saturday, with her and all that people around, sharing this moment gave me that: Catharsis and validation. And I hope everyone else, but specially Pau, felt that too. She sang it from the bottom of her heart to all of us, and we sang it back to her from the bottom of our hearts too. It was truly a gift, and I will treasure this moment in my heart. Forever. 😢❤

@@eduardovenegas1335 I dont think is so painfull as much as an emotional load for her, she is so sensitive and empathetic, true artists are like that, they have an enhance emotional receptivity, and sometimes is too much for them, however..thats why she is able to write so high quality moving musical scores..!

This is also why Black Sabbath created 'Paranoid'. The record label said running time for the album they were composing was three minutes light. So, they whipped the song together right then and there in the studio.

Or rather a "black holes" where the heart should have been

Mexican radio seldom play rock as far as I know. Hopefully The Warning will change it.

Ms. PUH PAU Can Break Anyone With A Heart !!! PUH PAU !!!

No baby girl should have to sing a song so sad.

"I try to reach over the endless waves Can't call for help, so I'll just call my name But not even I can hear I'll just disappear without a trace" How dark is that desperation though? Unbelievable that a 18 year olf girl wrote that!!! Pau could've won so many literary awards by publishing her profound metaphorical poetry.

Ningun atrevimiento, Suscribo cada palabra, asi es como esta naciendo una leyenda de las letras.saludos!!!

To me she is almost at the level of Bob Dylan, Leonard Cohen, Roger Waters & Paul McCartney. And I know that I am not the only one who thinks ike that. Saludos fron India.

She'll be 22 on Feb

She wrote this as an 18 year old in 2020

That's exactly what crossed my mind multiple times seeing and hearing pau. And i'm not even religious... She's like an old soul. Reincarnated with all the wisdom and living life to the fullest this time. Great to see so many people praise her and the warning and cheering for them. Not only because of their talent but for being those fantastic human role-models. Same with Floor and Nightwish. Social media and the news often leave me with a very gloom impression of mankind. But maybe it's not that bad and there is a silent mass of people having similar values and ideals.

AFAIK there hasn't been any explanation of what *Breathe* is about or what inspired its existence... we may find out, one day...

The story as I understand it, is that this song was a late addition to the album after they were already back in Mexico after recording...the label requested one more track so Paulina recorded this on the old piano in the living room of their house and sent it with the caveat that she would NEVER perform it live as it essentially a panic attack set to music...

@@DavidSJ_DAPwow thanks for the info

@@DavidSJ_DAP True