Honest Trailers do that bit justice fyi. Enjoy....

A Fyed and Paul, buddy cop cousin spin-off would have been amazing.

It was a cool thing to him.

@@tdyrc Honest trailers nailed that moment....

Lol that is interesting - my first reaction to that was Feyd smirks at the 'formality' of it all, like it's some sort of unnecessary show of respect since they are fighting to the death so him saying it back to him is in a sort of mocking way.

Paul: Takes a shit and buries it in the sand. Stilgar: He will know their ways as if born to them.

It is the legend…again

AS IT WAS WRITTEN

haha I love stilgar he becomes a straight up fanatic for the later part of the movie.

Stilgar " he is too humble to wear his gilded slippers ... PROOF!"

Nor did I to see Anton Chigurh and Llewellyn Moss work together and become friends.

Underrated comment!!!😂😂😂

And what a fight it was.

Lmfao, they both did a fantastic job in all characters they have played, including Paul and Feyd

Soon it’ll be Elvis vs Bob Dylan

Elevated Feyd's character to actually have weight behind his showboating, I like it from a story-telling perspective. It's giving Paul a more balanced character foil, and a single Harkonnen he can respect in combat, if not in personality. The blade to the brain is brutal though and I wish they used it in the film.

@@josepmahone5008yeah, the first time I was watching this, that’s what I was expecting when Feyd was trying to finish Paul off so I was clenching in my seat. But I guess a blade to the heart is a little more palatable

@@bryangregory48 trump card was supposed to be Count Fenrir but i guess hes not in the movies

@@lfccole08 yeah, I’m surprised they showed his wife but not him. Maybe he’ll show up in the next movie when Shaddam is exiled

I guess Denis wanted to highlight the fact that Feyd could have been the Kwisatz Haderach instead of Paul, just as the Reverend Mother said, so making him a good match for Paul's skills makes a lot of sense

I always said that books were a bit lackluster when describing the knife fights. Guess that wasn't the priority but considering the Sardaukar were supposed to be apex warriors but the Fremen slap them around like they're nothing you'd have to use your own imagination.

And stunt performers

@@noahsabin7386yes of course

What’s that brown stuff on the top of your nose?

@@ashzoleit’s shit obviously

5:18 mine laughed here

Stilgar looks like he almost forgot to get the line in that day and just remembered

@@pug_knight7756to me I just love that added stomp. So badass

It was a good way to break the tension!

Same lol everytime Lisan Al Gaib is mentioned lmao

Oh God, now I need a bad lip reading of this whole scene!

@@ApparentlyGoogledislikesmyname the first quote is from dune 1, baron to Leto

Damn I just now realized, lady Jessica is Duke Leto’s niece and Paul is his father’s son and nephew. Jerry Springer shit.

Yah I was confused too. In till I learned cousin is also a term between family houses under the same lord even if not related.

Yeah they are definitely related 😂

Nah it was super annoying and distracting.

nah you never been in the fight​@@BlackBinderGames

@@schonborn01 Irrelevant. It was annoying and distracting

@@BlackBinderGames you are annoying and distracting. pls leave my space and place. now.

@@BlackBinderGamesyou’re trying to hard go troll somewhere else

I think paul coulda stabbed his leg when he did that

As long as it's not a stab, a good shoe sole can deflect blade strikes. I remember seeing Antonio Banderas doing that in one of his Zorro's movies

The Mikiri exists for a reason.

Raid 2 did that in the final fight as well.

mikiri counter

Feyd, the only one who wasn’t useless

He also was the only one who didnt want power. He only wanted to prove he was the best of the best among the people in the room. The throne and the Princess were only secondary side quest and prizes. He was a competent Harkonnen, like his uncle, but without the doomed ambition.

@@martingenero6328 And was a badass fighter. Wonder how long Feyd would've lasted against Gurney.

​@@Pasan34 Gurney would wipe the floor with Feyd in a fair fight. The problem is that Feyd is a sewer rat who would never give him a fair fight. In the book, he almost defeated Paul by using a dirty trick of a poisoned needle in his hip. Furthermore, Gurney would attack blinded by hatred of the Harkonnens. Things wouldn't turn out well for him.

​@@santiago-mk6om what is it with these opinions downplaying Feyd in the movie? Feyd was a very tough fighter in these films and he literally almost killed Paul, nothing like the sewer rat or other adjectives you people like to keep using.

Feyd: “no you”

Feyd: yeah whatever to you to

May thy chip shatter

What does it mean ?

I would assume a neat way of wishing defeat upon the enemy.​@@setnomA

Man I never noticed that!

Dang, you right!

Wow. Excellent noticing!! Love it.

Wow holy shit

Wow

Then got kicked immediately after it because it's unnecessary lol.

He also tried to sneak in a swipe at Feyds leg mid spin

The impression I got from the books is that alot of the fighting was quite acrobatic.

When you an idol like him, you can’t just win. No you have to look good while winning!

Probably necessary to build hype in the coming jihad for one of Paul's visions of the future. Every single move was calculated according to the book.

Gotta love the atreides salute, simple but very commanding for whatever reason

​@@RisingBboyNeXuSit's like declaring they'll fight with their heart and their mind

@@matiasaguilar2500 oooo I like that, definitely using that quote dude that’s legendary

​@@matiasaguilar2500that's exactly what it means. I've trained in the martial art this is based on and the Salute means "I salute to you, striving for/giving knowledge (head) with all my inner energy (stomach) and respect and loyalty from my heart (heart)." They only skip the stomach move I think

​@@dinobot66 what martial art? I'm curious 👀

2:21 Stilgar on the other hand is wondering if it’s too late to get his lisan al-gaib membership refunded

​@@CuttingEdges 🤣

He also made Channi unnecessarily rebellious in this scene

@@youtubeistryingtocensorme Superior change.

@@CuttingEdges debatable

They did the same thing earlier in the movie too but I forget which scene it was

It felt so tense, especially since there was always some kind of ambiance or soundtrack for the rest of the movie

Fun fact: you can also hear Paul's vision of the green paradise before he pounds his chest and stomps the ground

​@@olofacosta3192 nice catch. that's crazy

If you splice this fight scene together with the Andore Cage Fight theme from the arcade version of Final Fight, it would fit perfectly.

Exactly, the fight was amazing to witness in the Cinema.

Aye choreography in episode 7 was fantastic, it was episode 8 and 9 that had a stroke and dropped the plot and quality. Revenge of the 5th!

Vey true!! Hollywood finally back with something that blows away the rest. About time.

@@glich5601the choreography of the 7th was one of the worst . Rey and Finn fought very badly , that make sense they are noob , but kylo ? He has no excuse .

I think you mean rehersed choreography of the prequels dude.

That and the winner doesn’t usually go unscathed. You know what they say,” in a knife fight the loser goes to the morgue and the winner goes to the icu”

The fight with Jamis echoed here. Also fast, and brutal, with everything at stake.

Hector vs Achilles (Troy 2004) had the same affect

The hard breathing were realistic and visceral too, when you move your full body like that you’ll tire out

Either that, or Pauls visions of a green Arrakis and the galaxy spanning war he'll unleash on the world. Free water, that can actually slosh around, is closely matched with death in Arrakis

Yup. The closer paul is to victory, the more he is bombarded with the future. Hence why he silences the visions with stomps and chest bumps​@@AntonGudenus

At first I thought “yeah, the moment Paul rips the blade free from Feyd’s heart. Ferocious.” Then I saw it. And it hit me.

AS WRITTEN

nice catch. Saw it twice on IMAX and hadn't noticed it.

The waves are also heard when Feyd called Chani a pet

What's making the wave sound?

@@sam.e.a6422 It’s a callback to Paul’s path to paradise and his vision of the ocean on Arrakis. After Paul takes the water of life he talks with his mother about the “narrow way through.” They show a 1 second vision of someone getting stabbed. Obviously that was Paul stabbing Feyd.

Same at 1:47

Real corn cob energy

"mAy tHy kNiFe cHiP aNd sHaTtEr"

Ah thats an interesting perspective. I thought it was Feyd just doing the cheesy villain taunt but actually he never knew better

@@luiousy7329 yeah the harkonnen's culture need to be studied hehe

That's a good perspective. I assumed it was him trying to goad him into fighting more seriously

How did the stab wound move from Paul’s side to his right shoulder?

@@pigpog2307 he let Feyd stab him in the shoulder and he pulled his knife out his stomach to stab him

@@jhedatitan4228paul was stabbed with both knives used in the battle and still won

@@jhedatitan4228 Yes.

Feyd's not only one of the only two characters who embody the Litany Against Fear and pass through without losing themselves, he's introduced actively disgusted that he has nothing to fear and thus no way to be who he truly is. Even Paul gave in to fear of Chani's potential death and drank the WoL; so ironically Feyd in this scene truly has become a "hero" and the only hope for billions of lives Muad'Dib's Jihad will take.

Should’ve taunted how fucked Paul is with his “golden path” since movie Feyd could see. Its what i would do lmao

Yeah, it does say something that, in his dying moment, he gives a genuine compliment to Paul. Maybe it's him trying to form some human connection in whatever time he has left.

Thats why hes an ultimate badass

He's very similar to that trope of badass villain you previously hated coming and kicking asses of some more despicable and less competent villains and showing them how it's done. Everyone, including the "good guys" are so manipulative and deceitful and here's this one guy who doesn't fear to fight his own battles, wears his heart on his sleeve and immediately gets shit done. He's someone you wanna see as the final boss or someone who ultimately comes to his senses, switches sides and teams up with the protagonist against the final boss. It's easy to see that potential. It's just that he was in the wrong kind of story for any of that to happen.

Avoid shame even in shaming situation. Just like German diplomat who stole pen from hotel to sign Treaty of Versailles because French delegation gave him pen from Alsace-Lorraine. Germany lost this land after World War I. So it would be double shame for them.

“hurry up bro i’m bleeding out from my stab wound”

I thought this as well. Had flashbacks to Lord Eddard

I read the book, so knew he had to win, but was still shocked. My girlfriend grabbed and squeezed my arm on the armrest. She hadn't read it 😂

same

My husband sitting at the edge of his seat for this scene 😂

Video quality has been updated.

You can see after Paul gets stabbed his face falls like "oh.... No lisan al'Gahib😔"

On the other hand it's definitely funny, but also that comedy in itself is extremely tragic. He used to be really charismatic and competent leader, now he's husk of his former self, only fit to become a comedic relief. I'm not gonna say all religions are inherently bad, but his faith definitely was to him.

On the left, a Harkonnen battle armor, and on the right, a Fremen stilsuit. Beautiful way of showing us how the date of Arrakis and this the universe depends on the outcome of this fight

I LOVE IT. Sitting in the IMAX theatre watching that for the first I was like "That was cool." lol

It was cool but unnecessary, I’m glad he got floored with a kick afterwards just to prove how it was more of a vanity display of skill by Paul rather than an effective dodge.

Its looks bad ass, but Paul overplays his hand there Feyd was ready for it.

I hope that it was Timothy that performed that stunt.

​@@PKTraceuryup, he wasn't simple nor direct and immediately pays for it.

Also in the book Jessica wanted Paul to use the word the Bene Gesserits subliminally inputed into Feyd's mind that would make him dull or slow, but Paul crying out that he won't use it stuns Feyd still.

Yeah thank God Zack Snyder didn't direct this. 😂

@@peterphan227 Zack Snyder directed the Batman warehouse scene in BvS. So he's more than capable of doing action like this

@@mazzo-4k Yes he can. But BvS was made almost a decade ago. Snyder has gone downhill since then. The current version of Snyder loves gratuitous slo-mo (see: Rebel Moon 1 and 2), and if he had directed this Dune fight scene today, it would likely be full of slo-mo.

@peterphan227 idk man I've been seeing a bunch of slo mo shots from denis. Not that slo motion is a bad thing but if you're gonna criticize snyder for it then denis deserves the same

@@mazzo-4k The difference is that Denis doesn't have gratuitous slo mo shots that he relies on to carry a movie 😂. Snyder's use of slo mo is off the charts. Just compare the number of slo mo shots in Snyder's Rebel Moon 1 and 2 versus Denis' Dune 1 and 2. Snyder's number is pretty huge. If Snyder had directed Star Wars: A New Hope, we would have a slow mo sequence of Luke, Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru doing moisture farming. Heck, we'd probably have a scene of Luke having a playful slo mo water fight with his aunt and uncle at sunset with for no other reason than Snyder being in love with such treacly, gratuitous visuals.

Yeah thanks to a lack of actually good sci fi films

@@Gin-San101 Bruh what? That's like saying LOTR is only good thanks to a lack of actually good fantasy films. You're acting as if Empire Strikes Back, Interstellar, Aliens, 2001, Blade Runner, Matrix, EEAAO, Avatar, Terminator 2, Arrival don't exist and Dune part two doesn't take a dump over all the aforementioned names except for a couple.

@@maazahmed506 There's not a lot of good fantasy movies either. You chose some of the best ones, sci fi has been around for decades upon decades and theres not a lot of even decent sci fi movies.

@@Gin-San101 Are you even reading your comments? In your first reply you said that Dune is only good because there is a lack of quality sci-fi films but when I mentioned some of the best sci-fi movies which Dune is supercedes (not all but most of them), you proceeded to tell me that I chose the best ones? You can either acknowledge that the sci-fi movies I mentioned are some of the best works of their genre or that Dune is good/better than them and not because there is a lack of good sci-fi movies.

@@maazahmed506 Yes I did. Don't put words in my mouth I didn't say Dune is "ONLY" good due to a lack of movies, I'm saying it's far easier to say so because there's not a lot of good sci fi movies, Dune 1 & 2 are great movies but the bar for sci fi is low. A lot of the sci fi you listed are incomparable conceptually, there's no similarity for Dune and Arrival other than the fact they are both sci fi. I don't have to adhere to what you think I have to acknowledge.

True.

Yep Yep!

Exact same move. Feyd had him beat.

Honestly, they have enough content for a decade long marvel type stint. Yet each movie is so carefully crafted, it could extend out to 10-15 years with just the next 3 movies. In my mind as a die hard Star Wars fan, dune deserves and should have that moving forward, a guaranteed quality showing, each time.

Didn’t Fayd Rautha murder his mother? Pretty sure she wouldn’t care if she was dead

We just had to sit there and take it..

Goodfellas

Sound quality. Our smartphone don't have an IMAX bass sound system behind them....

For two reasons. 1- you didn't see it coming the first time. 2- you didn't have the big IMAX speakers right behind you in this case. GREAT SCENE EITHER WAY. "LONG LIVE THE FIGHTERS".

Kind of cute in retrospective this twink is inserting his dominance

was it an IMAX theatre?

If I remember correctly, in the book Paul doesn’t know for sure he’s going to win. He sees possible futures and knows the course of action needed to get the future he considers best, but he still has to make it happen, he has to take action. And there are things he doesn’t see or can’t see clearly even after drinking the Water of Life, like the existance of Count Fenring. Paul reflects on the possible outcomes of the fight with Feyd. He knows the Holy War will happen even if Feyd kills him in that fight. He’ll end up as a martyr to the fremen and they will carry out the jihad in his name. It’s less about how powerful Paul is and more about how the war is inevitable by that point. You may be right and Paul was constantly assessing the situation and doing what he had to in order to win, but still, he could’ve died there.

It was the only way, not the best

it hits different in real life....

Felt like 10 minutes lol, so tense

Never thought of it that way but true! Just goes to show that Frank Herbert’s message of the dangers of a messianic figure we’re incredibly dangerous, even if Paul didn’t move any closer to fulfilling the prophecy

In the book, Emperor Shaddam was accompanied by someone unique, the only friend of the Emperor, Count Hasimir Fenring. He was a failed Kwisatz Haderach and one of the few people Paul doesn't see in his many visions of the future, which meant that in those futures, Paul dies to him. Fenring was ordered to kill Paul after his duel with Feyd, but he refused, which earned him a stiff backhand from the Emperor. Even though he was arguable the most skilled combatant in the immediate area (and possibly the whole empire) , he forgave the Emperor and told him that he is refusing to kill Paul for his sake and that the Emperor should give up. Faced with this, the Emperor had no choice but to surrender the throne. It is widely interpreted that if Paul had died either by Feyd or Fenring, the Fremen would have frenzied and killed everyone; the Jihad was inevitable. Both Fenring and Paul understood the assignment and choose to let Paul live to lessen the impact of the Jihad.

He killed 61 billion people in his jihad. Idk how you can kill more than that 😂

I'm currently reading the book, and Paul explicitly has a vision of exactly this, him dying prematurely and the subsequent jihad being just as brutal.

@@mattandrews2594 i never read the book but I should! I really enjoyed the movies, even tho in the first one I was barely awake loll, but the techonologies and ships was so stunning

He was stabbed in the side but the knife ends up in his right shoulder !! Blooper or did he magically move the wound ?

@@pigpog2307 I guess Feyd stabbed him in the side with his own crysknife, and as he was about to kill Paul with the Emperor's blade, Paul stabbed him but Feyd still managed to stab him in the shoulder...

​@@pigpog2307Paul decided to let his lesser position like feyd into driving the killing blow, while feyd was distracted paul removed the knife stuck in his abdomen whilst redirecting feyds knife into his shoulder, he allowed this to happen knowing that he would receive a non fatal blow, while also I flicking a fatal blow

You could say that he nearly got his Feyd in right there.

@@achaean7615Yeah, and still managed to keep standing after being stabbed twice. I would have passed out.

Now it’s Bob Dylan vs. Elvis Presley

People who have never fought or exercised in their lives

When people see even a real fistfight they're often shocked at how soon they end and just how badly someone can get seriously hurt, fast.

I still didn’t see how he pulled that last move off.

@@spac3cloud922Me neither!

Yup. I only realised after reading a huge thread about it on reddit. It is actually really confusing, and you dont even hear Paul's knife as he removes it from his abdomen whilst he is simultaneously holding and diverting Feyd's blade. Also.. After Paul has killed Feyd and stood up, there is a shot where he appears to still have a knife in the abdomen. It's about half a second long, just before the Stilgar line at 3:16 ... basically a continuity error! See if you can spot it. It's fast and a bit blurry. There is definitely something protruding from Paul's belly.... Edit... i have watched this bit at 3:16 a ton of times on repeat and conclude that they probably havent made an error and it's just the weird angle of Paul's body as he is down on one knee and twisted and bent slightly so that as we are looking at him from his right hand side and slightly behind him it somewhat appears as though blade protrudes from abdomen rather than shoulder. Tricky!!

Came here to try to understand the poor cinematography of the knives. I read the book, and know how it played out. But I don't understand why the director would allow a great movie to end with such a confusing scene. Paul is stabbed in the lower left abdomen, and knife remains there. Then Fayd tries to stab him with a different knife (where did that come from?) In the books, it's explained that he keeps hidden knives on his person, and there is also a smaller knife within the handle of the original one. But it's not clear in the movie where he suddenly got another knife? Or was it his original one that the emporer gave him. Then Paul grabs the blade directly and diverts it to his own shoulder. But it's not shown that Paul is using his other hand to pull the knife out of his own belly and stab Feyd with it. It's all terrible cinematography and terrible editing. At one point, it looks like the knife in Paul's abdomen disappears, then reappears in the next scene. What the heck? Could have been a great scene if things were more apparent about what's happening.

@@PhillipBell yes!! So so weird. So... there are only two knifes. The knife that Paul is initially stabbed with is his Own knife - somehow Feyd manages to divert Paul's hand/knife into himself - leaving Paul empty handed. Then, yes, Paul divert's the emperor's blade Feyd is pointing at him, into his shoulder for a non lethal wound, whilst simultaneously, and with zero squelching sound or apparently effort(?!), removing the blade from his own abdomen, turning it around and inserting it into Feyd in the perfect spot. Hmmmmm??!! (Though i must say, I could not figure that out for myself after seeing the film twice at the cinema. I actually thought they were trying to depict that Paul had miraculously reversed the direction of the blade Fed was pointed at him, even more unbelievably, and I came online because i was bewildered having noticed that first of all Paul had a blade in his abdomen, and then it was in his shoulder, and i wondered if anyone was talking about that. I had totally not picked up on the fact that Paul's own knife was supposed to have been turned against him, or the way that the final bit played out - unsurprisingly considering how darn unclear they made it!) And yes, there is that blurry shot from the right hand side of Paul at 3:16 that looks like the blade is back in his abdomen again after he has already supposedly removed it, stabbed Feyd with it, and removed it from Feyd. I am trying to believe that they couldn't possibly have got that bit wrong, and that it is just a really weird angle as we are seeing Paul from the side whilst he is bending down on one knee, but the height of the blade location in his shoulder in the next shot makes that hard to believe. I read on reddit people suggesting that because of the P13 rating, the knife insertions had to be not shown. Or some limit to the amount of wounds/blood etc, something like that. Which would explain the editing to some extent. But still, considering how fantastic the rest of the movie is for editing, it is confusing and disappointing for sure. Why not just make it clear and have a higher rating. I am going to watch it again in the cinema tonight, wonder if it will be any clearer on the big screen rather than my 13inch laptop now that i know the information. That's kinda besides the point though.

There are no waves it’s a desert it’s the wind

​@pigpog2307 actually it is waves, but it's because it's the vision paul had earlier of the ocean on Arrakis. He knows this is a pivotal moment to making his future he saw a reality.

Those same exact “waves” are heard during the Feyd pet exchange. Explain that

​@joshTHX Paul's vision is rapidly entering his mind. That's part of the reason he does the chest slam and stomping. Both to intimidate but also to silence them

Still losing blood. The suit recycles fluids but doesn’t send them to veins :)

I think the advantage paul had was the plot😅😂

Bene Gesserit training I think. I think he healed faster.

@@ritwikamajumdar5967 That, and due to the Fremen's strict water "discipline" and the environment they've adapted to, any bleeding wounds that a Fremen sufferes seem to clot pretty damn quick if they're not outright killed by them. There was a small part in the book when Jessica was tested by the Shadout Mapes that touches on this.

Elvis Presley vs Bob Dylan

@@lukekiely2450 the battle of the 60’s

@@lukekiely2450 Well said sir.

Batman vs Bane sucked. Nolan cannot film choreography

@@liamcephus9687 Say what you will but at least it was 100% practical and Bane never uttered the name "MARTHA"! Besides Nolan goes for realism not style.

I think they improved a lot in the second movie. I thought some of the action in the first one felt kinda weird, contrived, but they nailed it in the second movie. Awesome. Villeneuve is, in my opinion, the greatest mainstream director of this generation.

Rabban didn't kiss Feyd's feet either. He just made it look like he did, and if everyone sees that, then it's just as well.