They were smiling, you were smiling, I was smiling. 😊

Thanks Carmen - yes, that lurking lady is hilarious, never noticed it before. 🤣

It brought me such joy after a rough day at work to see your beaming face reacting to this. My heart would explode if you reacted to a couple of other happy songs - Cruisin' for a bruisin' and Rather be.

Apparently Avi was the only one who can’t rap. Lol check out Starships, and thrift shop and problem to see them all rapping, and also PopSpring 2016 can’t sleep love and Feeling myself by Superfruit for Mitch rapping.

Great reaction. Thank you. You are the first reactor that I've seen to notice the woman standing there watching. You get extra points for being super observant. lol. Subscribed.

I have watched this video at least 200 times and never noticed the lady just standing there. Oh to have your young eyes and observational skills. 😃 Now I have to wonder how many other things I've missed in their videos. Great reaction Carmen, really am enjoying your channel. Peace and blessings.

Everything they do is amazing. Can't wait to see them live in Toronto in August. Have no idea of what songs they will do but whatever they choose, you know will blow the crowd away.

My favorite part of the location/featured singer changes is they each have their own theme, and everyone's dress caters to the theme of the featured individual. So fun. Never noticed the photo bomb ^_^

They did soooo good on this song.

This is not only a great song, but one where I kept thinking how great all their smiles are -- every single one of them! You made me laugh, too -- if you saw "Pentatonix in the wild." lol😂

If I saw Pentatonix in the wild, I would be that lady in the pink dress too with my mouth hanging open! Besides their incredible vocals, it’s the dynamics / musicality that elevate their interpretations to the stratosphere and to do it a cappella is just mind-blowing 🔥❤️🙌

Avi's knee action! 😄 Another one with stellar work by Kevin and Avi (Mitch rapping!) is their cover of "Problem". Thanks for sharing Carmen.

I love younger PTX, they are so happy! Also the clarity, if unpolished, appeals to me. Cheers!

I love when the use songs to relate their history

They looked happy, you looked happy, what a good reaction! Well done, looking forward to more. Peace …

I’ve never noticed that lady in pink in the background. Lol

Great Monday morning choice Carmen! Have a great week! ☺️. Oh and I’ve seen this video sooo many times and never saw that lady in the back 😂

LOVED your reaction, Carmen, and really was impressed you caught that lady in the pink dress in the background. I’ve watched probably 50 different reactions to this video now and get so caught up in the music I never saw her!! I enjoy all your reactions, I have Liked and Subscribed and always look forward to your Pentatonix reactions ❤😊

Definitely watch the behind-the-scenes. The entire music video was shot at the campus of Mount St. Mary's University in the mountains near Los Angeles. The year following this video, Avi, Ben Bram (PTX's producer/arranger) and Rob Dietz (composer/arranger) founded the A Cappella Academy, an annual 10-day intensive Summer music camp for 12 to 18-year-olds from around the world, and it took place at this campus until the pandemic hit (it's now at another Southern California college campus). The kids who attend have to video audition for a spot, and those who make it through are extraordinary performers. An example of what they can do is the the 2019 A Cappella Academy full choir performing Avi's original song "The Seed". Beautiful and emotional. Definitely check it out.

Great Reaction. Hope all is well

Fantastic reaction, Carmen. This is true talent.

In all the times watching this video, I never noticed the woman in the background. I was so focused on Avi 😍, as usual, I didn't catch anything in the background. 😁

I always look forward to your Pentatonix Mondays reactions and especially happy to see how this song lifted your spirits. For me the two songs that are "go to" for me when I need a little boost are both by PTX, "Sing" which you have already reacted to and the other one is "Come Along" (a Cosmo Sheldrake cover). Great work, keep it up.

PTX was such a good EP. They were so good early.

As many times as I've watched this video over the years, I never noticed the lady in the pink dress behind them!!! Good eye!

Happy Monday Carmen. Always look forward to your reactions. PTX just came out with cover of Creep (with instruments) from their appearance on the Masked Singer. You should watch the unmasked version from the show.

If you liked this which you obviously did, please check out their original Sing! Upbeat, fun and has a lot of fans and celebrities in it and when they say cut at the end, don't stop, keep it going.

Such a great reaction 👍 your smile makes me smile 😁 I would love to see you react to Popspring Special 2016 ! They're live in Japan, recorded by MTV, the sound is incredible, you can hear any one of them so easily and.... Avi 😍 this live performance is 3 originals and one medley. Just wonderful ! The first one, Cracked, is written by Avi and Scott, fantastic ! The last one is my favorite, Water, written by Kirsty and Kevin... outstanding 😍 With your sensitivity and love of detail, you will love it for sure ! 15 minutes of art, talent and joy ! Hope to see you react to this one 🤞 Thanks for this great moment 😘

Recommend their cover of My Favorite Things.

An early one! :)

A Capela Band ,HOMEFREE- "A man of constant sorrow"or "Ring of Fire" with Avi Kaplan

Great reaction

They always do upgrades, not covers.

Are you going to see a show while they're still in Europe? There are a lot of Behind the Scenes videos I didn't know about!

You should react to come along from them it's amazing and so beautiful, also if you want to hear mitch rap more you should react to 'problem' mitch's rapping really shocked me when I saw it I loved it so much😄

There were a lot of crew there. She may have been one.

Your shirt matches your lantern behind you.