Bluestar was the first big character we had that constantly bashed on starclan with good and just reasoning. She had every reason to turn her back on starclan, they took everything from her. Her kids, her happiness, her sanity, everyone she could ever trust betrayed her on way or another. Kinda sad she went through all that, and still forgave straclan in her last breaths. They didn't deserve her forgiveness

I remember reading her death and then just immediately crying, I ran to my mom and was like "BLUESTAR IS DEAD" before just collapsing on the ground so well written, absolutely brutally tore my heart out, this PMV is absolutely wonderful

THIS IS SO RAW AND EMOTIONAL! It fits Bluestar and her trauma-induced breakdown soooo well and your art is so dynamic to match the feel of the song! In particular that shot where Bluestar is falling into the water is absolutely gorgeous!

I noticed that when Bluestar shouts or gets angry the lines of her drawing get all twisted and spiky and that's a thing I didn't notice immediately but I could feel her anger just by looking at her and that made me love your art style so much. Every line of the drawing carries so much emotion that I simply have no words for it, it's just soooo good. Another example is firepaw/hearth, when he is young and excited to learn from Bluestar his lines are soft and round when he helps Bluestar his lines are straight and boxier showing his concern about helping her and it stays like that for most of the time he's near Bluestar because what happened to her showing that he was unease to speak to her.

1:02 Holy s**t. Brilliant. That's a connection I never drew in a million years. To everyone else, think about it. Bluestar has WindClan-related trauma going back to when she was a kit. While that doesn't get shown here, it fits the theme of this video to a T. Her blaming WindClan for the theft- it was that trauma coming back as her mental state began to degrade, dredging up old memories that were no longer relevant to the present day! Phenomenal!

1:52 , BlueStar skidded to a halt at the top of the slope; the stench of dogs hit her throat. Below, the ferns shook as the dark shapes swarmed through the gully. FireHeart’s orange pelt flashed like flame through the greenery. He was keeping a good pace between himself and the pack, but the lead dog was breaking away and closing fast on the ThunderClan deputy. No! Not that one! You cannot use him as prey! BlueStar flung herself down the slope. Gulping air, muscles burning, she weaved around the trees, her paws skidding on the leafy forest floor. She hurtled through a swath of ferns, running blind as the leaves whipped her face. The gorge was close by. She could hear the river crashing between the sheer gray walls. Would FireHeart really be able to lure the dog pack over the edge? What if the packs leader caught him first? She erupted from the bracken and scrabbled to a stop in a clearing at the edge of the cliff. Leaves sprayed into the chasm as her paws slipped and slid Oh StarClan, no! FireHeart was dangling from the glistening jaws of a huge dog. The ThunderClan deputy struggled, spitting with fury. The dog shook him, it’s eyes glittering with triumph, but it’s clumsy paws were skittering dangerously close to the edge of the gorge. “I will not let you destroy my Clan!” BlueStar roared. She flung herself at FireHearts tormentor, slamming headfirst into its flank. The dog dropped FireHeart and spun around in surprise. BlueStar crouched and unsheathed her claws. Blood roared in her ears but she felt no fear. She had not felt this alive for moons. She lashed out at the dogs muzzle, but her claws raked empty air. The dog was sliding away from her! The ground beneath its hind legs was crumbling. Shards of stone showered down the steep face of the gorge as the dogs paws scrabbled to get a grip, but it’s blunt claws were slithering on the leaf-strewn forest floor as it’s haunches dragged its hind legs backward over the cliff. The pack thundered closer. “BlueStar!” FireHeart warned But BlueStar didn’t take her eyes from the pack leader. She was locked in its panicked gaze as dogs began to crash through the bracken behind her. The pack was upon them. BlueStar dug her claws into the swift earth as the air suddenly soured with fear. The lunging dogs has seen the gorge, and their howls turned to yelps as they skidded at its edge. BlueStar held her ground as a desperate yowl echoed down the chasm, the first dog had fallen. It’s body thumped against the cliff, and there was a moment of quiet before she heard it splash into the roaring water below. BlueStar narrowed her eyes, still fixed on the pack leader. “You should have never threatened ThunderClan!” She hissed. Suddenly the dog stretched its head forward and grasped her foreleg in its jaws. She felt the ground slide beneath her as the dog dragged her with it over the edge. Wind roared around her, blasting her pelt as she fell. The river swirled and foamed below. She scrabbled desperately against the cold wet air and struggled of the dog just a moment before she hit the water.

People really shouldn’t hate on Blue’Star. She had ptsd, and I don’t blame her for her breakdown.

When Bluestar started being depressed and unmotivated I was so sure that she'd get better. When she didn't and she died, I actually lost motivation to read the books for like 2 weeks. Rip bluestar ❤

No animation has ever showed me so much emotion and how much Bluestar went through.. this hurt me so much

Something i just noticed is that Moonflower, Snowfur and mosskit all have two spots down their right eye, that's a really neat detail!

Honestly this is one of the most refreshing and raw takes of Bluestar's story I've seen in a long time. Shows every beat of her arc for better or for worse, in a brutally exposing way. I also love that you just so eloquently and succinctly implied that Thistleclaw's shadow loomed over her for a long time, it's honestly terrible all of the things she never was able to get over. Your art is fun and dynamic, the editing is snappy and perfectly timed without being overly-much. I just love this, and honestly I got a bit misty eyed at the end. Again, thanks for making this. I know I'll be coming back to this one frequently to rewatch. Please, keep making art!!!

This is the first Warriors pmv I find that includes the part where Bluestar acusses Windclan of stealing prey, Fireheart warns them and then she loses faith in Fireheart, not that she automatically hates him. Good detail :D

Why dose non of your AMV or PMV get so popular that’s underrated. I swear your vids need more views. Can’t wait for this!

The fact I could immediately tell this was McCafferty because of how often I listen to their songs and never listening to this one - I really love McCafferty's songs and I just wish Nick Hartkop was a good perosn because his music is so good :(

The transition on ‘older now/got some kids’ from Firepaw to Mosskit, Mistykit, and Stonekit was so creative. First time I watched this I got chills, whole heartedly the best warriors content I’ve ever watched. Amazing work, you have earned yourself a new sub, my dear creator. ❤️

I am absolutely stunned, I was so psyched when I saw the pic you posted the other day! Since finding your Sin Triangle video I’ve just been in love with the content, this is no different! I definitely need to rewatch this over and over to get all the little details! And I’m glad these panel videos are becoming popular! (I think the lead singer of mccafferty will probably get the money from the video though, I don’t know if it’s divided among the whole band, just the lead, or even just the record label, lmk if you find out though! I’ve been wishing I could animated their stuff but, you know)

THIS HAS TO BE ONE OF THE MOST UNIQUE BLUESTAR PMVS EVER!! The expressions, the style, colours - and let me not mention the tiny comic-like panels in certain scenes, that is absolutely brilliant! The effects are phenomenal as well, you did an amazing job! Can’t wait to see more of your work in the future

1:05 Detail I saw was that the heart on Firehearts chest is broken when Bluestar sees flashes of a Evil fireheart! I loved this animation and I can't stop watching it no matter how many times I almost cried XD Keep up the detailed and amazing work!

[violently sobs over a fucking cat] why am i like this on a serious note, this is one of my new favorite amvs for blue star and it really did make me cry multiple times, she's such an amazing characters and it breaks my heart that people in the fandom don't give her a chance sometimes

Blue star is still my favourite character after having read almost every single warriors book, her story is so tragic and powerful. It’s feels like reality. I absolutely love this

Starclan deserved everything they got from her ya'll can fight me on this-

I just love the emotions you can show off of Bluestar! You really feel how she just felt like everyone was coming after her, even Starclan. I also love how you show their fur raise and everything when they get angry and yell, it's just another great way to show emotions!! I also loved seeing Fireheart trying his best for Bluestar, he's a good cat that was trying his best for a leader who was really losing it.

bluestar had such a terrible life, she thought starclan did this bc smth was wrong with her ( or also bc they kinda like hated her?) bluestar is one of my favorite characters because she still fought through the pain, she did become a bit depressed this is why shes my favorite character , tigerclaw also treated her terribly. i did this 5 monrhs ago, and now it doesnt make sense. i love bluestar. her past is jst so interesting, and i can personally relate to her.

I think it's really cool how they added thrushpelt in the end frame[he is my favorite character]

Oh my gosh this animation was put together so well. The way that every character reacts, the gradual build up of Bluestar's frustrations and feeling that Star Clan had abandoned her. The transitions, the usage of blue lineart on all of the characters and outlining the borders of scenes that are negative in Bluestar's eyes. And the beautiful transition of Bluestar replacing Firestar diving into the waters, serving as a symbolism of the sudden fading of all of Bluestar's frustrations and denial of all of the good things that happened in her life despite the bad, ending with reuniting with those she loved and who they loved back. Just... breathtaking...

Wtf you’re criminally underrated

0:42 You really kicked on my emotions. She looks so terrified- and I’m sad-

this is SO beautiful in every way and gave me chills

Your pmvs and amvs always make me emotional. The way you've made the emotions and the anger of Bluestar so real, so personal is fantastic. I really, really enjoy this and I think I've found a new song as well. Great coloring, great tones, it's just stunning.

i hate that i relate to blue. being constantly reminded of your trauma by things with little relation. taking your sadness out with anger. feeling little hope to do anything. blaming your trauma on other things so you dont remind yourself that the world only gets worse. isolating yourself away from the people you love because of how you feel.

Wow I love this, I think bluestar is definitely a really complex character and you showed her losing control of her clan and herself really well. I love how you made tiger star actually beat blue star up, not a lot of videos do that and I feel like it adds to her trauma as she was completely over powered in that situation. Also who's the cat watching bluestar at 0:41? Again all your art takes such unique directions with the characters

I wonder what would have happened if Bluestar hadn't forgiven the whole of starclan during her last few moments

Bluestar deserved so much better- She was such a great cat and honestly just wanted to help. She experienced so many deaths of loved ones, faced trauma, and just when she was feeling terrible her deputy betrayed her. All Bluestar wanted was to help her Clan and lead a good life- she was wise, brave, and the most selfless cat I have ever seen. We love you Bluestar 💙⭐

the way you gave bluestar and fireheart the same exact cheek scars - both given by tigerstar's actions is INCREDIBLE. i can't get over it.

god how are your works always SO GOOD. like i can’t even put into words how much i adore this video. the just raw emotion of it knocked me off my feet holy hell. and all the details man. like the fact that when bluestar’s mind twists her image of fireheart and leads her to believe he’s a traitor for trying to peace with windclan the heart on his chest is cracked? DAMN MAN. its always the little things that end up hitting the hardest

i cannot WAIT for this, i adore your pmvs!!

You made "she wants me (to be loved)" omfg yes

2:09 made me break down and cry because the captions says " can you see me, son? " " as i float away "

(Sorry if I say stuff wrong I haven’t read the books in awhile) Honestly, This has to be one of my favorite warrior cats PMVs, Not because of the amazing editing and art style, dynamic and perspectives. But just because the emotion and how you showed what Bluestar has been through. She’s been through so much and watch so many clan mates and loved ones die, And I can understand how she would turn pretty cold. Some people draw or say Bluestar is a bad leader, But she was just depressed was dealing with a lot of trauma. Yes she made mistakes. No, She wasn’t a perfect leader. But she lost her mother, Sister, Kit, Mate, good Friend( Thrushpelt who was killed by Stonefur) Three deputies, Clan mates, two of her medicine cats, has Been betrayed. More clan mates, And more. I love how her death was written because she was able to say sorry, and say goodbye to her kits who grown to be strong warriors. And she was able to see all her loved ones. Okay, Enough with the analyzing and the art and editing. The editing is out standing, It reminded me of some comic book theme and I love that! Also the expressions and design for each cat and character were amazing, You can tell this masterpiece was made with love and care! I could say way more but my comments long enough XD Any who, This is amazing and keep up the good work! You earned a sub!

That was incredible!!!! The sheer, raw emotion of Bluestar's towards all the injustices in her life was so well-portrayed, I could truly feel it, as if I was experiencing it with her!! The pacing was also incredible as well, and your art style is just, gosh, *chef's kiss,* impeccable! 😘💕💖💗💓 (Also, just wanted to mention two things, one being that I'd like to suggest a gore warning, since the scene with Snowfur's and Brightpaw's trauma falls into that category. Two being that, unfortunately, the rest of McCafferty isn't all that innocent. Some of the current members are complicit with Nick's actions, though the former bandmates are obviously not to blame since they were victims/whistleblowers to his abuse. Otherwise, fantastic work, I'll be sure to revisit this like I do with Sin Triangle!!

GOD this is beautiful. Probably one of the best representations I’ve seen of Bluestar’s story and trauma. This is truly amazing. You have a wonderful style as well. It communicates this story so nicely ^^

ok but, this actually shows how lost and betrayed bluestar was and omg theres so much detail!!

I keep coming back to this vid, Its so well done. I feel like you really -get- the characters you make PMVs about, and this is no exception. It really clarifies Bluestars journey, and how it relates to the people around her. I especially love how you portrayed Fireheart, it feels very realistic. Plus your art and animation as always is really beautiful!!

I’m on the 4th book in the first series And tigerstar’s betrayal really had an impact on her! She is so anxious and I feel so bad! Poor bluestar.. she already went through so much:(

Baby Firepaw is so cute

I love the small detail of how the cut on blue starts cheek stays there and scars over this is phenomenal

bro this looks so good!! did you intend to put some sort of hidden message or easter egg at the scene with ferncloud and the rabbits? :0 i noticed the black and white one looks like swiftpaw and the blue-ish one looks like it may resemble cinderpaw

THIS IS SO PRETTY! You can see her going crazy and it’s just raw emotion! 👏32/10👏

bluestar’s character truly does deserve more attention, being broken by betrayal, trusting only fireheart and whitestorm. just to lose trust when fireheart tells windclan about her planning a unnecessary attack. i mean, she lost her kits, her faith, her sister, her trust in her clan, her deputy, but at the end, she forgives starclan, but i don’t think they deserve her apology. bluestar had a strong right to be broken and angry, i love your art style and display of emotions, truly incredible

THIS IS SO GOOD!!!!!! keep up the good work :0

Underrated the song matches the story so well but not enough, that’s where you come in and fill the gap with animation!

0:55 BLUESTAR LOAF

i'm not over here getting emotional. oh man, this blew my mind. it's so emotional and touches on things i haven't thought about before. oh gosh, i hope this blows up and gets all the attention it deserves.

This is the most... F*CKING BEAUTIFUL THING I’VE EVER SEEN ITS SO AMAZING AAAAAAAAH

Never have I ever cried to a warrior cat book or animation.... Wow, you're talented.

THE END GAVE ME A CHILL!!! YOU'VE DONE IT AGAIN!!

Ahhh this is so gorgeous!!! I'm blown away by the amount of emotion in their expressions and body language! Really amazing job!!!

I SWEAR TO GOD NO ONE GAVE YOU PERMS TO MAKE ME CRY OVER BLUESTAR’S DEATH AGAIN LIKE BLUESTAR’S DEATH WAS THE ONLY THING IN THE ENTIRE FRICKIN SERIES I CRIED ABOUT (OTHER THAN THAT ONE MAP W/ FIRESTAR AND TIGERS FINAL BATTLE BUT-) SINCE I WAS ALL FRESH AND NEW AND INNOCENT AND STILL HAD A SOUL AND THIS MADE ME CRY OVER IT AGAIN. DAMN IT ILYSM

dude. this is fucking STUNNING work, like seriously such a good combo of art and pacing and arrangement of everything. serious props i love this

Holy SHIT this is probably my favorite Bluestar Pmv ever

This was SO GOOD oh my goodness. The pop up parts are so pleasing and i love how well they fit in the scenes,, this has to be my absolute favourite way of using the pop up style. Also love how Fireheart gets the same cheek scars as Bluestar!!

The art is so beautiful. The backgrounds are especially astonishing!

This is so good!! Especially the bit at the end where she’s falling, it literally gave me chills

i am pretty new to this channel, as in, just found this channel, and i am really enlightened to have found it, and i just want to say, i love this a lot, (ignoring the musicians bad reputation, i know more than likely of course don't support any if it at all of course, i wouldn't really give any attention to the music from all of them though as it still counts as support by youtube systems and all that) first off, the style, i adore it so much, the small line work pairing with the base colors with no gigantic shading factors amongst the cats makes it look simple yet works really well like the lineart and the fur motion and for more sporadically woven expressions, the larger detail is put into the backgrounds with the coloring, speaking of backgrounds you made the backgrounds with gorgeous spectors, the water splashing, just, awhshsxbxb, the details with all the fire, and don't get me started on the way you drew the blood, it isn't too coiling in rivers of it, you were did really well with splatters, and for brightpaw the amount is just right, mmm chefs kiss next is the approach to the story telling factor in more minutes that you managed to conjure, the quick flashes of memories and the immediate emotion changes, a big thing i enjoyed was, the fact of when staring fireheart down, you can see where she was even suspicious of this literal child, sure anger counts but, all the suspicions towards star clan isn't the only factor bluestar had, some people don't understand just how frenzied this women was and you ended up doing really well meshing everything together to show it all off in total, i hope to support your works in the future from this point on and feel glad to have layed my eyes on such art (i also deeply apologize for such a long comment!)

This one made me cry

This should be more popular

2:03 good detail!! "You will burn through the forest like fire, but even the most powerful fire can be destroyed by water" - goosefeather

The way Bluestar's distrust of Windclan was shown was pretty creative/cool.

The storytelling with the panels is so good! It’s all so emotional and you did SO WELL in portraying her feelings and just- god, it’s so RAWLY EMOTIONAL AND IDK HOW TO EXPLAIN IT I’M NOT GOOD WITH WORDS LMAO, but like- you could practically FEEL what she was feeling and quite frankly, this is probably the only time I’ve actually felt like I UNDERSTOOD and even SYMPATHISED with her because you just showed it all SO WELL and HUFAHUjlksgklhfdkl The pacing? Perfect. The art? God-tier. The editing? Amazing. The colours? Breathtaking. I am so excited to see what you do next! All your videos are so great :’-0

Looks great! I'm excited! Edit: Was not disappointed, amazing as always!

The emotion you show in your art is absolutely outstanding. You were one of the main warrior cats artists that inspired me to try animating. Thank you so much.

This PMV was made like two years ago, but I still like the concept of it.The emotions, feelings, it fits so well with song.I always loved BlueStar as leader, she lived through the worst.I love how song fits with her so well, I admire this PMV and think you deserve more attention.

I was amazing I love your art style! Every second of it was beautiful!!!

THE RAWNESS AND ATTENTION TO DETAIL IS AMAZINGGG

This is heavily under rated. You did an absolutely phenomenal job with the art, editing, colors and the flashbacks? Oh my God I can go into so much detail but I'd be rambling about every single second! I love your style, I look forward to more!

can't stop watching this, js love how it tells her story so well and the artstylee

I- I have no words for this..honestly..it’s so great to the point I can’t even explain how good it looks in words..just...know that I’ll be revisiting this very very soon!

I'm actually going to cry.. her life was so sad!! bluestar deserved way better

Bluestar is one of my favorite leaders! She had a terrible life, in which everyone she loved and trusted betrayed her or left her in some way, including StarClan....

i don’t even like bluestar that much but i feel so fucking bad for her still. this is gorgeous, i love all your work but especially what you do with bluestar holy shit

OMG THE BEST PMV EVER :"""" sorry i'm crying

I keep seeing people reupload this video into youtube shorts edits and stuff even though you stated that you don't want people to reupload it. Most of them won't even give credit. :(

the "can you see me son?" with fireheart actually made me burst into tears oh my god

I love the details with Thistle'Claw!The way he looks unbothered and kinda annoyed that they got their ceremony in the back and how when blue'star sees him when being attacked he looks like a wolf/dog then a cat showing what he did to spotted'Leaf i also love the detail where starclan is 'mocking' her in the fire!!:0

Someone reposted some clips of these videos in a short the meme is like killer queen Edit 1 : their name is Sunny_wc and the name is There was this girl..

This is gonna be so good!!! You're my biggest inspiration!!! :D

THIS HAS GOT TO BE ONE OF MY FAVORITE WARRIOR CAT ANIMATIOSN EVER !!! bluestar is probably gotta be one of my favorite characters fr

Absolutely magnificent. The style, animation, everything. This has to be my favorite PMV of all time.

Never thought a book character would make me cry but warrior cats is to sad honestly but i still love it

Aaaaaa can't wait!

this is amazing! not just the cats! (wich i love) the details! and back grounds! and shading! and when it shows fire heart as like fire and then blue star water is was just so cool! Amazing!

This is amazing, the way you draw mouths and all the pain in the butt things that come with them, along with emotions, its fonominal. Keep it up my dude, stay safe. (Also the respective and hindlegs from behind is breath taking)

Dude. You are the king/queen of warrior cats pmvs. I eat up every single one of them and ive been in love with like all of them. They are all so in sync with the music and you really convey the cats emotions very well through their expressions, poses, etc.

im crying? i love how abruptly this ended, it really is just so fitting. her relationship with fireheart and her life with thunderclan and just. all of it i love bluestar so much !!!!!!

This song is really describing my day today and how I feel. My best friend betrayed me Blamed for something I didn’t do Had my first panic attack(wasn’t pretty) Got sent home School doesn’t trust me I’m going to a help center And suddenly I feel like Bluestar is just like me

I’m so obsessed with this, I can’t stop watching it it’s so good!!

bruh idk how you are able to capture emotions so beautifully, from the colors to the expression ugh just so amazing! i will be obsessing over this for months now😀👍

I'm literally crying! That's so amazing, great work!

YOOO this is absolutely stunning. i genuinely cannot form words. the transitions with the comicy sort of panels just work so so well i-

Blue stars story was the first story that made me cry. It’s so depressing. And this animatic perfectly captures everything.