I don't quite understand. Shouldn't phone calls between two countries like this be recorded by both sides? Otherwise, deciding on and executing an agreement between two countries based solely on a few people oral records seems abnormal. Of course, records of the phone conversation should be kept. Whether it violates diplomatic protocols and rules to show it to the public is another matter. Accusing someone of eavesdropping seems nonsensical.

China has the right and need to record the conversation, because they already know that Philippine will deny what they said. It happened many times. If Chinese didn’t do it, I would call them stupid.

Haha..so embarrassing. Caught lying. That's all Marcos knows how to do.

There is no such thing that any deal or agreement between states be made in an audio recording. Usually a delegation between ambassadors is present with their respective head of states in a formal meeting signed by both parties. China is S T U P I D.

China talk to a military officer when it come to territory ???😂😂😂excuse me we are not Junta of Mynmar 🇲🇲 .talk to our President 😂😂

I'd like to think Beijing isn't serious about their claim because who is on their right mind to talk to a military officer that doesn"t have authority to strike any deal? If they're true, then this is so far the stupidest thing China did in their history of false claims.

Kahit saan...magaling sila sa piracy.

An Admiral or other military officer has no authority to make foreign policy.. So the phone means nothing.

A guy talking isn't the same as a Government signed agreement.

Obviously, Marcos has similar recording and even video transactions with China, but they have not been announced.

Treason for any unofficial deal or agreement without the knowledge of the Filipino people!

I don't understand how China justifies an oral conversation becoming binding at this scale and at this modern age. Even signed treaties among or between countries on paper becomes irrelevant when one side choses to withdraw from an agreement for reason of convenience.

Only the president has the power to negotiate whatever it is concerning national interest. Any officials of the government below him has no authority to do so

Well, this confirmed the fact that China allows Philippine supply ship to deliver food but not construction material. Otherwise, they could black every supply ship.

If this is true, Manila will have a reason to limit Chinese Embassy's activities or worse, close the Chinese Embassy

Agreement with an officer? LOL, hold up, lemme ask the manager of this mcdonalds branch that I'll be buying their franchise. This is just clownery by yours truly Xi Jinping 🤣

China cant honor the ruling that they dont own WPS, now they want philippines to honor something they just made up. 😂😂

Yes,China is wrong . They should talk to Biden . 😂😂😂😂😂

An AI recording the Karen of Asia is at it's finest 😂

maritess to maritess.thats chinas colorom business

You have an affair with the neighbour's wife and you get angry when he releases your phone recording 😂

ASEAN NOT SYRIA, PHILIPPINES NOT ASEAN. Marcos betrayed the regional brotherhood by reintroducing the stench of colonialists back into the region. I am no mens slave...Periyar ❤

Duterte didn’t deny it. In a few interviews this yr, he confirmed that he had that agreement with china. Ur info is wrong, pls change it. Duterte put his pride & personal anger first, before the Philippines. He sided with china, instead of the US.

Philippines BongBonglengsky the new proxy kid on the block.😅❤😂

I got a recording of a deal too -China agreed to dismantle and evacuate all their fortified islands in the South China Sea in exchange for Xi Jinping parading in Manila's Chinatown in a two piece bikini ...I know this would be traumatic for the locals, but I hope the Chinese will honor this deal anyway.

Why Philippine Government continue to deal with those none sense issues. All of these are just Chinese propaganda. Philippine Government should focus on the things that matters the most. To claim what is rightfully belongs to the Philippines.

What does the tooth fairy, a Unicorn and Santa Clause all have in common with the West Philippines Seas?...none of them actually exist!

Good luck to filipinos in following U.S. Other countries in BRI are doing great. How is Flipino?

so, PH is doing to wrong. please just shut up.

Wire tapping, is a grave case in Philippine Law. These Chinese diplomats if proven guilty, are subject to black listing.

If this so called recording is true then let the Chinese release it. This way all parties get to study if this so called recording is legitimate and whoever is liable to be punished. Like Gen. Brawner said anyone can make a transcript. heck even I can make a transcript of any so called conversation and tell everyone it’s real without providing proof…

From the disclosed recordings, Chinese diplomats also specifically asked Alberto Carlos, who is responsible for communication, whether he had obtained approval from his superiors. The latter stated that it had been approved, and he was very certain of this. I guess China never expected that the commander of a country's Western Command could break his promise.🤣

Just a simple wiretapping u cant avoid??? N u still want to go to war with china???🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Later the comments section will be filled with chinese trolls 😂

agreement should be video recorded with all highest official for both side to be witness and not just some audio recording

The Chinese officials that wiretapped the confidential conversations with the Philippine military, is now subject to arrest! For breaching the national security code of a sovereign nation. The police is now looking for him and has departure hold on his passport! He’s not leaving the country.

If not true, then why Phi so worked up, saying its agst Phi's law. So the Phi is like US. Invent laws and interprete to their advantage.

Both houses of the PH Congress should investigate this very serious incident since it involves national security and international relations.

Philippines is panicked… waiting for Daddy Sam’s help? Hahaha

The Philippine-American War pitted one time allies in the overthrow of Spain against each other. Spain negotiated a separate peace with the United States in the Treaty of Paris, ceding colonial rule of the Philippine Islands to the Americans rather than granting the Filipinos independence. The American government accepted this new imperial role, and set about subduing any Filipinos who resisted. In this scene, the city of Iloilo is captured from Filipino forces by Americans led by Brigadier General Marcus Miller, with no loss of American lives. (Diorama in the Ayala Museum, Makati, Philippines, 2018.) Waging the American War How did the Americans justify their takeover of the Philippines? Are you convinced by this argument? In your opinion, did American conduct during the war match these justifications? Why or why not? How did the American military attempt to counter rumors of their brutality? Annexation of the Philippines as a colony of the United States was often justified by those in the U.S. government and media on moral and racial grounds. The U.S. was simply doing its duty as an advanced, Western nation, spreading civilization, democracy, and capitalism to primitive Asians who enjoyed none of these things and were too simple to be trusted with self-government. Historian Stuart Creighton Miller writes that in this view, “Americans altruistically went to war with Spain to liberate Cubans, Puerto Ricans, and Filipinos from their tyrannical yoke. If they lingered on too long in the Philippines, it was to protect the Filipinos from European predators waiting in the wings for an American withdrawal and to tutor them in American-style democracy.” Implicit in this attitude were notions of racial superiority and the inherent superiority of white America over primitive people of color. The ugly reality of Americans colonial mission was laid bare by Dean Worcester, an American colonial official, who wrote in his memoirs that the Filipinos were “treacherous, arrogant, stupid and vindictive, impervious to gratitude, incapable of recognizing obligations. Centuries of barbarism have made them cunning and dishonest. We cannot safely treat them as equals, for the simple and sufficient reason that they could not understand it. They do not know the meaning of justice and good faith. They do not know the difference between liberty and license…. These Filipinos must be taught obedience and be forced to observe, even if they cannot comprehend, the practices of civilization. On February 11, 1899-only one week after the first shots of the war were fired-American naval forces destroyed the city of Iloilo with bombardment by the USS Petrel and the USS Baltimore. The city was then captured by ground forces led by Brigadier General Marcus Miller, with no loss of American lives. Months later, after finally securing Manila from Filipino control, American forces moved northwards, engaging in combat at the brigade and battalion level in pursuit of the fleeing insurgent forces and their commanders. In response to the use of guerilla warfare tactics by Filipino forces beginning in September 1899, American military strategy shifted to a suppression footing. Tactics became focused on the control of key areas with internment and segregation of the civilian population in “zones of protection” from the guerrilla population (foreshadowing the Strategic Hamlet Program that would be utilized decades later, during the Vietnam War). Due to unsanitary conditions, many of the interned civilians died from dysentery. General Otis gained notoriety for some of his actions in the Philippines. Although multiple orders were given to Otis from Washington to avoid military conflict, he did very little to prevent the breakout of war. Otis refused to accept anything but unconditional surrender from the Philippine Army. He often made major military decisions without first consulting leadership in Washington. He acted aggressively in dealing with the Filipinos under the assumption that their resistance would collapse quickly. A member of the American colonial government offered an alternative theory on what Bell was achieving, noting in his official report that far from breaking the spirit of the Filipino people, the blanket policy of violence and destruction was: … sowing the seeds for a perpetual revolution. If these things need be done, they had best be done by native troops so that the people of the U.S.. will not be credited therewith. Otis also played a large role in suppressing information about American military tactics from the media. When letters describing American atrocities reached the American media, the War Department became involved and demanded that Otis investigate their authenticity. Each press clipping was forwarded to the original writer’s commanding officer, who would then convince or force the soldier to write a retraction of the original statements. Meanwhile, Otis claimed that Filipino insurgents tortured American prisoners in “fiendish fashion.” During the closing months of 1899, Aguinaldo attempted to counter Otis’ account by suggesting that neutral parties-foreign journalists or representatives of the International Committee of the Red Cross-inspect his military operations. Otis refused, but Aguinaldo managed to smuggle four reporters-two English, one Canadian, and one Japanese-into the Philippines. The correspondents returned to Manila to report that American captives were “treated more like guests than prisoners,” were “fed the best that the country affords, and everything is done to gain their favor.” The story went on to say that American prisoners were offered commissions in the Filipino army and that three had accepted. The four reporters were expelled from the Philippines as soon as their stories were printed. U.S. Navy Lieutenant J.C. Gilmore, whose release was forced by American cavalry pursuing Aguinaldo into the mountains, insisted that he had received “considerable treatment” and that he was no more starved than were his captors. Otis responded to publication of two articles concerning this by ordering the “capture” of the two authors, and that they be “investigated,” therefore questioning their loyalty. When F.A. Blake of the International Committee of the Red Cross arrived at Aguinaldo’s request, Otis kept him confined to Manila, where Otis’ staff explained all of the violations of international humanitarian law perpetrated by Filipino soldiers. Blake managed to slip away from an escort and venture into the field. Blake never made it past American lines, but even within American lines he saw burned out villages and “horribly mutilated bodies, with stomachs slit open and occasionally decapitated.” Blake waited to return to San Francisco, where he told one reporter that “American soldiers are determined to kill every Filipino in sight.” H.L. Wells, a staunch imperialist writing in the New York Evening Post, excused the troubling American racial theories that contributed to the often callous violence that characterized the Philippine-American War “There is no question that our men do ‘shoot niggers’ somewhat in the sporting spirit, but that is because war and their environments have rubbed off the thin veneer of civilization…Undoubtedly, they do not regard the shooting of Filipinos just as they would the shooting of white troops. This is partly because they are “only niggers,” and partly because they despise them for their treacherous servility…The soldiers feel they are fighting with savages, not with soldiers.”

Hello, this is not boyfriend-girlfriend chit-chat. I am sure the Philippines has a similar recording of the conversation. This is standard protocol for G-to-G phone calls on official matters.

In south PH, war is an everyday meal of every soldiers. Meanwhile China... 😂

Funny xi ping pong scolded Canadian Trudeau for divulging their meeting and here xi ping pong minions “release deals” that only they know.. 😂😂😂… xi ping pong wtf?😅

clearly trying to divide the filipino people

What will happen in the next elections? Can you afford expensive American weapons which require expensive maintanence and needs to be shipped 8,000 miles away? Will there be any additional economic development / trade/ aid in this American partnership since China is also one of Philippines largest trading partner?

This is what we Filipinos called "Usapang Lasing"

I’m not surprised how dirty the Chinese work. Just look how dirty they prepare their food.

Isn't everything being recorded for govt record? Or maybe we're doing the whole secrecy thing that's worked well for society.

Two scenarios: (1) this defense secretary was making unauthorized negotiation with foreign country that Phi had no intention to abide (2) this secretary was authorized to make promises but now Phi decides to discard it. EITHER way, it hurts credibility of Phi.

Haha, the Philippines watched as its lies were exposed by the evidence, and then, in a fit of embarrassment and anger, made some really foolish moves

never believe what china is saying, just always remember their products quality, made in china

In the Battle of Manila from February to March 1945, the United States Army advanced into the city of Manila in order to drive the Japanese out. During lulls in the battle for control of the city, Japanese troops took their anger and frustration out on the civilians in the city.

👑❤️✅ My Family Marcos Make the Philippines Great Again!

China could not facilitate that wiretapping without the connivance of a Philippines high-ranking official.

When truth hurts?

This is no wiretap but official recording of diplomatic negotiation. Now Philippines want to overturn the promise negotiation. What an asshole talking about wiretapping ?

So, the General agreed now Philippines govt angry that China recorded the agreement. Lol.

Evidence?

Do you know the world is interconnected with China and the Chinese ? The US now compared to the US in the past, is a total different situation. China now and China in the past, is far very different now too. Philippines keeps mentioning about US, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan against China. But if you go against China, China is not alone. Russia, North Korea, Africa, Brazil etc its alliances worldwide are all behind China because all economic and financial ties are deeply interrooted with China

Philippines Become USA friend Now its Distraction 100% Confirmed 😂

You believe something coming from a horse’s mouth 😂!

even customer service or a call from your HR has records.

Ahhh china saying that they have audio recording.. maybe more like Ai generated voice with Xilong Mah's voice: "Bluetooth device connected saksesfuley"😂 Ahhh... china never fail to make fake products.😂

lol imagine manilla trying to survive a corruption probe.

Desperate China. 😂😂😂

Pong choy la (pong choy la) Chichiri kong koyla Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Bobo chi-chang (bobo chi-chang) Chichiri kong tong nang Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Chiri wong wong choy, cho-ro kong tong loy Chidang bobo chi-chang, chiri kong tong nan Chiring cho ri yak kang kong, woop Butse kik-ik-ik-ik Pong choy la (pong choy la) Chichiri kong koyla Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Bobo chi-chang (bobo chi-chang) Chichiri kong tong nang Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Chiri wong wong choy, cho-ro kong tong loy Chidang bobo chi-chang, chiri kong tong nan Chiring cho ri yak kang kong, woop Butse kik-ik-ik-ik Chododo pong pong yok, chododo pong pang plu Chidang bobo chi-chang, chidi kong tong plok Bi bay botchok, chidi di plok Chididikok wok, chodo dokok, ngok, ngok Pong choy la (pong choy la) Chichiri kong koyla Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Bobo chi-chang (bobo chi-chang) Chichiri kong tong nang Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Chiri wong wong choy, cho-ro kong tong loy Chidang bobo chi-chang, chiri kong tong nan Chiring cho ri yak kang kong, woop Butse kik-ik-ik-ik Chododo pong pong yok, chododo pong pang plu Chidang bobo chi-chang, chidi kong tong plok Bi bay botchok, chidi di plok Chididikok wok, chodo dokok, ngok, ngok Pong choy la (pong choy la) Chichiri kong koyla Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Bobo chi-chang (bobo chi-chang) Chichiri kong tong nang Butse kik (butse kik), ik-ik-ik (ik-ik-ik) Chiri wong wong choy, cho-ro kong tong loy Chidang bobo chi-chang, chiri kong tong nan Chiring cho ri yak kang kong, woop Butse kik Yeah, yeah, butse kik Ye bah, ye bah, ye bah, butse kik Choro yoto mo toi, butse kik-ik-ik-ik

Horrible background music.

Thats nat real.. Chinese is famous for being faking everything 😂..

Can China be sued for anti wire tapping law? where? sa ICC? or sa barangay court? hoping Trillanes will file the case at the ICC.

really? if they were blindsided with the wiretapping, god forbid that they are not capable of doing their job of securing our country (the officials already showed their inactiveness and unwillingness to be more pro active). PS... most countries wiretaps every convos, especially official talks for security reasons. get with the times and stop acting like a deer in headlights and try to assert our rights!

It is Philippine territorial waters. Why do these Chinese limit Filipino access to this waters? The decision of one person is not the decision and sentiment of all Filipinos. We will defend what is rightfully ours.

palakasin na lang natin our military capability with our allies that in case of war we can fight them.

A monster is a type of creature that since ancient times, usually uses names such as xi jin ping. Monsters are often dangerous and aggressive and have a strange and frightening appearance that causes fear and dread. They are often monstrous out of this world and/or mutant animals or strange creatures of various shapes, but they can also take human form, such as mutants, ghosts, spirits, zombies, or cannibals, in addition to other forms. They may or may not have supernatural powers, but they usually have the ability to kill or cause some form of destruction, threatening the social or moral order of the human world.

He lies like a true US politician.

Just a criticism about this video. Just add a voice over instead of letting viewers read through the video it defeats the whole purpose of using an audio visual format to deliver a story. A voice over literally has more value than overly dramatic music.

Marcos chose this juncture to cozy up with a falling empire, the timing was incredible!

It's china's psychological warfare before the real deal. Umpisahan nyo na Wala din Naman choice mga Pinoy kundi harapin kayo sa laban.

Then should china release the transaction happened in 2014? 😂

6 years imprisonment and 100 dollar fine.

The Thomas Shoal was never and will never belong to China because in the 1561 Spanish map shows all the Thomas Shoal and Scarborough Shoal was and is part of the Philippine Territories that Spain conquered and named in the name of the king of spain King Felipe

Dont forget AI is the key

How desperate China is. Dealing with a low ranking official 😂 Well, it's not true anyway.

AI.

the philippines is such a wonderful country...................very very very rich, educated, prosperous and NOT a slave of the USA.....................they export their citizens as maids and seamen because these people are SOOOOOOOOOOOOO qualified and cleverer than the foreigners who employ them...........................the philippines deserves to be the greatest country in the world because their leaders are so intelligent and honest.............and also the philipinnes knows how to catch fish..............so clever

So what the F is it? Wiretapping, AI fabrication or through a recorded line?

So which way is it? Wiretapping or AI fabrication 😂

is it also counted as authorized if different country talked and made agreement with me without talking to the right authorized agency like the department of foreign affairs? This is the same as what china did to the Philippines. They talked to some unauthorized person and assumed that it was binding and legal.

GOD Always protect PBBM sa mga evils at ilayo nyo PO sa kapahamakan Panginoon JESUS Amen

Who can you trust?

Filipino wants more Chinese money 💰💰💰💰💰💰

They look like siblings.. filipino are chinese

China spy?! What a surprise…they’re so benevolent, respectful, charitable and kind

So the Philippines admit that it is the real recording. 😂 That philipinos doesn't respect the promise they made. Typical 😅

Dahil dito...sa pagpayag ni duterte sa agreement sa china...dapat Inday Sara for President sa susunod na halalan...para magkasundo ulit sila sa china🤣😂

Who's blackmail ?

What's the next steps of our government? Baka palalampasin nanaman yan.

Filipino wants more Chinese money 💰💰💰

This channel does not seem obective and neutral?

Isarado ang chinese embassy at pauwiin sila kaagad pag ganyan na binabastos nila ang kanilang host country

Only the president of the Philippines is allowed to make a deal to other nation not a single officer.