In my opinion the best version of Echoes in many ways.

Loving the last part with David and Richard (RIP) playing back and forth is so beautiful. Last time ever for Echoes

One of my favorite PF songs. David Gilmour has said he would not play this again without his friend Richard which makes this version even more special. Also check out High Hopes from the same concert, its got a beautiful extended acoustic outro.

Rarely music makes me cry but this ending with david and Richard does. Treasure this my friends because you will most likely never hear it live again like this.

Thank you so much for this reaction Ruben! This song is an absolute masterpiece, you can hear the perfect bond between David Gilmour and Rick Wright, how they complete each other both singing and playing. You can tell how much fun they were having during the funky jamming section, and then after the weird noise part comes one of the most atmospheric build up I've ever heard. Everything in this track is pure magic for me, I know it's a very long song but in my opinion it's worth the journey. Someone may complain about the version I chose for my request, I know that the live at pompeii is also amazing and it has the full band with Roger Waters, but on youtube you always find it in 2 separated parts. And this version is also very emotional for me because is the last performance with Rick. Gilmour said he won't play this song live anymore without him, and that shows how much they loved each other. That being said, thank you again Ruben, you are the best. Glad you liked the song and I hope you will listen to it again from time to time. Cheers!

There are very few humans alive who can convey so much emotion so effortlessly. there are two of them on the stage on this magical night. They literally reached perfection. watching the expressions on your face confirmed it completely to me!

Best band of all times .. 👍😎

hats off to the late great Richard Wright as well... co-vocals and keyboards and original member of Pink Floyd who joined Dave on this.

The studio version is fantastic...listened to it countless times since the early seventies

There is a video of this show available. Highly recommended.

All jokes aside,this is therapy at the highest level imaginable!

Absolutely genius

This was the best concert I've ever seen! Comfortably Numb at gdnask I think it's the best version out there. He had a full orchestra playing behind them and they were really into the music and absolutely amazing

Echoes, Live at Pompeii- you have to be beyond bad ass to play among a bunch of ancient souls. David Gilmore plugs his guitar into his sol and touches heaven, making the angels weep.

I was there in Gdansk in 2006, that was some spectacular memorable concert.

Timeless without expectations...THAT is Pink Floyd

This really shines a light on what you can do with a couple of instruments and a bunch of phenomenal musicians. The music does the talking.

Great suggestion, Lorenzo. I've always loved this song. So beautiful. Great reaction, Ruben. Love the channel!

This song is the musical version of a Diamond. its perfection.

I usually tell people to listen to other Pink Floyd songs and ease in before they jump into Echoes.....Hard for the other songs to match this.

Well Ruben I have been telling everyone for so long to listen to this version of echoes which is without doubt pink floyd at their very best it's absolutely fabulous I didn't want it to end I was in seventh heaven your mate recommended this good on him he has great taste and I can tell you absolutely loved it to what a group so amazingly talented I'm 73 been listening to floyd for over fifty odd years and enjoyed every second of it wonderful

Two friends playing together for the last time.

You are absolutely right, this body of work requires more than one listen to even begin to analyze, it needs many good sessions. What a masterpeice, decades of work went into that performance. 👏👏👏

What a trip. I know Pink Floyd doesn't get you the most views or likes, your audience is somewhere else and that is cool to. But know that your your other stuff doesn't go unnoticed. I wish I could give you more than one thumbs up. I am a big fan, even if metal isn't really my thing, I appreciate the talent. You made me discover a lot. Than you. Cheers from Canada 🇨🇦and from a huge Pink Floyd fan.

A piece of art 🎨 not for the sake of Art, but for the sake of beauty and pure enjoyment. It is almost not of this world. 🤜🤛

What a beautiful and heartfelt comment 💝

I would rate PF the same as Vincent van Gogh, Rembrandt,Bach,Mozart,Afro Jack or any other great artist to have ever lived!

You really should do Moody Blues. The Thresold of a dream record. They where the pre cursor for Pink Floyd.. Its fantastic. Made before you was even born man. No Computers at all. Just imaginations. Love you man.

I was there,man!

Sheer beauty and perfection.

Shine On is really personal too. Fantastic concert for sure.

Brit Floyd is the best coverband that I saw live. Check their tour.

This is one song that David Gilmour will not play again after Richard Wright's death very sad all round but I totally understand how on earth could he.

It's like Deep Purple's Lazy live on made in Japan album, it's a long groovy jam session.

👍 just perfect amazing 💖🌹😍

Awesome song just love it

Legenda . Uno dei pezzi più belli di sempre .

Brilliant, but would have chosen either album version or floyd live at Pompeii, love your facial expressions when gilmours guitar starts tho

Wow!

Can highly recommend the Australian Pink Floyd show if they come to Holland, after all this martial law pish comes to an end lol seen them 7 times in Scotland

Echoes part 1 and part 3 are absolute genius. But part 2 can prove boring for anyone who hasn't seen the visuals like stage show or Live in Pompeii (where the 4 members are seen wandering amidst the volcanic landscapes and Roman ruins). Anyways, this track is brilliant !

I picture the sea erns of the N. Hebrides.

Thanks, Ruben. this video is pure gold. i've been listening to all things Floyd for 40 years, and this is, in my humble opinion, the finest musical interaction that Gilmour and Wright experienced. highly suggest the DVD for the full experience. it is worth each and every penny.

OMG, GOD EXIST. AND PLAY THE GUITAR I AND IT'S CALLED DAVID GILMOUR

Aurora live : From Verftet online: We are honoured to welcome Aurora to this concert at Verftet Online Music Festival. Verftet music venue on Sunday 29 March at 8 pm (GMT+1). Watch for free at KZfaq: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jMuRetJe1rW2Yo0.html

Pompeii is the real live version actually anything with Waters is the real thing ;-)

I'll watch with you. This one's for Wright. RIP.

And what about 50,000 people silent in pure administration. Bravo.

Middle part both bass and lead guitar effects

Pink Floyd The Wall Silk Screen poster banner billboard rare Vintage Black Pink (ebay)

My wife and I went to a Roger Waters concert once.

I have the dvd.

Lol. And its not even my favourite version(meddle and pompeii). Yes Floyd are rock artists that paint with music.

Pompei one is better in my opinion. not sure who the keyboardist is in this one? Richard Wright vocals and keyboard on pompei and original were amazing. of course he could be on this but im not sure.

Opeth - Lovelorn Crime

5:25. Unison stank face.

The drummer and base player are missing the intensity of Mason and Waters. Very noticeable. Guess that was to be expected.

react to welcome to the machine

Kind of a Rock Sonata.

Mythique

And now David Gilmore has sold his guitar collection.......I really, really hated to hear that......even though all the proceeds went to a cause I support. Does that mean no more live David Gilmore?

Pompeii version is much better. Just the 4 original members (exception of Syd) and very raw.

Why would anyone choose this over Pink Floyd? The guitar on this is turned up way too loud. Always a problem with Gilmour and Gilmour era Floyd, guitar way too high in the mix. Plenty of power tho'.

Although I hate when the song is paused, I would prefer that the reactor did so and gave there full attention to the music. You sat quietly thru most of the quieter parts, then began talking thru a pivotal point in the song. Understand, it's not about me not being able to appreciate the song because of the talking. It's about the you not hearing all of the song that you're reviewing. I have listened to this song at least few 100 times over the past 50 years. You're the guy who hasn't. Well, I think that you still haven't. Not fully, anyway. Too harsh? Yeah, so I've been told.